Laminar separation bubble characteristics on an airfoil at low Reynolds numbers
Explore the source record for details and available documents.
O'Meara, M. M.↗
Engineering topics
Mueller, T. J.
Publications and source records attributed to Mueller, T. J..
Visualization of the laminar separation bubble on airfoils at low Reynolds numbers
The use of the smoke tube and titanium tetrachloride techniques in the study of low Reynolds number flow about two different airfoils is presented. Emphasis is placed on the problems of determining the characteristics of laminar separation bubbles occurring on the Wortmann FX63-137 airfoil and the NACA 66(3)-018 airfoil. Comparisons are made with the hot-wire technique and the use of kerosene vapor.
Mueller, T. J.↗
The structure of separated flow regions occurring near the leading edge of airfoils including transition
A semi-empirical method for predicting separation bubble characteristics was evaluated using low Reynolds number test data. On the basis of this data, several observations were made. First, a sizable growth in the momentum thickness can occur in the laminar portion of a separation bubble. This is in direct contrast to the theory and is apparently due to low Reynolds number effects. Secondly, the transition Reynolds number (R sub l sub 1) which governs the extent of a bubble's laminar region, was found to be much lower than that used in the method. At present, there does not seem to be any evidence supporting a single value for R sub l sub 1. Apparently, R sub l sub 1 is affected by the freestream disturbance environment, and airfoil's pressure distribution, and possibly the chord Reynolds number as well. Thirdly, the growth in momentum thickness over a bubble's turbulent region was predicted reasonably well by the method, provided that Roberts' suggested value for the mean dissipation coefficient was used. Finally, the present data does not substantiate the universality of the velocity profile at reattachment. However, measurement error may be responsible for this result.
Mueller, T. J.↗
Experimental determination of the laminar separation bubble characteristics on an airfoil at low Reynolds numbers
An experimental investigation was conducted in order to document the structure and behavior of laminar separation bubbles at low Reynolds numbers. Data of this type is necessary if the currently insufficient analytical and numerical models are to be improved. The laminar separation bubble which forms on a NACA 66(3)-018 airfoil model was surveyed at chord Reynolds numbers ranging from 50,000 to 200,000 at angles of attack from 8 to 12 degrees. The effects of the various testing conditions on the separation bubble were isolated, and the data was analyzed in relation to existing separation bubble correlations in order to test their low Reynolds number applicability. This analysis indicated that the chord Reynolds number and the disturbance environment strongly influence the experimental pressure distributions. These effects must be included in any analytic prediction technique applied to the low Reynolds number flight regime.
Omeara, M. M.↗
Laser velocimetry measurement in a transonic tunnel
Some preliminary velocity measurements were carried out inside the transonic tunnel using the laser velocimeter (LV) system in association with the smoke generator. Pressure measurements were also performed using a pressure tap located on the side wall of the test section slightly upstream of the windows. Though the pressure measurements and the LV measurements were not taken at exactly the same location, extrapolation of the pressure data into the location of the LV measurements indicated a very close agreement between the velocity values obtained using the two different methods. Thus it is believed that the smoke particle is following the air flow with little or no velocity slip. Velocity measurements with airfoil at various angles of attack are now being carried out in conjuction with schlieren flow visualization. In the near future pressure distribution around and on the airfoil will be obtained by putting pressure taps on the side windows and using a pressure tap model (currently under construction) of the airfoil.
Ng, T. T.↗
The influence of laminar separation and transition on low Reynolds number airfoil hysteresis
Explore the source record for details and available documents.
Mueller, T. J.↗
The structure of separated flow regions occurring near the leading edge of airfoils, including transition
The structure and behavior of the separation bubble including transition and the redeveloping boundary layer after reattachment over an airfoil at low Reynolds numbers was studied. The intent is to further the understanding of the complex flow phenomena so that analytic methods for predicting their formation and development can be improved. These analytic techniques have applications in the design and performance prediction of airfoils operating in the low Reynolds number flight regime.
Mueller, T. J.↗
Conference on Low Reynolds Number Airfoil Aerodynamics, Notre Dame, IN, June 16-18, 1985, Proceedings
Topics of interest in the design, flow modeling and visualization, and turbulence and flow separation effects for low Reynolds number (Re) airfoils are discussed. Design methods are presented for Re from 50,000-500,000, including a viscous-inviscid coupling method and by using a constrained pitching moment. The effects of pressure gradients, unsteady viscous aerodynamics and separation bubbles are investigated, with particular note made of factors which most influence the size and location of separation bubbles and control their effects. Attention is also given to experimentation with low Re airfoils and to numerical models of symmetry breaking and lift hysteresis from separation. Both steady and unsteady flow experiments are reviewed, with the trials having been held in wind tunnels and the free atmosphere. The topics discussed are of interest to designers of RPVs, high altitude aircraft, sailplanes, ultralights and wind turbines.
Mueller, T. J.↗
An analysis of a separation bubble transition criterion at low Reynolds numbers
Factors which influence the criterion governing the length of the laminar region of a separation bubble on an airfoil at low Re were investigated. The criterion is the onset of separation when a critical Re value is surpassed. Wind tunnel data were gathered for the flow around a NACA 66(3)-018 airfoil at Re from 50,000-200,000. The data were taken with either hot-wire anemometers or pressure taps. The value of the critical Re was influenced by the chord Re, the angle of attack and the level of turbulence in the free stream. However, the turbulence levels examined, up to 0.184 percent, did not greatly affect the critical Re. Further characterizations of the effects of the three factors on the critical Re are necessary before the important features of separation bubbles can be identified with an acceptable level of certainty.
Schmidt, G. S.↗
The influence of laminar separation and transition on low Reynolds number airfoil hysteresis
An experimental study of the Lissaman 7769 and Miley MO6-13-128 airfoils at low chord Reynolds numbers is presented. Although both airfoils perform well near their design Reynolds number of about 600,000, they each produce a different type of hysteresis loop in the lift and drag forces when operated below chord Reynolds numbers of 300,000. The type of hysteresis loop was found to depend upon the relative location of laminar separation and transition. The influence of disturbance environment and experimental procedure on the low Reynolds number airfoil boundary layer behavior is also presented. The use of potential flow solutions to help predict how a given airfoil will behave at low Reynolds numbers is also discussed.
Mueller, T. J.↗
Experimental studies of the boundary layer on an airfoil at low Reynolds numbers
An experimental wind tunnel investigation was carried out to study the effect of laminar separation bubbles on a NACA 66(3)-018 airfoil for Reynolds numbers less than 4.0 x 10 to the 5th. Leading edge laminar separation bubbles formed for angles of attack of approximately 7 to 12 deg. To study the leading edge separation bubble more closely, hotwire anemometer measurements were made in the airfoil a Reynolds number of 8.0 x 10 to the 4th. Velocity and turbulence intensity profiles were obtained and boundary layer parameters were calculated. Frequency spectra were also calculated at key points in the airfoil boundary layer for this case. Correlation of the anemometry data with static pressure distributions, and flow visualization data provided insight into laminar separation bubble behavior at low Reynolds numbers.
Jansen, B. J., Jr.↗
The structure of separated flow regions occurring near the leading edge of airfoils, including transition
Data was obtained for the NACA 663-018 airfoil in order to assess the advantages of tripping the boundary layer very near the leading edge for chord Reynolds numbers between 40,000 and 200,000. Single element trips were made from tape 2.5 mm wide and 0.15 mm thick. The unmodified tape trip in five thicknesses was placed across the span at 1.1% chord and the results of lift and drag measurements compared with the smooth airfoil case. Saw tooth geometry trips were also cut from tape and studied using five thicknesses. The saw tooth trips were placed across the span with the sharp points facing upstream at 1.1% chord and with the valley of the teeth at the 2.5% chord position. A large number of bumps and wiggles were produced in the lift coefficient versus angle of attack curves with various combinations of Reynolds number, thickness, and type of trips. The main result in the drag coefficient was an increase in C sub d min with increase in trip thickness.
Mueller, T. J.↗
The influence of free-stream disturbances on low Reynolds number airfoil experiments
The results of an investigation of the influence of free stream disturbances on the lift and drag performance of the Lissaman 7769 airfoil are presented. The wind tunnel disturbance environment is described using hot-wire anemometer and sound pressure level measurements. The disturbance level is increased by the addition of a 'turbulence screen' upstream of the test section and/or the addition of a flow restrictor downstream of the test section. For the Lissaman airfoil it was found that the problems associated with obtaining accurate wind tunnel data at low chord Reynolds numbers (i.e., below 200,000) are compounded by the extreme sensitivity of the boundary layers to the free stream disturbance environment. The effect of free stream disturbances varies with magnitude, frequency content, and source of the disturbance.
Mueller, T. J.↗
Experimental studies of the Eppler 61 airfoil at low Reynolds numbers
The results of an experimental study to document the effects of separation and transition on the performance of an airfoil designed for low Reynolds number operation are presented. Lift, drag and flow visualization data were obtained for the Eppler 61 airfoil section for chord Reynolds numbers from about 30,000 to over 200,000. Smoke flow visualization was employed to document the boundary layer behavior and was correlated with the Eppler airfoil design and analysis computer program. Laminar separation, transition and turbulent reattachment had significant effects on the performance of this airfoil.
Burns, T. F.↗
Experimental and numerical studies of the incompressible viscous flow over a two-dimensional airfoil
Physical and numerical experiments for the low Reynolds number flow over a two-dimensional NACA 66(3)-018 airfoil have been performed. Pressure distributions and smoke flow photographs have been obtained for a Reynolds number based on airfoil chord and free-stream conditions of approximately 40,000 at angles of attack of 0 and 6 deg, and for a Reynolds number based on airfoil chord and free-stream conditions of approximately 400,000 at angles of attack of 0 and 12 deg in a low turbulence wind tunnel. Finite difference numerical experiments, using an approximate factorization method, have been obtained for a Reynolds number of 40,000 at angles of attack of 0 and 6 deg. Although the comparison of the wind tunnel and computer results is encouraging, further studies of this type are clearly necessary.
Mueller, T. J.↗
Experimental studies of the laminar separation bubble on a two-dimensional airfoil at low Reynolds numbers
The laminar separation, transition and turbulent reattachment near the leading edge of a two-dimensional NACA 663-018 airfoil were investigated using a low speed, smoke visualization wind tunnel. Lift and drag force measurements were made using an external strain gauge balance for a chord Reynolds number range of 40,000 to 400,000. An extensive flow visualization study was performed and correlated with the force measurements. Experiments were also conducted with distributed surface roughness at the leading edge and external acoustic excitation to influence the development of the airfoil boundary layer. This study delineates the effects of angle of attack and chord Reynolds number on the separation bubble characteristics and airfoil performance
Mueller, T. J.↗
Visualization of the laminar-turbulent transition in the flow over an airfoil using the smoke-wire technique
A flow visualization technique, referred to as the smoke-wire, was used for visualization of the transition of the free shear layer associated with the laminar separation bubble of a NACA 66 sub 3-018 airfoil section at low Reynolds number (50,000-130,000). The smoke-wire technique allows the introduction of fine smoke streaklines into the flow field through the electrical resistive heating of a very fine wire which has been coated with oil and which is located upstream from the leading edge of the airfoil section. Streakline data were collected using both high speed still and motion picture photography.
Batill, S. M.↗
On the laminar separation, transition, and turbulent reattachment of low Reynolds number flows near the leading edge of airfoils
The laminar separation, transition, and turbulent reattachment near the leading edge of a cylindrical nose-constant thickness airfoil model were investigated using a low turbulence, low speed smoke wind tunnel. The locations of separation, transition, and reattachment were obtained from smoke flow photographs and surface oil flow techniques for chord Reynolds numbers from about 150,000 to 470,000. These visual data combined with static pressure distributions and lift and drag measurements delineate the effects of angle of attack, flap deflection angle, and chord Reynolds number on the separation bubble characteristics. The data concerning the length of the laminar and turbulent portions of the bubble agree with the empirical prediction methods for short bubbles.
Arena, A. V.↗