Search NASA⌕ Search

Engineering topics

Shannon, Steven

Publications and source records attributed to Shannon, Steven.

Science challenges and research opportunities for plasma applications in microelectronics

Low-temperature plasmas (LTPs) are essential to manufacturing devices in the semiconductor industry, from creating extreme ultraviolet photons used in the most advanced lithography to thin film etching, deposition, and surface modifications. It is estimated that 40%–45% of all process steps needed to manufacture semiconductor devices use LTPs in one form or another. LTPs have been an enabling technology in the multidecade progression of the shrinking of device dimensions, often referred to as Moore’s law. New challenges in circuit and device design, novel materials, and increasing demands to achieve environmentally benign processing technologies require advances in plasma technology beyond the current state-of-the-art. The Department of Energy Office of Science Fusion Energy Sciences held a workshop titled Plasma Science for Microelectronics Nanofabrication in August 2022 to discuss the plasma science challenges and technical barriers that need to be overcome to continue to develop the innovative plasma technologies required to support and advance the semiconductor industry. One of the key outcomes of the workshop was identifying a set of priority research opportunities (PROs) to focus attention on the most strategic plasma science challenges to address to benefit the semiconductor industry. For each PRO, scientific challenges and recommended strategies to address those challenges were identified. Furthermore, this article summarizes the PROs identified by the workshop participants.

36 MATERIALS SCIENCE↗

Verification and validation of the open-source plasma fluid code: Zapdos

Zapdos is an open-source finite element plasma fluid solver based on the MOOSE multiphysics framework. This paper outlines Zapdos verification, benchmarking, and validation efforts for 1D and 2D RF capacitively coupled plasma discharge models for mid-range pressures (0.1 - 1 Torr). The verification process involved using the method of manufactured solutions to assess Zapdos spatial and temporal error convergence. L2 errors ranged from 10 -2 to 10 -4 , while the convergence’s slope were in agreement with the predicted slopes for the tested variable and time integration orders. The benchmarking process involved comparisons to previously results from the validated finite element code, LSODI. These works included 1D and 2D simulations for a range of plasma parameters (densities, temperatures, voltage, etc.). For the 1D cases, Zapdos and LSODI results were in very good agreement. In the 2D cases, variable behaviors matched, with slight discrepancies in peak values. The validation process involved comparisons to experimental works including electron density measurements by microwave interferometry and metastable density measurements by planar laser-induced fluorescence imaging. Results shown reasonable agreement at higher pressure, with results starting to diverge at low pressures. Furthermore, probable causes for this diverges are the limitation of the fluid assumption for plasmas at low pressure, or the need for more robust boundary conditions. Overall, Zapdos shown reasonable results for the verification, benchmarking, and validation efforts, and Zapdos can be downloaded at https://github.com/shannon-lab/zapdos.

70 PLASMA PHYSICS AND FUSION TECHNOLOGY↗

Effect of dielectric target properties on plasma surface ionization wave propagation

Surface ionization waves (SIWs) propagating along dielectric covered, grounded surfaces have been studied for various dielectric bulk and surface conditions; a dependence on the propagation velocity with respect to dielectric electrical thickness and near surface permittivity profiles are observed. SIWs generated by an atmospheric pressure plasma source are imaged interacting with planar dielectric surface. Surface wave velocity is obtained by tracking emission intensity as a function of time. Target dielectric thickness is varied from $d = 0.15-10$ mm and dielectric constant is varied from $\epsilon_r = 6.21 - 9.4$. The propagation of SIWs can be generally predicted by relating their velocity to the RC time constant of the circuit generated between the plasma and the dielectric surface, but it is found that this approximation breaks down for dielectric substrates of sufficient thickness and wave velocity becomes constant. The results show that wave velocity is stable and predictable for target thicknesses beyond a certain point determined by the permittivity of the target material. It is also shown that SIW propagation is strongly driven by the dielectric material near to the surface of the target in addition to the bulk material. The possible mechanisms driving these thickness dependent behaviors is discussed.

70 PLASMA PHYSICS AND FUSION TECHNOLOGY↗

Depyrogenation using plasmas: A novel approach for endotoxin deactivation using a dielectric barrier discharge at atmospheric pressure

Developing a low-cost depyrogenation process is vital in extending the medical applicability of polymers that can be used in medicine. We present an overview of the plasma-based depyrogenation literature and address the need to develop a nonthermal plasma-based depyrogenation process for delicate materials such as chitosan. We present a low-cost plasma apparatus to treat chitosan powder in hermetically sealed bags. We decouple the experiments into two parts: depyrogenation experiments for dried standard endotoxin on glass slides and analysis of chitosan modifications through Fourier-transform infrared spectroscopy. We demonstrate depyrogenation efficacy with up to a 4-log reduction in endotoxin levels and discuss minor changes observed in plasma-treated chitosan.

atmospheric pressure plasmas↗

Continued Validation Studies using the MOOSE Framework for Plasma Simulation with Electromagnetics

Resources and tools for the modeling and simulation of low-temperature plasma (LTP) discharges are increasingly vital to progress in the field in order to properly characterize and study complex source designs and plasma chemistries beyond the scope of traditional diagnostics. Open-source software provides powerful platforms for this work and can enable community-driven LTP R&D. Within the Multiphysics Object-Oriented Simulation Environment (MOOSE) open-source framework [1], capabilities have been demonstrated in the areas of plasma fluids (Zapdos [2]), plasma chemistry (CRANE [3]), and general electromagnetic wave theory (Electromagnetic Library for Kinetics & fluids [ELK] [4]). ELK has since been coupled to Zapdos/CRANE to enable fully coupled electromagnetic plasma simulations. This talk will detail the continued validation efforts and discuss Zapdos-ELK-CRANE code coupling with various-low temperature plasma sources. The impact of fully coupled electromagnetics on process parameters (e.g., temperature and electron/ion energy) versus an electrostatic description will also be discussed. [1] Permann et al., SoftwareX, 11 (2020) 100430. [2] Lindsay et al., J. Phys. D: Appl. Phys. 49 (2016) 235204. [3] Keniley et al., Talk, GEC Session DT3.00002 (2019). [4] Icenhour et al., Talk, GEC Session RR1.00006 (2019). Acknowledgements: INL Graduate Fellowship Program, NSF SI2 Grant 1740300, U.S. Dept. of Energy Office of Science Graduate Student Research Program

70 PLASMA PHYSICS AND FUSION TECHNOLOGY↗

Validation Studies using ELK and the Open-Source MOOSE Framework Application Zapdos for Electromagnetic Coupled Plasma Simulation

An open source simulation platform that captures electromagnetics, plasma chemistry, and fluid treatment of the plasma domain would be a powerful tool for studying low temperature plasma (LTP) phenomena. Within the Multiphysics Object-Oriented Simulation Environment (MOOSE) open source framework, ELK, CRANE, and Zapdos are combined to provide open source simulation capability for the LTP community. This talk presents continued validation of the general electromagnetic (EM) simulation tool ELK (Electromagnetic Library for Kinetics & fluids). Previous validation efforts focused on simulating standard waveguide and antenna benchmarks in vacuum and linear dielectrics, but ELK has since been coupled with the MOOSE-based plasma fluid application Zapdos [Lindsay et al 2016 J. Phys. D: Appl. Phys. 49 235204] to perform radio-frequency (rf) capacitively coupled plasma (CCP) system simulation. Plasma validation efforts initially focused on electrostatic benchmarks to demonstrate ELK-Zapdos code coupling and then moved to electromagnetic benchmarks based on interesting geometries and conditions (VHF effects in a CCP reactor, microwave heating, etc.). Results and progress in these efforts will be summarized and discussed.

70 PLASMA PHYSICS AND FUSION TECHNOLOGY↗

Electromagnetics Simulations with Vector-valued Finite Elements in MOOSE

Vector-valued finite elements have become an essential part of modern electromagnetic (EM) numerical simulation. This talk will describe the development and initial validation of a MOOSE-based EM solver application, ELK (Electromagnetics Library for Kinetics and fluids), that utilizes the recently added vector-valued finite element system. The primary motivation for the development of ELK was to study EM wave propagation in radio-frequency (rf) driven systems, such as those encountered in the study of antenna structures, waveguides, and plasma physics. In simulating these scenarios with traditional scalar-valued finite elements, boundary conditions on tangential field components can sometimes be difficult to define, and field discontinuities encountered with certain geometric or structural features (e.g., abrupt corners and inhomogeneous materials) can often lead to non-physical results. Vector-valued elements can largely mitigate and even eliminate these difficulties. ELK verification and validation efforts thus far have focused on standard wave propagation benchmarks for antennas and waveguides, and the impact of vector-valued elements on the implementation and results of these simulations will be described. Progress using ELK for plasma physics simulation, where inhomogeneous simulation domains are commonplace, will also be discussed.

70 PLASMA PHYSICS AND FUSION TECHNOLOGY↗

Elk: A New MOOSE Framework Application for Radio-frequency Electromagnetics

A new tool in-development for general electromagnetic (EM) simulation for modeling radio-frequency (rf) systems is presented. The primary motivation for development of this tool is to leverage the flexibility and high-performance-computing capability of the Multiphysics Object-Oriented Simulation Environment (MOOSE) Framework developed by Idaho National Laboratory (INL) for complex EM problems. A MOOSE application (or MOOSE App) enables the end user to create a fully-functional simulation scenario without needing explicit knowledge of the underlying finite-element weak form implementation. MOOSE combines the libMesh library and the PetSc suite as the finite element and solver libraries, giving a robust platform for solving highly non-linear, coupled sets of PDEs such as those found in EM and plasma physics problems. Initial validation efforts have included standard waveguide and antenna benchmarks with the current focus being field validation against the well-known capacitively-coupled GEC Reference Cell (GEC-CCP). The results of this effort will be outlined and discussed. Future work plans including cold-plasma rf wave propagation studies and coupling to the plasma fluid MOOSE App, Zapdos [Lindsay et al 2016 J. Phys. D: Appl. Phys. 49 235204], will also be discussed.

70 PLASMA PHYSICS AND FUSION TECHNOLOGY↗

Multi-physics Object Oriented Simulation Environment (MOOSE)

This two-day workshop is a hands-on introduction to the Multi-Physics Object Oriented Simulation Environment (MOOSE). MOOSE is a simulation framework built from PETSc that enables efficient simulation of complex physical systems with minimal programming background. Attendees are encouraged to visit the MOOSE website at www.mooseframework.org and walk through the step by step process of installing the framework on their computer. Support through this process is provided through the MOOSE Google Group message board. The workshop itself will consist of interactive modules where instructors from the MOOSE development team will work with attendees to build a simple plasma model. Each module will build on previous modules to introduce fundamental MOOSE features that will combine to demonstrate simulation capabilities for low temperature plasma modeling. The intention is not to provide an exhaustive overview of simulation capabilities but to instead provide attendees with the necessary tools to build unique simulation capabilities for their specific research challenges. Users should attend the workshop with laptop computers with MOOSE installed to allow for interactive instruction. At the completion of the workshop attendees will be able to install and run MOOSE and associated applications as well as carry out plasma simulations studies.

70 PLASMA PHYSICS AND FUSION TECHNOLOGY↗

Novel Engineered Refractory Materials for Advanced Reactor Applications

This report summarizes the results of DOE-NEUP grant 10-853. The project spanned 48 months (36 months under the original grant plus a 12 month no cost extension). The overarching goal of this work was to fabricate and characterize refractory materials engineered at the atomic scale with emphasis on their tolerance to accumulated radiation damage. With an emphasis on nano-scale structure, this work included atomic scale simulation to study the underlying mechanisms for modified radiation tolerance at these atomic scales.

21 SPECIFIC NUCLEAR REACTORS AND ASSOCIATED PLANTS↗

Atomistic structures of nano-engineered SiC and radiation-induced amorphization resistance

In this paper, nano-engineered 3C–SiC thin films, which possess columnar structures with high-density stacking faults and twins, were irradiated with 2 MeV Si ions at cryogenic and room temperatures. From cross-sectional transmission electron microscopy observations in combination with Monte Carlo simulations based on the Stopping and Range of Ions in Matter code, it was found that their amorphization resistance is six times greater than bulk crystalline SiC at room temperature. High-angle bright-field images taken by spherical aberration corrected scanning transmission electron microscopy revealed that the distortion of atomic configurations is localized near the stacking faults. Finally, the resultant strain field probably contributes to the enhancement of radiation tolerance of this material.

36 MATERIALS SCIENCE↗

Competing effects of electronic and nuclear energy loss on microstructural evolution in ionic-covalent materials

Ever increasing energy needs have raised the demands for advanced fuels and cladding materials that withstand the extreme radiation environments with improved accident tolerance over a long period of time. Ceria (CeO2) is a well known ionic conductor that is isostructural with urania and plutonia-based nuclear fuels. In the context of nuclear fuels, immobilization and transmutation of actinides, CeO2 is a model system for radiation effect studies. Covalent silicon carbide (SiC) is a candidate for use as structural material in fusion, cladding material for fission reactors, and an inert matrix for the transmutation of plutonium and other radioactive actinides. Understanding microstructural change of these ionic-covalent materials to irradiation is important for advanced nuclear energy systems. While displacements from nuclear energy loss may be the primary contribution to damage accumulation in a crystalline matrix and a driving force for the grain boundary evolution in nanostructured materials, local non-equilibrium disorder and excitation through electronic energy loss may, however, produce additional damage or anneal pre-existing defects. At intermediate transit energies where electronic and nuclear energy losses are both significant, synergistic, additive or competitive processes may evolve that affect the dynamic response of materials to irradiation. The response of crystalline and nanostructured CeO2 and SiC to ion irradiation are studied under different nuclear and electronic stopping powers to describe some general material response in this transit energy regime. Although fast radiation-induced grain growth in CeO2 is evident with no phase transformation, different fluence and dose dependence on the growth rate is observed under Si and Au irradiations. While grain shrinkage and amorphization are observed in the nano-engineered 3C SiC with a high-density of stacking faults embedded in nanosize columnar grains, significantly enhanced radiation resistance is attributed to stacking faults that promote efficient point defect annihilation. Moreover, competing effects of electronic and nuclear energy loss on the damage accumulation and annihilation are observed in crystalline 4H-SiC. Systematic experiments and simulation effort are needed to understand the competitive or synergistic effects.

36 MATERIALS SCIENCE↗

Origin of radiation tolerance in 3C-SiC with nanolayered planar defects

We have recently found that the radiation tolerance of SiC is highly enhanced by introducing nanolayers of stacking faults and twins [Y. Zhang et al., Phys. Chem. Chem. Phys. 14, 13429 (2012)]. To reveal the origin of this radiation resistance, we used in situ transmission electron microscopy to examine structural changes induced by electron beam irradiation in 3C-SiC containing nanolayers of (111) planar defects. We found that preferential amorphization, when it does occur, takes place at grain boundaries and at (111) and (111) planar defects. Radiation-induced point defects, such as interstitials and vacancies, migrate two-dimensionally between the (111) planar defects, which probably enhances the damage recovery.

36 MATERIALS SCIENCE↗

Nanoscale Engineering Of Radiation Tolerant Silicon Carbide

Radiation tolerance is determined by how effectively the microstructure can remove point defects produced by irradiation. Engineered nanocrystalline SiC with a high-density of stacking faults (SFs) has significantly enhanced recombination of interstitials and vacancies, leading to selfhealing of irradiation-induced defects. While single crystal SiC readily undergoes an irradiationinduced crystalline to amorphous transformation at room temperature, the nano-engineered SiC with a high-density of SFs exhibits more than an order of magnitude increase in radiation resistance. Molecular dynamics simulations of collision cascades show that the nano-layered SFs lead to enhanced mobility of interstitial Si atoms. The remarkable radiation resistance in the nano-engineered SiC is attributed to the high-density of SFs within nano-sized grain structures that significantly enhance point defect annihilation.

Environmental Molecular Sciences Laboratory↗