Search NASA⌕ Search

Engineering topics

Menikoff, Ralph

Publications and source records attributed to Menikoff, Ralph.

At least 55 records · Page 3

JWL Equation of State

The JWL equation of state (EOS) is frequently used for the products (and sometimes reactants) of a high explosive (HE). Here we review and systematically derive important properties. The JWL EOS is of the Mie-Grueneisen form with a constant Grueneisen coefficient and a constants specific heat. It is thermodynamically consistent to specify the temperature at a reference state. However, increasing the reference state temperature restricts the EOS domain in the (V, e)-plane of phase space. The restrictions are due to the conditions that P ≥ 0, T ≥ 0, and the isothermal bulk modulus is positive. Typically, this limits the low temperature regime in expansion. The domain restrictions can result in the P-T equilibrium EOS of a partly burned HE failing to have a solution in some cases. For application to HE, the heat of detonation is discussed. Example JWL parameters for an HE, both products and reactions, are used to illustrate the restrictions on the domain of the EOS.

45 MILITARY TECHNOLOGY, WEAPONRY, AND NATIONAL DEF↗

Detonation Wave Profile

The Zel’dovich-von Neumann-Doering (ZND) profile of a detonation wave is derived. Two basic assumptions are required: i. An equation of state (EOS) for a partly burned explosive; P(V, e, λ). ii. A burn rate for the reaction progress variable; d/dt λ = R(V, e, λ). For a steady planar detonation wave the reactive flow PDEs can be reduced to ODEs. The detonation wave profile can be determined from an ODE plus algebraic equations for points on the partly burned detonation loci with a specified wave speed. Furthermore, for the CJ detonation speed the end of the reaction zone is sonic. A solution to the reactive flow equations can be constructed with a rarefaction wave following the detonation wave profile. This corresponds to an underdriven detonation wave, and the rarefaction is know as a Taylor wave.

45 MILITARY TECHNOLOGY, WEAPONRY, AND NATIONAL DEF↗

Shock-to-detonation transition simulations

Shock-to-detonation transition (SDT) experiments with embedded velocity gauges provide data that can be used for both calibration and validation of high explosive (HE) burn models. Typically, a series of experiments is performed for each HE in which the initial shock pressure is varied. Here we describe a methodology for automating a series of SDT simulations and comparing numerical tracer particle velocities with the experimental gauge data. Illustrative examples are shown for PBX 9502 using the HE models implemented in the xRage ASC code at LANL.

45 MILITARY TECHNOLOGY, WEAPONRY, AND NATIONAL DEF↗

Numerical computation of Pop plot

The Pop plot — distance-of-run to detonation versus initial shock pressure — is a key characterization of shock initiation in a heterogeneous explosive. Reactive burn models for high explosives (HE) must reproduce the experimental Pop plot to have any chance of accurately predicting shock initiation phenomena. This report describes a methodology for automating the computation of a Pop plot for a specific explosive with a given HE model. Illustrative examples of the computation are shown for PBX 9502 with three burn models (SURF, WSD and Forest Fire) utilizing the xRage code, which is the Eulerian ASC hydrocode at LANL. Comparison of the numerical and experimental Pop plot can be the basis for a validation test or as an aid in calibrating the burn rate of an HE model. Issues with calibration are discussed.

45 MILITARY TECHNOLOGY, WEAPONRY, AND NATIONAL DEF↗

Explosive Products EOS: Adjustment for detonation speed and energy release

Propagating detonation waves exhibit a curvature effect in which the detonation speed decreases with increasing front curvature. The curvature effect is due to the width of the wave profile. Numerically, the wave profile depends on resolution. With coarse resolution, the wave width is too large and results in a curvature effect that is too large. Consequently, the detonation speed decreases as the cell size is increased. We propose a modification to the products equation of state (EOS) to compensate for the effect of numerical resolution; i.e., to increase the CJ pressure in order that a simulation propagates a detonation wave with a speed that is on average correct. The EOS modification also adjusts the release isentrope to correct the energy release.

97 MATHEMATICS AND COMPUTING↗

Molecular Solid EOS based on Quasi-Harmonic Oscillator approximation for phonons

A complete equation of state (EOS) for a molecular solid is derived utilizing a Helmholtz free energy. Assuming that the solid is nonconducting, phonon excitations dominate the specific heat. Phonons are approximated as independent quasi-harmonic oscillators with vibrational frequencies depending on the specific volume. The model is suitable for calibrating an EOS based on isothermal compression data and infrared/Raman spectroscopy data from high pressure measurements utilizing a diamond anvil cell. In contrast to a Mie-Gruneisen EOS developed for an atomic solid, the specific heat and Gruneisen coefficient depend on both density and temperature.

97 MATHEMATICS AND COMPUTING↗

Effect of Resolution on Propagating Detonation Wave

Simulations of the cylinder test are used to illustrate the effect of mesh resolution on a propagating detonation wave. For this study we use the xRage code with the SURF burn model for PBX 9501. The adaptive mesh capability of xRage is used to vary the resolution of the reaction zone. We focus on two key properties: the detonation speed and the cylinder wall velocity. The latter is related to the release isentrope behind the detonation wave. As the reaction zone is refined (2 to 15 cells for cell size of 62 to 8μm), both the detonation speed and final wall velocity change by a small amount; less than 1 per cent. The detonation speed decreases with coarser resolution. Even when the reaction zone is grossly under-resolved (cell size twice the reaction-zone width of the burn model) the wall velocity is within a per cent and the detonation speed is low by only 2 per cent.

97 MATHEMATICS AND COMPUTING↗

Simulations of Rod Impact Experiments

Rod impact on a high explosive (HE) gives rise to a two-dimensional flow that is of interest for both studying shock initiation and testing HE burn models. Here we report on simulations preformed with the xRage code using two burn models; SURF and Ignition & Growth. For a 17 mm diameter rod generating an impact pressure of 4.5 GPa in a thick PBX 9501 sample, the simulations show a 1-D shock-to-detonation transition on axis. Subsequently, a detonation wave propagates radially outward from the point of ignition. With the SURF model a dead zone is left behind in the region adjacent to the corner of the rod due to shock desensitization. The dead zone is analogous to what has been observed in corner-turning experiments. Rod impact data consists of velocity time histories from PDV probes for a series of experiments with different thickness of HE. Initiation only occurs when the HE sample is thicker than the distance-of-run to detonation on the Pop plot at the impact pressure. The simulations are compatible with the data, though the probes alone are not sufficient to determine whether or not a lateral detonation wave propagates after initiation on axis.

45 MILITARY TECHNOLOGY, WEAPONRY, AND NATIONAL DEF↗

Cylinder Test Wall Velocity: Experimental and Simulated Data

The cylinder test consists of a cylinder of high explosives (HE) within a thin walled copper tube. A detonation wave is initiated at one end of the cylinder. After propagating a few tube diameters, the flow behind the detonation wave approaches a steady state and the outward wall motion is measured; either using a streak camera to record the radial expansion of the wall (from which a wall velocity can be inferred) or a VISAR or PDV probe to measure a component of the wall velocity. The wall acceleration is related to the pressure along the release isentrope from the detonation state. Consequently, cylinder test data are used to calibrate equation of state (EOS) models for HE products. Model EOS parameters are fit by comparing the experimental data to simulated data from hydro codes. The simulated data consists of the particle velocity along a Lagrangian trajectory originating on the surface of the wall. The purpose of this note is to describe what the experiments actually measure, and to relate the experimental wall velocity to the physical velocity along a particle trajectory. Data for PBX 9501 is used to illustrate the differences among the experimental wall velocities and the particle velocity obtain from a simulation.

45 MILITARY TECHNOLOGY, WEAPONRY, AND NATIONAL DEF↗

Complete Mie-Gruneisen Equation of State

The Mie-Gruneisen equation of state (EOS) is frequently used in hydro simulations to model solids at high pressure (up to a few Mb). It is an incomplete EOS characterized by a Gruneisen coefficient, {Lambda} = -V({partial_derivative}{sub e}P){sub V}, that is a function of only V. Expressions are derived for isentropes and isotherms. This enables the extension to a complete EOS. Thermodynamic consistency requires that the specific heat is a function of a single scaled temperature. A complete extension is uniquely determined by the temperature dependence of the specific heat at a fixed reference density. In addition we show that if the domain of the EOS extends to T = 0 and the specific heat vanishes on the zero isotherm then {Lambda} a function of only V is equivalent to a specific heat with a single temperature scale. If the EOS domain does not include the zero isotherm, then a specific heat with a single temperature scale leads to a generalization of the Mie-Gruneisen EOS in which the pressure is linear in both the specific energy and the temperature. Such an EOS has previously been used to model liquid nitromethane.

36 MATERIALS SCIENCE↗

xRage: HE Initiation Models

The xRage code contains three HE ignition models: Forest Fire, Cerro Grande and Ignition and Growth. After describing these models we present results of verification and validation (V and V) tests. These include simulations to determine the Pop-plot for each model and comparision with embedded velocity gauge data for shock-to-detonation transition (SDT) experiments. The data for the SDT experiments on PBX 9502 is taken from the recently developed high explosive database (HED). The HED data files contains additional meta-data with the key experimental parameters. This enables the use of scripts to automate testing: generating xRage input file, running simulation and generating comparison plots with experimental and simulated data. The simulations show that the models are robust. But there is a mesh dependence with the time for transition-to-detonation varying by several tenths of microseconds. After the transition to a detonation wave, the detonation speed and pressure may vary by a few per cent.

36 MATERIALS SCIENCE↗

Systematic approach to verification and validation: High explosive burn models

Most material models used in numerical simulations are based on heuristics and empirically calibrated to experimental data. For a specific model, key questions are determining its domain of applicability and assessing its relative merits compared to other models. Answering these questions should be a part of model verification and validation (V and V). Here, we focus on V and V of high explosive models. Typically, model developers implemented their model in their own hydro code and use different sets of experiments to calibrate model parameters. Rarely can one find in the literature simulation results for different models of the same experiment. Consequently, it is difficult to assess objectively the relative merits of different models. This situation results in part from the fact that experimental data is scattered through the literature (articles in journals and conference proceedings) and that the printed literature does not allow the reader to obtain data from a figure in electronic form needed to make detailed comparisons among experiments and simulations. In addition, it is very time consuming to set up and run simulations to compare different models over sufficiently many experiments to cover the range of phenomena of interest. The first difficulty could be overcome if the research community were to support an online web based database. The second difficulty can be greatly reduced by automating procedures to set up and run simulations of similar types of experiments. Moreover, automated testing would be greatly facilitated if the data files obtained from a database were in a standard format that contained key experimental parameters as meta-data in a header to the data file. To illustrate our approach to V and V, we have developed a high explosive database (HED) at LANL. It now contains a large number of shock initiation experiments. Utilizing the header information in a data file from HED, we have written scripts to generate an input file for a hydro code, run a simulation, and generate a comparison plot showing simulated and experimental velocity gauge data. These scripts are then applied to several series of experiments and to several HE burn models. The same systematic approach is applicable to other types of material models; for example, equations of state models and material strength models.

36 MATERIALS SCIENCE↗

Deflagration Wave Profiles

Shock initiation in a plastic-bonded explosives (PBX) is due to hot spots. Current reactive burn models are based, at least heuristically, on the ignition and growth concept. The ignition phase occurs when a small localized region of high temperature (or hot spot) burns on a fast time scale. This is followed by a growth phase in which a reactive front spreads out from the hot spot. Propagating reactive fronts are deflagration waves. A key question is the deflagration speed in a PBX compressed and heated by a shock wave that generated the hot spot. Here, the ODEs for a steady deflagration wave profile in a compressible fluid are derived, along with the needed thermodynamic quantities of realistic equations of state corresponding to the reactants and products of a PBX. The properties of the wave profile equations are analyzed and an algorithm is derived for computing the deflagration speed. As an illustrative example, the algorithm is applied to compute the deflagration speed in shock compressed PBX 9501 as a function of shock pressure. The calculated deflagration speed, even at the CJ pressure, is low compared to the detonation speed. The implication of this are briefly discussed.

36 MATERIALS SCIENCE↗

A reactive burn model for shock initiation in a PBX: scaling and separability based on the hot spot concept

In the formulation of a reactive burn model for shock initiation, we endeavor to incorporate a number of effects based on the underlying physical concept of hot spot ignition followed by the growth of reaction due to diverging deflagration fronts. The passage of a shock front sets the initial condition for reaction, leading to a fraction of the hot spots that completely burn while others will quench. The form of the rate model is chosen to incorporate approximations based on the physical picture. In particular, the approximations imply scaling relations that are then used to mathematically separate various contributions. That is, the model is modular and refinements can be applied separately without changing the other contributions. For example, the effect of initial temperature, porosity, etc. predominantly enter the characterization of the non-quenching hot spot distribution. A large collection of velocity gauge data is shown to be well represented by the model with a very small number of parameters.

45 MILITARY TECHNOLOGY, WEAPONRY, AND NATIONAL DEF↗