Search NASA⌕ Search

Engineering topics

Trenton M. Ricks

Publications and source records attributed to Trenton M. Ricks.

Multiscale Progressive Failure Analysis of 3D Woven Composites

Application of three-dimensional (3D) woven composites is growing as an alternative to the use of ply-based composite materials. However, the design, analysis, modeling, and optimization of these materials is more challenging due to their complex and inherently multiscale geometries. Herein, a multiscale modeling procedure, based on efficient, semi-analytical micromechanical theories rather than the traditional finite element approach, is presented and applied to a 3D woven carbon–epoxy composite. A crack-band progressive damage model was employed for the matrix constituent to capture the globally observed nonlinear response. Realistic microstructural dimensions and tow-fiber volume fractions were determined from detailed X-ray computed tomography (CT) and scanning electron microscopy data. Pre-existing binder-tow disbonds and weft-tow waviness, observed in X-ray CT scans of the composite, were also included in the model. The results were compared with experimental data for the in-plane tensile and shear behavior of the composite. The tensile predictions exhibited good correlations with the test data. While the model was able to capture the less brittle nature of the in-plane shear response, quantitative measures were underpredicted to some degree.

3D woven composites↗

Residual Stresses Induced due to Curing of the Bulk Matrix in a Simplified Three-Dimensional (3D) Woven Repeating Unit Cell

It has been observed that 3D woven materials are highly susceptible to processes induced defects including tow misalignment, intratow and intertow cracking and/or voids. Adequate process modeling of 3D woven Polymer Matrix Composites (PMCs) is necessary to predict and estimate the effects of the manufacturing process on these defects. A preliminary step towards this is achieved with the commercial Finite Element Analysis (FEA) tool Abaqus complemented with written user subroutines to account for the effect of shrinkage and thermoelastic properties evolution as a function of the degree of cure of the bulk matrix phase in a 3D woven composite repeating unit cell (RUC). As a pathfinder, the process modeling framework is demonstrated on a simplified 3D woven RUC of an AS4/RIMR 135 system. Curing simulations are performed on the 3D woven RUC to observe the processing induced residual stresses. The results of the analysis show that high stress concentrations, present within the 3D intertow matrix bordering the binder tow, coincide with X-Ray computed tomography (X-Ray-CT) scan data depicting cracking in the same location

3D Woven↗

Application of the NASA Multiscale Analysis Tool: Multiscale Integration and Interoperability

In order to demonstrate NASMAT’s multiscale operability, a series of illustrative examples will be presented that focus on the application of NASMAT to practical problems. First, the multiscale integration and data recursion is demonstrated by performing a multiscale analysis using only built-in micromechanics methods. NASMAT’s integration is then highlighted by running a multiscale analysis where an external finite element software calls NASMAT. In this case, at each integration point within the finite element model, a local NASMAT analysis is performed to account for failure behavior at the constituent scale. In a similar example, an external program is called from within NASMAT. This case would be relevant for a user wanting to implement an outside micromechanics technique. A combination of these examples is then presented to further illustrate the code’s flexibility when interfacing with outside codes in a multiscale framework. For all examples, data is presented using a custom-developed visualization tool. Additional potential use cases are also addressed. Finally, the plan for upcoming features and added capabilities is discussed.

NASMAT↗

Application of the NASA Multiscale Analysis Tool: Multiscale Integration and Interoperability

The NASA Multiscale Analysis Tool (NASMAT) was developed recently to allow a wide variety of multiscale analysis problems to be effectively and efficiently solved. The architecture of NASMAT was established specifically to enable parallelized, “plug-and-play” functionality to reduce the complexity associated with adding new features to the code in the future and to allow end users to rapidly implement and evaluate user-defined capabilities. Additionally, the tool utilizes recursive data structures and subroutines to allow for an arbitrary number of length scales when performing multiscale analyses of heterogeneous materials. These features permit the rapid integration of user-defined capabilities (e.g., a material model, micromechanics approach, or failure theory) at all stages within a NASMAT calculation while leveraging built-in techniques where needed. Additionally, these features allow NASMAT to both be called from an external program as well as call an external program. This paper specifically focuses on the multiscale integration and interoperability of NASMAT with other analysis techniques through an illustrative, multiscale analysis of a 3D woven polymer matrix composite (PMC).

NASMAT↗

Software Architecture and Hierarchy of the Nasa Multiscale Analysis Tool

The NASA Multiscale Analysis Tool (NASMAT) serves as a state-of-the-art, “plug and play,” software package which utilizes multiscale recursive micromechanics as a platform for massively multiscale modeling for hierarchical materials and structures subjected to thermomechanical loads on high performance computing systems. This paper is intended to give an overview of the design of NASMAT and how the design supports modularity, upgradability and maintainability, interoperability, and utility. First, the software architecture and hierarchy will be explored. Details on each of the 11 NASMAT procedures and the arrangement of NASMAT data will be presented. Finally, application program interfaces (APIs) that were developed to facilitate the communication of NASMAT with other programs will be described.

multiscale modeling↗

Thermal Conductivity of 3D Woven Composite Thermal Protection System Materials via Multiscale Recursive Micromechanics

Multiscale micromechanics predictions have been made for the effective thermal conductivities and local thermal fields for a novel 3D woven composite thermal protection system material. The Multiscale Recursive Micromechanics approach, which enables micromechanics models to call other micromechanics models (or themselves recursively) to consider finer and finer length scales, has been employed. The multiscale model uses a recently developed version of the High-Fidelity Generalized Method of Cells micromechanics theory at each of three length scales. Results focus on the impact of the microstructural geometry representation at each length scale on the material’s effective thermal conductivity, along with the local thermal flux and temperature fields induced in the microstructures.

Composites↗

Multiscale Thermal Conductivity Modeling of 3D Woven Composite Thermal Protection System Materials

Novel thermal protection systems (TPS) for re-entry and hypersonic vehicles utilize 3D woven composite materials with blended carbon filament tows (yarns) and a phenolic resin matrix. The presence of continuous carbon fibers provides superior stiffness and strength compared to legacy TPS, while the 3D weave pattern provides a great deal of design flexibility for both in-plane and through thickness thermomechanical behavior. However, modeling of 3D woven composites is notoriously complex and numerically intensive. The present investigation utilizes a unique ultra-efficient approach, known as Multiscale Recursive Micromechanics (MsRM), wherein recursive semi-analytical micromechanics methods are employed at various length scales within the composite. The MsRM approach has recently been extended to solve for the effective thermal conductivity as well as the local temperature and thermal flux fields throughout the composite. Presented model results focus on the impact of the microstructural geometry representation at each length scale on the material’s effective thermal conductivity, along with the local thermal flux and temperature fields induced in the microstructures, for a novel 3D woven TPS.

Composite↗

Estimation of 3D Woven Design Sensitivities Using a Rapid Multiscale Analysis Technique

Highly-refined finite element models of three-dimension (3D) woven composite systems currently require excessive computational demands that limit their use in sensitivity analysis, uncertainty quantification, and optimization. An alternative analysis methodology was developed using the NASA Multiscale Analysis Tool (NASMAT) where multiscale models of a 3D woven composite (including inter-tow matrix voids and constituent failure) can be completed on a single central processing unit(CPU)on the order of ~30 s. To develop inputs and validation data for the NASMAT model, coupon and acid-digesting testing and x-ray computed tomography were performed. The NASMAT inputs were parameterized using a set of 25 input variables and distributions. These inputs were randomly sampled to generate a total of 100,000 NASMAT analyses that could be used to understand the influence of different material and geometric properties on the warp and weft-direction stiffness and strength. These analyses (including pre/post-processing) were performed in less than eight hours on a 120 CPU cluster. The computational efficiency of the NASMAT model enabled a sensitivity analysis to be performed, and dominant input variables were able to be identified. Key results were consistent with theoretical and experimental observations for the specific 3D woven system studied in this work.

NASMAT↗

A Partitioned -Task Parallel Implementation of the NASA Multiscale Analysis Tool for High Performance Computing

The NASA Multiscale Analysis Tool (NASMAT) is a “plug and play” software package that allows users to conduct massively multiscale modeling of hierarchical and nonlinear materials. This work extends the scalability and improves the High Performance Computing friendliness of NASMAT by adopting a Partitioned Task-Parallel approach. Interoperability of NASMAT with external software is enhanced through preCICE, a open source library for multiphysics coupling in a partitioned manner. Enhancement through preCICE allows for easy integration of NASMAT to other macro solvers and dissociates the parallelization strategy adopted within NASMAT from the macro solver. The task-parallel framework based on Master-Worker approach is implemented as the parallelization scheme. The scheme accounts for hierarchy of multiple scales (task-dependence) and heterogeneous nature (dynamic load balancing) of computations. The applicability and scalability of the framework will be evaluated by analyzing large scale engineering problems through massively multiscale methods.

NASMAT↗

Simulation of Dynamic Crushing Behavior of Simulated Carbon/Epoxy Stanchions Using MAT58 and MAT213 in LS-DYNA

Carbon fiber-reinforced polymer (CFRP) composites have shown promise as a material for structures designed to absorb energy in crush-style impact loading. In complementing the lightweight and tailorable characteristics of CFRP structures, the benefits of impact energy absorption are particularly interesting in aerospace vehicles that require excellent crashworthiness performance. However, simulating the behavior of CFRP structures in dynamic, crushing-style impact loading is challenging because of the many damage and failure modes that are essential to capture in the model. For the present investigation, CFRP stanchions were tested using a crash sled experimental test rig. The stanchions were designed by the Composite Materials Handbook-17 (CMH-17) Crashworthiness Working Group for the purpose of comparing experimental crash sled tests to corresponding simulations of the tests. The stanchions are C-channel shaped and represent a geometry common in the interior of aerospace vehicle structures. Explicit simulations in LSDYNA were performed using a well-established composite material model (MAT58) and a next-generation material model (MAT213). Fully integrated shell elements were utilized instead of 3D solid elements to limit computation time. In all models, each of the sixteen plies were represented with individual layers of shell elements with tiebreak contact between each adjacent ply pair to simulate interlaminar fracture. Simulating the crushing of the stanchions occurred in two phases. First, the material models were calibrated using flat specimens that were manufactured with the same layup as the stanchions. While the original goal was calibration of material-related properties, meshdependent behavior was observed in simulations with either material model, and an unstructured mesh was selected to remediate undesirable mesh-dependent failure modes. Additionally, for both the MAT58 and MAT213 models, it was found that either the crush force or the failure mode could be modeled accurately, but no set of parameters could be identified to attain both results in the same model. Once satisfactory calibration was achieved, the same material parameters were applied to the stanchion crush simulations. The stanchion simulations showed that MAT213 more accurately predicted the experimentally determined crush force, and both material models predicted key aspects of the experimentally observed failure modes.

Composite Materials↗

The Nasa Multiscale Analysis Tool: an Enabling Platform for Achieving Vision 2040

Vision 2040 is a community-driven consensus document, written in 2018, aimed at defining the potential 25-year future state required for performing integrated multiscale modeling of materials and systems for future aerospace and aeronautical applications. Nine Vision Key Elements (KEs) were defined along with associated technical gaps. This paper will address current NASA GRC research efforts utilizing the NASA Multiscale Analysis Tool (NASMAT). This paper will specifically focus on NASMAT’s ability to address gaps in three of the nine Vision 2040 KEs: 1) Models and Methods, 2) Multiscale Measurements and Characterization Tools and Methods, and 6) Data, Informatics, and Visualization. NASMAT is a versatile platform for performing computationally efficient multiscale analyses of heterogeneous materials. NASMAT offers the user flexibility to define an arbitrary number of length scales (levels) where a variety of micromechanics theories can be implemented at each level. Micromechanics theories can be selected to balance accuracy and computational efficiency and range from analytical (Mori-Tanaka) to several semi-analytical (method of cells) formulations. NASMAT can also be coupled with external software and used to perform multiscale analyses of more complex structures. The paper will include a recent application of NASMAT to model a complex, three-dimensional woven composite, with a particular emphasis placed on multiscale measurements utilized to enhance the quality of the multiscale analysis. Since typical NASMAT analyses can be completed in on the order of seconds to minutes, a second example will demonstrate NASMAT’s ability to generate large quantities of data useful for sensitivity analysis, uncertainty quantification, or machine learning applications. Current progress on developing multiscale data visualization tools will also be addressed along with the challenges associated with and proposed solutions for sifting through large amounts of data. These examples will demonstrate that NASMAT is an enabling platform for achieving the goals in Vision 2040.

Vision 2040↗

Application of the MAT 213 Composite Impact Model to NASA Problems of Interest

A material model has been developed which incorporates several key capabilities which have been identified as lacking in currently available composite impact models. The material model utilizes experimentally based tabulated input to define the evolution of plasticity and damage as opposed to specifying discrete input parameters (such as modulus and strength). The material model has been implemented into LS-DYNA® as MAT 213. The model can simulate the nonlinear deformation, damage and failure that takes place in a composite under dynamic loading conditions. The deformation model utilizes an orthotropic plasticity formulation. For the damage model, the nonlinear unloading response that is observed prior to the point where the peak stress is reached can be simulated, as well as the stress degradation response that occurs after the peak stress is reached. A variety of failure models, including a generalized tabulated failure model which facilitates the utilization of general failure surfaces, have been implemented into MAT 213. Recent studies at NASA have concentrated on using MAT 213 to analyze both the impact and crush response of a variety of laminated and textile architectures. Several of these studies will be discussed in the presented paper. For example, a woven carbon/Kevlar composite is currently being examined for use in an energy absorber system for rotorcraft structures. MAT 213 analyses have been conducted to examine the ability of the model to accurately simulate the dynamic crush response of this material. Studies are also being conducted to examine the ability of MAT 213 to simulate the ballistic impact response of representative laminated and woven thermoplastic and thermoset matrix composites. NASA efforts are also concentrated on developing methods and processes for improving characterization methods and developing “best practices” for using MAT 213, a summary of which will be discussed in the paper.

Polymer Matrix Composites↗