Search NASA⌕ Search

Engineering topics

McMath, G. E.

Publications and source records attributed to McMath, G. E..

Predicting Solar Modulation Potentials for Modeling Cosmic Background Radiation

The modeling of the detectability of special nuclear material (SNM) at ports and border crossings requires accurate knowledge of the background radiation at those locations. Background radiation originates from two main sources, cosmic and terrestrial. Cosmic background is produced by high-energy galactic cosmic rays (GCR) entering the atmosphere inducing a cascade of particles that eventually impact the earth's surface. The solar modulation potential represents one of the primary inputs to modeling cosmic background radiation. Usoskin et al. formally define solar modulation potential as 'the mean energy loss [per unit charge, in units of megavolts (MV),] of a cosmic ray particle inside the heliosphere...'. Modulation potential, a function of elevation, location, and time, shares an inverse relationship with cosmic background radiation. As a result, radiation detector background thresholds require adjustment to account for differing background levels, caused in part by differing solar modulations. Failure to do this can result in higher rates of false positives and failed detection of SNM during low and high levels of solar modulation potential, respectively. This study focuses on solar modulation's time dependence and seeks the best method to predict modulation for future dates. The best method will be incorporated into NINESIM, a discrete event simulator. An in-depth description of NINESIM is beyond the scope and purpose of this paper. (authors)

46 INSTRUMENTATION RELATED TO NUCLEAR SCIENCE AND ↗

MCNP 6.2.0 Delayed-Particle Production Improvements

Development began on a delayed-particle physics package for the Monte Carlo Radiation transport code MCNPX in 2004 incorporating the CINDER90 depletion code and delayed particle libraries. When MCNP5 was merged with MCNPX to form MCNP6 in 2010, this delayed-particle capability was passed on and has been continuously improved in subsequent versions of MCNP6. Today, the delayed-particle feature in MCNP6 allows for the production of delayed neutrons, gammas, betas, and alpha particles. Future development includes the addition of delayed-positron production in the next release of MCNP6. Delayed particles can be sampled with MCNP using the ACT card in conjunction with the FISSION and NONFISS keywords. The user can specify one or more of the four available delayed-particle types mentioned above on one or both of the FISSION and NONFISS keywords. If a delayed-particle type is selected on the FISSION keyword, then delayed production of that particle from fission products and their progeny will be produced. Likewise, if a delayed-particle type is selected on the NONFISS keyword then delayed production of that particle from non-fission interactions and spontaneous decay will be produced. In some cases, the sheer number of delayed particles that can be produced from nuclear reactions and spontaneous decay (i.e. hundreds of delayed gamma lines when spontaneous fission is possible) can make it difficult to achieve converged solutions in an efficient and timely manner. Truncation methods are the simplest form of variance reduction and can be used to decrease convergence times by limiting calculations to the phase space of interest. This paper introduces several such truncation methods that allow the user to restrict the number of possible delayed particles available for sampling to only those of interest in the problem. It is important to stress that the use of any truncation method should be verified by first assessing the impact of the truncated particles (i.e. by disabling the truncation) for one or more baseline cases. In addition to these new methods, a new delayed-gamma sampling algorithm implemented in MCNP 6.2.0 is introduced. Comparisons to ENDF data and analytical benchmarking with the new algorithm show a substantial improvement in accuracy over previous versions. New improvements to the delayed-particle capability have been added to MCNP 6.2.0. These improvements include an updated treatment of the THRESH keyword which omits delayed-particle lines below a set amplitude, and addition of the PECUT and HLCUT keywords which allow the user to truncate delayed-particles lines based on energy and half-life, respectively. The delayed-gamma sampling algorithm has also been improved to allow exact energy sampling. Comparisons of MCNP calculations directly to ENDF data and analytical benchmarks have verified the significant improvement in the new delayed gamma sampling algorithm. (authors)

97 MATHEMATICS AND COMPUTING↗

Comparing Thick Target Neutron Yield Calculations for Alphas on F-19 using MCNP6 1.1 Beta with TENDL 2012 Libraries

Because of the heritage of MCNPX, the first production release of MCNP6{sup TM} used physics models, instead of ACE (A Compact Evaluated Nuclear Data File) formatted libraries, for simulating the transport of alpha particles at all energies, as MCNPX could not yet read ACE formatted light ion libraries. For non-Coulombic interactions, the physics models have suggested minimums of ∼ 20-200 MeV. The first production release of MCNP6, MCNP6{sup TM} 1.0, was still capable of transporting alphas to low energies; however, the physics models resulted in poor prediction of inelastic reactions at energies below the suggested minimums. This poorer prediction at low energies resulted in orders of magnitude lower neutron yields for events resulting from light ion interactions at low energies. For example, F-19(α,n)Na-22 from U-234 decay in UF{sub 6} produced poor neutron production results. Modeling these types of interactions correctly is vital for signal analysis for nonproliferation safeguards and nuclear security as well as for correctly characterizing source terms for radiation protection and shielding calculations. The TALYS computer code was developed to simulate nuclear reactions involving neutrons, photons, protons, deuterons, tritons, alphas and He-3 particles, in the 1 keV - 200 MeV energy range. TENDL is a nuclear data library, which provides the output of the TALYS nuclear model code system for direct use in applications (i.e. ACE formatted cross sections). Since 2008, TENDL had publicly provided ACE formatted libraries for alpha transport; however, not until the release of MCNP6{sup TM} 1.1 beta, had MCNP6 publicly possessed the capability to read such libraries. At the Radiation Protection and Shielding Division topical meeting in 2014, initial testing of MCNP6 1.1 beta showed that MCNP6 using TENDL 2012 resulted in poor prediction when compared to the compilation of experiment data provided in R. Heaton et al. Further comparisons for PuBe sources, using the MCNP6 1.1 beta spontaneous decay alpha feature coupled with alpha transport, were also given in the winter American Nuclear Society meeting in 2014, where the results showed large discrepancies with measured data. For F-19(α,n)Na-22 interactions, the R. Heaton et al. paper is a conglomeration of several important references; and the data provided by R. Heaton et al. used a numerical fit of the excitation function provided by Norman et al.. Norman et al. has recently published their (α,n) thick target yield data for PbF{sub 2} in tabular form, backing out the thick target yields of F-19(α,n)Na-22 and computing F{sub 2} and UF{sub 6} thick target neutron yields (as supplements to the PbF{sub 2} data). Here we compared measured thick target yields of E. B. Norman et al. to MCNP6 1.1 beta using TENDL 2012 libraries. Deterministically backing out the thick target yield from measured values involves using the stopping power. MCNP uses either the SPAR code or an interpolation of the Spar code and Bethe-Boch formula for computing stopping powers. As a result one may believe that these separate methods will arrive at separate thick target yields independent of the production cross section. In our MCNP calculations, we simulated the alpha until the alpha completely stopped in the medium. The energy loss in the condensed history algorithm is not continuous but discrete and related to the stopping powers. Because the neutron production yield is energy dependent, the energy loss dictates the emission of secondary neutrons; and therefore the difference in stopping powers used may have some slight effect on the yield difference. For this study, we chose to use the default condensed history algorithm setup, while future studies should address tightening steps in the condensed history algorithm to prove whether or not choice of stopping power actually matters. The fact that all 5 evaluated isotopic compositions resulted in different thick target yield percent differences does warrant this type of investigation. A typical user may not be only interested in integral emission, taking 10 s to 100 s of processor hours to simulate, but rather a timely generation of the spectra. Such an application would require biasing the production of secondaries from alpha sources such that millions of secondaries could be produced, emulating a converged energy dependent spectra. Neutron production biasing from alpha sources does not currently exist; however, developing a biasing algorithm for neutron production from alpha sources should be investigated in the future.

73 NUCLEAR PHYSICS AND RADIATION PHYSICS↗

MCNP6 Study of Spatial Fidelity Required for ROC Curve Convergence

The detection of special nuclear material at ports and borders is one of the primary missions of the Department of Homeland Security's (DHS) Domestic Nuclear Detection Office (DNDO). In support of this mission a large-scale modeling and simulation effort has been undertaken with the goal of providing a comprehensive tool-kit that addresses the complexity of problems involved with developing and maintaining technologies deployed to global nuclear detection architecture (GNDA) nodes. An important objective of DNDO's mission is to characterize detector system performance before deployment. In the effort to support this mission, the latest version of MCNP has been used to perform detectability studies of highly enriched uranium (HEU) to populate a database that will be used for the tool-kit. The characterization method used in the implementation of the database is the receiver operating characteristic (ROC). A ROC curve shows the limits of detectability of a given system as well as an overall metric of the efficacy of a detection system. This is accomplished by comparing total detector count distributions to the count distribution produced by background alone. For an in-depth explanation of the theory behind the MCNP production of ROC curves please refer to the paper, 'How To Use The Receiver Operating Characteristic Tally Option in MCNP6'. Building a useful database requires an expansive parameter space. The current tool-kit use nine parameters, which if varied with just 5 options each, results in nearly two million simulations to run. Depending on the set of parameters these simulations can take a few hours or a few weeks to complete. This computational cost necessitates the use of scaling algorithms to interpolate between the data contained in the database. The tool-kit employs a discrete event method to simulate the movement and detector response of special nuclear material (SNM) through a GNDA node. Given the nature of a discrete event simulation, constant motion of SNM must be split up in to discrete spatial detection points. The fidelity required of the spatial splitting to achieve a properly converged answer is investigated here for a neutron detection system. The detector used was a SNAP-3 neutron detector in front of a sphere of SNM in the presence of background radiation. A parameter study has been performed to determine the spatial fidelity required for ROC curve convergence for moving objects in a discrete event simulator. It appears that 5 points is the minimum number of detection points with 7 points needed for one of the parameter sets. The convergence worsens with increases to detection length but appears to improve with increasing detector distance. These results will help future work involving quantifying the accuracy based on given tolerances and parameters. (authors)

46 INSTRUMENTATION RELATED TO NUCLEAR SCIENCE AND ↗