LLNL Report: Presented (on-line) to the Nuclear Data Advisory Group on December 3, 2020 [Slides]
Abstract not provided.
Engineering topics
Publications and source records attributed to Percher, Catherine.
Abstract not provided.
This presentation states that new TSLs in ENDF/B-VIII.0 will reduce the overprediction of the library for the most moderated cases. The differences between VII.1 and VIII.0 are driven by the 239 Pu changes and are consistently higher for all configurations. The VIII.0 239 Pu thermal cross sections were specifically adjusted lower to better predict plutonium thermal solutions criticality benchmarks, yet they overpredict the TEX thermal configurations, moderated by PE. Other, smaller differences have been seen for 240 Pu and 56 Fe. PMM-002 has shown utility in testing cross sections over a wide range of neutron energies.
The Working Party on Nuclear Criticality Safety (WPNCS) under the guidance of the Organization for Economic Co-operation and Development (OECD) Nuclear Energy Agency (NEA) has over 20 years of experience addressing concerns related to static and transient configurations encountered within the nuclear fuel cycle: fuel fabrication, transportation, reprocessing, storage, and geological disposal. One of the cornerstone activities of the WPNCS is the International Criticality Safety Benchmark Evaluation Project (ICSBEP), which was established to identify a comprehensive set of criticality benchmark data, evaluate the data, including quantification of overall uncertainties; compile the data into a standardized format, perform sample calculations utilizing modern nuclear data sets and codes utilized in nuclear criticality safety, and formally document the work into a single source of verified benchmark data. Annually, members of the ICSBEP Technical Review Group (TRG) contribute evaluated benchmark data that undergoes comprehensive technical review prior to publication in the ICSBEP Handbook. In the years since the ICSBEP was established, there has been much work to prepare benchmark data to support validation activities in nuclear criticality safety. The 2020 edition of the ICSBEP Handbook contains acceptable benchmark specifications for 5,053 critical, subcritical, or near-critical configurations in 582 benchmark evaluations. Modern benchmark development benefits from decades of experienced international participants, a well-established handbook format, supplementary guides to deal with uncertainty quantification, and a comprehensive review process based upon independent reviews from international experts. The ICSBEP Handbook also contains 838 configurations deemed unacceptable to support criticality safety efforts. They are recorded, with the reasoning for their rejection, to preserve the experimental data, prevent reevaluation of data that are incomplete or contain known errors, and/or to potentially allow future reevaluation of the experiment pending the identification of sufficient data to resolve identified inconsistencies and errors. Users of the ICSBEP Handbook today might notice that the rigor and quality of modern criticality safety benchmarks is much greater than those prepared within the initial decade of the project. Benchmarks with 1s uncertainties in k eff greater than 1% were traditionally rejected unless they were identified as unique experiment types that encompassed materials, fuels, or designs not available from other benchmark experiments. However, benchmarks developed using modern experimental techniques and practices typically have uncertainties on the order of a few tenths of a percent. There have been ongoing efforts to improve the overall quality of previously published benchmark evaluations. Seventy-eight evaluations, containing approximately 600 configurations, have been revised just within the past decade. An additional eleven benchmarks are under revision for updated release in the 2020 edition of the ICSBEP Handbook. If some of the historic benchmarks were resubmitted in their current form to the TRG today, they would be rejected due to lack of data, missing components in the uncertainty analysis, or incomplete benchmark model development. The use of historic criticality safety benchmarks that underestimate the total uncertainty, lack properly quantified biases, or provide inadequate benchmark specifications do not sufficiently support modern criticality safety and nuclear data efforts. Although the ICSBEP Handbook is recognized by regulating bodies to support criticality safety, users are required to justify their reasons to ignore historic benchmark data and include additional safety margins within their designs. Discussions were held at the WPNCS 23rd Annual Meeting in September 2019 regarding the aforementioned issues. The resultant decision was to establish Subgroup 8 (SG-8): Preservation of Expert Knowledge and Judgement Applied to Criticality Benchmarks. The current activities of SG-8 are discussed herein.
The Hanford tank farms contain 56 million gallons of waste across 177 tanks. The primary criticality safety concern for the waste is the plutonium inventory in waste solids – approximately 670 kg in total. Criticality safety analysis credits the absorption and dilution properties of the large quantities of other elements (aluminum, chromium, iron, manganese, nickel, silicon, sodium, and zirconium) present in the waste. Of these, iron and manganese are by far the most significant neutron absorbers, particularly for the waste compositions of highest criticality safety concern. The criticality safety analyses at the Hanford Waste Treatment and Vitrification Plant (WTP) and the Savannah River tank farms also credit iron and manganese as the primary neutron absorbers to demonstrate subcriticality.
Lawrence Livermore National Laboratory has completed the final design for the first phase of the Thermal Epithermal experiments (TEX), which focused on critical configurations composed of plutonium/aluminum Zero Power Physics Reactor (ZPPR) plates moderated by polyethylene with and without a tantalum diluent. {sup 239}Pu and {sup 240}Pu were identified as being the number one and two nuclear data need by the nuclear criticality safety and nuclear data communities, with special emphasis placed on performance issues of the Pu cross sections in the intermediate energy region. Preliminary TEX design recommended tantalum as the first diluent to pursue for final design, as it represented a high priority data need, showed the highest sensitivity and largest contribution to uncertainty with the Pu ZPPR system, and a large number of high quality Ta plates from the ZPPR inventory in Idaho was readily available. The goals of the new critical experiments are 1) to create assemblies that span a wide range of fission energy spectra, from thermal (below 0.625 eV), through the intermediate (0.65 eV to 100 keV), and to fast energies (above 100 keV), and 2) to easily modify the assemblies to include high priority materials like tantalum. A total of ten critical configurations were designed as part of CED-2. Five TEX experiments (Experiments 1-5) were designed to establish baseline configurations with the Pu ZPPR plates covering the thermal, intermediate, and fast fission energy regimes. For all five experiments, the ZPPR plates will be arranged in layers of 24 plates (6 plates by 4 plates), resulting in approximately a 12 inch by 12 inch footprint. Multiple layers will be stacked together with varying thicknesses of interspersed polyethylene placed between the layers to fine tune the neutron spectrum of the assembly. The other five experiments (Experiments 6-10) will be similar to the five baseline experiments, except that a tantalum layer will be placed next to each plutonium plate layer, thus diluting the stack and allowing for tests of the neutron cross section for tantalum. (authors)
Following de-inventory of high security materials from LLNL, a new subcritical assembly for training and detector development purposes was designed and built. This paper describes the safety features inherent in the assembly design and accomplishments related to development, simulation and utilization of the new assembly. (authors)
The goal of the US Nuclear Criticality Safety Program's Thermal Epithermal experiments (TEX) is to design and conduct new critical experiments to address high priority nuclear data needs from the nuclear criticality safety and nuclear data communities, with special emphasis on intermediate energy (0.625 eV - 100 keV) assemblies. The second set of TEX experiments will use stacks of highly enriched uranium Jemima plates, hafnium (Hf) diluent plates, and polyethylene moderator plates to create assemblies that span a wide range of fission energy spectra, from thermal, through intermediate, to fast energies. As the hafnium plates need to be fabricated and represent a significant cost for this experiment, a parameter study examining experimental configurations with various Hf thicknesses was completed using KENO V.a to determine optimal dimensions. The Hf plate thicknesses were optimized based on three major design criteria: 1) ensuring thermal, intermediate, and fast critical configurations could be built, 2) creating assemblies with a height to diameter ratio of approximately one, and 3) maximizing sensitivity to hafnium isotope cross sections, as predicted by the SCALE/TSUNAMI package. Based on the calculations presented in this report, a hafnium thickness of 0.10 cm will result in compact critical assemblies using the existing Jemima plate inventory, while reducing Hf cost and ensuring adequate sensitivity of the system to hafnium cross sections. (authors)
In the frame of the ongoing Thermal/Epithermal experiments program, supported by the DOE-NCSP, we are characterizing expected data with analysis of sensitivity coefficients to nuclear data. The computations were performed for detailed and simplified models of the experimental configurations in order to demonstrate their invariance with respect to small geometry variations. The sensitivity coefficients were computed with recently developed precise methodologies using Monte Carlo tools (MCNP-6.1, SCALE 6.1 and MORET 5.C.1) with the following nuclear data libraries: ENDF/B-VII.0, ENDF/B-VII.1, and JEFF3.1. Since the considered experiments are devoted to tantalum data validation, their neutronic characteristics are compared with the relevant integral experiment data collected in the OECD/NEA ICSBEP Handbook. Although analysis of sensitivity coefficients taken alone is insufficient for an entire assessment, we can conclude that TEX experimental results can fill gaps in the available benchmarks to facilitate quantification of uncertainty for plutonium containing systems with epithermal neutron spectra (e.g. wet plutonium-based powders). However, analysis of sensitivity profiles demonstrates that an advanced statistical methodology will be needed to fit tantalum nuclear data or to evaluate the associated uncertainties. (authors)
The LLNL Nuclear Criticality Safety Division has developed a training center to illustrate criticality safety and reactor physics concepts through hands-on experimental training. The experimental assembly, the Inherently Safe Subcritical Assembly (ISSA), uses surplus highly enriched research reactor fuel configured in a water tank. The training activities will be conducted by LLNL following the requirements of an Integration Work Sheet (IWS) and associated Safety Plan. Students will be allowed to handle the fissile material under the supervision of LLNL instructors. This report provides the technical criticality safety basis for instructional operations with the ISSA experimental assembly.