Search NASA⌕ Search

Engineering topics

Stark, David James

Publications and source records attributed to Stark, David James.

At least 19 records

Beryllium–tungsten graded density inner shells in double shell capsules for improved hydrodynamic stability

The outer surface of the high-Z inner shell in the double shell configuration of inertial confinement fusion experiments experiences Rayleigh–Taylor instability growth during the implosion process due to inverted density and pressure gradients between a highly compressed foam interstitial layer and the accelerating dense inner shell. Graded density layers have long been known to reduce instability growth rates. In this study, we employ high-fidelity radiation hydrodynamic simulations to demonstrate this improved stability when grading beryllium into tungsten. We first characterize the response to L-band preheat of these layers using a newly calibrated radiation drive. While graded layer capsules suffer reduced performance (here, measured as DD neutron yield from a CD foam fuel) in 1D simulations due to reduced kinetic energy coupling and reduced fuel compression, they suffer less of a performance drop when 2D instabilities are accounted for. With the improved stability of graded layers, we explore the performance of capsules with larger fuel radii and thinner shells as a preliminary study to find new designs in which graded layers produce the highest yields.

70 PLASMA PHYSICS AND FUSION TECHNOLOGY↗

Outer shell symmetry for double shell capsules with aluminum ablators

Double shell targets are a promising potential avenue to obtain robust neutron yield at current laser facilities. Similar to single shell designs, double shells require the symmetric implosion of an ablator in order to uniformly compress and heat a fuel volume, with the goal of achieving thermonuclear burn. Significant differences between double and single shells include the usage of an aluminum ablator as well as a reverse ramp laser pulse. In addition, double shells require a different convergence than single shells for fuel ignition. Numerical implosion studies at various energies with comparisons to experimental outcomes are required to gain confidence that simulations can capture the ablator shape from subscale to full scale. The current work builds on previous implosion experiments conducted at 1-MJ laser energy to con firm achieved ablator symmetry at 1.25 and 1.5 MJ. Average ablator P2 and P4 shapes measured in these experiments are within 5% of the simulated shape, which merits the platforms for further experimental studies.

70 PLASMA PHYSICS AND FUSION TECHNOLOGY↗

Bayesian batch optimization for molybdenum versus tungsten inertial confinement fusion double shell target design

Access to reliable, clean energy sources is a major concern for national security. Much research is focused on the “grand challenge” of producing energy via controlled fusion reactions in a laboratory setting. For fusion experiments, specifically inertial confinement fusion (ICF), to produce sufficient energy, the fusion reactions in the ICF fuel need to become self-sustaining and burn deuterium-tritium (DT) fuel efficiently. The recent record-breaking NIF ignition shot was able to achieve this goal as well as produce more energy than used to drive the experiment. This achievement brings self-sustaining fusion-based power systems closer than ever before, capable of providing humans with access to secure, renewable energy. In order to further progress toward the actualization of such power systems, more ICF experiments need to be conducted at large laser facilities such as the United States's National Ignition Facility (NIF) or France's Laser Mega-Joule. The high cost per shot and limited number of shots that are possible per year make it prohibitive to perform large numbers of experiments. As such, experimental design relies heavily on complex predictive physics simulations for high-fidelity “preshot” analysis. These multidimensional, multi-physics, high-fidelity simulations have to account for a variety of input parameters as well as modeling the extreme conditions (pressures and densities) present at ignition. Such simulations (especially in 3D) can become computationally prohibitive to turn around for each ICF experiment. In this work, we explore using Bayesian optimization with Gaussian processes (GPs) to find optimal designs for ICF double shell targets, while keeping computational costs to manageable levels. These double shell targets have an inner shell that grades from beryllium on the outer surface to the higher Z material molybdenum, as opposed to the nominally used tungsten, on the inside in order to trade off between the high performance associated with high density inner shells and capsule stability. We describe our results for “capsule-only” xRAGE simulations to study the physics between different capsule designs, inner shell materials, and potential for future experiments.

70 PLASMA PHYSICS AND FUSION TECHNOLOGY↗

Los Alamos National Laboratory Double Shell Program Target Development

The Double Shell Program at Los Alamos National Laboratory is studying an alternative platform for achieving robust alpha-particle heating at the National Ignition Facility. Double shells benefit from having a low convergence ratio and lower predicted temperature for achieving volume ignition. The joint required to assemble a double shell has an imperfection in the outer shell that seeds instabilities that can greatly impact the inner capsule’s implosion at bang time. Furthermore, different variations of the shape and placement of the joint were implemented with improvements in the quality of the machining leading to measurable improvements in yield. High-Z coatings on the outer joint mitigated the impact of the 1- to 2-μm gap sometimes found in double shell assemblies.

70 PLASMA PHYSICS AND FUSION TECHNOLOGY↗

Mechanisms of shape transfer and preheating in indirect-drive double shell collisions

Implosions of Hohlraum-driven double shell targets as an alternative inertial confinement fusion concept are underway at the National Ignition Facility. The double shell system relies on a series of energy transfer processes starting from thermal x-ray absorption by the outer shell, followed by collisional transfer of kinetic energy to a heavy metal inner shell, and finally, conversion to the internal energy of the deuterium-tritium fuel. During each of these energy transfer stages, low-mode asymmetries can act to reduce the ideal transfer efficiency degrading double shell performance. Mechanisms, such as hard x-ray preheat from the Hohlraum, not only decrease the efficiency of kinetic energy transfer but may also be a source of low-mode asymmetry. In this article, we evaluate the shape transfer processes through the time of shell collision using two-dimensional integrated Hohlraum and capsule computations. We find that the dominant mode of the shape transfer is well described using a “radial impulse” model from the shape of the foam pressure reservoir. To evaluate the importance of preheat on inner shell shape, we also report on first measurements of Au L-shell preheat asymmetry in a double shell with a tungsten pusher. These measurements showed a 65% higher preheat velocity at the pole of the capsule relative to the equator. We also found that the experiments provided rigorous constraints by which to test the Hohlraum model settings that impact the amount and symmetry of Au L-shell preheat via the plasma conditions inside the outer cone Au bubble.

70 PLASMA PHYSICS AND FUSION TECHNOLOGY↗

Coupling 1D xRAGE simulations with machine learning for graded inner shell design optimization in double shell capsules

Advances in machine learning provide the ability to leverage data from expensive simulations of high-energy-density experiments to significantly cut down on computational time and costs associated with the search for optimal target designs. This study presents an application of cutting-edge Bayesian optimization methods to the one-dimensional (1D) design optimization of double shell graded layer targets for inertial confinement fusion experiments. This investigation attempts to reduce hydrodynamic instabilities while retaining high yields for future NIF experiments. Machine learning methods can use predictive physics simulations to identify graded layer designs from within the vast design space that demonstrate high predicted performance, including novel designs with high uncertainty in performance that may hold unexpected promise. By applying machine learning tools to the simulation design, we map the trade-off between 1D yield and instability, specifically isolating parameter ranges, which maintain high performance while showing significantly improved Rayleigh–Taylor stability over the point design. Furthermore, the groundwork laid in this study will be a useful design tool for future NIF experiments with graded layer targets.

70 PLASMA PHYSICS AND FUSION TECHNOLOGY↗

Gravitomagnetic vorticity generation in black hole accretion discs: a potential spatial constraint on plasma flow stability

We calculate the vorticity generation rate in the accretion disc near a slowly rotating black hole in the low-velocity, weak-field limit of general relativity. Specifically, we find that the frame-dragging effect due to the black hole’s rotation – manifested through the gravitomagnetic field – can generate vorticity in a moving plasma in the accretion disc. The mechanism remains operational as long as the accretion disc has non-negligible vertical height and is independent of the exact thermodynamical profile of the disc. The enstrophy density generation rate, as a measure of turbulence and dissipation, is presented, which indicates that the frame-dragging effect can disrupt the stability of the disc away from the z = 0 plane.

79 ASTRONOMY AND ASTROPHYSICS↗

Symmetry requirements for double shell capsules with aluminum ablators

Double shell targets present a promising avenue to obtain robust neutron yield on current laser facilities. The nature of the target, like current single shell designs, requires a symmetric implosion of an outer ablator to obtain a symmetric fuel volume that will lead to alpha heating and thermonuclear burn. Due to using aluminum as an ablator material and requiring different convergence than single shell symmetry studies at various energies are required. This paper moves forward from previous experiments conducted at 1MJ to show implosion symmetry at 1.25 and 1.5MJ. Symmetry in these experiments is sufficient to merit experiments using double shells to study the platform further. Additional studies are carried out on the outer shell symmetry impacts, showing that mitigating mode growth on the outer ablator is of great importance.

73 NUCLEAR PHYSICS AND RADIATION PHYSICS↗

Detrimental effects and mitigation of the joint feature in double shell implosion simulations

Double shell capsules provide an attractive option in inertial confinement fusion experiments due to their potential for achieving a low-convergence, robust burn. However, these designs suffer from symmetry degradation and accompanying reduced fuel confinement due to the currently necessary joint between the two hemispheres of the outer shell. Here, the gap widens as a result of the excess ablation pressure produced by x rays that penetrate the joint during the drive phase, and this perturbation grows and imprints onto the inner shell during the collision. xRAGE Eulerian radiation-hydrodynamic simulations predict significant reductions in deuterium–tritium fusion yields compared to joint-less simulations when the depth of the outer joint is increased, whereas the performance is less sensitive to the depth of the inner gap. Here we examine the technique of plating the insides of the outer gap with a high-Z material to mitigate the impact of this feature. Gold-plating in quantities comparable to or exceeding the “missing” outer shell mass shows promise toward restoring both implosion symmetry and yield closer to the joint-less levels, and synthetic diagnostics suggest that high-energy x-ray radiographs can capture this shape retention of the inner and outer shells in experiments.

70 PLASMA PHYSICS AND FUSION TECHNOLOGY↗

Constraining computational modeling of indirect drive double shell capsule implosions using experiments

Double shell capsule implosions are an alternative approach to achieving alpha heating on the National Ignition Facility. Current machining techniques construct the outer shell as two hemispheres that are glued together, and the deuterium and tritium (DT) liquid inside the inner shell will be injected by a fill tube. These features introduce asymmetries and jetting that may disrupt the confinement of the DT fuel if not carefully controlled. Simulations indicate that in order to achieve high yields in the laboratory, these features as well as susceptibility to the Rayleigh–Taylor instability (RTI) must be mitigated. Furthermore, due to uncertainties in computational models and the expense of using the best physics models at adequate resolution in three dimensions, our computational modeling must be constrained by experiments. We report on the results of recent hydrogrowth radiography and dual-axis keyhole experiments with double shell targets that have been used to evaluate our modeling of the outer shell joint as well as the impacts of high-energy x-ray preheat that strongly impacts RTI growth. Our simulations show good agreement with the experimental data and inform several important modeling choices.

70 PLASMA PHYSICS AND FUSION TECHNOLOGY↗

Birefringence in thermally anisotropic relativistic plasmas and its impact on laser–plasma interactions

One of the paradigm-shifting phenomena triggered in laser–plasma interactions at relativistic intensities is the so-called relativistic transparency. As the electrons become heated by the laser to relativistic energies, the plasma becomes transparent to the laser light even though the plasma density is sufficiently high to reflect the laser pulse in the non-relativistic case. This paper highlights the impact that relativistic transparency can have on laser-matter interactions by focusing on a collective phenomenon that is associated with the onset of relativistic transparency: plasma birefringence in thermally anisotropic relativistic plasmas. Here, the optical properties of such a system become dependent on the polarization of light, and this can serve as the basis for plasma-based optical devices or novel diagnostic capabilities.

70 PLASMA PHYSICS AND FUSION TECHNOLOGY↗

Laser-ion acceleration using mixed compositions: Tailoring the target for each species

Particle-in-cell simulations of laser- ion acceleration demonstrate marked discrepancies in the acceleration experienced by the different ion species in complex target compositions, especially when the target becomes relativistically transparent to the pulse during irradiation. Beginning with proton contaminants in a carbon target, we show how the higher charge-to-mass ratio of the protons results in species stratification and late-time suppression of the carbon acceleration. The target normal sheath acceleration (TNSA) primarily experienced by the protons can be exploited to mitigate this tamping by using a shaped rear surface of the target, leaving the break-out afterburner-driven carbons to accelerate close to the laser axis and then experience less tamping during a late-time TNSA phase. Here, we then explore preferentially accelerating the lighter species in a mixed composition target, particularly focusing on deuteron beam applications. We examine three different target compositions with the same areal electron density, CD 2 , CH 2 , and 7 LiD, and propose an alternative shaping of the rear surface of 7 LiD to increase the number of high-energy deuterons in the beam.

70 PLASMA PHYSICS AND FUSION TECHNOLOGY↗

Saturation of cross-beam energy transfer for multispeckled laser beams involving both ion and electron dynamics

The nonlinear saturation of crossed-beam energy transfer (CBET) for multispeckled laser beams crossing at arbitrary angles is examined using vector particle-in-cell simulations. CBET is found to saturate on fast (~10s of picosecond) time scales involving ion trapping and excitation of oblique forward stimulated Raman scattering (FSRS). Ion trapping reduces wave damping and speckle interaction increases wave coherence length, together enhancing energy transfer; ion acoustic wave (IAW) breakup in the direction transverse to the wavenumber increases wave damping and contributes to CBET saturation. Here, the seed beam can become unstable to oblique FSRS, which leads to beam deflection at a large angle and a frequency downshift (by the plasma frequency).

70 PLASMA PHYSICS AND FUSION TECHNOLOGY↗

Effects of dimensionality on kinetic simulations of laser-ion acceleration in the transparency regime

A particle-in-cell study of laser-ion acceleration mechanisms in the transparency regime illustrates how two-dimensional (2D) S and P simulations (laser polarization in and out of the simulation plane, respectively) capture different physics characterizing these systems, visible in their entirety in often cost-prohibitive three-dimensional (3D) simulations. The electron momentum anisotropy induced in the target by the laser pulse is dramatically different in the two 2D cases, manifested in differences in target expansion timescales, electric field strengths, and density thresholds for the onset of relativistically induced transparency. In particular, 2D-P simulations exhibit dramatically greater electron heating in the simulation plane, whereas 2D-S ones show a much more isotropic energy distribution, similar to 3D. An ion trajectory analysis allows one to isolate the fields responsible for ion acceleration and to characterize the acceleration regimes in time and space. The artificial longitudinal electron heating in 2D-P exaggerates the effectiveness of target-normal sheath acceleration into its dominant acceleration mechanism throughout the laser-plasma interaction, whereas 2D-S and 3D both have sizable populations accelerated preferentially during transparency.

70 PLASMA PHYSICS AND FUSION TECHNOLOGY↗

Final Report on Institutional Computing Project s15_hilaserion, “Kinetic Modeling of Next-Generation High-Energy, High-Intensity Laser-Ion Accelerators as an Enabling Capability”

This proposal sought of order 1M core-hours of Institutional Computing time intended to enable computing by a new LANL Postdoc (David Stark) working under LDRD ER project 20160472ER (PI: Lin Yin) on laser-ion acceleration. The project was “off-cycle,” initiating in June of 2016 with a postdoc hire.

43 PARTICLE ACCELERATORS↗