Planning/ Preparations to Receive and Use the MSR Samples: Report of the MSPG2 Study
No abstract provided
Zorzano, Maria-Paz↗
Engineering topics
McCubbin, Francis
Publications and source records attributed to McCubbin, Francis.
Considerations for the Mars Sample Return Containment Facility
No abstract provided
McCubbin, Francis↗
Receiving and Processing Isolators and the Handling of Martian Samples Inside a BSL-4 Containment Facility
No abstract provided
McCubbin, Francis↗
A New Look at Aubrites: Investigating 3D Modal Mineralogy with X-Ray Computed Tomography
The aubrites (approximately 30 known meteorites) are a unique group of differentiated meteorites that formed on asteroids with oxygen fugacities (ƒO2) from approximately 2 to approximately 6 log units below the iron-wustite buffer. At these highly reduced conditions, elements deviate from the geochemical behavior exhibited at terrestrial ƒO2, forming FeO-poor silicates and exotic sulfides. While previous studies have described the petrology and 2D modal abundances of aubrites, this work investigates the 3D modal mineralogies of silicate, metal, and sulfide phases in aubrite samples, which are then compared to the available 2D data. In addition to 3D modal mineralogies, we have examined the geochemistry of fourteen aubrites, including mineral major-element compositions, bulk-rock compositions, and oxygen isotopic compositions to understand their formation and evolution at extreme ƒO2 conditions. We utilize X-ray computed tomography (XCT) to non-destructively analyze the distribution and abundances of mineral phases in aubrites and locate composite clasts of sulfide grains for future analytical study. In order to better constrain elemental behavior under reduced conditions, we specifically target minerals phases that comprise moderately volatile elements (i.e. oldhamite [CaS], caswellsilverite [NaCrS2] and djerfisherite [K6Na(Fe,Cu,Ni)25S26Cl]) as it has been shown that their geochemical behavior changes as a function of ƒO2. Currently, we have produced 3D scans of the Norton County aubrite. The results of the XCT data have allowed for the determination of the abundances of silicate groundmass (i.e., enstatite, forsterite, albite, and diopside), light (based on electron density) sulfides (i.e. alabandite [MnS] and daubréelite [FeCr2S4]), heavy (based on electron density) sulfides (i.e., troilite [FeS]), and Fe,Ni metal by segmenting a density histogram in Volume Graphics Studio software. XCT scans of additional aubrites are underway. By combining the 3D representation of the exotic phases found in aubrites with existing 2D characterizations, we are able to better determine modal abundances. By integrating 3D and 2D modal abundances and geochemistry, we can ultimately better constrain aubrite petrogenesis and elemental partitioning under reduced conditions. Furthermore, application of this new 3D approach offers the opportunity to identify and select clasts for future study prior to cutting the sample, which will minimize sample loss of this precious material.
Wilbur, Zoe↗
Advanced Curation Development of Tools and Methods for Microparticle Curation
The Astromaterials Acquisition and Curation Office at NASA Johnson Space Center is currently developing new tools and methods for the collection, storage, handling and characterization of particles less than 100 microns in diameter, or microparticles. Astromaterials Curation currently maintains four microparticle collections: Cosmic Dust that has been collected in Earth’s stratosphere by ER2 and WB-57 aircraft, Comet 81P/Wild 2 dust returned by NASA’s Stardust spacecraft, interstellar dust that was returned by Stardust, and asteroid Itokawa particles that were returned by the JAXA (Japan Aerospace Exploration Agency)’s Hayabusa spacecraft. NASA Curation is currently preparing for the anticipated return of two new astromaterials collections – asteroid Ryugu regolith to be collected by Hayabusa II spacecraft in 2021 (samples will be provided by JAXA as part of an international agreement), and asteroid Bennu regolith to be collected by the OSIRIS-REx (Origins Spectral Interpretation Resource Identification Security - Regolith Explorer) spacecraft in 2023. In order to maximize the scientific yield from these valuable acquisitions, it will be necessary to develop methods that extend our current microsample handling capabilities. Here we describe recent progress in the development of sample handling techniques that will enhance our microparticle curation capabilities. Further described are: Six-Axis Robot Arms for Particle Manipulation, and Charge-Dissipative Substrates.
Snead, Christopher↗
Tracing the Evolution of Hydrogen in the Martian Crust Through Laboratory Studies of Apatite
Introduction: Northwest Africa (NWA) 7034 and its pairings represent a regolith breccia of basaltic bulk composition, the finegrained matrix of which bears a strong resemblance to the major and trace element composition estimated for the ancient southern highlands crust on Mars. Therefore, NWA 7034 may represent a key sample for constraining the composition of the Martian crust, particularly the ancient highlands. Here we seek to constrain the hydrogen isotopic composition of the Martian crust using apatite [Ca5 (PO4)3(Cl,F,OH)]. Apatites across all lithologic domains in NWA 7034 have been affected by a Pb-loss event at ~1.5 Ga before present and so they are unlikely to have retained magmatic volatile composition and are more likely to have equilibrated with fluids within the Martian crust that may or may not have exchanged with the Martian atmosphere.
Barnes, Jessica↗
Calculating the Modal Mineralogy of Aubrite Meteorites Using X-Ray Computed Tomography
The aubrites are a group of differentiated meteorites that formed in extremely reducing conditions, with oxygen fugacities (ƒO2) ranging from ~2 to ~6 log units below the Iron-Wüstite buffer. At these extreme conditions, elements that are lithophile (silica-loving) on Earth can behave as chalcophiles (sulfur-loving) or siderophiles (metal-loving), and FeO-poor silicates and exotic sulfides can form. Elemental partitioning among minerals at these conditions are still not well understood, thus studying aubrites could help better constrain elemental behavior. Only 30 aubrites exist; however, they display various textures, which can be difficult to identify in small samples. Identifying composite clasts can help in understanding the igneous history of the aubrite parent bodies. In order to distinguish different minerals and textures in larger samples, we use X-ray computed tomography (XCT), which is a useful, non-destructive analysis that can produce a 3D representation of a meteorite's textures, structures, and modal mineralogy. This study investigates the Norton County aubrite using XCT. Norton County is a fragmental impact breccia aubrite, and was an observed fall with a main mass of 1.1 tons. This large amount of material offers an opportunity to investigate a great volume of reduced, aubritic sample and study a more diverse variety of clasts. Here we report XCT results of two samples of Norton County (NC 15417) in order to constrain the 3D modal mineralogy of silicates, sulfides, and metals, and to identify unique clasts within the matrix.
Wilbur, Zoe↗
NASA's Astromaterials Acquisition and Curation Office: Enabling 50 Years of Lunar and Planetary Research, Now Heading to Mars
No abstract available
Evans, Cynthia↗
From Apollo to the Future, the NASA Curation Model for Engaging the Sample Science Community Maximizes Science on Extraterrestrial Samples
The Astromaterials Acquisition and Curation Office at Johnson Space Center (JSC) has enjoyed a long-term partnership (50 years!) with a broad community of planetary sample scientists. This partnership has enabled the curators of planetary samples to plan for and enact evolving requirements for preservation of sample scientific integrity and for handling and long-term storage. The basis for this relationship is a standing peer review advisory committee composed of leading scientists who are recognized for achievements in sample analysis. The committee and its descendants have brought familiarity with the most relevant scientific investigations and the associated analytical and contamination challenges. Beginning with Apollo, the review committee was charged with oversight of curatorial operations and with ensuring fair access to samples. As additional samples from other planetary bodies were acquired, the committee evolved, taking on new responsibilities, reflected in committee name changes. However, oversight of curatorial operations and fair allocation of samples remain basic responsibilities. Committee recommendations are sent to the NASA Headquarters Discipline Scientist for approval. To minimize conflict of interest and maximize fair access, the rules governing the make-up of the committee is structured. Systematic rotation of leadership and staggered terms of membership allow the committee to retain expertise while bringing in fresh ideas. The first peer review committee was called the Lunar Sample Analysis and Planning Team (LSAPT) and was formalized in early 1968 with about 15 members. Their function was to review a) the equipment and procedures used in the new Lunar Receiving Laboratory (LRL); b) the proficiency and capability of the LRL staff; c) the sequence of sample analysis and allocation after quarantine release; and d) the findings of the Preliminary Examination Team (PET). According to LSAPT member Gerald Wasserburg, one of the first issues they faced was deciding whether to have most of the sample analyses performed in house at the LRL or to distribute samples to members of the scientific community. LSAPT concluded that the major scientific investigations should be carried out externally to the LRL by scientists chosen for their expertise in specific disciplines. Further they recommended that the PET's basic characterization of samples be circulated to the broad scientific community. LSAPT set its own agenda, paid attention to facility details, closely monitored the move of samples from the LRL to the interim curatorial facility in 1973, and was active in inspecting curation facilities. Between 1975 and 1979, a Facility Subcommittee of LSAPT oversaw the design and construction of a permanent facility for preservation of lunar samples. The result was an outstanding facility still in use today. In 1977, a separate peer review committee, the Meteorite Working Group (MWG), was formed to evaluate requests for new meteorites then being collected in Antarctica under what would in 1980 become a 3-agency agreement (National Science Foundation, NASA, Smithsonian Institution). By 1979, after lunar samples were moved into the new permanent facility, the vacated gloveboxes and laboratory were prepared for meteorite curation. Recognizing that LSAPT had been helpful in setting up the JSC curatorial facility for Antarctic meteorites, JSC recommended the review committee be given expanded duties, including advice on curation and analysis of materials from other planetary bodies and the name be changed to Lunar and Planetary Sample Team (LAPST). In 1993, LAPST was renamed the Curation and Analysis Planning Team for Extraterrestrial Materials (CAPTEM) to reflect additional functions. CAPTEM is chartered to be (1) a community-based, interdisciplinary forum for discussion and analysis of matters concerning the collection and curation of extraterrestrial samples, including planning future sample return missions and (2) a standing review panel, charged with evaluating proposals requesting allocation of all extraterrestrial samples contained in NASA collections. Efficiency and flexibility are gained through use of subcommittees, both ad hoc and standing. Transition of the MWG to a subcommittee of CAPTEM was completed in 2017. Today subcommittees review allocation requests for lunar samples, Antarctic meteorites, cosmic dust, Stardust cometary samples, Genesis solar wind samples, and samples returned from asteroids. Other subcommittees address facilities, informatics, and micro-cratered substrates. Planetary samples have been sent to research teams in over 30 countries world-wide. The expertise in the care and fair distribution of astromaterials by NASA using this model spans generations of planetary sample scientists and is a valuable resource to be tapped for future sample returns - OSIRIS-REx, Hayabusa 2, and Mars 2020.
Allton, Judith↗
Experimental Study into the Partitioning Behavior of Fluorine, Chlorine, Hydroxyl, and Sulfur (S2-) Between Apatite and a Synthetic Kreep Basalt Melt
The mineral apatite (Ca5 (PO4)3(F, Cl, OH)) is known for its ability to constrain the petrogenesis of the rock in which it is hosted and for its ubiquity throughout the Solar System, as it is found in lunar, martian, and terrestrial rocks alike (McCubbin et. al, 2015). The abundance of volatile elements, and for this particular study, the elevated abundance of sulfur (S2-) in high-Al basalt samples bearing apatite, could provide more insight for inquiries posed about the behavior of volatiles in lunar and martian magmatic systems (Boyce et. al, 2010). Oxygen fugacity will be an important parameter for these experiments, as the Moon, Mars, and Earth have different redox states (Herd, 2008). The objective of this experimental endeavor is to determine apatite-melt partition coefficients for the volatile elements (F-, Cl-, OH-, S2-) that make up the X-site (i.e., the typically monovalent anion site) in the mineral apatite in a lunar melt composition under lunar oxygen fugacity conditions approx.1-2 log units below the iron-wüstite buffer). All experiments will be conducted at NASA, Johnson Space Center in the High Pressure Experimental Petrology Laboratory. In order to conduct apatite-melt partition experiments with oxygen fugacity as an additional parameter, we will create a synthetic mix of the lunar KREEP basalt 15386, a sample retrieved during Apollo 15 that is believed to represent an indigenous volcanic melt derived from the lunar interior (Rhodes, J.M et. al, 2006). Other geochemically significant elements including C, Co, Ni, Mo, and rare earth elements will be included in the mix at trace abundances in order to assess their partitioning behavior without effecting the overall behavior of the system. The synthetic mix will then be loaded into a piston cylinder, an apparatus used to simulate high-pressure/high-temperature conditions of planetary interiors, and exposed to 0.5 GPa of pressure, the pressure observed in the upper mantle of the Moon, and heated to the melting temperature of the materials. To make sure crystals grow large enough for the necessary analyses, the sample will be kept at the crystallization temperature for 8 hours. This extended run time should also allow the sample to achieve a steady state which is necessary to accurately assess the partitioning of these elements between apatite and melt. The results from this experimental study will allow us to determine the fate of F-, Cl-, OH-, and S2- during the magmatic evolution of the Moon.
Turner, Amber↗
Evidence for a Heterogeneous Distribution of Water in the Martian Interior
The abundance and distribution of H2O within the terrestrial planets, as well as its timing of delivery, is a topic of vital importance for understanding the chemical and physical evolution of planets and their potential for hosting habitable environments. Analysis of planetary materials from Mars, the Moon, and the eucrite parent body (i.e., asteroid 4Vesta) have confirmed the presence of H2O within their interiors. Moreover, H and N isotopic data from these planetary materials suggests H2O was delivered to the inner solar system very early from a common source, similar in composition to the carbonaceous chondrites. Despite the ubiquity of H2O in the inner Solar System, the only destination with any prospects for past or present habitable environments at this time, outside of the Earth, is Mars. Although the presence of H2O within the martian interior has been confirmed, very little is known regarding its abundance and distribution within the martian interior and how the martian water inventory has changed over time. By combining new analyses of martian apatites within a large number of martian meteorite types with previously published volatile data and recently determined mineral-melt partition coefficients for apatite, we report new insights into the abundance and distribution of volatiles in the martian crust and mantle. Using the subset of samples that did not exhibit crustal contamination, we determined that the enriched shergottite mantle source has 36-73 ppm H2O and the depleted shergottite mantle source has 14-23 ppm H2O. This result is consistent with other observed geochemical differences between enriched and depleted shergottites and supports the idea that there are at least two geochemically distinct reservoirs in the martian mantle. We also estimated the H2O content of the martian crust using the revised mantle H2O abundances and known crust-mantle distributions of incompatible lithophile elements. We determined that the bulk martian crust has approximately 1400 ppm H2O, which is likely distributed toward the martian surface. This crustal water abundance would equate to a global equivalent layer (GEL) of water at a depth of-229 m, which can account for at least some of the surface features on Mars attributed to flowing water and may be sufficient to support the past presence of a shallow sea on Mars' surface.
McCubbin, Francis↗
Curating NASA's Future Extraterrestrial Sample Collections: How Do We Achieve Maximum Proficiency?
The Astromaterials Acquisition and Curation Office (henceforth referred to herein as NASA Curation Office) at NASA Johnson Space Center (JSC) is responsible for curating all of NASA's extraterrestrial samples. Under the governing document, NASA Policy Directive (NPD) 7100.10E "Curation of Extraterrestrial Materials", JSC is charged with "The curation of all extraterrestrial material under NASA control, including future NASA missions." The Directive goes on to define Curation as including "... documentation, preservation, preparation, and distribution of samples for research, education, and public outreach." Here we describe some of the ongoing efforts to ensure that the future activities of the NASA Curation Office are working towards a state of maximum proficiency.
McCubbin, Francis↗
Endogenous Lunar Volatiles: Insights into the Abundances of Volatiles in the Moon from Lunar Apatite
At the time of publication of New Views of the Moon, it was thought that the Moon was bone dry with less than about 1 ppb H2O. However in 2007, initial reports at the 38th Lunar and Planetary Science Conference speculated that H-species were present in both apatites and pyroclastic volcanic lunar glasses. These early reports were later confirmed through peer-review, which motivated many subsequent studies on magmatic volatiles in and on the Moon within the last decade. Some of these studies have cast into question the post-Apollo view of lunar formation, the distribution and sources of volatiles in the Earth-Moon system, and the thermal and magmatic evolution of the Moon. The mineral apatite has been one of the pillars of this new field of study, and it will be the primary focus of this abstract. Although apatite has been used both to understand the abundances of volatiles in lunar systems as well as the isotopic compositions of those volatiles, the focus here will be on the abundances of F, Cl, and H2O. This work demonstrates the utility of apatite in advancing our understanding of lunar volatiles, hence apatite should be among the topics covered in the endogenous lunar volatile chapter in NVM II. Truncated ternary plot of apatite X-site occupancy (mol%) from highlands apatite and mare basalt apatite plotted on the relative volatile abundance diagram from. The solid black lines delineate fields of relative abundances of F, Cl, and H2O (on a weight basis) in the melt from which the apatite crystallized. The diagram was constructed using available apatite/melt partitioning data for fluorine, chlorine, and hydroxyl.
McCubbin, Francis↗