Engineering topics
Rognlien, T. D.
Publications and source records attributed to Rognlien, T. D..
2D analysis of tokamak divertor-plasma detachment-bifurcation with operational parameters and geometries
UEDGE simulations with density scans for various input power, transport coefficients and outer poloidal leg length are performed to study the conditions for the existence of a bifurcation-like drop of T e at the outer strike point, commonly referred to as a detachment cliff, when transitioning to a detached plasma from an attached plasma in the outer divertor as the upstream density increases (McLean et al., 2015). The simulation results show that a detachment cliff tends to occur with a higher power input regardless of diffusivities and leg length. Further analysis of change of plasma profiles at a cliff indicate that, in addition to the sharp reduction of the E x B drift fluxes in the outer divertor studied in Jaervinen et al., (2018), the substantial change of the Mach number in the outer divertor and the decrease of the outer mid-plane T e due to the radiation front moving across the separatrix into the confinement region above the X-point consistently occur for all UEDGE density scans that have a detachment cliff. UEDGE time-dependent simulation of the evolution of a detachment cliff shows that the rapid increase of radiation above the X-point occurs in a time scale of ~0.3–0.5, which could possibly be the trigger for the formation of a detachment cliff, quicker than the Mach number change in a time scale of ~1 ms and the drop of T e in a time scale of ~2–3 ms in the outer divertor.
UEDGE modeling of plasma detachment of CFETR with ITER ‐like divertor geometry by external impurity seeding
Abstract Efficient handling of high heat flux on the plasma‐facing components, particularly the divertor targets, poses a significant challenge for the Chinese Fusion Engineering Testing Reactor (CFETR) with fusion power of Gigawatt. This work investigates the divertor plasma detachment of CFETR with a standard ITER‐like divertor geometry by neon (Ne) or argon (Ar) impurity seeding using UEDGE code. The cross‐field drifts terms are switched off, and fluid neutral models and a “fixed‐fraction” impurity model are applied to enable efficient simulations for the study of CFETR detachment. In order to reduce the heat load on the divertor targets below the acceptable level (<10 MW/m 2 ), the impurity fraction ( f ), pumping speed ( S ), and upstream density are varied to identify the suitable operations window during Ne seeding. The effects of Ne and Ar impurities on the plasma detachment are compared. It is found that with the power across the core‐edge interface P SOL = 200 MW and separatrix density of 2.8 10 19 , Ne impurity fraction ≥1.7%, and Ar impurity fraction ≥0.24% can achieve the partial detachment. Achieving similar total radiation power (˜148 MW), the Ne fraction is 2.3% and the Ar fraction is 0.24%. Moreover, the simulation results indicate that Ar exhibits better power radiation efficiency and core compatibility compared with Ne.
Modeling of deuterium and carbon radiation transport in MAST-U tokamak advanced divertors
Modest effects of deuterium and carbon radiation opacity in the Super-X and snowflake divertor plasmas are predicted for MAST Upgrade tokamak with core plasma input power 2.5–5 MW and plasma current 1 MA. The radiation transport modeling is based on the SOLPS-EIRENE and UEDGE code divertor plasma predictions. Two radiation transport models are used: one is based on a full radiation transport equation implemented in the radiation transport and collisional-radiative code CRETIN (without feedback on the background plasma), and another is an internal self-consistent UEDGE model with ionization, recombination, and heating rates corrected for Ly α line trapping based on the escape probability model implemented in CRETIN. In MAST-U, the Super-X and snowflake divertor plasmas are predicted to reach detached regimes at lower upstream densities than the standard divertor, and the conclusion still holds with radiation transport effects included. At neutral densities m -3 , modest Ly α deuterium line trapping with optical depths 10–15 is predicted in the Super-X divertor. Divertor plasmas are optically thin to other Lyman and Balmer lines, as well as to strong C III and C IV lines that are responsible for most of divertor radiated power. Insignificant changes (within a few percent) to divertor deuterium ionization and recombination rates are found. Radiation fluxes on outer divertor target are modified within a factor of 2–3 when the radiation transport is accounted for, and a similar variation is found due to the line shape models that define the absorption and emission line profiles in the radiation transport modeling. The predicted Lyman and Balmer spectral intensities are significantly modified due to radiation trapping. A measurement of divertor radiation transport effects is discussed using the Ly β /Ba α line ratio. In the snowflake divertor configuration, divertor plasmas are found to be optically thin to Lyman series lines within a large range of parameter variations that include upstream density, divertor transport coefficients, and magnetic configurations. Finally, modest radiation transport effects are only found in a few cases with strongest divertor transport and magnetic configurations closest to the ideal snowflake configuration, however, the plasma background models that were used are yet to be validated with an experiment.
Modeling Snowflake Divertors in MAST-U Tokamak
We report that in a snowflake (SF) divertor, two magnetic field nulls are placed close to each other, creating four strike points (SPs) compared to two in a standard X-point divertor. In preparation for MAST-U experiments, magnetic configurations with the standard and SF divertors with various locations and separation distances of the nulls were modeled using the two-dimensional multi-fluid code UEDGE with a full plasma transport model featuring charge-state-resolved sputtered carbon impurities. The complex interplay of the plasma transport and magnetic configurations was comprehensively studied using a simple model for the theoretically predicted fast plasma mixing driven by the 'churning' mode instability in the two-null SF region. The modeling results show that (1) all SF-plus configurations and SF-minus configuration with closely located nulls produce the same plasma parameters and heat fluxes at the same SPs; (2) SF divertors approach the outer and inner SP detachment conditions at lower upstream density w.r.t. the standard divertor; (3) heat flux profiles at primary SPs are substantially broadened and peak values are reduced in SF configurations w.r.t. SN divertors; this broadening becomes more pronounced with the fast plasma mixing increase.
FESS Design Simulations: methods, tools, & issues for the edge/scrape-off-layer region
This topic describes the plasma and neutral particles in the transition boundary region between the hot core plasma and the surrounding material walls. A key geometrical transition that occurs in this region is where the equilibrium magnetic field changes topology from a set of closed, nested magnetic flux surfaces inside the magnetic separatrix to flux surfaces, and therefore magnetic field lines that intersect material walls. Because the plasma exhaust heat flows very rapidly along the field lines, these intersection locations can have heat fluxes much higher than the walls can withstand. The most promising strategy pursued here to avoid this problem is injection of moderate-Z impurities that radiate the exhaust power over a much larger surface area on the walls, thus keeping the peak heat flux at or below the goal of 10 MW/m 2 . Further, the intrusion of injected and wall-sputtered impurities into the core region must be kept below certain limits to prevent degradation of the fusion power generated in the core.
Edge and scrape-off layer modeling for a Fusion Nuclear Science Facility with tungsten walls; a summary report for 2019-21
This report summarizes model development and simulations for the edge/scrape-off layer (SOL) region of a Fusion Nuclear Science Facility (FNSF) as part of the DOE Fusion Energy Systems Studies project. An overview of the FNSF device is given in Ref. 1. Our earlier related modeling of FNSF in the 2015-16 timeframe is reported in Ref. 2, and similar work on the ARIES ACT-1 tokamak device is described in Ref. 3. During 2017-18, we contributed to the analysis of a liquid lithium wall for FNSF [4].
Comparison of a collisional-radiative fluid model of H2 in UEDGE to the kinetic neutral code EIRENE
Not Available
Overview of the fusion nuclear science facility, a credible break-in step on the path to fusion energy
The Fusion Nuclear Science Facility (FNSF) is examined here as part of a two step program from ITER to commercial power plants. This first step is considered mandatory to establish the materials and component database in the real fusion in-service environment before proceeding to larger electricity producing facilities. The FNSF can be shown to make tremendous advances beyond ITER, toward a power plant, particularly in plasma duration and fusion nuclear environment. A moderate FNSF is studied in detail, which does not generate net electricity, but does reach the power plant blanket operating temperatures. The full poloidal Dual Coolant Lead Lithium (DCLL) blanket is chosen, with alternates being the Helium Cooled Lead Lithium (HCLL) and Helium Cooled Ceramic Breeder/Pebble Bed (HCCB/PB). Several power plant relevant choices are made in order to follow the philosophy of targeted technologies. Any fusion core component must be qualified by fusion relevant neutron testing and highly integrated non-nuclear testing before it can be installed on the FNSF in order to avoid the high probability of constant failures in a plasma-vacuum system. A range of missions for the FNSF, or any fusion nuclear facility on the path toward fusion power plants, are established and characterized by several metrics. A conservative physics strategy is pursued to accommodate the transition to ultra-long plasma pulses, and parameters are chosen to represent the power plant regime to the extent possible. An operating space is identified, and from this, one point is chosen for further detailed analysis, with R = 4.8 m, a = 1.2 m, IP = 7.9 MA, BT = 7.5 T, βN Gr = 0.9, fBS = 0.52, q95 = 6.0, H98 ∼1.0, and Q = 4.0. The operating space is shown to be robust to parameter variations. A program is established for the FNSF to show how the missions for the facility are met, with a He/H, a DD and 5 DT phases. The facility requires ∼25 years to complete its DT operation, including 7.8 years of neutron production, and the remaining spent on inspections and maintenance. The DD phase is critical to establish the ultra-long plasma pulse lengths. The blanket testing strategy is examined, and shows that many sectors have penetrations for heating and current drive (H/CD), diagnostics, or Test Blanket Modules (TBMs). The hot cell is a critical facility element in order for the FNSF to perform its function of developing the in-service material and component database. The pre-FNSF R&D is laid out in terms of priority topics, with the FNSF phases driving the time-lines for R&D completion. A series of detailed technical assessments of the FNSF operating point are reported in this issue, showing the credibility of such a step, and more detailed emphasis on R&D items to pursue. These include nuclear analysis, thermo-mechanics and thermal-hydraulics, liquid metal thermal hydraulics, transient thermo-mechanics, tritium analysis, maintenance assessment, magnet specification and analysis, materials assessments, core and scrape-off layer (SOL)/divertor plasma examinations.
Impact of ion temperature anisotropy on 2D edge-plasma transport
Not Available
Modeling snowflake divertors in MAST-U tokamak using UEDGE code
Not Available
Summary of 2020 edge-plasma modeling for FNSFand plans for 2021
This year, following the study of liquid-wall options, our edge-plasma modeling has returned to analyzing issues associated with a solid tungsten-wall, Fusion Nuclear Science Facility (FNSF)-size device, primarily using the 2D UEDGE plasma/neutral transport code. The focus is to predict plasma/neutral heat and particle fluxes to various wall components and determine the concentration of injected and wall-sputtered impurities that reach the core plasma region. Our models have been advanced in a number of areas compared to the initial modeling done in the 2017 timeframe: this year we include each individual charge-state of impurity ions instead of assuming a fixed concentration of impurities relative to the deuterium-tritium (DT) fuel plasma, including the interaction between inner and outer divertor legs. Here edge fueling of the impurity and pumping in the private-flux region is incorporated. Increasingly detailed atomic-physics rate files for impurity radiation have been compared, as well as the role of molecules. The impact of spatial variation of the turbulence-driven radial plasma transport is considered to contribute to the understanding of the heat-flux-limit effects of choosing a double-null or single-null divertor configuration. Detailed plasma/neutral wall fluxes, densities, and temperatures have been provided to the ERO group for their more detailed studies of wall sputtering and near-surface impurity transport.
Progress in DIII-D towards validating divertor power exhaust predictions
In this study, UEDGE simulations highlight the role of cross-field drifts on the onset of detached conditions, and new calibrated divertor vacuum ultra violet (VUV) spectroscopy is used to challenge the predictions of radiative constituents in these simulations. UEDGE simulations for DIII-D H-mode plasmas with the open divertor with the ion ∇B-drift towards the X-point show a bifurcated onset of the low field side (LFS) divertor detachment, consistent with experimentally observed step-like detachment onset (Jaervinen A.E. et al 2018 Phys. Rev. Lett. 121 075001). The divertor plasma in the simulations exhibits hysteresis in upstream separatrix density between attached and detached solution branches. Reducing the drift magnitude by a factor of 3 eliminates the step-like detachment onset in the simulations, confirming the strong role of drifts in the bifurcated detachment onset. When measured local plasma densities and temperatures are within proximity of predicted values in the simulations, there is no shortfall of the local emission of the dominant resonant radiating lines. However, the simulations systematically predict a factor of two lower total integrated radiated power than measured by the bolometer with the difference lost through radial heat flow out of the computational domain. Even though there is no shortfall in the emission of the dominant lines, a shortfall of total radiated power can be caused by underpredicted spatial extent of the radiation front, indicating a potential upstream or divertor transport physics origin for the radiation shortfall, or shortfall of radiated power in the spectrum between the dominant lines. In addition to the underpredicted spatial extent, in detached conditions, the simulations overpredict the peak radiation and dominant carbon lines near the X-point, which can be alleviated by manually increasing divertor diffusivity in the simulations, highlighting the ad hoc cross-field transport as one of the key limitations of the predictive capability of these divertor fluid codes.
Implementation and assessment of an extended hydrogenic molecular model in UEDGE
Abstract Two sets of pure deuterium plasmas are simulated using UEDGE, one including atoms and molecules and the other including atoms only as separate fluid species. Simulation results in one and two dimensions are reported to assess the role of molecules in tokamak plasmas. It is shown that thermal coupling of the molecules to the plasma can be relevant for the onset of detachment under highly collisional conditions in simple geometries, but play a modest role at low collisionality. Ion‐molecule equipartition presents an additional ion energy loss channel, dissipating ion energy that would otherwise heat the electrons by equipartition. The resulting reduced electron temperature increases the ion‐electron recombination by an order of magnitude as the plasma density is increased, yielding earlier and deeper detachment.
Role of poloidal E × B drift in divertor heat transport in DIII‐D
Abstract Simulations for DIII‐D high confinement mode plasmas with the multifluid code UEDGE show a strong role of poloidal E × B drifts on divertor heat transport, challenging the paradigm of conduction‐limited scrape‐off layer (SOL) transport. While simulations with reduced drift magnitude are well aligned with the assumption that electron heat conduction dominates the SOL heat transport, simulations with drifts predict that the poloidal convective E × B heat transport dominates over electron heat conduction in both attached and detached conditions. As poloidal E × B flow propagates across magnetic field lines, poloidal transport with shallow magnetic pitch angles can reach values that are of the same order as would be provided by sonic flows parallel to the field lines. These flows can lead to strong convection‐dominated divertor heat transport, increasing the poloidal volume of radiative power front, consistent with previous measurements at DIII‐D. Due to these convective flows, the Lengyel integral approach, assuming zero convective fraction, is expected to provide a pessimistic estimate for the radiative capability of impurities in the divertor. For the DIII‐D simulations shown here, the Lengyel integral approach underestimates the radiated power by a factor of 6, indicating that, for reliable DIII‐D divertor power exhaust predictions, full two‐dimensional (2D) calculations, including drifts, would be necessary.
Modeling K-DEMO Plasma Power Exhaust with UEDGE
The goal of this project is to develop simulation capability for the edge plasma region of K-DEMO in order to assess the heat and particle loads on plasma facing components. The roles of Lawrence Livermore National Laboratory (LLNL) are to provide the UEDGE simulation code for this purpose, to obtain initial edge-plasma solutions for K-DEMO, and to train K-DEMO staff members in both the use of the 2D UEDGE and the code structure such that future modification can be made. A schematic of K-DEMO highlighting the power exhaust is shown in Fig. 1. The major radius of the device is 6.8 m, and the total power to be exhausted is 280 MW in the edge plasma region. Evaluating impact of different divertor geometries and the use of seeded impurity radiation to manage the peak heat flux to divertor-plate surfaces are key aspects that have been addressed during this project.
A simplified lithium vapor box divertor
A detached divertor plasma is predicted to be necessary to mitigate the heat fluxes and ion energy, and so sputtering, at the divertor plate of a fusion power plant. It has proven difficult in current experiments, however, to prevent the detachment front, once formed, from running up to the main plasma resulting in deterioration of pedestal performance. The lithium vapor box divertor localizes a dense cloud of lithium vapor away from the main plasma, in order to induce detachment at a stable, distant location. The vapor localization is created by local evaporation and nearby condensation, a configuration inaccessible for non-condensing seed impurities. This paper provides simulations of lithium vapor flow using the SPARTA direct simulation Monte Carlo (DSMC) code, in which the lithium vapor dynamics are governed by Li–Li collisions that should dominate in regions with little plasma. Inertia is included in this code, permitting the formation of shocks. The plasma model implemented in SPARTA is based on UEDGE results for the location of ionization and recombination. We find that a simplified lithium vapor box configuration, without baffles, provides robust stabilization of the detachment front and acceptable lithium vapor flow to the main chamber. Lithium is evaporated from a capillary porous surface on the private-flux side of the divertor, distant from the main plasma, and is condensed on the other side walls of the divertor chamber. The condensed lithium flows back to the evaporator through 2 cm internal diameter pipes. The capillary pressure differential at the surface of the evaporator is capable of overcoming MHD back-force in the piping, with a great deal of margin if a sandwich flow channel insert is implemented. Very little lithium should be accumulated on the first wall of the main chamber if it is maintained at 600 °C, as expected for a power-producing fusion system.