Engineering topics

Shirazi, Siamack A.

Publications and source records attributed to Shirazi, Siamack A..

8 records

DOE OSTI2022

Experimental investigation of low velocity and high temperature solid particle impact erosion wear

Next generation Concentrating Solar Power (CSP) plants utilizing solid particles as the heat transfer medium (HTM) are expected to achieve greater operational efficiencies. However, the erosion from the solid particles can cause significant damage to component materials. Low particle speeds (1–2 m/s) are proposed as a means of preventing excessive damage to containment materials. Within the current investigation, solid particle erosion of three potential containment materials, stainless-steel grade 316L, a nickel alloy (Inconel 740H), and a refractory material (Tufcrete 60 M), are examined at a particle impact speed of 1.6 m/s. CarboBead-HSP 40/70 particles, a candidate HTM for CSP systems, impact the specimens at a relatively high impact angle of 60° based on containment design criteria. Experiments were conducted at ambient temperature and 800 °C to examine erosion of the materials at very low impact speeds and determine how temperature effects erosion. Initial results revealed surprising outcomes inconsistent with available literature: ambient temperature erosion of SS316L is an order of magnitude lower than IN740H, but erosion (erosion-corrosion) of SS316L at 800 °C surpasses IN740H by two orders of magnitude. Furthermore, results suggest removal of oxide layers (erosion-corrosion) is responsible for the significant erosion that was observed even at these low particle speeds.

36 MATERIALS SCIENCE↗

DOE OSTI2021

Effect of temperature on abrasion erosion in particle based concentrating solar powerplants

The use of solid particles as a heat transfer medium is being explored for concentrated solar power plants (CSP) to increase their efficiency by achieving operating temperature >700 °C. During operation, these hot particles are expected to move along the various components within the collector system, resulting in material degradation from a combination of high-temperature oxidation and erosion. In the present study, the performance of candidate materials was evaluated through a series of abrasion erosion experiments at room temperature as well as at 800 °C. Wear in metallic and refractory type materials was investigated using CarboBead® HSP 40/70 particles inside a resistance heated kiln. Furthermore, cross-sectional scanning electron microscopy (SEM) and energy dispersive x-ray spectroscopy (EDS) analysis on the specimens tested at 800 °C determined that the specific wear rate in Inconel 740H and stainless steel 316 metallic specimens was influenced by the thermally grown oxide morphology. High chromium Inconel 740H specimens exhibited greater resistance to wear with a steady state specific wear rate of 1.92E-4 mm 3 N -1 m –1 compared to 5.7E-3 mm 3 N -1 m –1 for Stainless Steel 316.

14 SOLAR ENERGY↗

DOE OSTI2021

Abrasion wear at high temperature in particle receiver type Concentrating Solar Power Systems

The use of solid particles as a heat transfer fluid in receivers for concentrating solar powerplants has garnered much attention in the past decade. Particles are not only stable at temperatures above 700 °C but are also able to absorb solar energy directly, which gives them a distinct advantage over conventional molten salts. The use of particles can, however, cause material degradation from the flow of hot or cold particles through discharge hoppers or along the inner receiver surfaces and other system components (e.g. tubes, valves etc.), depending on operating mode of the receiver. Stainless steel alloy 316, nickel-based alloy Inconel® 740H®, Haynes 230, and a 60% alumina, low-cement refractory castable from Allied Mineral Products were tested for wear from first-of-a-kind high-temperature low-velocity abrasion-erosion experiments. The tests are designed to simulate potential conditions in Generation 3 falling particle Concentrating Solar Power (CSP) systems. Simultaneous experiments were conducted at room temperature as well to draw comparison on the role of temperature on abrasion wear rates. It was noted that the abrasion wear rate in candidate materials was driven by the oxidation resistance of the material. The findings from these experiments will be used to determine life-time of critical components in particle receiver concentrated solar powerplants.

14 SOLAR ENERGY↗

DOE OSTI2021

Wear in particle based CSP systems from particle abrasion and attrition at high temperature

High temperature particle-based receivers offer distinct advantages over conventional molten salt receivers due to their ability to achieve temperatures above 700 ºC, direct absorption of solar energy as they fall through a beam of concentrated sunlight, and the relative ease of storage (and retrieval using a secondary working fluid) in insulated storage tanks. The use of particles, however, also raises concerns with material degradation from the flow of hot or cold particles through discharge hoppers or along the inner receiver surfaces and other system components (e.g. tubes, valves etc.), depending on operating mode of the receiver. The flow of particles over surfaces may result in loss of material from abrasive wear, impact erosion from impingement under gravitational fall and particle attrition as particles fall and move on top of each other. In the present study, the performance of candidate materials and particles were evaluated through a series of abrasion erosion and particle attrition experiments at room temperature as well as at 800 °C. Candidate materials were subject to abrasive wear from particles at low particle to material velocities inside a resistance heated kiln, and analyzed for changes in mass and surface morphology using cross-sectional scanning electron microscopy (SEM) and energy dispersive x-ray spectroscopy (EDS) tests. The wear rate for different specimens was noted to be largely driven by the strength of chromia scales built on the specimens from exposure to high temperature. Particle attrition measurements explored the susceptibility of particles to breakdown from particle to particle interaction and the generation of fines from this process. At the low velocities expected in particle based CSP plants, the particles tested exhibited near negligible breakdown. However, changes in the particle hardness at 800 ºC resulted in a significantly higher particle breakdown to sizes <40 microns raising potential environmental concerns. In addition to particle breakdown, it was also noted that the sample had oxides from the stainless steel test setup mixed in with the particles. Similar oxides can be expected to turn up in the utility scale particle based CSP plants as well. The presence of oxide was also noted to affect the solar absorptivity of the mixture compared to a clean initial specimen, potentially resulting in a change in the overall efficiency of the CSP plant.

14 SOLAR ENERGY↗

DOE OSTI2020

High Temperature Erosion Modeling in Particle Based CSP Systems

1. Introduction. Wear and erosion damage of materials from solid particle and surface interactions is a major issue in various industries. Although more common in mining and oil and gas production, erosion is becoming a critical issue in renewable technologies as well such as particle based concentrated solar thermal power (CSP) systems. In particle based CSP systems, solid particles are used to absorb solar energy and as thermal storage. However, these particles may cause significant amount of wear to system components while through the system at high temperatures. This damage can be costly, and therefore, requires a greater understanding of solid particle erosion in CSP systems. Throughout the years, models and tools have been developed to predict and control erosion in industries such as oil and gas production. However, these erosion models and erosion prediction tools have been mainly developed based on erosion data for much higher velocities and lower temperatures, i.e. the operating conditions for which the existing models have been built are not pertinent to those expected in CSP system. It is known that erosion depends on many factors such as material properties, erodent particle properties, and particle impact speed and angle. However, the effect of temperature on erosion is not vastly investigated. In this work, a temperature-based correlation is introduced that will be used to modify the existing erosion models to predict erosion rates at velocities and temperatures relevant to Gen3 CSP systems. The existing models are first validated against erosion experiments run at low temperatures and low velocities. Subsequently, a temperature correction term is developed that can extend the existing models to high temperatures, based on the available experimental data showing the effect of temperature on impact erosion. 2. Erosion Models. Continuing sequence of impacts from solid particles on surfaces would result in loss of material due to mechanical interaction between solid surface and particles. Erosion equations have been developed to predict erosion under different conditions and erosion mechanism, including cutting and deformation erosion. These models are mainly either mechanistic, empirical, and semi-mechanistic models, when the latter combine the theory of the erosion mechanism and particle motion with the available experimental data. One of the first empirical correlation was introduced by American Petroleum Institute (API) Recommended Practice (RP) 14E [1]. This correlation was very conservative, and several improved empirical and semi-mechanistic equations were developed in the years following. More recently, the models introduced by Erosion/Corrosion Research Center (E/CRC) at the University of Tulsa and Arabnejad. et al. [2] are frequently used in the literature and industry, as they account for many parameters affecting erosion including particle impact speed and angle, material density and hardness, and particle size and shape. However, both these models were developed based on data at relatively high velocities and also do not take into account any mechanical changes in material associated with thermal cycling at high temperatures. 3. Erosion Prediction at High Temperatures. In this work, the accuracy of Arabnejad et al. model and E/CRC model is investigated to predict impact erosion at conditions relevant to Gen3 CSP systems. Two significant deviations expected in Gen3 systems compared to operating conditions used to build these models are particle impact velocities and system temperature. As a first step, the performance of these models was validated at low velocities and temperatures. Impact erosion experiments were conducted on SS316 coupons using HSP 40/70 ceramic particles. Assuming particle rate of 1 kg/s/m, 0.0254 m of particle curtain thickness, and particle velocity of 1.5 m/s in the system, an overall erosion of 0.59 mm/year was calculated. The experimental results were subsequently compared to those from computational simulations and erosion of 0.47 mm/year was obtained using the Arabnejad et al. model. The results indicated that the models work well at low velocities and low temperature conditions. To account for temperature effect, a mathematical correlation was developed using data published by DUCOM [3] for Inconel 600 eroded by alumina particles at high velocities. The correlation was applied to both Arabnejad et. al model and the E/CRC model. The prediction results from these modified models were within 20% of this experimental data. Predictions of of erosion by the modified E/CRC model at three different temperatures are made. Similar to the calculation at low temperature, a typical CSP system with 1 kg/s/m of particle flow rate per unit length of the particle curtain and a curtain thickness of 0.0254 m is assumed. The annual thickness loss calculations were run for different particle impact velocities, assuming a uniform particle impact area equal to the cross-sectional area of the curtain (particle-particle interactions and dispersion of particles are not considered in obtaining the results). It is observed that erosion increases exponentially as temperature increases. Furthermore, it is also noted that, erosion changes non-linearly with impact velocity. Currently, experiments are also being conducted to measure erosion of SS316 at 800 ºC with HSP 40/70 particles at low impact velocities. We expect to use the results from high temperature testing to further improve the temperature correlation function. Similar models are also being developed for abrasion erosion resulting from particle sliding along the surfaces as well as attrition from particle to particle and particle to surface interactions. References. [1] Institute, A. P. (1991). API Recommended Practice for Design and Installation of Offshore Production Platform Piping System, API RP 14E. [2] Arabnejad, H., Mansouri, A., Shirazi, S. A., and McLaury, B. S. (2015a). Development of mechanistic erosion equation for solid particles. Wear, 332–333, 1044–1050. http://doi.org/10.1016/j.wear.2015.01.031. [3] https://ducom.com/high-temperature-erosion-evaluating-sample-wear/

14 SOLAR ENERGY↗

DOE OSTI2020

Experimental testing of particle attrition in CSP systems at high temperature

An alternate and sustainable form of energy is CSP systems, which capture and store the sun’s energy in the form of heat. Increasing the operational temperature of CSP systems will increase the efficiency of electricity production while operating at temperatures exceeding 700 degrees Celsius also creates novel operational problems. One approach for high-temperature CSP systems is to utilize solid particles as the primary heat transfer medium. As particles flow through this system, the movement of particles creates erosion in the forms of impact, abrasion, and attrition erosion. In the real world, while all three forms of erosion will occur simultaneously, it is imperative to understand the individual effect of each erosion over the lifetime of the powerplant. Besides material erosion and long-term durability concerns, thermal cycling of the particles could also introduce changes in particle thermal performance due to alterations in particle morphology. Current research on the issue of erosion has been limited to industrial applications and does not necessarily coincide with the operating conditions in CSP systems. We focus on attrition erosion resulting from particle-to-wall and particle-to-particle interactions. Research has shown that besides material hardness affecting how fast particles break down, attrition erosion increased as the size of the particles increased due to a higher chance of collision between the particles. Particle attrition is relevant to the CSP community as it may result in material loss, change the system's thermal performance, and generation of fines which could pose an environmental hazard. In this work, we focus on developing a test set up that can isolate and measure particle attrition when subjected to conditions relevant to Gen3 CSP systems.

14 SOLAR ENERGY↗

DOE OSTI2020

High Temperature Erosion In Particle Based CSP Systems

Particle based concentrated solar power plants are increasingly being considered as an alternative to molten salts. Although these particle based systems provide the inherent safety and enhanced lifetime from reduced corrosion compared to molten salt systems, they bring in complexities associated with surface erosion from falling particle impact and sliding motion along the surfaces. Past research on particle related erosion has been limited to high velocity applications and doesn’t necessarily coincide with the operating conditions in CSP systems. In our work, we evaluate characterize the rate of erosion for particles and containment materials at 800ºC. Three different types of erosion resulting from a) impact of solid particles on receiver, particle storage, and heat exchanger walls; b) abrasion erosion from particle sliding motion along walls; and c) attrition erosion as the particles breakdown from particle-to-particle contact and particle-to-wall interactions are evaluated and compared across a varied spectrum of particle and containment material spectrum. From the results, It is noted that temperature plays a key role in the rate of erosion experienced by any material. With the increase in temperature, materials become more ductile and are more readily sheared away from particle impinging or sliding motion. Furthermore, the particles themselves have higher susceptibility to breakdown which also lowers particle thermal absorptance and thus efficiency as heat transfer fluid.

14 SOLAR ENERGY↗

DOE OSTI2020

High Temperature Erosion In Particle Based CSP Systems

14 SOLAR ENERGY↗