Search NASA⌕ Search

Engineering topics

McMurtrey, Michael

Publications and source records attributed to McMurtrey, Michael.

Updated ASME design correlations and qualification plan for powder bed fusion 316H stainless steel

This report provides an update on the Advanced Materials and Manufacturing Technologies (AMMT) program effort to qualify Laser-Powder Bed Fusion (L-PBF) 316H stainless steel for use with the ASME Boiler & Pressure Vessel Code Section III, Division 5 rules. The report summarizes progress in testing and characterizing L-PBF material at elevated temperatures by providing preliminary design data for L-PBF 316H and by comparing the elevated temperature performance of the L-PBF material to wrought and conventional fusion welded 316H. The report then updates the initial AMMT qualification plan for L-PBF 316H, originally developed in 2023, to update the accelerated qualification strategy adopted in that plan to account for the new high temperature test data. The report also explores a few methods for further accelerating the qualification process using machine learning techniques to supplement the more conventional, empirical analysis methods typically used by ASME to correlate and extrapolate time-dependent material test data.

36 MATERIALS SCIENCE↗

FY24 Integrated Results for High-Temperature Mechanical Testing of LPBF 316H Stainless Steel

This report provides the mechanical test data of laser powder bed fusion (LPBF) 316H stainless steel (SS) collected during Fiscal Year 2024 (FY 24) under the US Department of Energy, Office of Nuclear Energy’s Advanced Materials and Manufacturing Technologies program, along with the current state of microstructural-based understandings of the behaviors. Materials with variabilities in manufacturing site, machine, laser parameters, powder chemistry, porosity, specimen geometry and heat treatment were tested in high-temperature tension, creep, fatigue and creep-fatigue. Electron microscopy and optical microscopy were performed on selected materials before and after the tests to provide microstructural-based understandings to the mechanical behavior. It was discovered that the as-built (AB) and stress-relieved (SR) materials exhibit similar behaviors in tension and creep, as do the solution-annealed (SA) and hot-isostatic pressed (HIP) materials. The AB and SR materials are softer but more ductile than the SA and HIP materials in tension. In creep, the LPBF materials have comparable rupture times but lower rupture strains compared to the wrought materials. The AB and SR materials have low creep rupture strains (<10%) when tested at 720°C and 800°C, while the SA and HIP materials are much more ductile. The LPBF materials exhibit large scatter in fatigue and creep-fatigue lives. The cyclic lives of creep-fatigue tests are lower than those of fatigue tests. In fatigue and creep-fatigue, SR materials outperform SA materials. A common observation from the cyclic tests is that, given the same post-build heat treatment, a lower initial peak stress generally results in a longer cyclic life regardless of hold time. It was also discovered that the batch variation can be more impactful than heat treatment, as demonstrated by the overall better performance of one batch of material than another, regardless of the heat treatment. The results provided insights into how different factors impact the behaviors of LPBF 316H SS. An outlook to FY 25 work scope is provided.

36 MATERIALS SCIENCE↗

Sensors for passively measuring a maximum temperature of a nuclear reactor, and related methods

A sensor for passively measuring a maximum temperature within a nuclear reactor comprises a substrate, and a plurality of melt wires within a cavity defined within the substrate, at least one melt wire of the plurality of melt wires exhibiting a variable melting temperature along a length of the at least one melt wire. Related sensors and methods of forming the sensors are also disclosed.

Daw, Joshua↗

ASME Code Qualification Plan for LPBF 316 SS

This report describes a plan to qualify laser powder bed fusion (LPBF) 316 stainless steel for use with the American Society of Mechanical Engineers (ASME) Boiler & Pressure Vessel Code Section III, Division 5 rules for metallic components in high temperature nuclear reactors. Accomplishing this goal would make the material and manufacturing process available to vendors for inclusion in the next generation of advanced, high temperature reactors. The general approach adopted here is to treat LPBF 316 as if it was a completely new material and to develop a plan to qualify the material according to the current ASME practices. One key goal of this work is to explore and develop accelerated qualification approaches that might reduce the time required to qualify new materials by reducing the need for long term testing. However, the qualification plan here does not employ any accelerated qualification approaches to provide a limiting, bounding description of the number, duration, and types of testing required to qualify LPBF 316 without such techniques and to describe a comprehensive dataset that could be used to explore and validate accelerated qualification approaches in the future. The report addresses the fundamental challenges to qualifying Advanced Manufacturing (AM) materials for high temperature applications and summarizes the ASME Section III qualification process as well as current efforts to qualify LBPF and DED 316 for low temperature applications. The report then discusses specific issues, both material and logistical, related to qualifying PBF 316 steel. The final chapters of the report describe a complete test plan designed to generate sufficient data to qualify the material as well as a data management plan for how to store and manage the data to eventually provide the test data packaged needed to qualify the material with ASME.

22 GENERAL STUDIES OF NUCLEAR REACTORS↗

srlife: A Fast Tool for High Temperature Receiver Design and Analysis

This report describes a tool for estimating the structural service life of tubular, panel solar receivers operating at high temperatures. A complete version of the tool is available as open source software at https://github.com/Argonne-National-Laboratory/srlife and can be installed through the PyPi (https://pypi.org) package manager. Given the basic receiver geometry and the thermal loads on the receiver, the tool provides 1D, 2D, or 3D thermal and structural (single tube and simplified system) analysis and creep-fatigue service life prediction for six metallic alloys – 316H, 800H, Alloy 617, Alloy 740H, and Alloy 230. With the exception of Alloy 230 where the material data is preliminary, the software included a detailed set of models for the materials, well-supported by high temperature experimental test data. The tool is designed for easy integration with a software stack, including solar field and thermohydraulic simulations, for optimizing receiver designs to meet service life and economic targets. The report describes several heuristics that can be applied in srlife to reduce the analysis time by several orders of magnitude but with fairly accurate life estimation when compared with full analysis. The report provides several examples demonstrating the utility of srlife in receiver design. Finally, the report discusses high temperature tests on Alloy 282, collected as part of this project, used to develop and support the material model for that alloy.

47 OTHER INSTRUMENTATION↗

Orientation-selected micro-pillar compression of additively manufactured 316L stainless steels: Comparison of as-manufactured, annealed, and proton-irradiated variants

In this work, irradiation response and deformation mechanisms of additively manufactured (AM) 316L stainless steel were studied by atomic scale characterization and micro-pillar compression. The AM 316L stainless steels were fabricated by direct energy deposition, a laser-based additive manufacturing process. Irradiation with 2 MeV protons at 360°C was performed to create ~1.8 displacements-per-atom (dpa) damage in AM 316L. Deformation behaviors of the as-manufactured, annealed, and proton-irradiated variants were studied, focusing on the effects of manufacturing-induced pores, residual stress, and irradiation-introduced defects (dislocation loops and voids). Micro-pillars were prepared from grains of pre-selected orientation, avoiding contributions of grain boundaries and allowing determination of resolved shear stress on {111} glide planes. Transmission electron microscopy was used to characterize the pre- and post-deformation microstructure. It was found that in the as-manufactured alloy variant, moving dislocations were the major deformation carrier, with noticeable blocking by fabrication-induced pores, In the annealed variant, hardness was reduced, and deformation was also accomplished by dislocation gliding. In the proton-irradiated variant, significant twinning was observed. Comparing measured resolved shear stress and predicted critical stress for dislocation dissociation, we conclude that irradiation hardening became high enough to activate twinning. Therefore, the deformation mechanism changes from dislocation gliding to twinning. The study is important for both processing optimization and performance evaluation of AM alloys for reactor applications.

36 MATERIALS SCIENCE↗

Design Guidance for High Temperature Concentrating Solar Power Components

This report provides guidance for the design of components for concentrating power facilities operating at high temperatures and undergoing high, secondary thermal stresses relative to the applied primary pressure stress. The design rules were developed for the design of Generation 3 CSP tubular receivers manufactured from Alloy 740H, but are generally applicable to a wide range of component types undergoing similar loads. Part 1 of the report provides procedural design rules for components to be used in conjunction with the 2019 edition of the ASME Boiler & Pressure Vessel Code. Part 2 provides corresponding design data for Alloy 740H. Part 3 of the report is a commentary describing the rationale behind the design rules and the data underlying the design material properties. Finally, Part 4 provides an extensive set of worked sample problems detailing the application of the rules to CSP components.

24 POWER TRANSMISSION AND DISTRIBUTION↗

Notch Effects on the Short Term Rupture Properties of Alloy 617 Base Metal and Weldments

Alloy 617 is currently undergoing approval for inclusion in the ASME Boiler and Pressure Vessel Code in Section III Division 5 for use in high temperature nuclear reactors. Prior to use in construction of these reactors, however, it must be approved by the Nuclear Regulatory Commission. Several concerns relating to the effects of geometric discontinuities, such as notches and multi-axial stress states (as opposed to uniaxial stress states typically present in laboratory run creep tests), must first be addressed. Alloy 617 has been found to be notch-strengthening in short term (1000-2500 hour) creep testing for both base metal and weld metal and will fail preferentially in a straight gauge section rather than at a sharp notch, provided that the applied stresses are similar in both the straight gauge and notch sections. Additionally, specimens designed with semi-circular notches (or U notches, as they are referred to in this report) to impose multi-axial stress states on the specimen during creep-testing were found to either maintain similar creep-rupture-lives as uniaxial stress specimens tested at similar conditions, or have creep-rupture-lives that were significantly longer. This work shows that notches and multi-axial stress states do not appear to raise concerns with relation to the use of design rules created for Alloy 617 using smooth, straight-gauge test specimens and uniaxial creep tests.

22 GENERAL STUDIES OF NUCLEAR REACTORS↗

Report on the FY18 creep rupture and creep-fatigue tests on the first commercial heat of Alloy 709

Creep, fatigue and creep-fatigue tests were performed on the Carlson plate of Alloy 709 (ID 58776). The plate, which is the first of the commercial heats tested, was divided into several sections, each undergoing different processing conditions. The effects of processing method and solution annealing temperature were studied in FY18 to inform best procedures for the second heat. The solution annealing temperature of 1050°C was found to be unacceptable due to the grain size being smaller than allowed by the specifications, as well as generally having poor creep properties. Both argon oxygen decarburization AOD and electro-slag remeltin ESR were found to have desirable properties, and the homogenization heat treatment was found to not significantly improve the mechanical properties.

11 NUCLEAR FUEL CYCLE AND FUEL MATERIALS↗

Overview of Alloy 617 Notched Specimen Testing

Prior to use in high temperature nuclear applications, Alloy 617, which is currently undergoing approval for inclusion in codes and regulations related to high temperature construction, must be approved by the Nuclear Regulatory Commission. Several concerns relating to the effects of geometric discontinuities, such as notches, and multi-axial stress states (as opposed to uniaxial stress states typically present in laboratory run creep tests) must first be addressed. This work has shown that at short time intervals (1000-2500 hours), 617 is notch strengthening and will fail preferentially at locations away from the notch, provided that diameters are similar (resulting in similar stresses). Additionally, specimens designed with semi-circular notches (or U-notches, as they are referred to in this report) to impose multi-axial stress states on the specimen during creep testing were found to either maintain similar creep rupture lives as uniaxial stress specimens tested at similar conditions, or have creep rupture lives that were significantly longer. This work, while not fully completed, shows that notches and multi-axial stress states do not appear to raise concerns with relation to the use of design rules created for Alloy 617 using smooth, straight gauge test specimens and uniaxial creep tests.

11 NUCLEAR FUEL CYCLE AND FUEL MATERIALS↗

Microstructural Effects on Creep-Fatigue Life of Alloy 709

Creep-fatigue tests were performed on plates of Alloy 709 from various heats and processing conditions, but often with inhomogeneous microstructures. After testing, metallographic analysis was performed and the specimens were generally found to either have a uniform grain size or a bimodal grain size distribution with either isolated or groups (bands) of large grains. Creep-fatigue life was characterized with respect to the length of the grain boundary perpendicular to the stress axis, and it was found that large grains (>400 μm) tended to be detrimental to creep-fatigue life, with the exception of elongated (parallel to the stress axis) grains and some specimens that underwent additional annealing.

11 NUCLEAR FUEL CYCLE AND FUEL MATERIALS↗

Microstructural Effects on Creep-Fatigue Life of Alloy 709

Cyclic testing has been carried out to characterize the fatigue and creep-fatigue behavior of Alloy 709, an advanced austenitic structural alloy. Specimens were machined from several plates of 709, subjected to different processing conditions and resulting in varying microstructures in the specimens, dependent on both the plate used for the machining and the location the specimen originated from within the plate. The cyclic testing has been conducted primarily at a single fatigue and creep-fatigue condition, which was at 650 °C and 1.0% total strain (+/-0.5% strain). For creep-fatigue, a 30 min. hold time at peak tensile strain was introduced. The combined results of the cyclic testing and post-test metallographic characterization suggest that the investigated microstructures, ultimately controlled by the processing conditions, have limited influence on the Alloy 709 fatigue cycle life. In contrast, some effect on the creep-fatigue cycle life due to the microstructure was observed, specifically that the presence of large grains may negatively impact the creep-fatigue resistance. The number of cycles to failure at the selected creep-fatigue condition varied by up to a factor of 5 for the specimens tested. Specimens with an optimum microstructure, a uniform distribution of grains with diameters less than approximately 200 ?m, resulted in a creep-fatigue resistance similar to that of 316-type stainless steel. The majority of the Alloy 709 cyclic test data has been previously reported in milestone reports - and the microstructural and processing details for the specific heats have been reported by Yamamoto et al. - This summary report includes creep-fatigue test results on three additional heats (011502F, 011502H, and 011539 (note, same plate as ORNL 011593)) for which the processing and microstructural details are available in previous reports.

11 NUCLEAR FUEL CYCLE AND FUEL MATERIALS↗

Creep Fatigue Testing -- Rev. 9

This practice is to be used by the Materials Science and Engineering Department (B120) in determining the fatigue and creep-fatigue properties of nominally homogeneous materials from test specimens subjected to uniaxial forces. This practice is restricted to the testing of uniform gage section test specimens (from the Scope Section of ASTM Standard E 606-04).

36 MATERIALS SCIENCE↗