Search NASA⌕ Search

Engineering topics

Terrani, K. A.

Publications and source records attributed to Terrani, K. A..

At least 19 records

A correlation-based approach for evaluating mechanical properties of nuclear fuel cladding tubes

The present work offers and evaluates a correlation-based approach to determine the tensile properties of nuclear fuel cladding tubes. A set of model materials with known properties (i.e., austenitic and ferritic steels, fcc- and hcp-alloys) were tested to build a correlation between conventional tensile tests and ring (hoop) and tube (axial) tests. It was shown that close-to-linear relationships exist for the basic mechanical properties (i.e., yield and ultimate stress, uniform and total elongation) between the uniaxial tensile test data and the ring and tube test data. Using the ring and tube specimen geometries, the feasibility of the approach was demonstrated via manufacturing and testing specimens from irradiated Zr and FeCrAl nuclear fuel cladding tubes. Limitations caused by specific deformation mechanisms (e.g., high ductility of 304L steel) were discussed in detail. The approach can be extended to other tubular products with different geometry and dimensions.

36 MATERIALS SCIENCE↗

Conceptual Design of the Transformational Challenge Reactor

The Transformational Challenge Reactor is a 3-MW(thermal) helium-cooled experimental nuclear reactor designed using an additive manufacturing–informed agile design process. This design process leverages rapid prototyping and advanced materials from emerging additive manufacturing technologies, key characteristics that enable rapid design maturation. The resulting core design incorporates a blend of advanced reactor technologies into an intermediate-spectrum microreactor, including conventionally manufactured tristructural isotropic (TRISO) fuel particles in an advanced manufactured SiC fuel element and a solid yttrium hydride moderator encapsulated in steel. Matured during the design effort, these technologies are incorporated with additively manufactured steel support and fluidic structures to form a 75-cm-outer-diameter cylindrical active core region. Below and above the active core region are axial SiC reflectors, which are housed inside the reactor pressure vessel. The reactor is controlled with an annular shroud actuated external to the pressure vessel in the gap between the pressure vessel and a steel radial reflector. A safety rod is at the center of the core to shut down the reactor when necessary. Helium pressurized at 5 MPa is forced into the pressure vessel below the core and around the core to the top plenum before it is forced down through the axial reflectors and the active core region. The primary pressurized helium loop is operated up to 500°C and includes the pressure vessel, the circulator, and the hot side of a helium-to-air heat exchanger. The secondary loop rejects all heat from the primary loop to ambient air through a heat exchanger. A vented temporary confinement building contains the entire primary loop, with penetrations for a stack, cooling, and the secondary ambient air loop. Finally, this is the first advanced nuclear microreactor designed using additive manufacturing technologies, demonstrating their applicability in an accelerated advanced design process.

21 SPECIFIC NUCLEAR REACTORS AND ASSOCIATED PLANTS↗

Mechanical behavior of additively manufactured and wrought 316L stainless steels before and after neutron irradiation

Fabrication of nuclear reactor components using additive manufacturing (AM) methods is now a practical option since the AM technologies have advanced to allow for building of complex parts with high quality materials. To assess the mechanical performance of printed components in reactor-relevant conditions and to build a property database for the AM 316L stainless steel (SS), mechanical testing and characterization were performed before and after neutron irradiation. In this work, miniature tensile specimens were irradiated at the High Flux Isotope Reactor (HFIR) to 0.2 and 2 displacements per atom (dpa) at 300 and 600°C. The AM 316L SS was tested in the as-built, stress-relieved, and solution-annealed conditions, and the wrought (WT) 316L SS in solution-annealed condition as a reference alloy. The baseline test result showed that the AM 316L SS, regardless of the post-build heat treatment, had higher strength than the WT 316L SS, but similar ductility. Post-irradiation tensile testing was conducted at RT, 300°C, and 500°C for selected irradiation conditions. Neutron irradiation induced significant changes in the mechanical behavior of the AM stainless steels, including both hardening and softening. Although the as-built 316L steel after 300°C irradiation showed necking just after yielding, the overall property changes of the as-printed alloy became less significant after 600°C irradiation. Irradiation-induced ductilization was also observed after the higher temperature irradiation. In general, the strength change was smaller in the relatively stronger as-built and stress-relieved AM SSs than in the solution-annealed AM and WT SSs. These relatively lower strength 316L SSs overall retained higher ductility in the irradiation conditions tested, but the stronger 316L SSs demonstrated a similar level of ductility after the higher temperature (600°C) irradiation. It is a positive assessment for the AM 316L materials that no embrittlement was observed within the test and irradiation conditions of the experiment.

36 MATERIALS SCIENCE↗

Transformational Challenge Reactor preconceptual core design studies

In the nuclear industry, a manufacturing-informed design approach has the potential to yield the most benefit from advanced manufacturing. By leveraging advanced materials, data science, and rapid testing and deployment, manufacturing-informed design can drive down costs and development times, ultimately improving future commercial viability. This approach is being demonstrated in the US Department of Energy Office of Nuclear Energy (DOE-NE) Transformational Challenge Reactor (TCR) program. Preconceptual design activities for TCR have been focused on analyzing and maturing four reactor core design concepts: two fast-spectrum and two thermal-spectrum systems. Furthermore, the designs were iteratively modified and analyzed, and subcomponents were manufactured in parallel over weeks instead of months or years. To meet key program initiatives (e.g., timeline and material use), several constraints—including fissile material availability, component availability, materials compatibility, and additive manufacturing capabilities—were factored into the design effort, yielding small cores less than one cubic meter in volume with near-term viability. Additionally, the TCR program has made significant progress on development of advanced moderator materials such as yttrium hydride, advancing the feasibility of gas-cooled thermal spectrum systems using less than 250 kg of high-assay low enriched uranium (HALEU) and occupying less than 1 m3. Each of the two resulting thermal designs uses a different fuel form: traditional UO2 ceramic fuel and tristructural isotropic (advanced TRISO) fuel particles embedded inside a SiC matrix. Core neutronics and thermal performance for these systems were assessed and summarized. Evaluation of the performance metrics for these two moderated designs has yielded the downselected TCR design: a TRISO-fueled and yttrium hydride moderated gas-cooled reactor.

22 GENERAL STUDIES OF NUCLEAR REACTORS↗

Mechanical Properties and Deformation Behavior of Additively Manufactured 316L Stainless Steel (FY2020)

The Transformational Challenge Reactor (TCR) program plans to build most of the TCR core components through additive manufacturing (AM) processes. These processes include laser powder bed fusion (LPBF) for the metallic (316L) components and the newly developed combined process of binderjet printing and chemical vapor infiltration (CVI) for the SiC fuel matrix. Mechanical testing and characterization tasks have been carried out since the beginning of the TCR program to (1) build a property database for the AM materials that will be used in TCR core and (2) to assess the materials’ performance in TCR-relevant conditions. This document reports the outcome of the testing and characterization efforts for the fiscal year with a focus on the mechanical performance data of AM 316L stainless steel (SS). Baseline tensile testing over a wide temperature range of room temperature–600 °C was completed for the AM 316L alloy in as-built, stress-relieved, and solution-annealed conditions. The as-built 316L showed the highest strength, and the alloy after the post-build treatments showed reduced strengths in the low-strain range. However, the strength differences among the AM materials became insignificant in the later part of deformation. Furthermore, regardless of post-build processing, the AM 316L SS showed higher strength and comparable ductility when compared with wrought 316L SS. Thermal creep testing and microstructural evolution during creep deformation were also performed under selected conditions. It was found that the AM 316L steel showed the best creep resistance in the stress-relieved condition. In-situ tensile tests were performed using scanning electron microscopy and 1-ID beamline at the Advanced Photon Source to elucidate the deformation and fracture behavior of AM 316L and the evolution of crystalline stress, dislocations, and pore distribution. Using these in-situ testing data, an in-depth analysis of the roles of microstructural features in deformation and fracture processes is presented herein. The final section of the document introduces ongoing and future activities for materials testing and characterization, including irradiation effect studies and ball punch testing on AM 316L and AM IN718 alloys.

21 SPECIFIC NUCLEAR REACTORS AND ASSOCIATED PLANTS↗

Mechanical and Thermophysical Properties of 3D-Printed SiC-FY20

In the Transformational Challenge Reactor (TCR), the fuel blocks consist of an additively-manufactured silicon carbide (SiC) matrix and uranium nitride tristructural isotropic (UN TRISO) fuel particles, which are stacked to form fuel columns. The SiC matrix is manufactured using binderjet 3D printing followed by loading the TRISO fuel particles and the chemical vapor infiltration (CVI) process. Because the fuel matrix is a primary component of the TCR core and its response to mechanical and thermal loads during operation is one of the most influential factors on the integrity of TCR core, testing and evaluation have focused on producing mechanical and thermophysical properties data for the binderjet/CVI SiC. Mechanical and thermophysical properties were measured from various types of specimens printed for two or three orientations, which included equibiaxial flexural failure strength, elastic constants, thermal diffusivity and conductivity, density, and the coefficient of thermal expansion. Flexural failure strength datasets showed similar Weibull distributions regardless of sample variants including different orientations. The mean failure strengths of the 3D-printed SiC variants were in the range of 286–306 MPa, which are 22–27% lower than that of the CVD SiC. Thermophysical test results showed that specific heat and thermal expansion are not sensitive to the build directions of SiC samples, while thermal diffusivity is highly dependent on the build direction and can be correlated to the anisotropic character of the 3D-printed SiC. This report also includes discussions on the uniaxial tensile properties of the as-printed SiC before CVI and on ongoing efforts for irradiation effects studies.

21 SPECIFIC NUCLEAR REACTORS AND ASSOCIATED PLANTS↗

In-pile thermal conductivity of uranium dioxide at low burnup

In-pile thermal conductivity of uranium dioxide (UO 2 ) was investigated at low burnup levels (<0.2 kWd/kg-UO 2 ) to elucidate the concurrent effects of the fission damage and the thermal recovery. In-pile experiments were performed in the Halden reactor. The fuel centerline and the cladding temperatures were measured during the experiments, and the power level of specially designed test rodlets were also monitored. The uncertainty of the pellet-cladding gap's thermal resistivity was minimized with a liquid-metal bond, while comparable measurements were made in reference test rodlets without liquid metal bonding. The experimental data were analyzed using the inverse heat transfer approach. The heat conduction equation was solved by applying the measured temperature of the cladding as a boundary condition, and the calculated fuel centerline temperature was compared with the measured fuel centerline temperature to determine the relative matrix resistivity. Results showed that the in-pile matrix resistivity, the phonon-lattice interaction terms of the thermal conductivity, was ~1.5–2.5 times higher than its unirradiated value due to fission-induced damage. Finally, the in-pile annealing caused a significant recovery of the matrix resistivity, and the amount of recovery increased from ~20 to ~33%, while the annealing temperature increased from 700 to 1,000 °C.

11 NUCLEAR FUEL CYCLE AND FUEL MATERIALS↗

Influence of hot isostatic pressing on the performance of aluminum alloy fabricated by ultrasonic additive manufacturing

Ultrasonic additive manufacturing (UAM) is a solid-state manufacturing technique employing principles of ultrasonic welding coupled with mechanized tape layering to fabricate fully functional parts. However, UAM-fabricated parts often exhibit a reduction in strength when loaded normal to the welding interfaces (Z-direction). Here, the effect of hot isostatic pressing (HIP) on UAM builds of aluminum alloy was explored. Tensile testing and microstructure characterization were conducted; it was established that HIP eliminated the brittle Z-direction fracture and improved the strength and ductility of the Z-direction specimens. HIP eliminated voids and produced recrystallized structure; however, welding interfaces survived the HIP treatment.

36 MATERIALS SCIENCE↗

Fuel performance modeling of FeCrAl cladding failure during loss of coolant conditions

Accident tolerant materials are defined as those that provide significantly increased response time in the event of an accident while providing similar or improved performance as the conventional UO2/Zircaloy-4 fuel rods during normal operation. One avenue for materials to demonstrate enhanced accident tolerance is to have improved reaction (e.g., oxidation) kinetics with steam, resulting in slower hydrogen (or other combustible gases) generation rate, while maintaining acceptable thermo-mechanical properties, fuel-clad interactions, and fission product behavior. Due to their improved reaction kinetics with steam compared to Zircaloy-4, iron-chromium-aluminum (FeCrAl) alloys are being considered as an accident tolerant cladding material. In order to determine whether FeCrAl alloys are indeed accident tolerant materials, comparisons between conventional zirconium-based claddings under accident conditions is required. To this end, we have developed a burst (failure) criterion for FeCrAl using existing experimental data for first-generation alloys. This model was incorporated into the BISON fuel performance code to perform comparative studies with Zircaloy-4 cladding tubes under non-oxidizing and oxidizing LOCA conditions. The separate effects LOCA conditions considered were adopted from the PUZRY and REBEKA test series. Due to the fact that FeCrAl alloys have a larger thermal absorption cross-section and higher stiffness than Zircaloy-4, cladding thickness will be smaller for FeCrAl than for Zircaloy-4. Three different cladding thicknesses were analyzed in this work. The results indicate that for both non-oxidizing (PUZRY) and oxidizing (REBEKA) LOCA conditions, FeCrAl has similar burst behavior (i.e., time to burst and pressure at burst) as Zircaloy-4. It should be noticed that this study used data for first-generation FeCrAl alloys to develop the burst criterion. Although no burst data?currently exists for C35M (a second-generation FeCrAl alloy under development at Oak Ridge National Laboratory), improved burst behavior is anticipated. As burst data for C35M becomes available the burst criterion will be updated and the simulations revisited to determine the accident tolerance of second-generation FeCrAl alloys.

11 NUCLEAR FUEL CYCLE AND FUEL MATERIALS↗

RIA simulation tests using driver tube for ATF cladding

Pellet-cladding mechanical interaction (PCMI) is a potential failure mechanism for accident-tolerant fuel (ATF) cladding candidates during a reactivity-initiated accident (RIA). This report summarizes Fiscal Year (FY) 2017 research activities that were undertaken to evaluate the PCMI-like hoop-strain-driven mechanical response of ATF cladding candidates. To achieve various RIA-like conditions, a modified-burst test (MBT) device was developed to produce different mechanical pulses. The calibration of the MBT instrument was accomplished by performing mechanical tests on unirradiated Generation-I iron-chromium-aluminum (FeCrAl) alloy samples. Shakedown tests were also conducted in both FY 2016 and FY 2017 using unirradiated hydrided ZIRLO™ tube samples. This milestone report focuses on testing of ATF materials, but the benchmark tests with hydrided ZIRLO™ tube samples are documented in a recent journal article.a For the calibration and benchmark tests, the hoop strain was monitored using strain gauges attached to the sample surface in the hoop direction. A novel digital image correlation (DIC) system composed of a single high-speed camera and an array of six mirrors was developed for the MBT instrument to better resolve the failure behavior of samples and to provide useful data for validation of high-fidelity modeling and simulation tools. The DIC system enable a 360° view of a sample’s outer surface. This feature was added to the instrument to determine the precise failure location on a sample’s surface for strain predictions. The DIC system was tested on several silicon carbide fiber/silicon carbide matrix (SiC/SiC) composite tube samples at various pressurization rates of the driver tube (which correspond to the strain rates for the samples). The hoop strains for various loading conditions were determined for the SiC/SiC composite tube samples. Future work is planned to enhance understanding of the failure behavior of the ATF cladding candidates of age-hardened FeCrAl alloys and SiC/SiC composites in detail during RIA conditions informed by the computational studies performed under the US Department of Energy Office of Nuclear Energy Advanced Fuels Campaign. The testing instrument and the new DIC system will be further developed to reach different stress-state conditions and to perform tests at elevated temperatures.

11 NUCLEAR FUEL CYCLE AND FUEL MATERIALS↗

FUEL PERFORMANCE MODELING OF FECRAL CLADDING FAILURE DURING LOSS OF COOLANT CONDITIONS

Accident tolerant materials are defined as those that provide significantly increased response time in the event of an accident while providing similar or improved performance as the conventional UO2/Zircaloy-4 fuel rods during normal operation. One avenue for materials to demonstrate enhanced accident tolerance is to have improved reaction (e.g., oxidation) kinetics with steam, resulting in slower hydrogen (or other combustible gases) generation rate, while maintaining acceptable thermo-mechanical properties, fuel-clad interactions, and fission product behavior. Due to their improved reaction kinetics with steam compared to Zircaloy-4, iron-chromium-aluminum (FeCrAl) alloys are being considered as an accident tolerant cladding material. In order to determine whether FeCrAl alloys are indeed accident tolerant materials, comparisons between conventional zirconium-based claddings under accident conditions is required. To this end, we have developed a burst (failure) criterion for FeCrAl using existing experimental data for first-generation alloys. This model was incorporated into the BISON fuel performance code to perform comparative studies with Zircaloy-4 cladding tubes under non-oxidizing and oxidizing LOCA conditions. The separate effects LOCA conditions considered were adopted from the PUZRY and REBEKA test series. Due to the fact that FeCrAl alloys have a larger thermal absorption cross-section and higher stiffness than Zircaloy-4, cladding thickness will be smaller for FeCrAl than for Zircaloy-4. Three different cladding thicknesses were analyzed in this work. The results indicate that for both non-oxidizing (PUZRY) and oxidizing (REBEKA) LOCA conditions, FeCrAl has similar burst behavior (i.e., time to burst and pressure at burst) as Zircaloy-4. It should be noticed that this study used data for first-generation FeCrAl alloys to develop the burst criterion. Although no burst data?currently exists for C35M (a second-generation FeCrAl alloy under development at Oak Ridge National Laboratory), improved burst behavior is anticipated. As burst data for C35M becomes available the burst criterion will be updated and the simulations revisited to determine the accident tolerance of second-generation FeCrAl alloys.

11 NUCLEAR FUEL CYCLE AND FUEL MATERIALS↗

Reactivity-initiated accident simulation to inform transient testing of candidate advanced cladding

This paper leverages three-dimensional reactor-core-simulation capabilities to provide information on appropriate experimental test conditions for candidate advanced cladding materials in a control-rod-ejection event. These test conditions use three-dimensional nodal kinetics simulations of a reactivity-initiated accident (RIA) in a representative state-of-the-art pressurized water reactor with both nuclear-grade iron-chromium-aluminum (FeCrAl) and silicon-carbide (SiC-SiC)-based cladding materials. The effort yields boundary conditions for experimental mechanical tests, specifically peak cladding strain during the power pulse following the rod ejection. The impact of candidate cladding materials on the reactor kinetics behavior of RIA progression versus that of reference Zr cladding is predominantly due to differences in -1) fuel mass/volume/specific power density, -2) spectral effects due to parasitic neutron absorption, -3) control rod worth due to hardened (or softened) spectrum, and -4) initial conditions due to power peaking and neutron transport cross sections in the equilibrium cycle cores resulting from hardened (or softened) spectrum. This study shows minimal impact of SiC-SiC-based cladding configurations on the transient response versus reference Zircaloy cladding. However, the FeCrAl cladding response indicates similar energy deposition, but with significantly shorter pulses of higher magnitude. Therefore, the FeCrAl-based cases have a more rapid fuel thermal expansion rate, and the resultant pellet-cladding interaction occurs more rapidly. (authors)

21 SPECIFIC NUCLEAR REACTORS AND ASSOCIATED PLANTS↗

Electron microscopy analysis of high burnup commercial fuel

Modern electron microscopy analysis can provide detailed insight into the microstructure and chemistry of high burnup UO{sub 2} fuel. This more complete understanding of fuel evolution and performance in reactor can provide critical insight necessary to validate fuel performance models and optimize reactor operations. Preliminary results from the investigation of a polished cross-section of high burnup UO{sub 2} fuel (seven cycles) from the H.B. Robinson pressurized water reactor will be discussed. The analysis focuses on scanning electron microscopy (SEM) of the complete cross-section, while scanning transmission electron microscopy (S/TEM) was performed on targeted features identified by SEM where specimens were fabricated by traditional focused ion beam lift-out techniques. Analysis of the complete cross-section allowed for investigation of the microstructural variations from centerline to fuel/clad interface, pellet/pellet interface, and cladding. Secondary electron imaging and backscatter electron imaging was performed to identify variations in the distribution of fission product secondary phases and bubbles/voids. The analysis of the pellet/pellet interface is a unique feature of this sample where initial analysis shows segregation of fission product phases at the pellet/pellet interface and also indicates an interface microstructure lacking of bubbles and voids. X-ray spectrum imaging was performed by both SEM and STEM techniques to identify the composition of the secondary phases present in the fuel. Multivariate statistical analysis (MVSA) of the X-ray spectrum images has been applied to improve the sensitivity of the analysis and highlight minor variations in the fuel chemistry and secondary phases comprised of fission product as well as the distribution of sub-surface Xe gas bubbles in the high burnup structure. The results presented demonstrate the level of microstructural understanding that is attainable with a combination of SEM techniques along with S/TEM techniques.

22 GENERAL STUDIES OF NUCLEAR REACTORS↗

Overview of the multifaceted activities towards development and deployment of nuclear-grade FeCrAl alloys

A large effort is underway under the leadership of US DOE Fuel Cycle Research program to develop advanced FeCrAl alloys as accident tolerant fuel (ATF) cladding to replace Zr-based alloys in light water reactors. The primary motivation is the excellent oxidation resistance of these alloys in high-temperature steam environments right up to their melting point (roughly three orders of magnitude slower oxidation kinetics than zirconium). A multifaceted effort is ongoing to rapidly advance FeCrAl alloys as a mature ATF concept. The activities span the broad spectrum of alloy development, environmental testing (high-temperature high-pressure water and elevated temperature steam), detailed mechanical characterization, material property database development, neutron irradiation, thin tube production, and multiple integral fuel test campaigns. Instead of off-the-shelf commercial alloys that might not prove optimal for the LWR fuel cladding application, a large amount of effort has been placed on the alloy development to identify the most optimum composition and microstructure for this application. The development program is targeting a cladding that offers performance comparable to or better than modern Zr-based alloys under normal operating and off-normal conditions. This paper provides a comprehensive overview of the systematic effort to advance nuclear-grade FeCrAl alloys as an ATF cladding in commercial LWRs. (authors)

11 NUCLEAR FUEL CYCLE AND FUEL MATERIALS↗

Fabrication of FeCrAl cladding for accident tolerant fuel

General Electric (GE) is working with the US Department of Energy (DOE) to develop a high performance nuclear fuel that will have enhanced tolerance to failure under severe accident conditions. The leading FeCrAl alloy candidate for the cladding is APMT, a powder metallurgy alloy developed by Kanthal/Sandvik for high temperature applications. Zirconium alloys have been used for cladding the fuel for over six decades. That is, zirconium alloys can be fabricated as several meters long tubes with an outside diameter of about 10 mm and a wall thickness in the order of 1 mm or less. The GE team is working to demonstrate that APMT can be fabricated as long thin walled tubes for the cladding application. A first production route for 10 x 0.5 mm APMT tubes was established showing that pilgering and drawing are viable processes to fabricate the APMT cladding. The mechanical properties of APMT were evaluated before and after the cold forming. Yield strength, tensile strength and hardness increased and elongation decreased due to cold forming, which was expected. No abnormality has been noted in the microstructures. The 3D image visualization of TIG welded APMT rodlet and the images of welding areas taken at different locations show no welding defects such as distortion, porosity or lack of penetration along/adjacent to the welded areas, confirming overall good welds and no opening or defects across the entire width of the tube thickness. Tests have shown no effect of welding on the hardness or mechanical strength in the area nearing the weld.

36 MATERIALS SCIENCE↗