Search NASASearch

Engineering topics

Michael G Jones

Publications and source records attributed to Michael G Jones.

An Experimental and Predictive Study of Bent-Chamber Acoustic Liners

Acoustic liner samples with rectangular, sharp chamber bends are 3D-printed and tested in the NASA Normal Incidence Tube. The angle of the bend is varied from 0 to 180 degrees. Four different methods are used to predict the impedance behavior of these samples: (1) midline-length assumption, (2) Cummings correction for curved duct bends, (3) Cummings prediction for 180 degrees sharp duct bends, and (4) Helmholtz equation via finite element method. Trends in the experimental data are discussed, predictions are compared to the experimental data, and recommendations are made on prediction method usage. Follow-on work is suggested, including capturing additional test points at higher frequencies and with different chamber geometries. Future modeling strategies are also briefly described.

chamber

Effects of Layer Spacing for a Multilayered Facesheet Acoustic Liner

A single degree-of-freedom acoustic liner, a perforate facesheet over honeycomb core, is modified to have a facesheet comprised of three layers. The top and bottom perforate layers have the same dimensions with aligned perforations while the middle layer perforate can be longitudinally shifted up to 0.075 inches to change the effective porosity of the facesheet. These configurations range in porosity from 100% open down to 10% open in addition to two closed configurations (0% porosity). Gaps are introduced between the facesheet layers ranging from no gap to 0.016 inches. These configurations are tested in the NASA Langley Grazing Flow Impedance Tube to determine their acoustic impedance spectra. Introduction of a gap affects the acoustic impedance of the liner where the resonant frequency of the liners decreases with increased gap thickness for liners with an open area ratio above 25% but increases with gap thickness for liners with an open area ratio below 25%. Additionally, it is observed that increasing the gap height results in a reduction of the effect of porosity on acoustic impedance. The results show that the presence of such gaps can have a significant effect on liner impedance especially as porosity decreases.

acoustic liners

Low-Drag Acoustic Liner Development

Interest in characterization of the aerodynamic drag of acoustic liners has increased in the past several years. This report details experiments in the NASA Langley Grazing Flow Impedance Tube to quantify the relative drag of several perforate-over-honeycomb liner configurations at flow speeds of M=0.3 and 0.5. Various perforate geometries and orientations are investigated to determine their resistance factors using a static pressure drop approach. Comparison of these resistance factors gives a relative measurement of liner drag. For these same flow conditions, acoustic measurements are performed simultaneously with the drag measurements for tonal excitation from 400 to 3000 Hz at source sound pressure levels of 140 and 150 dB. Educed impedance and attenuation spectra are used to determine the impact of variations in perforate geometry on acoustic performance. The goal is to identify a perforate that will reduce the drag penalty associated with conventional round-hole perforates by 60%. One perforate design, based on a slot geometry, is shown to reduce this penalty by 50%. Further reductions may be possible but require a reduction in measurement uncertainty to allow a statistically rigorous evaluation.

drag

High Intensity Modal Impedance Tube Development at NASA Langley

A High Intensity Modal Impedance Tube (HIMIT) was developed for evaluation of acoustic liners in a normal incidence, high sound pressure level (SPL), and high frequency environment. Capabilities of the HIMIT are demonstrated here by testing three classes of acoustic liners: a narrow chamber liner, conventional single degree of freedom liners, and over-the-rotor liners. The experimental results are compared to results in NASA Langley's Normal Incidence Tube (NIT) for validation. The Zwikker and Kosten Transmission Line (ZKTL) model is also compared to the HIMIT results for selected configurations to study its applicability at high SPLs and frequencies. The HIMIT and NIT impedance spectra compare favorably up to 3.0 kHz, which is the upper frequency limit of the NIT analysis. The ZKTL model was used at frequencies up to 6.0 kHz and showed great comparison for the entire frequency range tested, indicating that the model may be used at high frequencies when the plane wave mode is dominant.

Chelsea Solano

Implementation of the NASA High Intensity Modal Impedance Tube

This paper provides a description of the High Intensity Modal Impedance Tube (HIMIT) and its use for the evaluation of acoustic liners. Tests conducted with two liners, one linear and one nonlinear, are used to evaluate the suitability of the HIMIT for evaluation at frequencies up to 6 kHz and sound pressure levels up to 155 dB. Two impedance eduction methods are used, one suitable for plane wave frequencies and the other applicable over the full frequency range. These educed impedances are compared against those computed with an impedance prediction method and against those educed with another zero-flow test rig. These results confirm that the HIMIT can be used with confidence for the evaluation of acoustic liners over these frequency and sound pressure level ranges.

impedance

IFAR Liner Benchmark Challenge #1 - DLR Impedance Eduction of Uniform and Axially Segmented Liners and Comparison with NASA Results

This paper presents the contribution from the German Aerospace Center (DLR) to the first liner benchmark challenge under the framework of the International Forum for Aviation Research (IFAR).Therefore, two sets of acoustically damping wall treatment, called ’liner samples’, have been produced by additive manufacturing based on the design data provided by NASA coordinating this benchmark. These liner samples have been integrated and acoustically characterized in the liner flow test facility DUCT-R at DLR Berlin as well as in the liner flow test facility GFIT at NASA Langley. Besides the dissipation coefficients and the axial pressure profiles, the liner wall impedance was educed by first determining the axial wave numbers and then applying a straightforward method based on the one-dimensional Convected Helmholtz Equation. Finally, the comparison of the liner impedance values to the NASA results show a fairly good agreement.

liner characterization

A Summary of Normal Incidence Tube Tests of NASA'S Bio-inspired Broadband Acoustic Absorber

Motivated by the need to reduce noise pollution from aircraft engines, NASA has continued to design, manufacture and test recently patented structures that mimic the geometry and the broadband and low frequency acoustic absorption of assemblies of natural reeds. This report documents a screening test, which is a precursor to more controlled modelling experiments. The purpose of this experiment was to identify variables and prototype design features that might play a dominant role in the acoustic performance of these structures. To date, twenty-four prototypes, each with an overall shape of a cube (nominally 50 mm x 50 mm x 50 mm), were designed and additively manufactured from thermoplastics using a Fused Filament Fabrication technique. The prototypes were tested in the NASA Glenn and Langley Normal Incidence Tubes to experimentally determine the acoustic absorption as a function of frequency from 400 Hz to 3000 Hz. Results indicate that a variety of structures exhibit substantial acoustic absorption in that frequency range, with an average absorption coefficient greater than 0.6, especially in the frequency range of 400 Hz to 1000 Hz. Six basic prototype designs were chosen to inform future modeling research. Results of these experiments can be used to evaluate existing physics-based models of the interaction of sound waves with these structures or to develop new models. Validated physics-based models of these structures can help engineers optimize the designs for different commercial noise control applications.

Acoustics

A Review of Acoustic Liner Experimental Characterization at NASA Langley

This paper presents a review of tools used by the NASA Langley Research Center over the last four decades to experimentally characterize acoustic liners for aircraft noise reduction. Descriptions of past and present NASA test rigs are included to provide context for the application of data acquisition and analysis methods. These test rigs range from simple applications of a raylometer to a waveguide with detailed control over higher-order modes. Methods for impedance eduction based on data acquired in these test rigs are explored in some detail. Strengths and weaknesses of each data acquisition and analysis method are presented, as well as current practices applied in the NASA Langley Liner Technology Facility.

Michael G Jones

Evaluation of Variable Facesheet Liner Configurations for Broadband Noise Reduction

This paper investigates the broadband noise reduction properties of a distributed (variable) facesheet liner. Candidate uniform samples are selected using the Wave Propagation Model and Two-Parameter Model developed at the NASA Langley Research Center. Three uniform and one distributed facesheet samples are tested in the Normal Incidence Tube (NIT) at NASA Langley. Initial results show that the distributed facesheet sample possesses broadband noise reduction properties. Acoustic impedances educed from these NIT tests are used as inputs into the Convected Helmholtz Equation (CHE) propagation code developed at NASA Langley to synthesize the acoustic pressure field in the Grazing Flow Impedance Tube (GFIT) with no flow. Three uniform, one distributed, as well as one three-zone liner, oriented in two different directions, are investigated. Preliminary results showed the distributed facesheet and three-zone liners exhibit broadband noise reduction properties.

M C Brown

An Initial Assessment of Variable Depth Liner Optimization for Ducted Proprotor Applications

The rise of the Urban Air Mobility market has spurred the design of a new generation of novel aircraft. To aid industry and researchers interested in these types of aircraft, the Revolutionary Vertical Lift Technology project at NASA has developed a fleet of reference vehicles for system studies. A new six-passenger reference vehicle has recently been added to the research portfolio that has ducted proprotors for propulsors. The ducts present an opportunity to apply acoustic treatment to the interior of the duct that could target both tonal and broadband noise, representative of the sound produced by this type of propulsor. In this paper, design methodologies are presented to design a variable depth liner for this application. An optimizer is used to design multiple liners with variable chamber depths. Experimental results from normal impedance testing are compared to numerical predictions using the optimizer model and a finite element model. Results show that an optimizer can be used to design an acoustic liner with favorable performance for a broad range of frequencies, which could be appropriate for a ducted proprotor application.

Matthew B Galles

A Fundamental Study of Bifurcation Acoustic Treatment Effects on Aft-Fan Engine Noise

Increasing air traffic and more stringent aircraft noise regulations continue to expand requirements on aircraft noise levels for conventional and unconventional aircraft configurations. A major component of the overall aircraft noise is the sound associated with the propulsion system mounted in the engine nacelle. Acoustic liners mounted in the aircraft engine nacelles provide a significant portion of the current fan noise reduction. However, they must be further optimized if challenging noise reduction goals are to be achieved. One location within the aft bypass duct that may be an excellent candidate for increased attention is the acoustic treatment on the engine bifurcations (i.e., engine pylon and lower bifurcation). This paper presents the continuation of a fundamental study of the effects of bifurcation treatment on simulated aft fan noise and the validation of numerical tools to predict such effects. Five bifurcation configurations (four treated and one hardwall) were fabricated and tested in the NASA Langley Curved Duct Test Rig. Results show that mode scattering may occur due to both the presence of the bifurcation, as well as variable impedance distributions on the bifurcation surface. Future work will also include optimization of bifurcation treatments for testing in the Curved Duct Test Rig. These initial results are promising and this work provides valuable information for further study and improvement of the performance of bifurcation acoustic treatments.

bifurcation effects

Investigation of the Impedance Characteristics of Perforate Sheet Hole Clustering Over an Array of Uniform Depth Chambers

A series of normal incidence impedance tube tests are conducted to characterize the facesheet impedance differences between uniformly distributed and nonuniformly tightly packed hole layout patterns, defined here as "hole clustering." These hole clustered samples contain the same number of holes as their uniformly distributed counterparts but target edge to edge distances between holes down to 0.01". Resonant frequency shifts between uniformly distributed and hole clustered samples are presented to demonstrate potential design benefits. Mass end correction differences between samples are also shown to better quantify differences in designs, including the effect of acoustic particle velocity. It is found that hole clustered facesheets over an array of uniform depth chambers can provide significant reactance increases at minimal expense to resistance, thereby lowering resonant frequencies. Additionally, moving these hole clustered layouts toward common chamber corners provides additional resonance shifts to lower frequencies.

acoustic liner impedance hole clustering perforate

Toward Fully 3D-Printed Two Degree of Freedom Acoustic Liners

An acoustic liner optimization tool is developed for designing two degree of freedom (2DOF) liners with high absorption over a wide range of frequencies and sound pressure levels (SPLs). Two additively manufactured 2DOF liners (one constant and one variable chamber depth) are designed and printed with an embedded perforate layer as the septum. A normal incidence impedance tube study is performed to directly compare impedance and absorption spectra to a more traditionally manufactured 2DOF liner with embedded mesh caps in phenolic honeycomb. Comparisons of test data to predictions are shown as well as SPL sensitivities for each acoustic liner. Broadband absorption is achieved with the 3D printed 2DOF liner containing constant chamber depths, although due to current limitations in printed embedded perforate hole size, not as broad as the traditional mesh cap liner. However, results also show that the 3D printed variable chamber depth sample is more comparable to the mesh cap liner absorption, demonstrating the viability of printed embedded perforates in novel concepts.

acoustic liner 2DOF two degree of freedom 3D print

Bypass Duct Acoustic Liner Design With and Without Bifurcation Effects

The growth in air traffic and the commitment to sustainable aviation continue to provide new challenges to reducing aircraft noise levels. Acoustic liner design methodologies must therefore provide the capability to efficiently predict the acoustic benefits of novel liner configurations within complex aircraft nacelle geometries. With these observations in mind, a broadband acoustic liner optimization process has been developed and assessed through a series of design and experimental studies at increasing technology readiness levels. This work applies the design process to the aft-fan noise component and explores the effects of bypass duct bifurcations (e.g., the pylon and lower bifurcation). In addition to this new application, the design study is expanded to include the use of a commercially available duct propagation code. Despite the different general workflow for the two propagation codes, consistent optimized impedance spectra and in-duct attenuation predictions were obtained for several acoustic treatment options. The preliminary results are promising, and this work increases confidence in the enhanced broadband liner design methodology and lays the groundwork for complimentary use of the codes in future studies. The potential benefits of acoustic treatment on the upper and lower bifurcations are also demonstrated. The knowledge gained through this preliminary stage of the liner design process will be used to guide the identification of candidate liner designs for a proposed static engine test within the next year.

Acoustic Liner Design

Comparison of Inlet Broadband Acoustic Liner Predictions to Quiet Technology Demonstrator 3 Flight Data

Companion acoustic liner attenuation predictions and flight data representative of certification conditions are analyzed to determine the validation quality and gain an understanding of current prediction shortcomings. These comparisons are limited to the inlet broadband component of fan noise. Two prediction methods are assessed: a traditional, semiempirical model, and a computational approach with a parabolic duct propagation code coupled with a Ffowcs Williams-Hawkings solver for free-field propagation. The semiempirical method is widely used for aircraft system noise predictions, but does not explicitly account for several physical parameters important for sound attenuation. The computational approach includes these effects, but requires a significant increase in cycle time. For the three-degree-of-freedom (3DOF) liner tested, both methods have a bias error less than 0.5 dB for cutback and takeoff power settings, and a much larger 3–4 dB bias for approach power setting. The standard deviation of each method varies between 1–2 dB for different conditions. The similar performance of both approaches illustrates that, in this instance, the additional complexity of the computational approach does not provide a clear improvement over the semiempirical method. Planned improvements to the numerical grid and source assumptions may result in reevaluation of this conclusion in later work.

aircraft system noise