Coupled abrasion Erosion-Oxidation wear from particles in Concentrating solar thermal power facilities
Not provided.
Energy & Fuels↗
Engineering topics
Shirazi, Siamack
Publications and source records attributed to Shirazi, Siamack.
Experimental Testing of Particle Erosion and Attrition in CSP Systems
In CSP systems using solid particles for heat transfer, erosion from the falling particles can damage the system components upon impact, and from sliding against the component walls. Furthermore, the resulting attrition of particles can change the thermal performance due to alterations in particle morphology. The research on these issues has been limited to industrial applications, and don’t necessarily coincide with the operating conditions in CSP systems. In this work, we investigated the durability of the particles selected as the heat transfer media, as well as special substrate materials that are of interest as lining materials to the particle storage tanks and hoppers. Three different erosion phenomena were studied: impact, abrasion, and attrition erosion. The low-temperature experiments revealed negligible losses from attrition and abrasion erosion. Although the substrates indicated visible surface damage from impact erosion, the actual material mass loss was small even after a throughput of 500kg of particles 63 days of 1MW CSP plant operation assuming 14 hours per day of operation. Erosion is typically classified as impact, abrasion, or attrition erosion. For example, the CSP systems utilizing solid particles as heat transfer media will likely experience impact erosion on the receiver hopper and heat exchanger walls as the solid particles fall from the reservoir. Additionally, there will be sliding erosion along the receiver walls as particles move through the hopper, and lastly, there will also be attrition erosion as the particles rub against each other. The extent of erosion depends on many factors including but not limited to particle shape and size, material hardness/brittleness and ductility, and particle impact speed and angle. Mechanistic erosion equations that are available in the literature are mostly derived from data pertaining to specific experiments and therefore can’t be applied to all applications without suitable adjustments. Survey of the literature relating to particle-based receivers revealed that the most prevalent approach has been to choose low velocities to limit erosion, but to our knowledge, little effort has been put in to fully characterize erosion at the expected operating conditions. A relatively recent work investigated the erosion of wire mesh proposed for use in a particle receiver, where the results actually showed an increase in mass as oxidation occurred on the mesh surface but the work did not investigate the particle attrition rate, and the erosion rate of a solid substrate. The end goal of this work is to develop a comprehensive particle and substrate durability model that will allow a comprehensive understanding of particle-based CSP operating conditions on component durability.
14 SOLAR ENERGY↗
Falling particle impact erosion testing for particle based CSP systems
CSP systems are currently being examined as an effective method for using solar energy to generate electricity. While much of this research has been conducted using molten salt as the heat transfer medium, in recent years, solid particles have been posited as a cheaper and more energy efficient heat transfer medium for use in CSP systems. Many researchers have looked into the effectiveness of solid particles as a heat transfer medium. However, a concern with the use of particles is that the falling particles will impact various components within the CSP system, such as the hopper, the heat exchanger, and the insulating material, resulting in surface erosion and damage. With repeated impacts from falling particles, material from the surfaces under impact is removed. The degree of erosion depends on whether the substrate is made of brittle or ductile material. Furthermore, factors such as particle shape, size, hardness, concentration, impact angle, particle velocity, and substrate hardness will contribute to the erosion process and determine how much and how quickly erosion will takes place in a system. Three types of erosion will be observed simultaneously: impact erosion from particle impact on receiver, particle storage, and heat exchanger walls, abrasion erosion from particle sliding motion along walls, and attrition erosion as the particles breakdown from particle-to-particle contact and particle-to-wall interactions. It is imperative to understand each of these erosions individually for a more comprehensive understanding and prediction of CSP system durability. In this work, we developed an experimental test setup capable of measuring impact erosion at conditions relevant to 1MW CSP plant. Subsequently, Impact erosion measurements were performed for three different candidate substrate materials at low particle velocities using HSP 40/70 ceramic particles.
14 SOLAR ENERGY↗
EXPERIMENTAL INVESTIGATION OF IMPACT AND ABRASION EROSIONS AT LOW VELOCITIES AND COMPARISON TO CFD SIMULATIONS
Wear and erosion damage of materials due to interaction of the surface with solid particles is a major issue in various industries. This phenomenon is common in mining, and oil and gas production, causing damages worth millions of dollars annually. Erosion is becoming a critical issue in renewable technologies as well such as concentrated solar thermal power (CSP) systems. In some CSP systems, solid particles can be used to absorb solar energy and enhance the heat storage. However, these particles may cause significant amount of wear to system components while falling down the power tower at high temperatures. This damage can be costly, and therefore, investigating solid particle erosion in CSP systems is of utmost importance. In collaboration with Sandia National Laboratories, the erosion durability of particle-based Generation 3 (GEN3) CSP system are being investigated both experimentally and numerically. In order to develop models to predict the life time of such systems, erosion under low temperature and low particle impact velocity conditions are investigated. Impact erosion and abrasion erosion experiments are conducted for low velocity and low temperature conditions for various candidate particles and containment materials. The impact erosion testing is conducted for three different containment material including Stainless Steel 316, special refractory material, and Inconel 740H with CARBOBEAD HSP 40/70 ceramic particles and UNIWEST 430 silica quartz erodent particles. All this data will enable us to better model the erosion behavior of these materials and provides a data base to investigate erosion at high temperatures experienced in CSP systems. At low temperatures and low velocities the softer refractory material exhibited greater erosion by an order-of-magnitude when compared to the harder Inconel 740H and Stainless Steel 316 materials. The overall erosion ratio for all the candidate materials was of the order of 10 -7 kg/kg. We also investigated wear in containment materials from sliding of particles over the surfaces at very low angles, also referred to as abrasion. For the velocities expected in a typical 1MW CSP plant, visible surface wear was noted, but the overall mass loss per unit surface area was found to be dependent on the hardness of the containment material tested. In this manuscript, we also present Computational Fluid Dynamics (CFD) simulations and erosion prediction of low velocity impact erosion. These results are compared with the experimental data to evaluate the ability of available erosion models for predicting erosion under these conditions.
14 SOLAR ENERGY↗