Superposition principle and nonlinear response in spin glasses
The extended principle of superposition has been a touchstone of spin-glass dynamics for almost 30 years. Here the Uppsala group has demonstrated its validity for the metallic spin glass, CuMn, for magnetic fields H up to 10 Oe at the reduced temperature T r = T/T g = 0.95, where T g is the spin-glass condensation temperature. For H > 10 Oe, they observe a departure from linear response which they ascribe to the development of nonlinear dynamics. The thrust of this paper is to develop a microscopic origin for this behavior by focusing on the time development of the spin-glass correlation length, ξ(t, t w ; H). Here, t is the time after H changes, and t w is the time from the quench for T > T g to the working temperature T until H changes. We connect the growth of ξ(t, t w ; H) to the barrier heights Δ(t w ) that set the dynamics. The effect of H on the magnitude of Δ (t w ) is responsible for affecting differently the two dynamical protocols associated with turning H off (TRM, or thermoremanent magnetization) or on (ZFC, or zero-field-cooled magnetization). This difference is a consequence of nonlinearity based on the effect of H on Δ (t w ). Superposition is preserved if Δ(t w ) is linear in the Hamming distance Hd (proportional to the difference between the self-overlap q EA and the overlap q[Δ(t w )]). However, superposition is violated if Δ(t w ) increases faster than linear in Hd. We have previously shown, through experiment and simulation, that the barriers Δ(t w ) do increase more rapidly than linearly with Hd through the observation that the growth of ξ(t,t w ;H) slows down as ξ(t,t w ; H) increases. In this paper, we display the difference between the zero-field-cooled ξ ZFC (t, t w ; H) and the thermoremanent magnetization ξ TRM (t, t w ; H) correlation lengths as H increases, both experimentally and through numerical simulations, corresponding to the violation of the extended principle of superposition in line with the finding of the Uppsala Group.