Training physical matter to matter
A new paradigm for generating adaptive functionality in materials.
Engineering topics
Publications and source records attributed to Nagel, Sidney R..
A new paradigm for generating adaptive functionality in materials.
Evolution in time-varying environments naturally leads to adaptable biological systems that can easily switch functionalities. Advances in the synthesis of environmentally responsive materials therefore open up the possibility of creating a wide range of synthetic materials which can also be trained for adaptability. We consider high-dimensional inverse problems for materials where any particular functionality can be realized by numerous equivalent choices of design parameters. By periodically switching targets in a given design algorithm, we can teach a material to perform incompatible functionalities with minimal changes in design parameters. We exhibit this learning strategy for adaptability in two simulated settings: elastic networks that are designed to switch deformation modes with minimal bond changes and heteropolymers whose folding pathway selections are controlled by a minimal set of monomer affinities. The resulting designs can reveal physical principles, such as nucleation-controlled folding, that enable such adaptability.
Significance Many protocols used in material design and training have a common theme: they introduce new degrees of freedom, often by relaxing away existing constraints, and then evolve these degrees of freedom based on a rule that leads the material to a desired state at which point these new degrees of freedom are frozen out. By creating a unifying framework for these protocols, we can now understand that some protocols work better than others because the choice of new degrees of freedom matters. For instance, introducing particle sizes as degrees of freedom to the minimization of a jammed particle packing can lead to a highly stable state, whereas particle stiffnesses do not have nearly the same impact.
Disorder is present to some extent in every material. The disorder can be sparse and localized – individual defects – or globally such as in a glass. Normally disorder is considered to be detrimental to function. However, this is not necessarily always the case. This project addressed the question: How does disorder provide new potentialities for the behavior of a material that would be absent in a crystalline material of the same composition? We have discovered a new principle for disordered matter: Independence of bond-level response. This work has introduced the possibility of creating new classes of mechanical meta-materials with applications everywhere from microscopic biological molecules (allostery) to large scale architectural disordered networks. During the course of this grant, we have subsequently elaborated on these novel ideas about bond-level independence of properties in disordered materials. In particular, this study has required that we understand the limits of disorder. That is, if crystals are perfect order, is there another diametrically opposed pole which is the most disordered state? We have shown that, in a well-defined way, jamming is one extreme disordered pole of rigid matter. Jamming is a far-from-equilibrium way of creating a rigid solid by rapidly quenching a random distribution of particles to a mechanically stable system at zero temperature. To understand the jammed state of matter, we have elucidated the low-frequency excitation of these systems. This has allowed a new way of understanding materials that cannot be easily classified as crystals or glasses. These ideas can be extended to address the mechanical properties of polycrystalline matter. Memory formation in matter can take inspiration from memory that occurs in a biological context. The issue of memory formation raises another set of questions at the heart of how the energy landscape is organized and how it can be manipulated to store information in a solid. This project has explored how to understand the degree to which multiple memories can be stored in a single system and has created a holistic understanding of how inputs can be used to create a desired response.
An interacting-rearrangement model for sheared solids shows multiple interaction-encoding memories and complex limit cycles.
Significance It is well appreciated that many disordered materials deform their shape irreversibly (plastically) under an external load (e.g., memory foam). Here, we show that this plasticity can be exploited to train materials to develop novel elastic responses by straining them periodically. By applying different periodic strains to a common viscoelastic material, we are able to design a number of different responses. These include a maximally negative Poisson’s ratio, bistable behavior, and nonlocal bond-specific responses. In contrast to computer-aided design, we rely on plasticity to self-organize the system in response to local stresses. This approach shows promise to achieve an unprecedented control over behavior at large strains well beyond the linear-response regime.
Disordered solids often change their elastic response as they slowly age. Using experiments and simulations, we study how aging disordered planar networks under an applied stress affects their nonlinear elastic response. We are able to modify dramatically the elastic properties of our systems in the nonlinear regime. Using simulations, we study two models for the microscopic evolution of properties of such a material; the first considers changes in the material strength, while the second considers distortions in the microscopic geometry. Both models capture different aspects of the experiments including the encoding of memories of the aging history of the system and the dramatic effects on the material’s nonlinear elastic properties. Our results demonstrate how aging can be used to create complex elastic behavior in the nonlinear regime.
Disordered materials are often out of equilibrium and evolve very slowly in a rugged and tortuous energy landscape. This slow evolution, referred to as aging, is deemed undesirable as it often leads to material degradation. However, we show that aging also encodes a memory of the stresses imposed during preparation. Because of inhomogeneous local stresses, the material itself decides how to evolve by modifying stressed regions differently from those under less stress. Because material evolution occurs in response to stresses, aging can be “directed” to produce sought-after responses and unusual functionalities that do not inherently exist. Aging obeys a natural “greedy algorithm” as, at each instant, the material simply follows the path of most rapid and accessible relaxation. Our experiments and simulations illustrate directed aging in examples in which the material’s elasticity transforms as desired because of an imposed deformation.
We design and create isotropically auxetic networks with Poisson's ratio close to −1 in experiments. To achieve this, we selectively prune bonds from disordered networks, and then optimize the properties of individual bonds and nodes.
Memory formation in matter is a theme of broad intellectual relevance; it sits at the interdisciplinary crossroads of physics, biology, chemistry, and computer science. Memory connotes the ability to encode, access, and erase signatures of past history in the state of a system. Once the system has completely relaxed to thermal equilibrium, it is no longer able to recall aspects of its evolution. The memory of initial conditions or previous training protocols will be lost. Thus many forms of memory are intrinsically tied to far-from-equilibrium behavior and to transient response to a perturbation. This general behavior arises in diverse contexts in condensed-matter physics and materials, including phase change memory, shape memory, echoes, memory effects in glasses, return-point memory in disordered magnets, as well as related contexts in computer science. Yet, as opposed to the situation in biology, there is currently no common categorization and description of the memory behavior that appears to be prevalent throughout condensed-matter systems. Here the focus is on material memories. Here, the basic phenomenology of a few of the known behaviors that can be understood as constituting a memory will be described. The hope is that this will be a guide toward developing the unifying conceptual underpinnings for a broad understanding of memory effects that appear in materials.
Nature is rife with networks that are functionally optimized to propagate inputs to perform specific tasks. Whether via genetic evolution or dynamic adaptation, many networks create functionality by locally tuning interactions between nodes. Here we explore this behavior in two contexts: strain propagation in mechanical networks and pressure redistribution in flow networks. By adding and removing links, we are able to optimize both types of networks to perform specific functions. We define a single function as a tuned response of a single “target” link when another, predetermined part of the network is activated. Using network structures generated via such optimization, we investigate how many simultaneous functions such networks can be programed to fulfill. We find that both flow and mechanical networks display qualitatively similar phase transitions in the number of targets that can be tuned, along with the same robust finite-size scaling behavior. We discuss how these properties can be understood in the context of constraint–satisfaction problems.
Here, at densities higher than the jamming transition for athermal, frictionless repulsive spheres we find two distinct length scales, both of which diverge as a power law as the transition is approached. The first, ξ Z , is associated with the two-point correlation function for the number of contacts on two particles as a function of the particle separation. Additionally, the second, ξ f , is associated with contact-number fluctuations in subsystems of different sizes. On scales below ξ f , the fluctuations are highly suppressed, similar to the phenomenon of hyperuniformity usually associated with density fluctuations. The exponents for the divergence of ξ Z and ξ f are different and appear to be different in two and three dimensions.
The modulus of a rigid network of harmonic springs depends on the sum of the energies in each of the bonds due to an applied distortion such as compression in the case of the bulk modulus or shear in the case of the shear modulus. Yet, the distortion need not be global. Here we introduce a local modulus, L i , associated with changing the equilibrium length of a single bond, i , in the network. We show that L i is useful for understanding many aspects of the mechanical response of the entire system. It allows an efficient computation of how the removal of any bond changes the global properties such as the bulk and shear moduli. Additionally, it allows a prediction of the distribution of these changes and clarifies why the changes of these two moduli due to removal of a bond are uncorrelated; these are the essential ingredients necessary for the efficient manipulation of network properties by bond removal.
Recent theoretical work suggests that systematic pruning of disordered networks consisting of nodes connected by springs can lead to materials that exhibit a host of unusual mechanical properties. In particular, global properties such as Poisson's ratio or local responses related to deformation can be precisely altered. Tunable mechanical responses would be useful in areas ranging from impact mitigation to robotics and, more generally, for creation of metamaterials with engineered properties. However, experimental attempts to create auxetic materials based on pruningbased theoretical ideas have not been successful. In this study, we introduce a more realistic model of the networks, which incorporates angle-bending forces and the appropriate experimental boundary conditions. A sequential pruning strategy of select bonds in this model is then devised and implemented that enables engineering of specific mechanical behaviors upon deformation, both in the linear and in the nonlinear regimes. In particular, it is shown that Poisson's ratio can be tuned to arbitrary values. The model and concepts discussed here are validated by preparing physical realizations of the networks designed in this manner, which are produced by laser cutting 2D sheets and are found to behave as predicted. Furthermore, by relying on optimization algorithms, we exploit the networks' susceptibility to tuning to design networks that possess a distribution of stiffer and more compliant bonds and whose auxetic behavior is even greater than that of homogeneous networks. Finally, taken together, the findings reported here serve to establish that pruned networks represent a promising platform for the creation of unique mechanical metamaterials.
We explore the range over which the elasticity of disordered spring networks can be manipulated by the removal of selected bonds.
In this work, we consider the contribution to the density of vibrational states and the distribution of energy barrier heights of incipient instabilities in a glass modeled by a jammed packing of spheres. On approaching an instability, the frequency of a normal mode and the height of the energy barrier to cross into a new ground state both vanish. These instabilities produce a contribution to the density of vibrational states that scales as ω 3 at low frequencies ω, and a contribution to the distribution of energy barriers ΔH that scales as ΔH -1/3 at low barrier heights.
Athermal disordered systems can display a remarkable response to an applied oscillatory shear: After a relatively few shearing cycles, the system falls into a configuration that had already been visited in a previous cycle. After this point the system repeats its dynamics periodically despite undergoing many particle rearrangements during each cycle. We study here the behavior of orbits as we approach the jamming point in simulations of jammed particles subject to oscillatory shear at fixed pressure and zero temperature. As the pressure is lowered, we find that it becomes more common for the system to find periodic states where it takes multiple cycles before returning to a previously visited state. Thus, there is a proliferation of longer periods as the jamming point is approached.