Search NASA⌕ Search

Engineering topics

Saldaña, Christopher

Publications and source records attributed to Saldaña, Christopher.

15 records
All sourcesNASA NTRSDOE OSTI
DOE OSTI2024

Digital bead modeling for wire-arc directed energy deposition

Prediction of 2D cross-section and full 3D geometry for stacked weld beads is critical for the outcome of wire-arc directed energy deposition (DED) parts; however, most additive path planning software packages model beads as extrusions of a rectangle. Weld beads are not rectangular, and the resulting shape is dependent upon physics effects at the moment of deposition. Physics phenomena such as the geometry of the underlying surface, the heat input of the welding mode, and the direction of gravity contribute to bead shape. Here, this paper presents a novel implicit modeling method that discretizes a 2D area or 3D volume of space into pixels or voxels and constructs fields based on these physics phenomena. The fields are combined using a weighting scheme trained on 3D scan measurements of welds and wire-arc DED prints. Pixels or voxels are added until the known amount of deposited volume has been achieved. Thereby, a strong conservation of mass principle is applied to the process. Utilizing machine learning techniques, the present model can be trained on a database of scans allowing for the representation of a wide variety of prints. Results show that this method can produce predictions with realistic bead morphology and sub-millimeter form error.

Bead geometry modeling↗
DOE OSTI2024

Impact of Heat Input and Step Over Distance on Part Geometry for Multi-Bead WAAM Components

Abstract This study investigates the impact of heat input and overlap ratio or stepover distance on part geometry in wire arc additive manufacturing (WAAM). In this work, an experimental approach was taken to quantify the variation in height and aspect ratio of walls at different combinations of overlap and heat input. Multi-bead walls were deposited with the overlap ratio varying from ½, ⅔, and 1 at a low, medium, and high-power set point on the welding power supply. A relationship between heat input, overlap ratio, and the resultant part geometry is established. Trials with an overlap ratio of one and low to medium heat input exhibited greater lack of fusion defects than the high heat input trials. At higher heat input levels, the as-deposited geometry was found to have less variation in height and an increase in aspect ratio compared to lower heat input trials. The aspect ratio of deposited walls ranged from approximately 1, for the low-power trial with an overlap ratio of ½, to approximately 7, for the high-power trial with an overlap ratio of 1. Additionally, the low and medium power trials with an overlap ratio of ⅔ exhibited the least height variation in the top surface for those heat input levels with an average range of 2.9 mm and 1.8 mm respectively. For the high heat input trials, an overlap ratio of 1 was observed to have the least variation in height with a standard deviation of 0.42 mm and an average range of 1.7 mm; however, lack of fusion defects were present in the top surface and the part cross section.

Hussein, Zaky↗
DOE OSTI2024

Quantifying Trapped Powder in Electron Beam Powder Bed Fusion

Abstract Electron beam powder bed fusion (PBF-EB) shows great potential for manufacturing complex parts including those with internal cavities for heat exchanger, manifold systems, or energy absorption purposes. PBF-EB allows for the manufacture of channel geometries without the need for support structures. Due to the nature of the powder spreading process, powder feedstock is often trapped in intentionally manufactured cavities. This trapped powder can often be difficult to remove and can disturb the intended flow of fluid through the cavity or damage downstream components in its use case. These trapped powder particles present a risk of contamination and component failure if not completely evacuated. Ti6Al4V is a choice material for aerospace applications due to its high strength to weight ratio and its composition as a nonferrous metal; however, in weight sensitive applications excess entrapped powders or powders loosely attached to the surface could cause undesirable weight increases. The inherent spreading process of PBF-EB is different than laser powder bed fusion (PBF-LB) in its operational temperature, sintering. In addition, PBF-EB is less commonly studied in literature compared to its PBF-LB counterpart, and as a result the complexity of the semi-sintered powder and its spreading behavior are not well understood. Prior work has investigated the difficulty in removing trapped powder from PBF-EB, but these studies do not address how to quantify the amount of trapped powder in the cavity. Thus, an accurate method to measure the amount of trapped powder in the cavity must be investigated. In this work, Ti6Al4V coupons were manufactured with horizontal and vertical cavities of three different sizes. Archimedes testing allows for the determination of density differences caused by porosity and trapped powders by measuring mass and volumetric dispersion. Computed tomography (CT) is well suited for segmenting the internal structure and features of a part and has been studied for applications including voids, porosity, and dross. Thus, CT was explored as a method for evaluating trapped powder content in this work. The volumetric representation of the segmentation of the reconstructed CT volume can vary greatly depending on the input filter and thresholding methods. In this study, four different types of segmentation approaches were evaluated to determine the best approach for segmenting the volume as compared to an operator labeled ground truth. The percentage density results from the Archimedes testing were compared to the volumetric percent density from the computed tomography approach. Differences in packing density between two different internal channel features were investigated. Overall, this work sought to validate the use of computed tomography for the detection of trapped powders and present a framework for volumetric segmentation.

Johnstone, Brian↗
DOE OSTI2023

Prediction of Substrate Distortion in Powder DED Using Finite Element Model

Abstract Leveraging the capabilities of both additive and subtractive manufacturing to repair tooling and other high value items can result in significant cost and time saving opportunities. However, when dimensional accuracy of the repaired component must be held within a specified tolerance, distortion of the component induced during repair can lead to an out of specification final component. This work presents simulation of a novel method to mitigate part distortion using sacrificial support structures. A blown powder directed energy deposition system was utilized for deposition of sacrificial support structures and clad surface depositions. Sacrificial support structures were deposited on the underside of the substrate with varying geometries prior to clad surface depositions. A finite element model was developed and verified using experimental results. The simulation and experimental control results were found to match within 6%. It has been shown that simulation can be used to predict effects of sacrificial support structures on substrate distortion in a blown powder directed energy deposition process.

Burl, Alan G.↗
DOE OSTI2023

Effect of Blown Powder Directed Energy Deposition Angle On Overspray Contamination

Abstract Blown powder directed energy deposition (DED) hybrid machine tools are particularly beneficial when the net shape of a component is to be manufactured in an additive and machined interleaved fashion. This investigation seeks to analyze the effect of the additive head lean angle relative to the part on blown powder DED surface contamination due to overspray. These hybrid DED platforms are commonly installed on multi-axis machining systems where the lean of the deposition head relative to the component surface can be controlled by tilting the component. The blown powder DED process has a 10–50% lower catchment efficiency as compared to wire fed DED systems. This excess powder is still fed towards the deposition location where the particles are heated by the laser and rebound off the melt pool. Some of these heated particles impact the previously machined thin-wall surface. While the deposition process and tool path planning process has been evaluated, the effect of the overspray due to lean angle of the deposition head on the previously thin-wall machined surface is not yet fully understood. This investigation found that minimum lean angle coincides with minimal overspray effect with nearly no contamination. If a lean angle is required, the maximum lean angle possible should be implemented for the smallest effected overspray area on the machined surface which was found to decrease the affect zone by half compared to intermediate lean angles. A diameter divergence was also noticed as the deposition angle was increased. In this study, a thorough analysis of the surface and geometric effects when depositing thin-walled components at varying angles is completed. It has been shown that part quality can be significantly affected by lean angle and thus must be incorporated as an additional design consideration in the manufacturing process.

Heinrich, Lauren↗
DOE OSTI2023

The Effect of Laser Cutting Heuristic Presentation Modality on Design Learning

Abstract The goal of this work is to study the way student designers use heuristics to effectively design for laser-cut manufacturing methods. With the recent advent of academic makerspaces, digital fabrication tools like laser cutters are relatively new additions to the classroom. Therefore, there is a gap in formal education or training on these tools, and students can find it challenging to design effectively for them. A study was performed to investigate the way students apply heuristics to redesign laser-cut assemblies when received in different modalities. All participants were given an identical lecture on laser cutting heuristics. Then, a redesign problem was presented to students, and three different experimental groups were given the heuristics in different modalities: Text-Only, text with Visual aids, and text with Tactile aids. The novelty and quality of each of the resulting redesigns were evaluated. It was hypothesized that participants would have more difficulty interpreting and applying the Text-Only heuristics, lowering the quality of their redesigned solutions relative to the other two conditions. It was also hypothesized that participants would experience fixation caused by interacting with the tactile aids, leading to the lower novelty of their redesigned solutions relative to the other two conditions. Results showed that modality played a significant role in participants’ feelings of self-efficacy after the intervention, as well as in their understanding of laser cutter design skills when responding to quiz-style questions. However, analysis of novelty and quality showed little significant impact of the intervention and varying modalities on participants’ designs.

Engineering↗
DOE OSTI2023

Methods for the Automated Determination of Sustained Maximum Amplitudes in Oscillating Signals

Machine condition monitoring has been proven to reduce machine downtime and increase productivity. The state-of-the-art research uses vibration monitoring for tasks such as maintenance and tool wear prediction. A less explored aspect is how vibration monitoring might be used to monitor equipment sensitive to vibration. In a manufacturing environment, one example of where this might be needed is in monitoring the vibration of optical linear encoders used in high-precision machine tools and coordinate measuring machines. Monitoring the vibration of sensitive equipment presents a unique case for vibration monitoring because an accurate calculation of the maximum sustained vibration is needed, as opposed to extracting trends from the data. To do this, techniques for determining sustained peaks in vibration signals are needed. Here, this work fills this gap by formalizing and testing methods for determining sustained vibration amplitudes. The methods are tested on simulated signals based on experimental data. Results show that processing the signal directly with the novel Expire Timer method produces the smallest amounts of error on average under various test conditions. Additionally, this method can operate in real-time on streaming vibration data.

Industrial Internet of Things↗
DOE OSTI2023

Data-Driven Approaches for Bead Geometry Prediction Via Melt Pool Monitoring

In the realm of additive manufacturing, the selection of process parameters to avoid over and under deposition entails a time-consuming and resource-intensive trial-and-error approach. Given the distinct characteristics of each part geometry, there is a pressing need for advancing real-time process monitoring and control to ensure consistent and reliable part dimensional accuracy. Here, this research shows that support vector regression (SVR) and convolutional neural network (CNN) models offer a promising solution for real-time process control due to the models’ abilities to recognize complex, non-linear patterns with high accuracy. A novel experiment was designed to compare the performance of SVR and CNN models to indirectly detect bead height from a coaxial image of a melt pool from a single-layer, single bead build. The study showed that both SVR and CNN models trained on melt pool data collected from a coaxial optical camera can accurately predict the bead height with a mean absolute percentage error of 3.67% and 3.68%, respectively.

36 MATERIALS SCIENCE↗
DOE OSTI2023

Vision-based localization for cooperative robot-CNC hybrid manufacturing

Wire and arc additive manufacturing (WAAM) has shown promise in recent years for producing large-scale parts with higher deposition rates than other additive processes. WAAM is often combined with subtractive machining to form a hybrid manufacturing process. This hybrid process can be realized by retrofitting computer numerical control (CNC) machines with deposition heads, adding spindles and deposition heads to robots, or developing part localization methods to transfer parts from an additive cell to a CNC machine. Here, a novel, robot-CNC hybrid configuration is introduced where a maneuverable robot is placed in front of a CNC machine to deposit material within the machine envelop. Furthermore, this method removes the need for part localization and the extensive machine modifications required for retrofitting; however, the problem of robot localization is also added. In this work, the effects of error in vision-based, contactless robot localization on machining parameters in a robot-machine hybrid process were studied. Performance was characterized on an implementation of this system using classical computer vision techniques. In addition, machining simulations were conducted to evaluate the effects of image-induced error on chip thickness, material removal rate, and machining allowance. Initial tests show that computer vision could adequately locate a robot for the hybrid WAAM process within .5 mm.

Hybrid manufacturing↗
DOE OSTI2022

Effects of weave path parameters on the geometry of wire arc additive manufactured features

Here, the present work investigates the effect of process parameters on the geometry of wire arc additive manufactured parts. The geometric accuracy of features produced with a weaving strategy is compared to what can be accomplished with a typical overlapping bead strategy. In this work, single-layer and multi-layer geometries were deposited under varying process and path parameters. The wavelength, amplitude, and torch speed of the weaving path were varied, while the power, wire feed speed, and contact tip to work distance remained constant. The geometric deposition efficiencies of several samples produced with a weave strategy are directly compared to samples generated with two parallel overlapping beads with torch speeds defined to match the deposition rate of the weave samples. Feature geometries were characterized using optical microscopy and laser scanning data. The results indicate that implementing a weave path strategy can improve the geometric accuracy of wire arc additive features, thus increasing the effective volumetric deposition rate of the process. It is shown that the most consistent improvements resulted from the combination of low wavelength and high amplitude, which correlate to wider and taller printed layers.

GMAW↗
DOE OSTI2022

Build plate conduction cooling for thermal management of wire arc additive manufactured components

Wire arc additive manufacturing (WAAM) allows for quick, large component manufacturing with fast deposition rates while leveraging readily available wire feedstock that is significantly cheaper than metal powder. However, the increased deposition rate of this process requires enhanced thermal management as failures can occur due to overheating. A common strategy to mitigate overheating is to dwell, or pause, between individual layers; however, this can significantly increase build times and eliminate the advantage of additive manufacturing being able to manufacture components quickly. To help mitigate this issue, this study explores the use of active cooling to maintain process control and to decrease overall build time. In this work, conductive cooling applied to either the bottom or side of the print substrate was explored. Results from this study showed that bottom build plate active cooling can be used to decrease dwell times by up to 50% and decrease cool-down to room temperature after the building process by up to 75%. Results from this study demonstrate that the use of active cooling strategies for WAAM can be used for better thermal control over the process and should be further investigated.

36 MATERIALS SCIENCE↗
DOE OSTI2022

Generalizability analysis of tool condition monitoring ensemble machine learning models

Tool condition monitoring (TCM) is an essential research area for the optimization and automation of metal machining processes, and could help manufacturers reduce costs, production time, machine downtime, energy use, and part scrappage. However, TCM systems developed in prior studies have struggled to reach the high level of generalizability which is necessary for industrial applications. This study addresses TCM system generalizability to new machining conditions, how variations in machining and environmental conditions may be used to improve model generalizability, and ensemble machine learning techniques for TCM. Further, milling tool life experiments were conducted using various machining conditions, and the processes' sound, spindle power, and axial load signals were collected. Different machine learning models were evaluated for the prediction of tool wear levels, including four individual models and five ensemble models. Changes in cutting speed were found to display a large effect on model performance, while the chip load showed some effect, and the feed rate had little effect. A simulated noise data augmentation technique for model improvement is applied within TCM for the first time, and resulted in increased model generalizability and reduced overfitting. Across several performance metrics the extremely randomized trees ensemble machine learning model generally performed the best for this application, achieving a leave-one-group-out cross validation accuracy score of 92.4 %, a 10-fold cross validation score of 98.9 %, and an averaged accuracy across 11 generalizability tests of 87.3 %.

42 ENGINEERING↗
DOE OSTI2022

Indirect Tool Condition Monitoring Using Ensemble Machine Learning Techniques

Abstract Tool condition monitoring (TCM) has become a research area of interest due to its potential to significantly reduce manufacturing costs while increasing process visibility and efficiency. Machine learning (ML) is one analysis technique which has demonstrated advantages for TCM applications. However, the commonly studied individual ML models lack generalizability to new machining and environmental conditions, as well as robustness to the unbalanced datasets which are common in TCM. Ensemble ML models have demonstrated superior performance in other fields, but have only begun to be evaluated for TCM. As a result, it is not well understood how their TCM performance compares to that of individual models, or how homogeneous and heterogeneous ensemble models’ performances compare to one another. To fill in these research gaps, milling experiments were conducted using various cutting conditions, and the model groups were compared across several performance metrics. Statistical t-tests were also used to evaluate the significance of model performance differences. Through the analysis of four individual ML models and five ensemble models, all based on the processes’ sound, spindle power, and axial load signals, it was found that on average, the ensemble models performed better than the individual models, and that the homogeneous ensembles outperformed the heterogeneous ensembles.

Engineering↗
DOE OSTI2022

Extreme variation in fatigue: Fatigue life prediction and dependence on build volume location in laser powder bed fusion of 17-4 stainless steel

Laser powder bed fusion (LPBF), a metal additive manufacturing technology, is well-suited for design optimization but fatigue life is limited by manufacturing defects. In this work, 17-4 stainless steel components were manufactured in densely populated build volumes, simulating at-scale LPBF production. Tests revealed extreme variability in fatigue life data, analyzed via rigorous statistical tools. The El-Haddad model, modified for finite-life, enabled defect-based life prediction. Specimen location within the build volume correlated to life, which was heteroscedastic. Investigating defect concentration over the build volume explained typical life and scatter. Finally, these findings argue for qualification approaches which acknowledge high material lot variability.

36 MATERIALS SCIENCE↗