Search NASA⌕ Search

Engineering topics

Pope, Timothy R.

Publications and source records attributed to Pope, Timothy R..

In-field alpha spectrometry system for uranium enrichment verification of uranium hexafluoride

A portable In-Field Alpha Spectrometry (IFAS) system was developed to support on-site uranium enrichment determination for samples taken at facilities working with gaseous UF 6 . It consists of a modified commercial alpha spectrometer, a vacuum pump, a laptop computer, and associated connectors and cables. The IFAS uses specially designed Single-Use Destructive Assay (SUDA) samplers to capture gaseous UF 6 and convert and store it as UO 2 F 2 in a thin-film zeolite. To examine the quantitative performance of the IFAS system a large number of replicate SUDA samples was acquired for natural uranium (NU, 0.72 wt%, 23 samples), low enriched uranium 1 (LEU1, 2.33 wt% 235 U, 10 samples), and low enriched uranium 2 (LEU2, 4.62 wt% 235 U, 10 samples). The standard deviation (SD) values for uranium enrichment determination with the IFAS for NU, LEU1, and LEU2, in 20-hour assays, were 0.037 wt% 235 U, 0.063 wt% 235 U, and 0.072 wt% 235 U, respectively. In addition, a separate analysis suggests that comparable SD values can be achieved in less time, approximately 8-10 hours. For context, these SD values are well below the International Atomic Energy Agency’s International Target Values for the determination of uranium enrichment in non-destructive assay measurements.

46 INSTRUMENTATION RELATED TO NUCLEAR SCIENCE AND ↗

Optimization Of In-field Alpha Spectrometry For Uranium Enrichment Determination In Uranium Hexafluoride

In response to needs identified by the International Atomic Energy Agency (IAEA) research is underway to develop In-Field Alpha Spectrometry (IFAS) as a method to allow IAEA safeguards inspectors to collect samples of uranium hexafluoride (UF6) at processing facilities to assess and verify uranium enrichment. For sample collection, the IFAS method uses Single-Use Destructive Assay (SUDA) samplers, which contain thin zeolite coatings that trap UF6 gas and convert it to the safer, more stable form uranyl fluoride (as a dihydrate, UO2F2·2H2O). For alpha spectrometry, the IFAS instrument employs a large area silicon semiconductor transducer to detect and record alpha particle energy-deposition events. Over the past year optimization work has significantly increased the diameter of useful SUDA samples (from 12.7 mm to 48 mm), improved the manufacturability and reproducibility of SUDA samples, increased the area of the IFAS alpha spectrometer sensor from 1.2 cm to 3.1 cm, and improved source positioning within the IFAS. This paper will report on this optimization work, its impacts on IFAS performance, and future plans for IFAS miniaturization, improvements, and testing.

Chichester, David↗

Single-Use Destructive Assay for Uranium Hexafluoride Sampling

Sampling uranium hexafluoride (UF6) for the determination of enrichments by destructive analysis (DA) is a critical component in the International Atomic Energy Agency’s layered safeguards approach for uranium processing facilities. Typically, gram-quantity UF6 samples are collected during inspections and stored under tag-and-seal until transportation to an off-site analytical laboratory. The shipping times can be long, and evolving restrictions on radioactive/corrosive materials shipments may increasingly limit the IAEA’s ability to transport UF6 samples easily. Pacific Northwest National Laboratory has developed a low-cost UF6 sampling technology called Single-Use Destructive Assay (SUDA) that addresses these challenges, as well as provides DA sample geometries that can be tailored for different analytical methods, including potential on-site analyses. The SUDA samplers, along with a unique holder, are designed for direct attachment to existing taps at uranium processing facilities, allowing gaseous UF6 to come into direct contact with a zeolite film. The SUDA technology features the ability to capture uranium in a more easily shipped and handled form as the solid, more stable, and relatively less hazardous hydrated uranyl fluoride (UO2F2•nH2O), which is formed through the controlled hydrolysis of UF6. We have recently simulated uranium collection under enrichment plant sampling conditions to further improve our understanding of SUDA sampling. Presented here is our recent work on measuring the relationship between sampling conditions and uranium collection, which includes control of the uranium-mass-to-zeolite ratio and assessing variable UF6 gas and sampling parameters that can affect collection using the SUDA sampler.

Pope, Timothy R.↗

Aspects of Crystal Growth and Atomic-Scale Characterization of U/Th Age-Dating Particles

Trace analysis of particulate material collected on environmental swipe samples continues to be one of the cornerstones of the IAEA’s process of verifying member state compliance as part of the Non-Proliferation Treaty (NPT). While complementary to traditional bulk analysis, the ability to measure individual particles can be far more impactful from a radiochronometry perspective. The 234U/230Th radiochronometer is being evaluated as a means of establishing model ages for discrete particles with sufficient confidence. To support the extension of current capabilities, reference materials with a suitable particle form factor and well-documented purification date are actively sought for development with large geometry secondary ion mass spectroscopy.

Nuclear Safeguards, IAEA, Particle Standards↗

Build Orientation Dependent Microstructure in Polymer Laser Sintering: Relationship to Part Performance and Evolution with Aging

Laser sintering (LS) is widely used to produce functional polymeric parts; however, the resulting parts are often limited by their porous structure, and performance of the part may be strongly anisotropic. Relating the structural features of parts to build process conditions or powder feedstock has been explored previously. In contrast, little is known regarding how the unique internal structures of LS parts evolve and relate to their performance later in their life cycle, for example, after use in a real-world operating environment. In this study, a tightly controlled LS build process and measurement campaign by standard X-ray computed tomography (XCT), supported by high-resolution synchrotron XCT, was used to benchmark the internal microstructure (e.g. porosity) as a function of four different build orientations in printed polyamide-12 (PA-12) parts. The initial performance of the parts after printing was characterized by tensile testing and dynamic mechanical analysis (DMA). Arrays of PA-12 parts in different build orientations were exposed to steam (under pressure) and air across multiple temperature and time points for the purposes of accelerated aging through oxidative and hydrolytic breakdown. Exposing parts to steam dramatically altered the internal microstructure and functional properties such as the glass transition temperature, tensile properties, and damping behavior. Notably, post-aging XCT revealed large microstructural changes after only 40 h of steam treatment relative to the as-printed specimens. Furthermore, pore reorganization and changes in crystallinity occurred regardless of whether the steam temperature was aggressive enough to induce a significant loss in mechanical properties. The build orientation dependence on the aging rate was minimal with the relative trend in performance persisting across most metrics among the different orientations even after aging.

36 MATERIALS SCIENCE↗

"Sintering" Models and In-Situ Experiments: Data Assimilation for Microstructure Prediction in SLS Additive Manufacturing of Nylon Components

Selective laser sintering methods are workhorses for additively manufacturing polymer-based components. The ease of rapid prototyping also means it is easy to produce illicit components. It is necessary to have a data-calibrated in-situ physical model of the build process in order to predict expected and defective microstructure characteristics that inform component provenance. Toward this end, sintering models are calibrated and characteristics such as component defects are explored. This is accomplished by assimilating multiple data streams, imaging analysis, and computational model predictions in an adaptive Bayesian parameter estimation algorithm. From these data sources, along with a phase-field model, bulk porosity distributions are inferred. Model parameters are constrained to physically-relevant search directions by sensitivity analysis, and then matched to predictions using adaptive sampling. Using this feedback loop, data-constrained estimates of sintering model parameters along with uncertainty bounds are obtained.

3D printing, Additive Manufacturing, polymer, sint↗

Production of Particle Reference and Quality Control Materials

Maintaining the superior performance of new analytical instrumentation and pushing the boundaries of ever-smaller particle analysis by methods such as secondary ion mass spectrometry (SIMS) has become limited by the availability of certified particle standards for calibration, quality control, and validation. To meet this growing demand for a reliable and universal approach to the generation of uranium particle reference material, the Pacific Northwest National Laboratory (PNNL) and Savannah River National Laboratory (SRNL) are collaborating on a joint venture that establishes a number of chemical pathways to the fabrication, purification, and stabilization of uranium particle material to within a fixed particle size range, and well-characterized isotopics. PNNL particle standards are designed and tailored to meet the criteria essential to the calibration and benchmarking of instruments used in both the non-destructive and destructive assay of particulate material, typically collected from environmental swipe sampling. Previous testing and optimization of this colloidal approach to particulate material has centred on tight size distributions, singular composition and density, uniform morphology, and tailored isotopic abundances. Extensive validation of this material has since been performed, both at the National Institute of Standards and Technology (NIST) and the International Atomic Energy Agency (IAEA), demonstrating its suitability for quality control needs of large geometry (LG)-SIMS analysis. Building on this momentum, the production of low-enriched uranium particle reference material, with specially tailored isotopics, has moved from development to full operation. Herein, various aspects of the production cycle will be discussed, including detailed accounts of the technical methodologies being employed, as well as insights into the sample characterization and acceptance testing requirements.

Nuclear Safeguards, Particle Standards, IAEA↗

Polysaccharide-based liquid storage and transport media for non-refrigerated preservation of bacterial pathogens

The preservation of biological samples for an extended time period of days to weeks after initial collection is important for the identification, screening, and characterization of bacterial pathogens. Traditionally, preservation relies on cold-chain infrastructure; however, in many situations this is impractical or not possible. Thus, our goal was to develop alternative bacterial sample preservation and transport media that are effective without refrigeration or external instrumentation. The viability, nucleic acid stability, and protein stability of Bacillus anthracis Sterne 34F2, Francisella novicida U112, Staphylococcus aureus ATCC 43300, and Yersinia pestis KIM D27 (pgm-) was assessed for up to 28 days. Xanthan gum (XG) prepared in PBS with L-cysteine maintained more viable F . novicida U112 cells at elevated temperature (40°C) compared to commercial reagents and buffers. Viability was maintained for all four bacteria in XG with 0.9 mM L-cysteine across a temperature range of 22–40°C. Interestingly, increasing the concentration to 9 mM L-cysteine resulted in the rapid death of S . aureus . This could be advantageous when collecting samples in the built environment where there is the potential for Staphylococcus collection and stabilization rather than other organisms of interest. F . novicida and S . aureus DNA were stable for up to 45 days upon storage at 22°C or 40°C, and direct analysis by real-time qPCR, without DNA extraction, was possible in the XG formulations. XG was not compatible with proteomic analysis via LC-MS/MS due to the high amount of residual Xanthomonas campestris proteins present in XG. Our results demonstrate that polysaccharide-based formulations, specifically XG with L-cysteine, maintain bacterial viability and nucleic acid integrity for an array of both Gram-negative and Gram-positive bacteria across ambient and elevated temperatures.

59 BASIC BIOLOGICAL SCIENCES↗

Final Report on the Viability of Acoustic Techniques for Density and Mass Flow in Enrichment Plants

The primary purpose of this research is to study the viability of acoustic signatures and sensors that could support accurate, noninvasive, and unattended measurement of uranium hexafluoride (UF6) gas density and mass flow rate in situations representative of gaseous centrifuge enrichment plants (GCEP) under safeguards by the International Atomic Energy Agency. The measurement method under development can be readily retrofitted to the exterior of piping in existing systems, potentially facilitating acceptance by facility operators. The findings from the demonstration of a preliminary prototype design and first-generation analysis algorithms in this project will inform the safeguards community as to whether continued acoustic instrument and methods development are warranted. This project conducted two types of measurements, depending on the flow conditions of the gas. For static measurements, the focus is on understanding the acoustic properties at low pressure for non-flowing UF6. For flow measurements, the focus is on understanding the performance of the acoustic system in a simulation of a GCEP pipe using a surrogate gas under fully developed flow conditions. Testing with flowing UF6 was not considered because the cost of building a flowing UF6 system with flow similar to a GCEP was considerably greater than allocated project resources. This document summarizes the results of research conducted over the course of the project. Based on the results to date, the approach is seen to be promising with non-invasive acoustic measurements shown to be possible at the desired pressures. The project has demonstrated • 5% uncertainty of the UF6 gas density for static measurements at pressures relevant to GCEP operations over a 5-minute measurement window with a clear path forward to achieving considerably lower uncertainties over a two-hour period, • Measurements of flowing surrogate gases at pressures relevant to GCEP operations. However, additional research remains to be done to further develop the measurement approach and transition the technology for field use. These development needs include: • Understand the impact of flowing gas on gas density measurements, • Adding sensors and improving the measurement procedure, • Augmenting the data analysis methods by leveraging machine learning approaches, • Reevaluating uncertainty requirements for density and mass flow given observed Online Enrichment Monitor (OLEM) measurement uncertainties, • Designing a robust instrumentation package for field-testing, and • Evaluating measurement results to understand the potential impact on mass balance calculations within GCEP facilities.

42 ENGINEERING↗

LASER-BASED MEASUREMENT TOOLS FOR FUTURE ENRICHMENT PLANT SAFEGUARDS

The International Atomic Energy Agency (IAEA) has a long history of testing and using laser-based technologies for a variety of safeguards applications. Notable laser-based on-site applications include: 3-dimensional laser range (3DLR) instruments, used for facility design information and verification (DIV); laser measurements to verify unique labels and detect signs of tampering; and laser spectroscopy, for non-contact process monitoring. The IAEA is also evaluating analytical laboratory instruments, such as laser-ablation inductively-coupled plasma mass spectrometry (LA-ICP-MS) for interrogating individual particles to determine uranium isotopic ratios in collected environment samples. Recent laser technology advancements will likely continue to fuel future IAEA adoption of new and novel laser-based safeguards tools. The Pacific Northwest National Laboratory (PNNL) is currently developing one such tool, called laser ablation, absorption ratio spectrometry (LAARS), for quantitative measurements of uranium material. LAARS uses three tunable diode lasers to simultaneously measure atomic 235U and 238U absorption in an ablation plume created by a fourth pulsed laser. Commercial availability of compact pulsed ablation lasers and the extreme wavelength accuracy and stability of PNNL’s tunable diode laser architecture play a pivotal role in achieving high fidelity LAARS assay measurements. The LAARS method is ultimately targeted for either on-site or laboratory-based 235U relative abundance measurements of destructive assay (DA) samples in support of uranium enrichment plant safeguards. DA samples are currently collected on-site, and then shipped to an analytical laboratory for mass spectrometric assay, because the measurement uncertainty requirements for this application are quite challenging. This paper will present the key elements of the LAARS laser system design, recent assay results on collected uranium hexafluoride (UF6) DA samples, and future operational configurations that may provide immediate on-site DA inspection results or rapid laboratory DA sample screening to prioritize further analysis by mass spectrometry.

IAEA, Safeguards, Uranium Enrichment Plants↗

Laser Ablation, Absorbance Ratio Spectrometry (LAARS) Assay Performance Study (FY2018 Annual Report)

The International Atomic Energy Agency (IAEA) has a long history of testing and using laser-based technologies for a variety of safeguards applications. Notable laser-based on-site applications include: 3-dimensional laser range (3DLR) instruments, used for facility design information and verification (DIV); laser measurements to verify unique labels and detect signs of tampering; and laser spectroscopy, for non-contact process monitoring. The IAEA is also evaluating analytical laboratory instruments, such as laser-ablation inductively-coupled plasma mass spectrometry (LA-ICP-MS) for interrogating individual particles to determine uranium isotopic ratios in collected environment samples. Recent laser technology advancements will continue to fuel future IAEA adoption of new and novel laser-based safeguards tools. Pacific Northwest National Laboratory (PNNL) is developing one such tool, called the Laser Ablation, Absorbance Ratio Spectrometry (LAARS) technology, which is designed to provide high-fidelity 235 U/ 238 U isotope ratio measurements to support either on-site enrichment plant or off-site laboratory destructive assay (DA). Analyzing uranium hexafluoride (UF 6 ) DA samples on-site by LAARS could provide early indication of discrepancies with operator declarations during physical inventory verifications, so that such discrepancies could be addressed immediately, rather than after off-site analysis is completed. The IAEA is also seeking on-site DA options, because sample shipping time can be long and evolving restrictions on radioactive/corrosive material shipments may increasingly limit the IAEA’s ability to easily transport UF 6 samples. Routine on-site LAARS analysis could provide timely assay results and reduce the DA sample shipment inventory to just those needed for more definitive determination. A laboratory-based LAARS instrument could also provide rapid, cost-effective prescreening of selected DA samples shipped to the IAEA’s Nuclear Materials Laboratory in Seibersdorf, Austria. PNNL has also developed a complementary UF 6 sampling technology and method, called the Single-Use Destructive Assay (SUDA) sampler to easily collect DA samples that are ideal for on-site analysis by LAARS. Combining the LAARS and SUDA sampler technologies could provide a powerful new on-site DA option for the IAEA.

46 INSTRUMENTATION RELATED TO NUCLEAR SCIENCE AND ↗

Acoustic Techniques for UF6 Density and Mass Flow Measurements

A key enabling capability for enrichment plant safeguards is high-accuracy, non-invasive, unattended measurement of UF6 gas density and mass flow rate. Acoustic techniques are currently used to non-invasively monitor gas flow in industrial applications; however, the operating pressures at gaseous centrifuge enrichment plants (GCEPs) are roughly two orders magnitude below the capabilities of commercial instrumentation. Pacific Northwest National Laboratory is refining acoustic techniques for estimating density and mass flow rate of UF6 gas in scenarios typical of gaseous centrifuge enrichment plants, with the goal of achieving 1% measurement uncertainty. Proof-of-concept laboratory measurements of UF6 have demonstrated signature sensitivity to gas density at pressures equivalent to 10-50 Torr of UF6, typical pressures for GCEP unit header pipes. This sensitivity was clearly observable above background acoustic interference. Current efforts involve developing a test bed for conducting acoustic measurements on flowing surrogate gas, air and SF6, at representative flow rates and pressures to ascertain the viability of conducting gas flow measurements under these conditions. Density and flow measurements will be conducted to support the evaluation. If successful, the approach could enable an unattended, non-invasive approach to measure UF6 density and mass flow in unit header pipes of GCEPs.

International safeguards instrumentation, acoustic↗

Enhanced anti-counterfeiting measures for additive manufacturing: coupling lanthanide nanomaterial chemical signatures with blockchain technology

The significant rise of additive manufacturing (AM) in recent years is in part due to the open sourced nature of the printing processes and reduced cost and capital barriers relative to traditional manufacturing. However, this democratization of manufacturing spurs an increased demand for producers and end-users to verify the authenticity and quality of individual parts. To this end, we introduce an anti-counterfeiting method composed of first embedding engineered nanomaterials into features of a 3D-printed part followed by non-destructive interrogation of these features to quantify a chemical signature profile. The part specific chemical signature data is then linked to a securitized, distributed, and time-stamped blockchain ledger entry. To demonstrate the utility of this approach, lanthanide-aspartic acid nanoscale coordination polymers (Ln3+- Asp NCs) / poly(lactic) acid (PLA) composites were formulated and transformed into a filament feedstock for fused deposition modeling (FDM) 3D printing. In the present case, a quick-response (QR) code containing the doped Ln3+-Asp NCs was printed using a dual-extruder FDM printer into pure PLA parts. The QR code provides a searchable reference to an Ethereum-based blockchain entry. The QR code physical features also serve as defined areas to probe the signatures arising from the embedded Ln3+-Asp NCs. Visible fluorescence emission with UV-excitation was quantified in terms of color using a smartphone camera and incorporated into blockchain entries. Ultimately, linking unique chemical signature data to blockchain databases is anticipated to make the costs of counterfeiting AM materials significantly more prohibitive and transactions between those in the supply chain more trustworthy.

Additive Manufacturing↗