Search NASA⌕ Search

Engineering topics

Sherlock, M. (ORCID:0000000180985732)

Publications and source records attributed to Sherlock, M. (ORCID:0000000180985732).

The accuracy of multi-group models for nonlocal electron transport in magnetized plasmas

In the extreme conditions of inertial confinement fusion experiments, heat flow plays a vital role, but local diffusive models frequently break down and overestimate the heat flow. The situation becomes more complicated again in the significant magnetic fields generated during laser–plasma interactions or in magnetized fusion schemes. Accurate non-local and magnetized heat flow computations can be carried out using Vlasov–Fokker–Planck (VFP) simulations, but these are computationally expensive. There is, therefore, significant interest in using faster multi-group models to accurately calculate the non-local heat flow in magnetized plasmas. We benchmark two such multi-group models for calculating the heat flow, M1 and hybrid-AWBS-BGK, against diffusive models and full VFP simulations, before applying the models to realistic example test cases, both magnetized and unmagnetized. We find that the multi-group models generally perform very well for moderate non-localities up to kλmfp∼0.01, but the computational cost increases dramatically. hybrid-AWBS-BGK performs more effectively than M1 at high non-localities, up to kλmfp∼1, due to its adaptive solver and robust P1 closure, but tends to fail in very strong magnetic fields. Both codes are much faster than VFP simulations but are still slow in steep temperature gradients.

Arran, C. (ORCID:0000000286448118)↗

Kinetic corrections to heat-flow and Nernst advection for laser heated plasmas

Reduced models for approximating the impact of kinetic electron behavior on the transport of thermal energy and magnetic field are investigated. The thermal flux limiter has improved agreement with Vlasov–Fokker–Planck data when a harmonic form is used that adjusts the electron mean free path to account for electron–electron collisions; these results apply to both unmagnetized and magnetized plasmas. Once a magnetic field is incorporated, the mean free path should also be modified using the electron gyroradius. A flux limiter on Nernst advection of magnetic fields is also required; a form that limits Nernst by the same fraction as the thermal heat-flow best reproduces kinetic simulations. A flux limiter form for the cross terms (Righi–Leduc and cross-gradient-Nernst) is also suggested. Hohlraum simulations relevant to fusion experiments on the National Ignition Facility are found to be sensitive to all of these details.

70 PLASMA PHYSICS AND FUSION TECHNOLOGY↗

Reconciling calculations and measurements of inverse bremsstrahlung absorption

It was recently shown that the use of Coulomb logarithms appropriate for bremsstrahlung radiation (rather than transport processes) along with corrections for the Langdon effect and ion screening reproduced measurements of collisional absorption in well-characterized underdense plasmas [D. Turnbull et al., Phys. Rev. Lett. 130, 145103 (2023)]. However, it was recognized at the time that the use of the standard absorption-reduction factor from Langdon's seminal paper was inconsistent with the use of Coulomb logarithms that are thermally averaged over a Maxwellian electron-velocity distribution function. A more accurate approach would be to average over the expected super-Gaussian distribution function while accounting for the Gaunt factor's velocity dependence, which somewhat mitigates the Langdon effect; however, at that time, this theory matched the data less well. This conflict is now eliminated with the additional insight that the ionization state of our mid-Z ion species (when present) was lower than had been assumed, as evidenced by the Thomson-scattering data and time-dependent Cretin simulations. We are now able to show that an improved treatment of the Langdon effect provides the best match to data. Otherwise, the prior conclusions remain unchanged. We also show an example of the substantial expected impact to the absorption rate in calculations of indirect-drive hohlraums.

70 PLASMA PHYSICS AND FUSION TECHNOLOGY↗

Review and meta-analysis of electron temperatures from high-intensity laser–solid interactions

The accelerated electron spectrum from high-intensity laser–solid interaction is often conveniently described using a Boltzmann distribution, whose temperature is known within the field as the hot-electron temperature. The importance of the electron temperature is highlighted by the sheer number of experimental and simulation studies on the subject over the past three decades. Recently, multi-kJ, multi-ps pulses have yielded electron spectra with temperatures far beyond the expected ponderomotive result. Expressions that predict the electron temperature considering laser parameters beyond intensity and wavelength have been developed, albeit using small datasets. In this review, we present what is, to the best of our knowledge, the largest dataset of electron temperatures gathered from experimental measurements and particle-in-cell simulations. This dataset allows us to compare existing analytical and empirical hot-electron temperature scaling models over a wide parameter range. We also develop new scaling models that incorporate the laser pulse duration of the laser and the plasma scale length. Three models that include pulse-duration and scale length dependence are especially successful at predicting both simulated and experimental data. The dataset will soon be made publicly available to encourage further investigation.

70 PLASMA PHYSICS AND FUSION TECHNOLOGY↗