Search NASA⌕ Search

Engineering topics

Sienicki, James J.

Publications and source records attributed to Sienicki, James J..

At least 19 records

In-Sodium Testing of a Prototype Thermoacoustic Power Sensor for Sodium-Cooled Fast Reactors

The ultimate goal of this project is to develop and demonstrate a thermoacoustic power sensor (TAPS) for Sodium-Cooled Fast Reactors (SFRs), with potential application also envisioned to other nuclear technologies such as Lead-Cooled Fast Reactors (LFRs), Molten Salt Reactors (MSRs), in addition to Light Water Reactors (LWRs). The project was led by Westinghouse Electric Company, LLC (Westinghouse) and carried out in collaboration with Argonne National Laboratory (ANL) and the University of Pittsburgh. A TAPS is a passive (self-powered), non-invasive (wireless) sensor envisioned for measuring key parameters, such as local temperature and neutron flux, in a nuclear reactor core. The sensor generates pressure waves (i.e., sound waves) with a frequency and amplitude dependent upon nuclear operating conditions (coolant temperature or power changes). The acoustic waves are able to travel through the core and associated structures, and reach to the sensor network placed outside and/or inside of the reactor vessel. These sensors require a very small amount of power which, during loss of power events, can be provided, for example, by harvesting gamma radiation energy, thus resulting in a monitoring system that can function both during normal operation and during loss of power events. Westinghouse and the University of Pittsburgh designed and fabricated TAPS prototypes for Argonne National Laboratory (ANL) to carry out in-sodium testing to evaluate the effects of sodium on the TAPS and the performance of the TAPS technique in sodium. Argonne received a TAPS prototype from Westinghouse, and the prototype was modified such that it can be installed into a test vessel and function in sodium at elevated temperature without potentially leaking. A water mockup test apparatus was constructed to validate proper working of the prototype. An instrumentation and control (I&C) system, running on the National Instruments (NI) LabView platform, was developed to: 1) operate both the water mockup test and the in-sodium test facility; and 2) process and analyze the received acoustic signals from an array of accelerometers and the Argonne sodium-submersible high-temperature acoustic sensor. The prototype was successfully tested in a water bath at different temperatures. Water mockup tests demonstrated that the TAPS prototype is working properly and its resonance frequency changes linearly with the coolant (water) temperature. A TAPS test apparatus was constructed and integrated with the upgraded Under-Sodium Viewing (USV) sodium test facility. The integrated USV-TAPS sodium test facility has been operational. The TAPS prototype and a high-temperature sodium-submersible acoustic sensor (SSAS) developed by Argonne were both installed inside the TAPS test vessel. Being operated within argon cover gas under ambient conditions, the TAPS prototype demonstrated that it was functioning properly with a resonance frequency at 1407.2 Hz, which was successfully detected by the accelerometers mounted on the external wall of the vessel and the high-temperature SSAS installed inside the vessel. After successfully transferring sodium into the vessel, in-sodium tests of the prototype were conducted. Tests of the TAPS prototype demonstrated that the resonance frequency of the TAPS changes linearly with respect to the temperature difference between the interior of the TAPS and bulk sodium. The early tests showed that the TAPS prototype could not establish a continuous and consistent resonance in sodium. The resonance diminished before the prototype reached its operating temperature. A signal postprocessor was added to the DAQ module latterly to isolate interferences, enhance signal conditioning, improve peak detection, and generate resonance frequency versus temperature plots. After testing in molten sodium and immersion at higher temperature for several weeks, the TAPS prototype was able to establish a continuous resonance. Performance evaluation of the TAPS prototype was then conducted in sodium. The tests included the investigation of 1) the effects of the temperature difference between the TAPS and bulk sodium, 2) the effects of sodium flowrate; and 3) the performance of the different sensor-receiver systems positioned inside or outside the vessel. Results of a test demonstrated that, with limited sodium circulation, a continuous and consistent resonance of the TAPS prototype was established occasionally. The tests also demonstrated that, because of the nature of detection principles and mounting methods, the high temperature SSAS is more affected by acoustic noise, while accelerometers are more affected by vibrations, in the test environment. It is unknown why the TAPS prototype only occasionally established a continuous and consistent resonance when the TAPS temperature reached its operating temperature in molten sodium, and why it ultimately failed to resonate at all. A failure modes assessment was conducted and a few potential causes of failure were identified. Different post in-sodium tests were conducted to obtain additional information potentially relevant to the cause of the failure. Nondestructive evaluation techniques are suggested to examine the internal integrity as well as the gas mixture of the prototype. If they prove inconclusive, the prototype should be cut open to conduct a thorough inspection of its internal integrity and determine the state of the gas mixture.

46 INSTRUMENTATION RELATED TO NUCLEAR SCIENCE AND ↗

Demonstration of Thermoacoustic Power Sensor

The goal of this project is to develop and demonstrate a thermoacoustic power sensor (TAPS) for Sodium-cooled Fast Reactor (SFR), with potential application also envisioned to other nuclear technologies such as Lead-Cooled Fast Reactor (LFR), Molten Salt Reactor (MSR), in addition to Light Water Reactors (LWRs). The project was led by Westinghouse Electric Company, LLC (Westinghouse) and carried out in collaboration with Argonne National Laboratory (ANL) and the University of Pittsburgh. A TAPS is a passive (self-powered), non-invasive (wireless) sensor envisioned for measuring key parameters, such as local temperature and neutron flux, in a nuclear reactor core. The sensor generates pressure waves (i.e., sound waves) with a frequency and amplitude dependent upon nuclear operating conditions (coolant temperature or power changes). The acoustic waves are able to travel through the core and associated structures, and reach to the detector network placed outside of the reactor vessel. These detectors require a very small amount of power which, during loss of power events, can be provided for example by harvesting gamma radiation energy, thus resulting in a monitoring system that can function both during normal operation and during loss of power events.

46 INSTRUMENTATION RELATED TO NUCLEAR SCIENCE AND ↗

Fiscal Year 2018 Sodium-CO2 Interaction Test

An experiment campaign was continued in Fiscal Year 2018 in the Argonne National Laboratory (Argonne) SNAKE facility that investigated the interactions between supercritical carbon dioxide (sCO 2 ) and sodium through injection of sCO 2 into an open surface sodium pool. Two of fifteen previous SNAKE tests revealed that self-plugging of the leakage path/nozzle occurs at higher initial sodium temperatures of about 500 ºC due to chemical reactions involving CO 2 , sodium, and sodium-CO 2 reaction products. At lower sodium temperatures, the interaction phenomena involve consumption of injected CO 2 and formation of an agglomerated mass of reaction products without self-plugging. The FY 2018 test investigated interactions at an intermediate initial sodium temperature of about 411 ºC, representative of the interior of a sodium-to-CO 2 heat exchanger in a Sodium-Cooled Fast Reactor (SFR) sCO 2 Brayton Cycle energy conversion system. The experiment was successfully conducted and did not show self-plugging as evidenced by a sustained chemical reaction between the injected CO 2 and sodium and consumption of CO 2 .

21 SPECIFIC NUCLEAR REACTORS AND ASSOCIATED PLANTS↗

Initial Argonne Sodium Draining Tests: Analysis of Test Results and Comparison with Water Draining Behavior

Three initial sodium draining experiments have been carried out in which sodium was drained from a 0.46 m high 4.6 mm inner diameter vertical stainless steel tube wetted by the sodium representative of a sodium channel in a compact diffusion-bonded sodium-to-CO 2 heat exchanger. Prior to the startup of sodium testing, shakedown tests were conducted with water. In all three sodium experiments, the sodium drained efficiently from the channel. Sodium and water both drain efficiently from a 4.6 mm inner diameter vertical stainless steel tube. This is an important and good result for the design of compact diffusion-bonded heat exchanger sodium channels. Sodium drains more efficiently than water. This is also an important and good result for the design of compact diffusion-bonded heat exchanger sodium channels. The draining phenomena observed with sodium and water are significantly different. The draining of water involves an initial rapid slug draining phase followed by a linear rate draining phase followed by a slow draining phase involving draining of rivulets and drops. This behavior has previously been reported in the literature for viscous fluids. The draining of sodium involves an initial rapid slug draining phase but no discernable linear rate draining phase. There is a subsequent slow draining phase. However, unlike the slow draining phase with water that involves a number of rivulets and drops, the slow draining phase with sodium in two out of three sodium tests mainly involves a single discrete event in which a mass of sodium drains from the tube. This single discrete draining event encompasses most of the sodium mass remaining inside of the tube following the rapid slug draining phase. The existence of a single discrete draining event during the slow draining phase with sodium versus several rivulet and drop draining events with water is thought to simply reflect the fact that significantly lower mass fractions of liquid are left behind inside of the tube following the rapid slug draining phase with sodium relative to water. For the sodium tests, the progress of wetting of the stainless steel by sodium was monitored by means of the voltage drop across the tube outer diameter measured by pairs of opposing electrodes welded to the tube outer surface at three different elevations. The electrode data remarkably reveals phenomena during the sodium draining. The downward passage of the sodium slug trailing edge past each electrode was observed from which a mean slug trailing edge velocity could be determined. The subsequent slower increase in voltage drop suggests draining and thinning of a sodium film left behind upon the tube inner surface; wiggles in the voltage drop data are suggestive of the descent of waves on the film. It is thought that the draining sodium film collects as a mass likely near the lower end of the tube and detaches corresponding to the single discrete draining event observed in the load cell data. The minimum circular channel inner diameter for the draining of water and sodium without the formation of lenses that bridge the channel and may remain inside of the tube without draining is predicted with a correlation to be 2.2 mm. The highest priority for future sodium draining testing is to investigate other channel geometries such as a rectilinear channel or a semicircular channel.

22 GENERAL STUDIES OF NUCLEAR REACTORS↗

Development of Thermoacoustic Sensors for Sodium-cooled Fast Reactors

This Final Report refers to the project “Development of Thermoacoustic Sensors for Sodium-cooled Fast Reactor Systems”, which was led by Westinghouse Electric Company (Westinghouse) and carried out in collaboration with Argonne National Laboratory (ANL) and University of Pittsburgh. Thermo-acoustic Power Sensors (TAPS) are self-powered, wireless sensors envisioned for measuring key parameters, such as local temperature and neutron flux, in a nuclear reactor core. This project was intended to specifically investigate their applicability to Sodium-cooled Fast Reactors (SFR). TAPS are non-invasive (wireless) and passive (self-powered) devices. The passivity derives from their ability to use conditions that “naturally” exist in a nuclear reactor, such as gamma and neutron flux, as power sources. They generate oscillating pressure waves (i.e., sound waves) which, with a frequency and amplitude dependent upon these conditions, can travel through the core and associated structures, and reach the outside of the reactor vessel where a properly designed network of receivers can detect and interpret them. These receivers require a very small amount of power which, during loss of power events, can be provided for example by harvesting gamma radiation energy, thus resulting in a monitoring system that can function both during normal operation and during loss of power events. The project aimed at TAPS development through a series of tasks which are listed and briefly discussed as follows. TASK 1 – Sensor hardware design Subtask 1a: Assessment of sensor applications to SFRs Subtask 1b: Development of sensor functional requirements Subtask 1c: Definition of sensor hardware design specifications Task description: TAPS design was informed by considerations on their application (Subtask 1a), both the ultimate one in an SFR and the actual one in the ANL testing facilities that was intended to be used in support of the project. Considerations were made to identify optimum sensor design features that optimize the sensor size, materials, and output signal, for installation inside an SFR core. These considerations led to the development of Functional Requirements (Subtask 1b) and Design Requirements (Subtask 1c). TASK 2 – Sensor Hardware Manufacture Subtask 2a: Sensor hardware construction drawing development Subtask 2b: Sensor manufacture and assembly Task description: TAPS technical drawings were developed (Subtask 2a) using the Design Requirements established under Task 1. Subsequently, in spite of some problems which ultimately caused the program to be delayed, TAPS manufacturing was completed based on drawings (Subtask 2b). TASK 3 – Development of TAPS Signal Measurement System and TAPS Testing in Water Subtask 3a: Design, assembly and testing of signal measurement system, and TAPS testing in water Subtask 3b: Signal prediction-correction methodology development Task description: An assessment was performed on the techniques that can potentially be used to detect the signals emitted by the TAPS, e.g. a fiber-optic based acoustic signal measurement system, a laser vibrometer system, or an accelerometer-based system. The most suited technology, i.e. the accelerometer-based system, was developed further, and tested in water (Subtask 3a). Moreover, efforts were made to develop the methodology required to determine the actual system temperature and neutron flux distribution using differences between the measured and predicted TAPS responses (Subtask 3b). TASK 4 – Sensor System Testing in Sodium Subtask 4a: Test plan development Subtask 4b: Design, assembly and testing in small-scale sodium facility Subtask 4c: Design, assembly and testing in large-scale sodium and structures facility Task description: Upon proper test plan development (Subtask 4a), the fabricated TAPS was planned to be tested in sodium, by using two sodium facilities at ANL having different size and different purpose. The Under Sodium Viewing (USV) small-scale facility was intended to be used to investigate the effect of sodium on the sensor and its performance (Subtask 4b). The Mechanism Engineering Test Loop (METL) large-scale facility was instead intended to be used to assess the additional effect of prototypical SFR structures, such as fuel assembly mockup or parts of the core restrain structure, on sensor performance (Subtask 4c). As discussed in Section 3.2.2.7, unexpected issues during the TAPS manufacturing process resulted in some activities being delayed, with the TAPS and USV facility developed to the point to be ready for testing in sodium, however without the possibility to actually perform such testing (including the testing in METL) due to the end of the program’s performance period. Overall, through the development and testing (in water only) of two TAPS devices (a First-Generation TAPS followed by an optimized Second-Generation TAPS), the project confirmed the capability of this technology to generate acoustic signals proportional to temperature, which can be detected through a network of accelerometers identified as the best-suited type of receivers for acoustic signal detection. Moreover, the project also developed a computational model to predict the characteristics of the acoustic signals being generated, which combines thermal analysis of the TAPS with Finite Element Modeling (FEM)-aided acoustic characterization of the system. This model was benchmarked against experimental data collected during the project and, although general agreement was obtained, some limitations of the modeling methods were identified, which require additional development. Additional testing is needed in order to assess the effect, on TAPS operation and performance, of environmental changes resulting from the transition from water to liquid sodium. Such testing, which is suggested to be performed in the future, should look specifically at 1) both the effect resulting from the different thermoacoustic behavior of sodium (relative to water) and the effects of higher temperature on TAPS performance, and 2) the performance of the sensor-receiver system when multiple TAPS are used simultaneously and prototypical reactor structures are positioned in the testing environment. The latter testing is needed to assess the effects that potential signal attenuation/ distortion phenomena, as well as potential interference between signals emitted simultaneously, have on the performance of the technology for ultimate application in a nuclear reactor.

21 SPECIFIC NUCLEAR REACTORS AND ASSOCIATED PLANTS↗

Conceptual Design of an Improved Sodium Plugging Loop

Based upon lessons learned in operating the initial sodium portion of the Sodium Plugging Phenomena Loop that itself became plugged and could not be unplugged, a set of improved design features have been identified for a new sodium loop that is less prone to inadvertent plugging. The new design features include a new sodium vessel that combines the functionalities of an expansion tank and a cold trap, increasing the loop tubing diameter/size, improving the thermal designs of the pump and flow meter, improved heater zoning, and an improved temperature distribution strategy along the loop. A new plugging loop conceptual design implementing these features has been developed.

21 SPECIFIC NUCLEAR REACTORS AND ASSOCIATED PLANTS↗

High Efficiency and Low Cost Thermal Energy Storage System

BgtL, LLC (BgtL) is focused on developing and commercializing its proprietary compact technology for processes in the energy sector. One such application is a compact high efficiency Thermal Energy Storage (TES) system that utilizes the heat of fusion through phase change between solid and liquid to store and release energy at high temperatures and incorporate state-of-the-art insulation to minimize heat dissipation. BgtL’s TES system would greatly improve the economics of existing nuclear and coal-fired power plants by allowing the power plant to store energy when power prices are low and sell power into the grid when prices are high. Compared to existing battery storage technology, BgtL’s novel thermal energy storage solution can be significantly less costly to acquire and maintain, does not have any waste or environmental emissions, and does not deteriorate over time; it can keep constant efficiency and operates cleanly and safely. BgtL’s engineers are experienced in this field and are able to design and engineer such a system to a specific power plant’s requirements. BgtL also has a strong manufacturing partner to fabricate the system such that it qualifies for an ASME code stamp. BgtL’s vision is to be the leading provider of compact systems for various applications including energy storage. BgtL requests that all technical information about the TES designs be protected as proprietary information. To honor that request, only non-proprietay summaries are included in this report.

25 ENERGY STORAGE↗

High Efficiency Heat Exchanger for High Temperature and High Pressure Applications

CompRex, LLC (CompRex) specializes in the design and manufacture of compact heat exchangers and heat exchange reactors for high temperature and high pressure applications. CompRex’s proprietary compact technology not only increases heat exchange efficiency by at least 25 % but also reduces footprint by at least a factor of ten compared to traditional shell-and-tube solutions of the same capacity and by 15 to 20 % compared to other currently available Printed Circuit Heat Exchanger (PCHE) solutions. As a result, CompRex’s solution is especially suitable for Brayton cycle supercritical carbon dioxide (sCO2) systems given its high efficiency and significantly lower capital and operating expenses. CompRex has already successfully demonstrated its technology and ability to deliver with a pilot-scale compact heat exchanger that was under contract by the Naval Nuclear Laboratory for sCO2 power cycle development. The performance tested unit met or exceeded the thermal and hydraulic specifications with measured heat transfer between 95 to 98 % of maximum heat transfer and temperature and pressure drop values all consistent with the modeled values. CompRex’s vision is to commercialize its compact technology and become the leading provider for compact heat exchangers and heat exchange reactors for various applications including Brayton cycle sCO2 systems. One of the limitations of the sCO2 Brayton power cycle is the design and manufacturing of efficient heat exchangers at extreme operating conditions. Current diffusion-bonded heat exchangers have limitations on the channel size through which the fluid travels, resulting in excessive solid material per heat exchanger volume. CompRex’s design allows for more open area and shorter fluid proximity for increased heat transfer efficiency while sustaining the structural integrity needed for the application. CompRex is developing a novel improvement to its current heat exchanger design where fluids are directed to alternating channels so that each fluid is fully surrounded by the opposing fluid. As compared to similar existing compact heat exchangers, the new design converts most secondary surface area to primary surface area, eliminating fin inefficiencies. CompRex requests that all technical information about the heat exchanger designs be protected as proprietary information. To honor that request, only non-proprietay summaries are included in this report.

47 OTHER INSTRUMENTATION↗

FY 2017 Progress Report on the Argonne Sodium Draining and Refilling Experiments

The main incentive for utilization of compact diffusion-bonded sodium-to-CO 2 heat exchangers for a Sodium-Cooled Fast Reactor (SFR) with a supercritical carbon dioxide ( s CO 2 ) Brayton cycle power converter is the potential for reduction in heat exchanger size and cost relative to traditional shell-and-tube technology. There is an incentive for the designer to reduce the width of the sodium and CO 2 channels as much as possible to realize the greatest size and cost reductions. However, there are practical limits on minimum channel size due to fundamental phenomena particular to sodium and CO 2 . One is that the channel size must be large enough to enable the rapid draining of sodium from the heat exchanger sodium channels in the event that a sodium leak is detected in an intermediate sodium heat transport system loop, in order to rapidly drain the sodium into the loop sodium storage vessel/tank and thereby limit the sodium mass released that could potentially burn if exposed to air. Information about the minimum sodium channel size can only be obtained by actually draining sodium from representative wetted stainless steel sodium channels under prototypical conditions. It is not possible to obtain such information through modeling and simulation or through simulant experiments. The ANL Sodium Draining and Refilling experiment facility has been designed and is being assembled to obtain data on the draining of sodium from compact diffusion-bonded sodium-to-carbon dioxide heat exchanger sodium channels including the mass of sodium drained versus time, the mass of sodium retained inside of the channels, and the potential for sodium to bridge the channel, freeze, and form a plug inside the channel versus the channel size. This information is needed to determine the minimum sodium channel size required to meet the requirements for sodium draining without bridges being left inside of the channels. Initial shakedown testing has been initiated using water and glass and plastic tubes before transitioning to sodium and stainless steel test sections. For the latter, the test sections will be heated to high temperature to promote rapid sodium wetting of the stainless steel prior to draining. Testing with sodium will be initiated in FY 2018.

22 GENERAL STUDIES OF NUCLEAR REACTORS↗

FY2017 Sodium-CO2 Interaction Tests

An experimental campaign was carried out in Fiscal Year 2017 in the ANL SNAKE facility that investigated the interaction between sCO 2 and sodium through injection of sCO 2 into a sodium-filled diffusion-bonded heat exchanger channel mock-up. This successful experiment demonstrated that a sustained chemical reaction between the injected CO 2 and sodium occurred at temperatures representative of the cold leg of an intermediate heat transport system for a SFR-to-sCO 2 Brayton Cycle energy conversion system. Evidence of the chemical reaction included: exothermic heatup of localized regions of the test vessel, production of carbon monoxide, consumption of CO 2 and production of solid reaction products that were observed during post-test examination. This experimental result was consistent with previous SNAKE experiments. Two of fourteen previous SNAKE tests confirmed that self-plugging of the leakage path/nozzle could occur at higher initial s odium temperatures due to chemical reactions involving CO 2 , sodium, and sodium-CO 2 reaction products. The remaining tests, including the one carried out in Fiscal Year 2017, began with low er initial temperatures and did not self-plug. A new model was developed to determine the reaction rate constant for sCO 2 injections into sodium by calculating the increase of bulk sodium temperature. This model will be developed further and used to simulate the behavior of reactor-scale sodium-to-sCO 2 heat exchanger failures.

38 RADIATION CHEMISTRY, RADIOCHEMISTRY, AND NUCLEA↗

Irradiation Testing Vehicles for Fast Reactors from Open Test Assemblies to Closed Loops

A review of irradiation testing vehicle approaches and designs that have been incorporated into past Sodium-Cooled Fast Reactors (SFRs) or envisioned for incorporation has been carried out. The objective is to understand the essential features of the approaches and designs so that they can inform test vehicle designs for a future U.S. Fast Test Reactor. Fast test reactor designs examined include EBR-II, FFTF, JOYO, BOR-60, PHÉNIX, JHR, and MBIR. Previous designers exhibited great ingenuity in overcoming design and operational challenges especially when the original reactor plant’s mission changed to an irradiation testing mission as in the EBRII reactor plant. The various irradiation testing vehicles can be categorized as: Uninstrumented open assemblies that fit into core locations; Instrumented open test assemblies that fit into special core locations; Self-contained closed loops; and External closed loops. A special emphasis is devoted to closed loops as they are regarded as a very desirable feature of a future U.S. Fast Test Reactor. Closed loops are an important technology for irradiation of fuels and materials in separate controlled environments. The impact of closed loops on the design of fast reactors is also discussed in this report.

22 GENERAL STUDIES OF NUCLEAR REACTORS↗

FY 2016 Progress Report on the ANL Sodium Draining and Refilling Experiments

The main incentive for utilization of compact diffusion-bonded sodium-to-CO 2 heat exchangers for a Sodium-Cooled Fast Reactor (SFR) with a supercritical carbon dioxide (sCO 2 ) Brayton cycle power converter is the potential for reduction in heat exchanger size and cost relative to traditional shell-and-tube technology. There is an incentive for the designer to reduce the width of the sodium and CO 2 channels as much as possible to realize the greatest size and cost reductions. However, there are practical limits on minimum channel size due to fundamental phenomena particular to sodium and CO 2 . One is that the channel size must be large enough to enable the rapid draining of sodium from the heat exchanger sodium channels in the event that a sodium leak is detected in an intermediate sodium heat transport system loop, in order to rapidly drain the sodium into the loop sodium storage vessel/tank and thereby limit the sodium mass released that could potentially burn if exposed to air. Information about the minimum sodium channel size can only be obtained by actually draining sodium from representative stainless steel sodium channels under prototypical conditions. It is not possible to obtain such information through modeling and simulation or through simulant experiments. The ANL Sodium Draining and Refilling experiment facility has been designed and is being assembled to obtain data on the draining of sodium from compact diffusion bonded sodium-to-carbon dioxide heat exchanger sodium channels including the mass of sodium drained versus time, the mass of sodium retained inside of the channels, and the potential for sodium to bridge the channel, freeze, and form a plug inside the channel versus the channel size. This information is needed to determine the minimum sodium channel size required to meet the requirements for sodium draining without bridges being left inside of the channels. Initial shakedown testing has been initiated using water and glass tubes before transitioning to sodium and stainless steel test sections. For the latter, the test sections will be heated to promote rapid sodium wetting of the stainless steel prior to draining. Testing with sodium will be initiated in FY 2017.

21 SPECIFIC NUCLEAR REACTORS AND ASSOCIATED PLANTS↗

Modeling and Validation of Sodium Plugging for Heat Exchangers in Sodium-cooled Fast Reactor Systems

The project “Modeling and Validation of Sodium Plugging for Heat Exchangers in Sodium-cooled Fast Reactor Systems” was conducted jointly by Westinghouse Electric Company (Westinghouse) and Argonne National Laboratory (ANL), over the period October 1, 2013- March 31, 2016. The project’s motivation was the need to provide designers of Sodium Fast Reactors (SFRs) with a validated, state-of-the-art computational tool for the prediction of sodium oxide (Na 2 O) deposition in small-diameter sodium heat exchanger (HX) channels, such as those in the diffusion bonded HXs proposed for SFRs coupled with a supercritical CO 2 (sCO 2 ) Brayton cycle power conversion system. In SFRs, Na 2 O deposition can potentially occur following accidental air ingress in the intermediate heat transport system (IHTS) sodium and simultaneous failure of the IHTS sodium cold trap. In this scenario, oxygen can travel through the IHTS loop and reach the coldest regions, represented by the cold end of the sodium channels of the HXs, where Na 2 O precipitation may initiate and continue. In addition to deteriorating HX heat transfer and pressure drop performance, Na 2 O deposition can lead to channel plugging especially when the size of the sodium channels is small, which is the case for diffusion bonded HXs whose sodium channel hydraulic diameter is generally below 5 mm. Sodium oxide melts at a high temperature well above the sodium melting temperature such that removal of a solid plug such as through dissolution by pure sodium could take a lengthy time. The Sodium Plugging Phenomena Loop (SPPL) was developed at ANL, prior to this project, for investigating Na 2 O deposition phenomena within sodium channels that are prototypical of the diffusion bonded HX channels envisioned for SFR-sCO 2 systems. In this project, a Computational Fluid Dynamic (CFD) model capable of simulating the thermal-hydraulics of the SPPL test section and provided with Na 2 O deposition prediction capabilities, was developed. This state-of-the-art computational tool incorporates a first-principles Na 2 O deposition model developed by ANL, and combines it with predictive capabilities for the spatial and temporal variation of temperature, velocity, dissolved oxygen concentration, and wall temperature under flowing sodium conditions. The CFD model was validated under no-deposition conditions using experimental data collected with the SPPL, demonstrating the model’s capability to predict the thermal-hydraulics of the SPPL test section within the measurement uncertainty characterizing the SPPL instrumentation. The model’s deposition prediction capability was not, however, validated as the SPPL could not be operated under plugging conditions during the project, resulting in the lack of deposition data with adequate pedigree for a CFD model validation. Two novel diagnostic techniques to detect and characterize Na 2 O deposits, i.e. Ultrasonic Time Domain Reflectometry (UTDR) and Potential Drop (PD) techniques, were developed to ultimately assist in the validation effort under plugging conditions, which can be performed once the SPPL becomes operational. This development effort consisted first in demonstrating, analytically and/or computationally, the capability of these techniques to diagnose Na 2 O deposits inside of small channels (particularly the deposit’s thickness), and subsequently in the fabrication and testing of prototypical UTDR and PD instrumentation. The testing, performed on mockups of the SPPL test section, demonstrated the capability of these techniques to detect and characterize material discontinuities like those induced by sodium oxide deposition on stainless steel channel walls. Because of the mentioned impossibility to run the SPPL in a plugging mode, the developed instrumentation could not be tested in-situ, i.e. at the SPPL while deposits are being formed inside of the SPPL test section. Recommended future work includes a possible enhancement in the CFD modeling technique and installation of the developed UTDR and PD instrumentation on the test section, followed by plugging tests to be conducted with the SPPL. The installation of the UTDR and PD diagnostic instrumentation on the SPPL test section will allow collection of Na 2 O deposition data after the onset of deposition to nearly complete channel plugging, which can ultimately be used for the validation of the CFD model.

21 SPECIFIC NUCLEAR REACTORS AND ASSOCIATED PLANTS↗

Transient Load Following and Control Analysis of Advanced S-CO2 Power Conversion with Dry Air Cooling

Supercritical carbon dioxide (S-CO2) Brayton cycles are under development as advanced energy converters for advanced nuclear reactors, especially the Sodium-Cooled Fast Reactor (SFR). The use of dry air cooling for direct heat rejection to the atmosphere ultimate heat sink is increasingly becoming a requirement in many regions due to restrictions on water use. The transient load following and control behavior of an SFR with an S-CO2 cycle power converter utilizing dry air cooling have been investigated. With extension and adjustment of the previously existing control strategy for direct water cooling, S-CO2 cycle power converters can also be used for load following operation in regions where dry air cooling is a requirement

Moisseytsev, Anton↗