Search NASA⌕ Search

Engineering topics

Schrier, Joshua

Publications and source records attributed to Schrier, Joshua.

Review of low-cost self-driving laboratories in chemistry and materials science: the “frugal twin” concept

This review proposes the concept of a “frugal twin,” similar to a digital twin, but for physical experiments. Frugal twins range from simple toy examples to low-cost surrogates of high-cost research systems. For example, a color-mixing self-driving laboratory (SDL) can serve as a low-cost version of a costly multi-step chemical discovery SDL. Frugal twins already provide hands-on experience for SDLs with low costs and low risks. They can also offer as test beds for software prototyping (e.g., optimization, data infrastructure), and a low barrier to entry for democratizing SDLs. However, there is room for improvement. The true value of frugal twins can be realized in three core areas. Firstly, hardware and software modularity; secondly, purpose-built design (human-inspired vs. hardware-centric vs. human-in-the-loop); and thirdly state-of-the-art (SOTA) software (e.g., multi-fidelity optimization). We also describe the ethical benefits and risks that come with the democratization of science through frugal twins. For future work, we suggest ideas for new frugal twins, SDL educational course outcomes, and a classification scheme for autonomy levels.

36 MATERIALS SCIENCE↗

Spatiotemporal Route to Understanding Metal Halide Perovskitoid Crystallization

Here, a spatiotemporal experimental route is reported for the antisolvent vapor diffusion crystal growth of metal halide perovskitoids. A computational analysis combining automated image capture and diffusion modeling enables the determination of the critical concentrations required for nucleation and crystal growth from a single experiment. Five different solvent systems and ten distinct organic ammonium iodide salts were investigated with lead iodide, from which nine previously unreported compounds were discovered. Automated image capture of the mother liquor and antisolvent vials was used to determine changes in solution meniscus positions and detect the nucleation event location. Matching the observations to a numerical solution of Fick's second law diffusion model enables the calculation of reactant, solvent, and antisolvent concentrations at both the time and position of the first stable nucleation and crystal growth. A machine learning model was trained on the resulting data, and it reveals solvent- and amine-specific crystallization tendencies. Solvent systems that interact more weakly with dissolved lead species promote crystallization, while those with stronger interactions can prevent crystallization through increased solubilities. Organic amines that interact more strongly with inorganic components and exhibit greater rigidity are more likely to be incorporated into crystalline products.

37 INORGANIC, ORGANIC, PHYSICAL, AND ANALYTICAL CH↗

Active meta-learning for predicting and selecting perovskite crystallization experiments

Autonomous experimentation systems use algorithms and data from prior experiments to select and perform new experiments in order to meet a specified objective. In most experimental chemistry situations, there is a limited set of prior historical data available, and acquiring new data may be expensive and time consuming, which places constraints on machine learning methods. Active learning methods prioritize new experiment selection by using machine learning model uncertainty and predicted outcomes. Meta-learning methods attempt to construct models that can learn quickly with a limited set of data for a new task. Here in this paper, we applied the model-agnostic meta-learning (MAML) model and the Probabilistic LATent model for Incorporating Priors and Uncertainty in few-Shot learning (PLATIPUS) approach, which extends MAML to active learning, to the problem of halide perovskite growth by inverse temperature crystallization. Using a dataset of 1870 reactions conducted using 19 different organoammonium lead iodide systems, we determined the optimal strategies for incorporating historical data into active and meta-learning models to predict reaction compositions that result in crystals. We then evaluated the best three algorithms (PLATIPUS and active-learning k-nearest neighbor and decision tree algorithms) with four new chemical systems in experimental laboratory tests. With a fixed budget of 20 experiments, PLATIPUS makes superior predictions of reaction outcomes compared to other active-learning algorithms and a random baseline.

37 INORGANIC, ORGANIC, PHYSICAL, AND ANALYTICAL CH↗

Dimensional Control over Metal Halide Perovskite Crystallization Guided by Active Learning

Metal halide perovskite (MHP) derivatives, a promising class of optoelectronic materials, have been synthesized with a range of dimensionalities that govern their optoelectronic properties and determine their applications. We demonstrate a data-driven approach combining active learning and high-throughput experimentation to discover, control, and understand the formation of phases with different dimensionalities in the morpholinium (morph) lead iodide system. Using a robot-assisted workflow, we synthesized and characterized two novel MHP derivatives that have distinct optical properties: a one-dimensional (1D) morphPbI 3 phase ([C 4 H 10 NO][PbI 3 ]) and a two-dimensional (2D) (morph) 2 PbI 4 phase ([C 4 H 10 NO] 2 [PbI 4 ]). To efficiently acquire the data needed to construct a machine learning (ML) model of the reaction conditions where the 1D and 2D phases are formed, data acquisition was guided by a diverse-mini-batch-sampling active learning algorithm, using prediction confidence as a stopping criterion. Querying the ML model uncovered the reaction parameters that have the most significant effects on dimensionality control. Based on these insights, we discuss possible reaction schemes that may selectively promote the formation of morph-Pb-I phases with different dimensionalities. The data-driven approach presented here, including the use of additives to manipulate dimensionality, will be valuable for controlling the crystallization of a range of materials over large reaction-composition spaces.

36 MATERIALS SCIENCE↗

Autonomous experimentation systems for materials development: A community perspective

Solutions to many of the world's problems depend upon materials research and development. However, advanced materials can take decades to discover and decades more to fully deploy. Humans and robots have begun to partner to advance science and technology orders of magnitude faster than humans do today through the development and exploitation of closed-loop, autonomous experimentation systems. This review discusses the specific challenges and opportunities related to materials discovery and development that will emerge from this new paradigm. Our perspective incorporates input from stakeholders in academia, industry, government laboratories, and funding agencies. We outline the current status, barriers, and needed investments, culminating with a vision for the path forward. We intend the article to spark interest in this emerging research area and to motivate potential practitioners by illustrating early successes. We also aspire to encourage a creative reimagining of the next generation of materials science infrastructure. To this end, we frame future investments in materials science and technology, hardware and software infrastructure, artificial intelligence and autonomy methods, and critical workforce development for autonomous research.

36 MATERIALS SCIENCE↗

Improving Data and Prediction Quality of High-Throughput Perovskite Synthesis with Model Fusion

Combinatorial fusion analysis (CFA) is an approach for combining multiple scoring systems using the rank-score characteristic function and cognitive diversity measure. One example is to combine diverse machine learning models to achieve better prediction quality. In this work, we apply CFA to the synthesis of metal halide perovskites containing organic ammonium cations via inverse temperature crystallization. Using a data set generated by high-throughput experimentation, four individual models (support vector machines, random forests, weighted logistic classifier, and gradient boosted trees) were developed. We characterize each of these scoring systems and explore 66 possible combinations of the models. When measured by the precision on predicting crystal formation, the majority of the combination models improves the individual model results. The best combination models outperform the best individual models by 3.9 percentage points in precision. In addition to improving prediction quality, we demonstrate how the fusion models can be used to identify mislabeled input data and address issues of data quality. In particular, we identify example cases where all single models and all fusion models do not give the correct prediction. Experimental replication of these syntheses reveals that these compositions are sensitive to modest temperature variations across the different locations of the heating element that can hinder or enhance the crystallization process. In summary, we demonstrate that model fusion using CFA can not only identify a previously unconsidered influence on reaction outcome but also be used as a form of quality control for high-throughput experimentation.

37 INORGANIC, ORGANIC, PHYSICAL, AND ANALYTICAL CH↗

Machine-Learning-Assisted Synthesis of Polar Racemates

Racemates have recently received attention as nonlinear optical and piezoelectric materials. We report a machine-learning-assisted composition space approach was applied to synthesize the missing M = Ti, Zr members of the Δ,Λ-[Cu(bpy) 2 (H 2 O)] 2 [MF 6 ] 2·3 H 2 O (M = Ti, Zr, Hf; bpy = 2,2'-bipyridine) family (space group: Pna2 1 ). In each (CuO, MO 2 )/bpy/HF(aq) (M = Ti, Zr, Hf) system, the polar noncentrosymmetric racemate (M-NCS) forms in competition with a centrosymmetric one-dimensional chain compound (M-CS) based on alternating Cu(bpy)(H 2 O) 2 2+ and MF 6 2– basic building units (space groups: Ti-CS (Pnma), Zr-CS (P1̅), Hf-CS (P2/n)). Machine learning models were trained on reaction parameters to gain unbiased insight into the underlying statistical trends in each composition space. A human-interpretable decision tree shows that phase selection is driven primarily by the bpy:CuO molar ratio for reactions containing Zr or Hf, and predicts that formation of the Ti-NCS compound requires that the amount of HF present be decreased to raise the pH, which we verified experimentally. Predictive leave-one-metal-out (LOO) models further confirm that behavior in the Ti system is distinct from that of the Zr and Hf systems. The chemical origin of this distinction was probed via fluorine K-edge X-ray absorption spectroscopy. Pre-edge features in the F1s X-ray absorption spectra reveal the strong ligand-to-metal π bonding between Ti(3d – t 2g ) and F(2p) states that distinguishes the TiF 6 2– anion from the ZrF 6 2– and HfF 6 2– anions.

37 INORGANIC, ORGANIC, PHYSICAL, AND ANALYTICAL CH↗

Templated vanadium tellurites: Identifying the effects of low density attractions on inorganic layer topology

Exploration of the NH 4 VO 3 /Na 2 TeO 3 /2,4,6-triaminopyrimidine/H 2 O system yielded the formation of two new phases, [C 4 H 8 N 5 ][VO 3 ] and [C 4 H 8 N 5 ] 2 [V 2 Te 2 O 10 ]. Phase selection in this system is largely dictated by the tellurium concentration during reaction. Differences in the [V 2 Te 2 O 10 ] n 2n- layer topologies in [C 4 H 8 N 5 ] 2 [V 2 Te 2 O 10 ] and two related phases, [C 6 H 16 N 2 ][V 2 Te 2 O 10 ] and [C 5 H 14 N 2 ][V 2 Te 2 O 10 ] were probed using noncovalent interaction energy ratios. These ratios allow for one to directly visualize and quantify differences in intermolecular interaction strengths between compounds. The presence or absence of π - π stacking interactions between organic ammonium cations in [C 4 H 8 N 5 ] 2 [V 2 Te 2 O 10 ] and two related phases, [C 6 H 16 N 2 ][V 2 Te 2 O 10 ] and [C 5 H 14 N 2 ][V 2 Te 2 O 10 ] is the source of layer connectivity differences. These π - π interactions between 2,4,6-triaminopyrimidinium cations in [C 4 H 8 N 5 ] 2 [V 2 Te 2 O 10 ] dictate their orientations between [V 2 Te 2 O 10 ] n 2n- layers, and direct the locations of hydrogen-bonding interactions. Effects associated with reactant concentrations, charge density matching and intermolecular interactions were probed using composition space analyses, Iterative Hirshfeld partial atomic charge, molecular surface area calculations and noncovalent interaction index calculations, respectively.

noncovalent interaction energy ratios↗

Gas Separation through Bilayer Silica, the Thinnest Possible Silica Membrane

Membrane-based gas separation processes can address concerns in energy and environment, but for many applications the permeance and selectivity of bulk membranes is insufficient for economical use. Theory and experiment suggest that permeance and selectivity can be increased by using two-dimensional materials with subnanometer pores as membranes. Motivated by experiments showing selective permeation of H 2 /CO mixtures through amorphous silica bilayers, here we perform a theoretical study of gas separation through silica bilayers. Using density functional theory calculations, we obtain geometries of crystalline free-standing silica bilayers (comprised of six-membered rings), as well as the seven-, eight-, and nine-membered rings that are observed in glassy silica bilayers, which arise due to Stone–Wales defects and vacancies. We then compute the potential energy barriers for gas passage through these various pore types for He, Ne, Ar, Kr, H 2 , N 2 , CO, and CO 2 gases, and use the data to assess their capability for selective gas separation. Our calculations indicate that crystalline bilayer silica, which is less than a nanometer thick, can be a high-selectivity and high-permeance membrane material for 3 He/ 4 He, He/natural gas, and H 2 /CO separations.

37 INORGANIC, ORGANIC, PHYSICAL, AND ANALYTICAL CH↗

Inducing polarity in [VO{sub 3}]{sub n}{sup n-} chain compounds using asymmetric hydrogen-bonding networks

1,4-Bis(3-aminopropyl)piperazine, (R)-3-aminopiperidine and (S)-3-aminopiperidine were used in the syntheses of [C{sub 10}H{sub 26}N{sub 4}][VO{sub 3}]{sub 2}{center_dot}2H{sub 2}O, [(R)-C{sub 5}H{sub 14}N{sub 2}][VO{sub 3}]{sub 2} and [(S)-C{sub 5}H{sub 14}N{sub 2}][VO{sub 3}]{sub 2}, which all contain similar [VO{sub 3}]{sub n}{sup n-} chains. Inversion symmetry within the 1,4-bis(3-aminopropyl)piperazine allows for crystallization of [C{sub 10}H{sub 26}N{sub 4}][VO{sub 3}]{sub 2}{center_dot}2H{sub 2}O in a centrosymmetric space group, while the use of enantiomerically pure sources of either (R)-3-aminopiperidine or (S)-3-aminopiperidine forces crystallographic noncentrosymmetry. Moreover, asymmetry in the hydrogen-bonding networks between the metavanadate chains and either [(R)-3-aminopiperidineH{sub 2}]{sup 2+} or [(S)-3-aminopiperidineH{sub 2}]{sup 2+} cations directs alignment of the chains and crystallization in a polar space group (C2, no. 5). Component and net dipole moments were calculated using iterative-Hirshfeld partial atomic charges. [(R)-C{sub 5}H{sub 14}N{sub 2}][VO{sub 3}]{sub 2} and [(S)-C{sub 5}H{sub 14}N{sub 2}][VO{sub 3}]{sub 2} both display type 1 phase-matching capabilities and exhibit second harmonic generation activities of {approx}140 Multiplication-Sign {alpha}-SiO{sub 2}. - Graphical abstract: One centrosymmetric and a pair of polar noncentrosymmetric templated metavanadates were synthesized under mild hydrothermal conditions. Asymmetry in the hydrogen-bonding between either [(R)-C{sub 5}H{sub 14}N{sub 2}]{sup 2+} or [(S)-C{sub 5}H{sub 14}N{sub 2}]{sup 2+} and [VO{sub 3}]{sub n}{sup n-} chains results in polar structures that exhibit type 1 phase-matching capabilities. Hirshfeld surfaces were used to probe the hydrogen-bonding networks and component and net dipole moments were calculated from atomic positions and iterative-Hirshfeld partial charges. Highlights: Black-Right-Pointing-Pointer One centrosymmetric and a pair of polar templated metavanadate chain compounds are reported. Black-Right-Pointing-Pointer Asymmetry in the hydrogen-bonding networks drives the compound polarities. Black-Right-Pointing-Pointer Iterative-Hirshfeld partitioning was used to calculate partial atomic charges. Black-Right-Pointing-Pointer Net and component dipole moments are calculated for each compound. Black-Right-Pointing-Pointer Type 1 phase-matching behavior and SHG activities of {approx}140 Multiplication-Sign {alpha}-SiO{sub 2} are found.

37 INORGANIC, ORGANIC, PHYSICAL, AND ANALYTICAL CH↗

From computational discovery to experimental characterization of a high hole mobility organic crystal

For organic semiconductors to find ubiquitous electronics applications, the development of new materials with high mobility and air stability is critical. Despite the versatility of carbon, exploratory chemical synthesis in the vast chemical space can be hindered by synthetic and characterization difficulties. Here we show that in silico screening of novel derivatives of the dinaphtho[2,3-b:2',3'-f]thieno[3,2-b]thiophene semiconductor with high hole mobility and air stability can lead to the discovery of a new high-performance semiconductor. On the basis of estimates from the Marcus theory of charge transfer rates, we identified a novel compound expected to demonstrate a theoretic twofold improvement in mobility over the parent molecule. Synthetic and electrical characterization of the compound is reported with single-crystal fieldeffect transistors, showing a remarkable saturation and linear mobility of 12.3 and 16cm2V-1 s-1 , respectively. This is one of the very few organic semiconductors with mobility greater than 10cm2V-1 s-1 reported to date.

37 INORGANIC, ORGANIC, PHYSICAL, AND ANALYTICAL CH↗

[R-C{sub 7}H{sub 16}N{sub 2}][V{sub 2}Te{sub 2}O{sub 10}] and [S-C{sub 7}H{sub 16}N{sub 2}][V{sub 2}Te{sub 2}O{sub 10}]; new polar templated vanadium tellurite enantiomers

New polar vanadium tellurite enantiomers have been synthesized under mild hydrothermal conditions through the use of sodium metavanadate, sodium tellurite and enantiomerically pure sources of either R-3-aminioquinuclidine or S-3-aminioquinuclidine. [R-C{sub 7}H{sub 16}N{sub 2}][V{sub 2}Te{sub 2}O{sub 10}] and [S-C{sub 7}H{sub 16}N{sub 2}][V{sub 2}Te{sub 2}O{sub 10}] contain [V{sub 2}Te{sub 2}O{sub 10}]{sub n}{sup 2n-} layers constructed from [(VO{sub 2}){sub 2}O(TeO{sub 4}){sub 2}] monomers. Steric effects associated with the hydrogen-bonding network between the [V{sub 2}Te{sub 2}O{sub 10}]{sub n}{sup 2n-} layers and [C{sub 7}H{sub 16}N{sub 2}]{sup 2+} result in polar structures and crystallization in the space group P2{sub 1} (no. 4). Electron localization functions were calculated to visualize the tellurite stereoactive lone pairs. Both iterative and non-iterative Hirshfeld techniques were evaluated as means to determine atomic partial charges, with iterative Hirshfeld charges more accurately representing charge distributions in the reported enantiomers. These charges were used to calculate both component and net dipole moments. [R-C{sub 7}H{sub 16}N{sub 2}][V{sub 2}Te{sub 2}O{sub 10}] and [S-C{sub 7}H{sub 16}N{sub 2}][V{sub 2}Te{sub 2}O{sub 10}] exhibit dipole moments of 17.37 and 16.62D, respectively. [R-C{sub 7}H{sub 16}N{sub 2}][V{sub 2}Te{sub 2}O{sub 10}] and [S-C{sub 7}H{sub 16}N{sub 2}][V{sub 2}Te{sub 2}O{sub 10}] both display type 1 phase-matching capabilities and exhibit second harmonic generation activities of {approx}50x{alpha}-SiO{sub 2}. - Graphical abstract: Two new vanadium tellurite enantiomers have been synthesized under mild hydrothermal conditions. Hydrogen-bonding between [C{sub 7}H{sub 16}N{sub 2}]{sup 2+} cations and [V{sub 2}Te{sub 2}O{sub 10}]{sub n}{sup 2n-} layers results in polar structures that exhibit type 1 phase matching capabilities. Component and net dipole moments were calculated from atomic positions and iterative Hirshfeld partial charges. Highlights: > A pair of new polar templated vanadium tellurite enantiomers is reported. > Sterics in the hydrogen-bonding network drive the compound polarities. > Iterative Hirshfeld portioning was used to calculate atomic partial charges.{yields} Net and component dipole moments are calculated for each compound.{yields} Type 1 phase matching behavior and SHG activities of {approx}50x{alpha}-SiO{sub 2} are found.

37 INORGANIC, ORGANIC, PHYSICAL, AND ANALYTICAL CH↗

Charge density matching in templated molybdates

The role of charge density matching in the formation of templated molybdates under mild hydrothermal conditions was investigated through the use of a series of structurally related amines: piperazine, 1,4-dimethylpiperazine, 2,5-dimethylpiperazine and 2,6-dimethylpiperazine. A series of reactions was conducted in which the relative mole fractions of each component were fixed at 2.5 MoO{sub 3}:1 amine:330 H{sub 2}O:2 H{sub 2}SO{sub 4} in order to isolate the effects of the amine, the only variation between reactions was the structure of the amine. Four distinct polyoxomolybdates anions were observed, ranging from zero-dimensional beta-[Mo{sub 8}O{sub 26}]{sup 4-} molecular anions to [Mo{sub 3}O{sub 10}]{sub n}{sup 2n-} and [Mo{sub 8}O{sub 26}]{sub n}{sup 4n-} chains and [Mo{sub 5}O{sub 16}]{sub n}{sup 2n-} layers. The primary influence over the structure of the molybdate anion is charge density matching with the protonated amine, which was quantified through surface area approximations based upon both calculated molecular surfaces and polyhedral representations of each anion. Secondary influences include amine symmetry and hydrogen-bonding preferences. The synthesis and characterization of two new compounds are reported. Crystal data: [C{sub 6}H{sub 16}N{sub 2}][Mo{sub 3}O{sub 10}].H{sub 2}O (1), triclinic, P-1 (no. 2), a=8.0973(7) A, b=8.8819(9) A, c=11.5969(11) A, alpha=71.362(9){sup o}, beta=82.586(8){sup o}, gamma=74.213(8){sup o}, Z=2, R/R{sub w}=0.0262/0.0564, and [C{sub 6}H{sub 16}N{sub 2}]{sub 2}[Mo{sub 8}O{sub 26}] (2), monoclinic, P2{sub 1}/n (no. 14), a=7.9987(11) A, b=12.5324(19) A, c=16.003(3) A, beta=97.393(14){sup o}, Z=2, R/R{sub w}=0.0189/0.0454. - Graphical abstract: A geometric decomposition method for surface area determination is presented in the context of charge density matching in new organically templated polyoxomolybdates.

36 MATERIALS SCIENCE↗