Horizontal Split-Table Conceptual Design to Support Advanced Reactor Validation Needs
Not Available
Engineering topics
Publications and source records attributed to Percher, Catherine M..
Not Available
This report presents the final design (CED-2) for three additional mixed-spectra configurations for plutonium Thermal/Epithermal eXperiments (TEX) to target the intermediate energy region (IER-553). The baseline cases of IER-184 (PU-MET-MIXED-002 [2]) spanned the entire fission energy spectrum. Case 3, which had a median fission energy (MFE) of approximately 6E-5 MeV and had a fission fraction of about 42% in the intermediate energy range, resulted in a $k_{eff}$ overestimation of 1.1%. Compared to 749 previous ICSBEP plutonium benchmarks, the baseline cases accurately predicted the experiments in the thermal and fast regions where the majority of benchmarks inhabit. The benchmarks in the intermediate energy region to date are sparse and overestimate $k_{eff}$ with an average C/E between 1.02 and 1.03. The additional proposed configurations span the whole of the intermediate energy region. The experimental design utilizes the plutonium/aluminum metal alloy Zero Power Physics Reactor (ZPPR) Plutonium-Aluminum No-Nickel (PANN) plates with varying polyethylene moderator thicknesses to span the intermediate fission energy region. Each of the cases have varying fractions of thermal, intermediate, and fast fissions. The designs were chosen to maximize the intermediate energy fraction. The experiment will take place on the universal critical assembly machine, Planet. The layers will be split as equally as possible between the lower platen and the upper stationary platform of Planet. The upper half of the experimental configuration will also have an upper reflector of polyethylene of specified thicknesses to achieve criticality when the lower platen is raised fully. The previous IER-184 configurations, specifically Case 3, were used to determine the configurations for the additional experiments and neutronics calculations were used to fine-tune the configurations to ensure criticality. The quadrature sum uncertainty in Δ$k_{eff}$ for Case 3 in PU-MET-MIXED-002 was found to be 0.00219. Section 3.8 gives a detailed description of the uncertainties calculated. The additional configurations, which are based directly on Case 3, are expected to have similar uncertainties. However, it is possible to reduce the overall uncertainty of Δ$k_{eff}$ for the additional configurations using the knowledge obtained from the calculations in the benchmark.
Oak Ridge National Laboratory and Lawrence Livermore National Laboratory are collaborating to develop a conceptual design for a horizontal split table for use in performing critical experiments. The goal of this design effort is to provide nuclear data testing and validation capabilities for advanced reactors such as pebble-bed high-temperature gas-cooled reactors, molten salt reactors, and heat pipe microreactor, but it could also be used for the current generation of reactors. The first concept being explored for the horizontal split table, a pebble-bed design based on the HTR-10 reactor, is described in this paper. A critical configuration corresponding to a footprint of about 4.5 m 2 was determined with SCALE/KENO-VI to fit the planned dimensions of the horizontal split table. The similarity of the pebble-bed design and the HTR-10 reactor application was assessed using SCALE/TSUNAMI, and a similarity coefficient $c_k$ of 0.9982 was obtained, proving that the concept will be useful for nuclear data validation and assimilation of pebble-bed type advanced reactors. In the proposed design, the materials with the highest $k_{eff}$ sensitivity are graphite and uranium, demonstrating that particular care must be given to carbon-related cross-section data. The effect of mechanical uncertainties between the fixed and moving tables was also assessed by calculating the reactivity change caused by vertical and horizontal gaps, as well as angular and torsion offsets between the two sides of the horizontal split table concept. The highest relative changes on the concept’s reactivity were caused by angular perturbations. The same analysis process is currently being used to create a molten salt advanced reactor type horizontal split table concept based on the Molten Salt Reactor Experiment (MSRE).
The US Department of Energy Nuclear Criticality Safety Program (NCSP) convened a multinational Thermal Epithermal eXperiments (TEX) meeting in July of 2011 to discuss the data and experimental needs of criticality safety practitioners. The number one and two priority integral experiment data needs were for 239 Pu and 240 Pu, with special emphasis on cross section performance in the intermediate energy range (from 0.625 eV to 100 keV). LLNL measured five critical configurations with LANL for the plutonium test bed (IER-184) and published the experiments as International Criticality Safety Benchmark Evaluation Project evaluation PUMET-MIXED-002. Modeling of the benchmark configurations using ENDF/B-VIII.0 nuclear data showed significant overprediction of reactivity for configurations that had a large percentage of fissions in the intermediate energy regime. This report documents a variation on the TEX plutonium test bed to provide a test of 240 Pu cross sections, with sensitivity of the configuration to 240 Pu radiative capture and fission cross sections a priority for the design.
This report presents the preliminary design (CED-1) of IER-539, focused on a new Horizontal Split Table (HST) critical assembly machine. The Department of Energy (DOE) National Nuclear Criticality Safety Program (NCSP) funds critical experiment R&D and its Mission and Vision document identifies a long-standing technical gap of a general purpose HST. HSTs have historically been used for experiments that are impractical to assemble on a vertical lift machine (VLM), usually due to their large physical size or weight. While many HSTs were historically employed in the US (including at LLNL), there are currently no surviving HSTs in the US. While there are two critical experiments facilities remaining in the US, the National Critical Experiments Research Center (NCERC) operated by LANL and the Critical Experiments Facility (CX) operated by SNL, these facilities are not equipped with a general purpose HST. There are a number of experiment designs that require an HST, including needs for Defense Programs and Nuclear Energy. Lack of an HST constraints the national ability to perform large and heavy experiments. Large footprints are needed to successfully create mockup experiments for advanced reactors (mock-up cold critical reactor cores, which is a urgent need for new reactor designs using novel materials and longer cycle lengths), to create solution experiments in lattices, or to test nuclear data of heavy metals. A new HST is a vital piece of criticality experiment infrastructure that would allow for the conduct of integral critical experiments to address needs in the nuclear criticality safety, nuclear data, and other DOE stakeholder communities.
Often when planning a criticality experiment, many design configurations are iteratively investigated with a Monte Carlo transport code. The goal is that the experiment will be optimal with respect to some variable, like the fraction of fissions occurring at a certain energy range, while simultaneously being critical. Unfortunately, the Monte Carlo transport simulations are expensive, which can ultimately limit the number of configurations that can be explored. In this work, we present how Gaussian processes (GPs) can be used as a reduced-order model in a constrained Bayesian optimization (CBO) algorithm to design a criticality experiment. The GPs replace the Monte Carlo transport simulations that explore the design space. The CBO algorithm efficiently identifies new points in the design space to run the Monte Carlo transport code while respecting the criticality constraint. It does so in a manner that both improves the accuracy of the GP and finds the approximate global optimum. We demonstrate the performance of CBO with the design of a Thermal Epithermal eXperiment (TEX) for the criticality safety validation of nuclear waste models of the Hanford Tank Farm.
Washington River Protection Solutions (WRPS) uses MCNP6.2 and the Whisper code for criticality safety analyses of the Hanford Tank Farm. Together the codes derive baseline upper subcritical limits (USLs) for the waste models using experimental benchmarks. Whisper returns higher USLs, i.e. , has less of a conservative penalty, when the neutronic similarity of the experimental benchmarks to the application is high. Unfortunately, few critical benchmarks have high similarity to the Hanford tanks. The waste in the tanks is highly dilute in plutonium and contains large masses of weakly neutron-absorbing elements like iron and manganese. Experimental benchmarks typically have low sensitivity to these absorbers because they are present as structural materials. Lacking similar benchmarks, new Thermal Epithermal eXperiment (TEX) configurations with high Pu content and interstitial iron absorbers have been designed for the criticality safety validation. The features of the design have been iterated upon to maximize the similarity between the experiment and different Hanford waste models. The similarity is quantified with sensitivity analysis and uncertainty quantification using the representativity coefficient, or c k . The representativity calculation requires nuclear data covariances, which may differ between nuclear data libraries and between library versions. Because of these variations, the optimal design may depend on the nuclear data covariances library. A scenario can be envisioned where an experiment is designed, and c k is maximized, with one set of covariance data. However, when the covariance data is changed, say from ENDF/B-VII.1 to ENDF/B-VIII.0, and the benchmark is used in a criticality safety evaluation, the experiment becomes suboptimal with respect to c k . In this paper, we present how the optimal design of the new TEX experiments varied depending on the nuclear data covariances used to calculate c k . We compare ENDF/B-VII.1 and ENDF/B-VIII.0, as if the library had been updated since the design of the experiment. Additionally, we use JEFF3.3 to simulate if the covariance data of a different library had been used. The results show that the covariances do have an important effect on the designs, less so for thermal systems (where the data are more consistent between evaluations) and more so for epithermal systems where more differences exist.
Five plutonium baseline experiments completed in September of 2018 from the Thermal Epithermal eXperiments (TEX) program have been accepted by the International Criticality Safety Benchmark Evaluation Project as PU-MET-MIXED-002 and will be included in the 2020 version of the handbook. The experiments were made up of stacked layers of plutonium Zero Power Physics Reactor (ZPPR) plates moderated by polyethylene (PE, chemical formula C2H4) to varying degrees to create configurations with five different neutron spectra, including one fast configuration, one thermal configuration, and three mixed configurations. Calculations of the benchmark show overprediction of k eff when using the most recent release of the Evaluated Nuclear Data File Version B (ENDF/B) library release (VIII.0) cross sections, particularly when compared to the previous ENDF/B-VII.1 results. One potential source of overprediction was hypothesized to be the new Molecular Dynamics (MD) generated PE Thermal Scattering Law (TSL). The overprediction was shown via calculation to not be caused by the new ENDF/B-VIII.0 thermal scattering law, and in fact the overprediction was mitigated by the new PE TSL.
This report documents the plutonium baseline experimental critical configurations for the United States Nuclear Criticality Safety Program’s Thermal/Epithermal eXperiments (TEX) program. Five TEX experiments (Experiments 1-5) were designed to establish baseline configurations with plutonium/aluminum metal alloy Zero Power Physics Reactor (ZPPR) Plutonium-Aluminum No-Nickel (PANN) plates covering five different fission energy regimes, with varying fractions of thermal, intermediate, and fast fissions. All five experiments are acceptable as benchmarks. As the neutron spectra of the five experiments differed, Case 1 is cross listed as PU-MET-FAST-048 and Cases 4 and 5 are cross listed as PU-MET-THERM-002. For all five experiments, the ZPPR plates were arranged on trays in layers of 24 plates (6 plates by 4 plates), resulting in approximately a 30 cm by 30 cm footprint. Multiple layers were stacked together with varying thicknesses of interspersed polyethylene placed between the layers to tune the neutron spectrum of the assembly. The experiments were completed in multiple campaigns over 2017 and 2018 at the National Criticality Experiments Research Center (NCERC) at the Nevada National Security Site (NNSS).
This report documents the experimental critical configurations for IER-184, Thermal/Epithermal eXperiments (TEX), using plutonium ZPPR plates moderated by polyethylene with and without a tantalum diluent. The experiments were completed in multiple campaigns over 2017 and 2018 at the National Critical Experiments Research Center (NCERC) at the Nevada National Security Site (NNSS).
This report presents the preliminary critical experiment design (CED-1) for IER-329, which consists of several critical experiment configurations that were designed using 233 U ZPPR plates moderated and reflected by high-density polyethylene (HDPE).
Critical experiment benchmarks are essential for validating calculational techniques used by criticality safety engineers to guarantee safe fissile material operations, yet there remain significant areas of need where existing benchmarks are insufficient or entirely absent. There is a particularly notable shortage of intermediate benchmarks (where the majority of fissions are caused by neutrons with energy between 0.625 eV and 100 keV). This work describes the design of a set of critical experiments that address this gap by developing a highly enriched uranium (HEU) test bed into which various materials of interest (diluents) can be substituted. The first diluent to be investigated with this test bed is hafnium, a neutron poison used in nu clear applications for which there are no sufficiently sensitive benchmarks. Twenty-one critical configurations made up of stacked disks of HEU, polyethylene, and hafnium were designed and simulated in MCNP6 to calculate their fission energy spectra and the sensitivity of k eff to changes in various cross sections. It was shown that configurations spanned the energy range from thermal (below 0.625 eV), through the intermediate energy range (0.625 eV to 100 keV), to fast (above 100 keV). Furthermore, it was determined that this set of experiments is sensitive to the hafnium and 235 U cross section data. These test bed experiments were designed to allow substitution of various diluent plates and can therefore be used to quickly and easily produce many more benchmarks.
Abstract not provided.
The Lawrence Livermore National Laboratory (LLNL), under the auspices of the Department of Energy’s Nuclear Criticality Safety Program (NCSP), began hosting a 4- Day Hands-on Nuclear Criticality Safety (NCS) Training Course in 2006. This class was designed to give NCS engineers the opportunity to experimentally measure the effects of different parameters on the reactivity of a fissile material assembly. Since the inception of the class, LLNL has conducted 35 classes and has drawn over 350 students from around the DOE complex, the Nuclear Regulatory Commission, Naval Reactors, the Department of Defense, the Department of Justice, the Federal Bureau of Investigation, and Aldermasten Weapons Establishment in the United Kingdom.
Materials Management (MM) has purchased a new calorimeter to be used in B332, Room 1314A under Operational Safety Plan (OSP) 332.032, Nuclear Material Measurements. Calorimeters quantitatively measure the decay heat produced by fissionable material to verify the fissionable mass of items for Material Control and Accountability (MC&A). The new commercially available calorimeter, the Setaram Large Volume air bath Calorimeter (LVC) 3013, was specially designed for measuring 3013 cans. Operations have requested Standard Criticality Control Conditions (SCCCs) consistent with the other calorimeters and MC&A workstations covered by OSP 332.032. This report documents the criticality safety evaluation of the new LVC 3013 with SCCCs A, V1, V2, and V6. An addendum to this evaluation, CSM 1576, Addendum 1, Criticality Safety Evaluation of Approved Items for LVC 3013 under OSP 332.032 (U), provides the technical basis for SCCC V3 and the accompanying approved item list from OSP 332.032.