Search NASA⌕ Search

Engineering topics

Minakata, Hisakazu

Publications and source records attributed to Minakata, Hisakazu.

Physics of parameter correlations around the solar-scale enhancement in neutrino theory with unitarity violation

We discuss the physics of the three neutrino flavor transformation with non-unitary mixing matrix, with particular attention to the correlation between the $\nu$SM- and the $\alpha$ parameters which represent the effect of unitarity-violating (UV) new physics. Towards this goal, a new perturbative framework is created to illuminate the effect of non-unitarity in the region of the solar-scale enhanced oscillations. We refute the skepticism about the physical reality of the $\nu$Standard Model CP phase $\delta$–$\alpha$ parameter phase correlation by analysis with the SOL convention of $U_{{\tiny MNS}}$, in which $e^{\pm i \delta}$ is attached to $s_{12}$. Then, a comparative study between the solar- and atmospheric-scale oscillation regions allowed by the framework reveals a dynamical $\delta$–(blobs of the $\alpha$ parameters) correlation in the solar oscillation region, in sharp contrast to the “chiral”-type phase correlation $[e^{- i \delta} \bar{\alpha}_{\mu e},\ e^{- i \delta} \bar{\alpha}_{\tau e},\ \bar{\alpha}_{\tau \mu}]$ in the Particle Data Group convention seen in the atmospheric oscillation region. An explicit perturbative calculation to the first order in the $\nu_{\mu} \rightarrow \nu_{e}$ channel allows us to decompose the UV related part of the probability into the unitary evolution part and the genuine non-unitary part. We observe that the effect of non-unitarity tends to cancel between these two parts, as well as between the different $\alpha_{\beta \gamma}$ parameters.

72 PHYSICS OF ELEMENTARY PARTICLES AND FIELDS↗

Standard versus non-standard CP phases in neutrino oscillation in matter with non-unitarity

We formulate a perturbative framework for the flavor transformation of the standard active three neutrinos but with a non-unitary flavor mixing matrix, a system which may be relevant for the leptonic unitarity test. We use the $\alpha$ parametrization of the non-unitary matrix and take its elements $\alpha_{\beta \gamma}$ ($\beta,\gamma = e,\mu,\tau$) and the ratio $\epsilon \simeq \Delta m^2_{21} / \Delta m^2_{31}$ as the small expansion parameters. Two qualitatively new features that hold in all the oscillation channels are uncovered in the probability formula obtained to first order in the expansion: (1) The phases of the complex $\alpha$ elements always come into the observable in the particular combination with the $\nu$SM CP phase $\delta$ in the form $[e^{- i \delta } \bar{\alpha}_{\mu e}, ~e^{ - i \delta} \bar{\alpha}_{\tau e}, ~\bar{\alpha}_{\tau \mu}]$ under the Particle Data Group convention of a unitary $\nu$SM mixing matrix. (2) The diagonal $\alpha$ parameters appear in particular combinations $\left( a/b - 1 \right) \alpha_{ee} + \alpha_{\mu \mu}$ and $\alpha_{\mu \mu} - \alpha_{\tau \tau}$, where $a$ and $b$ denote, respectively, the matter potential due to charged current and neutral current reactions. This property holds only in the unitary evolution part of the probability, and there is no such feature in the genuine non-unitary part, while the $\delta$–$\alpha$ parameter phase correlation exists for both. The reason for such remarkable stability of the phase correlation is discussed.

72 PHYSICS OF ELEMENTARY PARTICLES AND FIELDS↗

Using Low Energy Atmospheric Neutrinos for Precision Measurement of the Mixing Parameters

Use of low energy atmospheric neutrinos is considered for precision measurement of neutrino mixing parameters. At around energy $E \simeq$ a few $\times$100 MeV and baseline $L$ of a few $\times$1000 km, CP phase effect is $\sim$10 times larger than that of the conventional LBL accelerator neutrino experiments. We report here a few progresses: (1) To analyze physics in the region, a new perturbative framework at around the solar-scale enhancement is developed. (2) To know the characteristic features of CP $\delta$ dependence of the atmospheric neutrinos at low energies, we plot the ratio of the $\nu_{e}$ and $\bar{\nu}_{e}$ fluxes $F(\delta)/F(\delta=0)$ for $\delta=\pm \frac{\pi}{2}$ and $\pi$ as a function of $E$ using the Honda {\it et al.} flux. Interestingly, it shows $\delta$ dependence of $\simeq$5-10\% level, with positive (negative) sign for $\nu_{e}$ ($\bar{\nu}_{e}$). (3) To reduce the flux systematic errors, measurement of muon energy distribution around $\sim$1 GeV at high altitude may be useful. Water Cherenkov or muon range detectors may be the options with advantage in the latter if it is magnetized in view of the $\delta$ dependence of the flux.

72 PHYSICS OF ELEMENTARY PARTICLES AND FIELDS↗

Perturbing neutrino oscillations around the solar resonance

Atmospheric neutrinos at low energies, $E \lesssim 500$ MeV, are known to be a rich source of information on lepton mixing parameters. We formulate a simple perturbative framework to elucidate the characteristic features of neutrino oscillation at around the solar-scale enhancement due to the matter effect. The clearest message that we could extract from our perturbation theory is that CP violation in the appearance oscillation probability is large, a factor of $\sim 10$ times larger than CP violation at around the atmospheric-scale oscillation maximum. The underlying mechanism for this is that one of the suppression factors on the CP phase-dependent terms due to the smallness of $\Delta m^2_{21} / \Delta m^2_{31}$ is dynamically lifted by the solar-scale enhancement. Our framework has a unique feature as a perturbation theory in which a large $\Delta m^2_{31}$ term outside the key 1-2 sector for the solar-scale resonance does not yield sizable corrections. On the contrary, the larger the $\Delta m^2_{31}$, the smaller the higher-order corrections.

72 PHYSICS OF ELEMENTARY PARTICLES AND FIELDS↗

Universal correlation between CP phase $\delta$ and the non-unitarity $\alpha$ parameter phases

The non-unitarity of the neutrino mixing matrix is a problem related with a more fundamental question about the origin of the neutrino mass. After a brief discussion on the questions ``why do we need model-independent framework for unitarity test?'', we show interesting properties present in the oscillation probabilities of neutrinos propagating in matter with non-unitarity. That is, (1) partial unitarity and (2) universal phase correlation. %To illuminate these points, we formulate a perturbative framework with the two expansion parameters $\epsilon \equiv \Delta m^2_{21} / \Delta m^2_{31}$ and $\alpha$ matrix elements. The complex triangular $\alpha$ matrix is introduced through the definition of $3 \times 3$ non-unitary flavor mixing matrix $N$ as %\begin{eqnarray} N &=& \left( \bf{1} - \alpha \right) U = \left\{ \bf{1} - \left[ \begin{array}{ccc}\alpha_{ee} & 0 & 0 \\\alpha_{\mu e} & \alpha_{\mu \mu} & 0 \\\alpha_{\tau e} & \alpha_{\tau \mu} & \alpha_{\tau \tau} \\\end{array}\right] \right\}U \label{alpha-matrix-def}\end{eqnarray}%where $U$ is the unitary MNS mixing matrix, and hence $\alpha$ characterizes the size and the flavor dependence of unitarity violation (UV)\footnote{%%%%%%%%%%%%%Despite that in the physics literature UV usually means ``ultraviolet'', we use UV in this manuscript as an abbreviation for ``unitarity violation'' or ``unitarity violating''.}~~caused by new physics (NP) at low- or high-scales.~~~~The point (1) above essentially means that despite non-unitary mixing, neutrino evolution must be unitary because the three active neutrinos span a complete state space of neutral leptons. The {\em phase correlation} mentioned in the point (2) refers an intriguing property that the complex $\alpha$ parameters and $\nu$Standard Model CP phase $\delta$ always come into the oscillation probabilities in a correlated way, $e^{- i \delta } \alpha_{\mu e}$, $\alpha_{\tau e}$, and $e^{i \delta} \alpha_{\tau \mu}$, universally in all the oscillation channels. The physical meaning of this result is briefly discussed. }

72 PHYSICS OF ELEMENTARY PARTICLES AND FIELDS↗

Comment on 1801.10488

We perform a comparison between 1604.08167 and the recent paper 1801.10488. We show that the logic, methods and results are identical, apart from trivial convention and notation differences.

72 PHYSICS OF ELEMENTARY PARTICLES AND FIELDS↗

Addendum to "Compact Perturbative Expressions for Neutrino Oscillations in Matter" [Slides]

In this paper we rewrite the neutrino mixing angles and mass squared differences in matter given, in our original paper, in a notation that is more conventional for the reader. Replacing the usual neutrino mixing angles and mass squared differences in the expressions for the vacuum oscillation probabilities with these matter mixing angles and mass squared differences gives an excellent approximation to the oscillation probabilities in matter. Comparisons for T2K, NOvA, T2HKK and DUNE are also given for neutrinos and anti-neutrinos, disappearance and appearance channels, normal ordering and inverted ordering.

72 PHYSICS OF ELEMENTARY PARTICLES AND FIELDS↗

Analytic Neutrino Oscillation Probabilities in Matter: Revisited

We summarize our recent paper on neutrino oscillation probabilities in matter, explaining the importance, relevance and need for simple, highly accurate approximations to the neutrino oscillation probabilities in matter.

72 PHYSICS OF ELEMENTARY PARTICLES AND FIELDS↗

Compact perturbative expressions for neutrino oscillations in matter

We further develop and extend a recent perturbative framework for neutrino oscillations in uniform matter density so that the resulting oscillation probabilities are accurate for the complete matter potential versus baseline divided by neutrino energy plane. This extension also gives the exact oscillation probabilities in vacuum for all values of baseline divided by neutrino energy. The expansion parameter used is related to the ratio of the solar to the atmospheric $\Delta m^2$ scales but with a unique choice of the atmospheric $\Delta m^2$ such that certain first-order effects are taken into account in the zeroth-order Hamiltonian. Using a mixing matrix formulation, this framework has the exceptional feature that the neutrino oscillation probability in matter has the same structure as in vacuum, to all orders in the expansion parameter. It also contains all orders in the matter potential and $\sin\theta_{13}$. It facilitates immediate physical interpretation of the analytic results, and makes the expressions for the neutrino oscillation probabilities extremely compact and very accurate even at zeroth order in our perturbative expansion. Furthermore, the first and second order results are also given which improve the precision by approximately two or more orders of magnitude per perturbative order.

72 PHYSICS OF ELEMENTARY PARTICLES AND FIELDS↗

Simple and compact expressions for neutrino oscillation probabilities in matter

We reformulate perturbation theory for neutrino oscillations in matter with an expansion parameter related to the ratio of the solar to the atmospheric Δm 2 scales. Unlike previous works, use a renormalized basis in which certain first-order effects are taken into account in the zeroth-order Hamiltonian. Using this perturbation theory we derive extremely compact expressions for the neutrino oscillations probabilities in matter. We find, for example, that the ν e disappearance probability at this order is of a simple two flavor form with an appropriately identified mixing angle and Δm 2 . Furthermore, despite exceptional simplicity in their forms they accommodate all order effects θ 13 and the matter potential.

72 PHYSICS OF ELEMENTARY PARTICLES AND FIELDS↗

Correlated, precision measurements of θ 23 and δ using only the electron neutrino appearance experiments

Precision measurement of the leptonic CP violating phase δ will suffer from the, then surviving, large uncertainty of sin 2 θ 23 of 10–20% in the experimentally interesting region near maximal mixing of θ 23 . We advocate a new method for determination of both θ 23 and δ at the same time using only the ν e and ν̄ e appearance channels and show that sin 2 θ 23 can be determined automatically with much higher accuracy, approximately a factor of six, than sinδ. In this method, we identify a new degeneracy for the simultaneous determination of θ 23 and δ, the θ 23 intrinsic degeneracy, which must be resolved in order to achieve precision measurement of these two parameters. Spectral information around the vacuum oscillation maxima is shown to be the best way to resolve this degeneracy.

Minakata, Hisakazu↗