Search NASA⌕ Search

Engineering topics

Magee-Sauer, K.

Publications and source records attributed to Magee-Sauer, K..

The Volatile Fraction of Comets as Quantified at Infrared Wavelengths - An Emerging Taxonomy and Implications for Natal Heritage

It is relatively easy to identify the reservoir from which a given comet was ejected. But dynamical models demonstrate that the main cometary reservoirs (Kuiper Belt, Oort Cloud) each contain icy bodies that formed in a range of environments in the protoplanetary disk, and the Oort Cloud may even contain bodies that formed in disks of sibling stars in the Sun s birth cluster. The cometary nucleus contains clues to the formative region(s) of its individual components. The composition of ices and rocky grains reflect a range of processes experienced by material while on the journey from the natal interstellar cloud core to the cometary nucleus. For that reason, emphasis is placed on classifying comets according to their native ices and dust (rather than orbital dynamics). Mumma & Charnley [1] reviewed the current status of taxonomies for comets and relation to their natal heritage.

Mumma, M. J.↗

Primary Volatile Abundances in Comets from Infrared Spectroscopy: Implications for Reactions on Grain Surfaces in the Interstellar/Nebular Environment

Comets retain relatively primitive icy material remaining from the epoch of Solar System formation, however the extent to which they are modified from their initial state remains a key question in cometary science. High-resolution lR spectroscopy has emerged as a powerful tool for measuring vibrational emissions from primary volatiles (i.e., those contained in the nuclei of comets). With modern instrumentation, most notably NIRSPEC at the Keck II 10-m telescope, we can quantify species of astrobiological importance (e.g., H20, C2H2, CH4, C2H6, CO, H2CO, CH30H, HCN, NH3). In space environments, compounds of keen interest to astrobiology could originate from HCN and NH3 (leading to amino acids), H2CO (leading to sugars), or C2H6 and CH4 (suggested precursors of ethyl- and methylamine). Measuring the abundances of these precursor molecules (and their variability among comets) is a feasible task that contributes to understanding their delivery to Earth's early biosphere and to the synthesis of more complex pre biotic compounds. Over 20 comets have now been measured with IR spectroscopy, and this sample reveals significant diversity in primary volatile compositions. From this, a taxonomic classification scheme is emerging, presumably reflecting the diverse conditions experienced by pre-cometary grains in interstellar and subsequent nebular environs. The importance of H-atom addition to C2H2 on the surfaces of interstellar grains to produce C2H6 was validated by the discovery of abundant ethane in comet C/1996 B2 (Hyakutake) with C2H6/CH4 well above that achievable by gas-phase chemistry , and then in irradiation experiments on laboratory ices at 10 - 50 K. The large abundance ratios C2H6/CH4 observed universally in comets establish H-atom addition as an important and likely ubiquitous process, and comparing C2H6/C2H2 among comets can provide information on its efficiency. The IR is uniquely capable since symmetric hydrocarbons (e.g., C2H2, CH4, C2H6) have no electric dipole moment and thus no allowed pure rotational transitions. CO should also be hydrogenated on grain surfaces. Irradiation experiments on interstellar ice analogs show this to require very low temperatures, the resulting yields of H2CO and CH30H being highly dependent on temperature in the range approx 10 - 25 K. The relative abundances of these chemically-related molecules in comets provide one measure of the efficiency of H-atom addition to CO Oxidation of CO is also important on grain mantles, as evidenced by the widespread presence of C02 ice towards interstellar sources observed with ISO and in a survey of 17 comets observed with AKARI. H-atom addition to C2H2 produces the vinyl radical, and through subsequent oxidation1reduction reactions can lead to vinyl alcohol, acetaldehyde, and ethanol This may have implications for interpreting observed abundance ratios CO/C2H2. We will discuss possible implications regarding formation conditions in the context of measured primary volatile compositions, emphasizing recently observed comets and published results. These are continually providing new insights regarding our taxonomic scheme and also delivery of pre-biological material to the young Earth.

DiSanti, M. A.↗

The Molecular Composition of Comet C/2007 W1 (Boattini): Evidence of a Peculiar Outgassing and a Rich Chemistry

We measured the chemical composition of Comet C/2007 W1 (Boattini) using the long-slit echelle grating spectrograph at Keck-2 (NIRSPEC) on 2008 July 9 and 10. We sampled 11 volatile species (H2O, OH*, C2H6, CH3OH, H2CO, CH4, HCN, C2H2, NH3, NH2, and CO), and retrieved three important cosmogonic indicators: the ortho-para ratios of H2O and CH4, and an upper-limit for the D/H ratio in water. The abundance ratios of almost all trace volatiles (relative to water) are among the highest ever observed in a comet. The comet also revealed a complex outgassing pattern, with some volatiles (the polar species H2O and CH3OH) presenting very asymmetric spatial profiles (extended in the anti-sunward hemisphere), while others (e.g., C2H6 and HCN) showed particularly symmetric profiles. We present emission profiles measured along the Sun-comet line for all observed volatiles, and discuss different production scenarios needed to explain them. We interpret the emission profiles in terms of release from two distinct moieties of ice, the first being clumps of mixed ice and dust released from the nucleus into the sunward hemisphere. The second moiety considered is very small grains of nearly pure polar ice (water and methanol, without dark material or apolar volatiles). Such grains would sublimate only very slowly, and could be swept into the anti-sunward hemisphere by radiation pressure and solar-actuated non-gravitational jet forces, thus providing an extended source in the anti-sunward hemisphere.

Villanueva, G. L.↗

Interpreting Methanol v(sub 2)-Band Emission in Comets Using Empirical Fluorescence g-Factors

For many years we have been developing the ability, through high-resolution spectroscopy targeting ro-vibrational emission in the approximately 3 - 5 micrometer region, to quantify a suite of (approximately 10) parent volatiles in comets using quantum mechanical fluorescence models. Our efforts are ongoing and our latest includes methanol (CH3OH). This is unique among traditionally targeted species in having lacked sufficiently robust models for its symmetric (v(sub 3) band) and asymmetric (v(sub 2) and v(sub 9) bands) C-H3 stretching modes, required to provide accurate predicted intensities for individual spectral lines and hence rotational temperatures and production rates. This has provided the driver for undertaking a detailed empirical study of line intensities, and has led to substantial progress regarding our ability to interpret CH3OH in comets. The present study concentrates on the spectral region from approximately 2970 - 3010 per centimeter (3.367 - 3.322 micrometer), which is dominated by emission in the (v(sub 7) band of C2H6 and the v(sub 2) band of CH3OH, with minor contributions from CH3OH (v(sub 9) band), CH4 (v(sub 3)), and OH prompt emissions (v(sub 1) and v(sub 2)- v(sub 1)). Based on laboratory jet-cooled spectra (at a rotational temperature near 20 K)[1], we incorporated approximately 100 lines of the CH3OH v(sub 2) band, having known frequencies and lower state rotational energies, into our model. Line intensities were determined through comparison with several comets we observed with NIRSPEC at Keck 2, after removal of continuum and additional molecular emissions and correcting for atmospheric extinction. In addition to the above spectral region, NIRSPEC allows simultaneous sampling of the CH3OH v(sub 3) band (centered at 2844 per centimeter, or 3.516 micrometers and several hot bands of H2O in the approximately 2.85 - 2.9 micrometer region, at a nominal spectral resolving power of approximately 25,000 [2]. Empirical g-factors for v(sub 2) lines were based on the production rate as determined from the v(sub 3) Q-branch intensity; application to comets spanning a range of rotational temperatures (approximately 50 - 90 K) will be reported. This work represents an extension of that presented for comet 21P/Giacobini-Zinner at the 2010 Division for Planetary Sciences meeting [3]. Our empirical study also allows for quantifying CH3OH in comets using IR spectrometers for which the v(sub 3) and v(sub 2) bands are not sampled simultaneously, for example CSHELL/NASA IRTF or CRIRES/VLT.

DiSanti, Michael↗

Ethane in Planetary and Cometary Atmospheres: Transmittance and Fluorescence Models of the nu7 Band at 3.3 Micrometers

Ethane and other hydrocarbon gases have strong rovibrational transitions in the 3.3 micron spectral region owing to C-H, CH2, and CH3 vibrational modes, making this spectral region prime for searching possible biomarker gases in extraterrestrial atmospheres (e.g., Mars, exoplanets) and organic molecules in comets. However, removing ethane spectral signatures from high-resolution terrestrial transmittance spectra has been imperfect because existing quantum mechanical models have been unable to reproduce the observed spectra with sufficient accuracy. To redress this problem, we constructed a line-by-line model for the n7 band of ethane (C2H6) and applied it to compute telluric transmittances and cometary fluorescence efficiencies. Our model considers accurate spectral parameters, vibration-rotation interactions, and a functional characterization of the torsional hot band. We integrated the new band model into an advanced radiative transfer code for synthesizing the terrestrial atmosphere (LBLRTM), achieving excellent agreement with transmittance data recorded against Mars using three different instruments located in the Northern and Southern hemispheres. The retrieved ethane abundances demonstrate the strong hemispheric asymmetry noted in prior surveys of volatile hydrocarbons. We also retrieved sensitive limits for the abundance of ethane on Mars. The most critical validation of the model was obtained by comparing simulations of C2H6 fluorescent emission with spectra of three hydrocarbon-rich comets: C/2004 Q2 (Machholz), 8P/Tuttle, and C/2007 W1 (Boattini). The new model accurately describes the complex emission morphology of the nu7 band at low rotational temperatures and greatly increases the confidence of the retrieved production rates (and rotational temperatures) with respect to previously available fluorescence models.

Villanueva, G. L.↗

Primary Volatiles During the 2010 Apparition of Comet 103P/Hartley-2 as Revealed at Infrared Wavelengths: Production Rates and Spatial Profiles

We acquired high resolution near-infrared spectra of comet 103P/Hartley-2 with NIRSPEC at the W. M. Keck Observatory and CRIRES at the ESO VLT, emphasizing primary volatiles before, during, and after the comet's close approach to Earth (July-December 2010; R(sub h) =1.62 right arrow 1.26 AU). We will present the mixing ratios for trace volatiles (C2H6, HCN, CH3OH, etc.), their rotational temperatures, and their spatial distributions in the coma both along the polar jet (UT 19.5 October) and nearly orthogonal to the jet (UT 22.5 October).

Mumma, M. J.↗

Temporal and Spatial Aspects of Gas Release During the 2010 Apparition of Comet 103P/Hartley-2

We report measurements of eight primary volatiles (H2O, HCN, CH4, C2H6, CH3OH, C2H2, H2CO, and NH3) and two product species (OH and NH2) in comet lO3P/Hartley-2 using high dispersion infrared spectroscopy. We quantified the long- and short-term behavior of volatile release over a three-month interval that encompassed the comet's close approach to Earth, its perihelion passage, and flyby of the comet by the Deep Impact spacecraft during the EPOXI mission. We present production rates for individual species, their mixing ratios relative to water, and their spatial distributions in the coma on multiple dates. The production rates for water, ethane, HCN, and methanol vary in a manner consistent with independent measures of nucleus rotation, but mixing ratios for HCN, C2H6, & CH3OH are independent of rotational phase. Our results demonstrate that the ensemble average composition of gas released from the nucleus is well defined, and relatively constant over the three-month interval (September 18 through December 1,7). If individual vents vary in composition, enough diverse vents must be active simultaneously to approximate (in sum) the bulk composition of the nucleus. The released primary volatiles exhibit diverse spatial properties which favor the presence of separate polar and apolar ice phases in the nucleus, establish dust and gas release from icy clumps, and from the nucleus, and provide insights into the driver for the cyanogen (CN) polar jet. The spatial distributions of C2H6 & HCN along the near-polar jet (UT 19.5 October) and nearly orthogonal to it (UT 22.5 October) are discussed relative to the origin of CN. The ortho-para ratio (OPR) of water was 2.85 +/- 0.20; the lower bound (2.65) defines T(sub spin) > 32 K. These values are consistent with results returned from ISO in 1997 .

Mumma, M. J.↗

Temporal and Spatial Aspects of Gas Release During the 2010 Apparition of Comet 103P/Hartley-2

We report measurements of eight primary volatiles (H2O, HCN, CH4, C2H6, CH3OH, C2H2, H2CO, and NH3) and two product species (OH and NH2) in comet 103P/Hartley-2 using high dispersion infrared spectroscopy. We present production rates for individual volatiles species, their mixing ratios relative to water, and their spatial distributions in the coma on multiple dates that span the interval Sept. - Dec. 2010. The production rates vary strongly with nucleus rotation, but the mixing ratios remain constant throughout the campaign. The released primary volatiles exhibit diverse spatial properties which favor the presence of separate polar and apolar ice phases in the nucleus, establish dust and gas release from icy clumps (and also, directly from the nucleus), and provide insights into the driver for the cyanogen (CN) polar jet.

Bonev, B. P.↗

A Comparison of Oxidized Carbon Abundances among Comets

Comets contain relatively well preserved icy material remaining from the epoch of Solar System formation, however the extent to which these ices are modified from their initial state remains a fundamental question in cometary science. As a comet approaches the Sun, sublimation of the ices contained in its nucleus (termed " native ices") releases parent volatiles into the coma, where they can be measured spectroscopically. One means of assessing the degree to which interstellar ices were processed prior to their incorporation into cometary nuclei is to measure the relative abundances of chemically-related parent volatiles. For example, formation of C2H6 by hydrogen atom addition (e.g., to C2H2) on surfaces of ice-mantled grains was proposed to explain the high C2H6 to CH4 abundance observed in C/1996 B2 (Hyakutake) [1]. The large C2H6/CH4 abundance ratios measured universally in comets, compared with those predicted by gas phase production of C2H6, establishes H-atom addition as an important and likely ubiquitous process. CO should also be hydrogenated on grain surfaces. Laboratory irradiation experiments on interstellar ice analogs indicate this to require very low temperatures (T approx. 10-25 K), the resulting yields of H2CO and CH3OH being highly dependent both on hydrogen density (i.e., fluence) and on temperature ([2],[3]). This relatively narrow range in temperature reflects a lack of mobility below 8-10 K on the one hand, and reduced sticking times for H-atoms as grain surfaces are warmed above 20 K on the other. The relative abundances of these three chemically-related molecules in comets provides one measure of the efficiency of H-atom addition to CO on pre-cometary grains (Fig. 1).

DiSanti, M. A.↗

Seasonal/Diurnal Mapping of Ozone and Water in the Martian Atmosphere

Ozone and water are key species for understanding the stability and evolution of Mars atmosphere; they are closely linked (along with CO, H, OH, and O) through photochemistry. Photolysis of water produces the OH radical (thought to catalyze reformation of CO2 from CO and O2) and atomic hydrogen (which reacts with O3 forming OH and O2). Atomic hydrogen also reacts with O2 (forming HO2), thereby reducing the amount of O2 available to reform O3 from collisions between O and O2. Hence ozone and water should be anti-correlated on Mars. Photolysis of O3 produces O2(a(sup 1) delta g) with 90% efficiency, and the resulting emission band system near 1.27 mm traces the presence and abundance of ozone. This approach was initially used to study ozone on Earth and then applied to Mars. In 1997, we measured several lines of the O2(a(sup 1) delta g) emission using CSHELL at the NASA IRTF; the O2(a(sup 1) delta g) state is also quenched by collisions with CO2. This quenching dominates at lower altitudes so that the detected emissions are used to detect ozone column densities above ~20 km. The slit was positioned N-S along Mars' central meridian resulting in a one-dimensional map of ozone. Nearly simultaneous maps may be made of water using CSHELL by detecting the v1 fundamental band of HDO near 3.67 microns and using the D/H ratio for Mars. This technique was used by DiSanti and Mumma. With CSHELL, measurements for both O2(a(sup 1) delta g) emissions and HDO absorptions can be made during the day or night. Since January, 1997, we have repeated these measurements at different times during the Martian year. For all of these dates, we have positioned the slit N-S along the central meridian; for some of these dates, we have also stepped the slit across the planet at 1 arc-sec intervals generating a 2-dimensional map. We have also positioned the slit E-W on Mars thus providing diurnal variations of ozone and water along the slit.

Novak, R. E.↗

Detection of CO and Ethane in Comet 21P/Giacobini-Zinner: Evidence for Variable Chemistry in the Outer Solar Nebula

Ethane and carbon monoxide were detected in a short-period comet of probable Kuiper belt origin. Ethane is substantially less abundant compared with Hyakutake and Hale-Bopp, two comets from the giant-planets region of the solar nebula, suggesting a heliocentric gradient in ethane in pre-cometary ices. It is argued that processing by X-rays from the young sun may be responsible.

Mumma, M. J.↗

Detection of abundant ethane and methane, along with carbon monoxide and water, in comet C/1996 B2 Hyakutake: evidence for interstellar origin

The saturated hydrocarbons ethane (C2H6) and methane (CH4) along with carbon monoxide (CO) and water (H2O) were detected in comet C/1996 B2 Hyakutake with the use of high-resolution infrared spectroscopy at the NASA Infrared Telescope Facility on Mauna Kea, Hawaii. The inferred production rates of molecular gases from the icy, cometary nucleus (in molecules per second) are 6.4 X 10(26) for C2H6, 1.2 X 10(27) for CH4, 9.8 X 10(27) for CO, and 1.7 X 10(29) for H2O. An abundance of C2H6 comparable to that of CH4 implies that ices in C/1996 B2 Hyakutake did not originate in a thermochemically equilibrated region of the solar nebula. The abundances are consistent with a kinetically controlled production process, but production of C2H6 by gas-phase ion molecule reactions in the natal cloud core is energetically forbidden. The high C2H6/CH4 ratio is consistent with production of C2H6 in icy grain mantles in the natal cloud, either by photolysis of CH4-rich ice or by hydrogen-addition reactions to acetylene condensed from the gas phase.

Non-programmatic↗

Fabry-Perot observations of Comet Halley H2O(+)

Fabry-Perot scanning spectrometer observations of Comet Halley's H2O(+) emissions have yielded 6158.64 and 6158.85 A spin doublet data at distances in the range of 0 to 2 million km from the comet heat in the antisunward direction. Cometary plasma outflow velocities were ascertained on the basis of the emissions' Doppler shifts, yielding results that were mostly but not exclusively consistent with the plasma's constant antisunward acceleration; the acceleration varied from night to night of observations over a 30-300 cm/sec range. The unusual plasma kinematics of December 14-15, 1985, and January 10, 1986, may be associated with the tail-disconnection activity observed by others.

Scherb, F.↗

Comet Halley O(1D) and H2O production rates

Ground-based dual-etalon Fabry-Perot spectrometer observations have been made of Comet Halley's forbidden O I 6300 A emission. The 0.2 A resolution of the spectral scans was sufficient to resolve the O I forbidden line emissions from both nearby cometary NH2 and telluric emissions. On the basis of these measurements, the production rate Q of O(1D) was determined; it is then found, by taking into account the photodissociation of H2O and OH as sources of O(1D), that the ratio of H2O/O(1D) production rates is of the order of 6.

Magee-Sauer, K.↗

Fabry-Perot observations of NH2 emission from Comet Halley

The (0,8,0) cometary NH2 band lines have been isolated from both cometary and terrestrial OI 6300 A OH emissions in Fabry-Perot spectra of the emissions of Comet Halley near 6300 A. On the assumption that the major source of NH2 is NH3, these NH2 measurements limit NH3's abundance relative to H2O. The results thus obtained are noted to depend on the NH2 (0,8,0) band fluorescence efficiency factor g(B); using the g(B) value of A'Hearn (1982), the NH3 abundance is found to be about 0.1 percent of that of H2O, while the g(B) value of Tegler and Wyckoff (1989) yields a figure of 0.4 percent. Both results indicate a low NH3 abundance relative to water on Comet Halley.

Magee-Sauer, K.↗

Spatial distribution of O(1D) from Comet Halley

Images of comet Halley in forbidden OI 6300-A emission obtained using a 150 mm Fabry-Perot spectrometer in the imaging mode were combined with spectra taken in the scanning mode to deduce the distribution of cometary O(1D) within a 10-arcmin field of view centered on the comet head. The 10-km/sec bandpass of the system allows the distribution to be measured with little contamination from airglow O(1D) and cometary NH2 lines in the nearby spectrum. The results are modeled to provide photodestruction scale lengths for cometary H2O and OH, the predominant parents of O(1D). Results are compared with other experimental and theoretical results.

Magee-Sauer, K.↗

Spatial distribution of O(supra 1D) from Comet Halley

Images of Comet Halley in (OI)6300A emission obtained using a 150 mm Fabry-Perot spectrometer in the imaging mode were combined with spectra taken in the scanning mode to deduce the distribution of cometary O(1D) within a 10 arc min field of view centered on the comet head. The 10 km/sec bandpass of the system allows the distribution to be measured with little contamination from airglow O(1D) and cometary NH2 lines in the nearby spectrum. The results are modeled to provide photodestruction scale lengths for cometary H2O and OH, the predominant parents of O(1D). Results are compared with other experimental and theoretical results.

Roesler, F. L.↗

Spatial distribution of 6300A emission determined from narrow-band images of Halley's Comet

In March 1986 the Wisconsin dual-etalon Fabry-Perot spectrometer was adapted for use with an intensified CCD imaging detector and good quality images of OI 6300A emission from a 10 arcmin field centered on Halley's comet head were obtained in April and May 1986. The 10 km/sec bandpass was adequate to eliminate spectral contamination from cometary NH2 and, with appropriate Doppler shifts, terrestrial airglow. The observed distribution of OI emission indicates O(sup 1)D production from 2 sources, presumably photodissociation of H2O and OH. Scale lengths are determined for the distributions of these sources in the coma.

Roesler, F. L.↗