Search NASA⌕ Search

Engineering topics

Veeraraghavan, Swetha

Publications and source records attributed to Veeraraghavan, Swetha.

2.0 - MOOSE: Enabling massively parallel multiphysics simulation

The last 2 years have been a period of unprecedented growth for the MOOSE community and the software itself. The number of monthly visitors to the website has grown from just over 3,000 to now averaging 5,000. In addition, over 1,800 pull requests have been merged since the beginning of 2020, and the new discussions forum has averaged 600 unique visitors per month. The previous publication has been cited over 200 times since it was published 2 years ago. This paper serves as an update on some of the key additions and changes to the code and ecosystem over the last 2 years, as well as recognizing contributions from the community.

22 GENERAL STUDIES OF NUCLEAR REACTORS↗

MASTODON: An Open-Source Software for Seismic Analysis and Risk Assessment of Critical Infrastructure

Seismic analysis and risk assessment of safety-critical infrastructure like hospitals, nuclear power plants, dams, and facilities handling radioactive materials involve computationally intensive numerical models and coupled multiphysics scenarios. They are also performed in a strict regulatory environment that requires high software quality assurance standards, and in the case of safety-related nuclear facilities, a conformance to the American Society of Mechanical Engineers Nuclear Quality Assurance (NQA-1) standard. This paper introduces the open-source finite-element software, MASTODON (Multi-hazard Analysis of Stochastic Time-Domain Phenomena), which implements state-of-the-art seismic analysis and risk assessment tools in a quality-controlled environment. MASTODON is built on MOOSE (Multi-physics Object-Oriented Simulation Environment), which is a highly parallelizable, NQA-1 conforming, coupled multiphysics, finite-element framework developed at Idaho National Laboratory. MASTODON is capable of fault rupture and source-to-site wave propagation using the domain reduction method, nonlinear site response, and soil-structure interaction analysis, implicit and explicit time integration, automated stochastic simulations, and seismic probabilistic risk assessment. When coupled with other MOOSE applications, MASTODON can also solve strongly and weakly coupled multiphysics problems. This paper presents a summary of the capabilities of MASTODON and some demonstrative examples.

42 ENGINEERING↗

Simulation of site and topographic effects on ground motion in Los Alamos, NM mesas

Mesas, which consist of an elevated area of land with a flat top and steep cliffs at the sides, are one of the common geological formations present in the Los Alamos region. Previous research has shown that geological formations such as sedimentary canyons can amplify soil response during earthquakes. There have also been parametric studies to understand the response of an idealized and isolated mountain/canyon under inclined plane waves. In this study, a 2-D linear anelastic soil domain, with topography modelled after the Los Alamos region with many mesas and canyons, is considered to understand site-specific topographic effects in the presence of non-isolated topographical features. Various earthquake sources configurations ranging from point sources to finite faults with varying rupture length, dip angles and spatial slip distributions are considered. To isolate the effect of topography, three other soil domains—a homogeneous half-space, homogeneous half-space with mesas and canyons, and a computational domain with just the soil properties from the Los Alamos region on a flat soil domain is also considered. 2-D site-response analyses of these soil domains under earthquake excitation show that the free-field response of the soil can be amplified or de-amplified depending on the topography of the region and the location of the station relative to the fault. These studies also show that even relatively small mesas with height less than 100 m can significantly amplify the response (by a factor of 2 or more), which differ from the much smaller amplification factors (≤1.2) specified by standard building codes such as Eurocode-8 (2000) for topographical features with a similar slope. De-amplifications are also fairly common, especially close to the canyons. The results from this study agree qualitatively with those from the ambient vibration study conducted by Stolte et al. on a mesa from the Los Alamos region. Furthermore, such site-specific studies provide important insights into the variability of the topographic amplification factors within a region of interest. Such knowledge is important in the design of safety-related critical infrastructure located within that region.

22 GENERAL STUDIES OF NUCLEAR REACTORS↗

Modeling fuel assembly distortion in light water reactors using BISON

Individual fuel rods in a light water reactor fuel assembly (FA) often have different power profiles that result in a spatial temperature gradient in the FA. This temperature gradient causes some rods to elongate more than others which could in turn distort the entire FA. Such FA distortion has been known to cause operational difficulties with refueling and with the insertion of control rods [1]. Numerical modeling of FA distortion due to differential elongation of fuel rods requires: (i) modeling the thermal elongation as well as the creep and irradiation induced elongation of the fuel rods, and (ii) modeling the bending response of the FA due to the differential elongation of the fuel rods. Past studies on this topic have been focused on the mechanical deformation of the FA with simplistic modeling of fuel rod elongation. In this paper, a simulation approach is presented that directly couples 2D axisymmetric fuel performance models of the individual fuel rods in a FA with structural beam models of the fuel rods in a FA using the Bison code [2]. This allows all of the mechanisms internal to the fuel rod leading to cladding elongation to be accounted for in the FA distortion model. To demonstrate this capability, the bowing of a simplified and idealized 6x6 FA (Fig. 1a), modeled using beam elements, is analyzed under different spatially varying power profiles. For this study, the guide tubes are rigidly connected to the spacer grid. Also, the fuel rods are rigidly connected to the spacer grid in all directions except the vertical direction (Y) along which slipping can occur between the fuel rods and spacer grids, depending on the friction coefficient between them. Coupling the thermo-mechanical response of individual fuel rods to the global mechanical behavior of the FA can shed light on the mechanisms that cause distortion of the FA and potential solutions to address this issue.

11 NUCLEAR FUEL CYCLE AND FUEL MATERIALS↗

Nonlinear Modeling of Ground Motions at Lotung LSST Site with Nested Surface Soil Constitutive Model

Seismic analyses of nuclear facilities require the use of validated numerical models that can realistically reproduce the response of soils during earthquakes. The nested surface nonlinear, hysteretic soil constitutive model is one of the soil constitutive models that is vastly used due to (i) lower number of free parameters compared to other nonlinear soil constitutive models, and (ii) because of the ease of calibrating these parameters using the commonly available soil data, i.e., G/G max and damping curves as a function of shear strain. This material model is available in commercial finite element software packages (LS-DYNA and Abaqus) as well in the open source finite element tool (Mastodon). The purpose of this study is to estimate the parameters required for this material model from the soil data available for the Lotung site and to demonstrate that this nonlinear soil constitutive model used in a time domain, finite element analysis can reasonably reproduce the actual measured soil motions recorded at Lotung during the LSST07 event on May 20, 1986. Results are introduced from all the three softwares mentioned above using the same material model.

42 ENGINEERING↗

High frequency content in nonlinear soil response: A numerical artifact or a reality?

This article probes the reasons for the presence of high frequency components, which are not a part of the input, in the output of nonlinear site response analysis. The nonlinear site response analysis of a single soil element, under a single frequency sinusoidal displacement, is conducted to demonstrate the presence of frequencies higher than the input frequency in the soil element's shear stress and the free surface acceleration. The parameters of this one element problem are chosen carefully to minimize numerical errors. The shape of the stress-strain hysteresis loop is found to be the main cause for the presence of these higher frequencies. A quasi-static problem similar to the direct shear test is then considered to analyze the effect of different hysteresis shapes. Through this analysis, it is numerically and analytically shown that any deviation of the stress-strain hysteresis shape from a perfect ellipse results in output frequencies higher than the input frequency and the number of higher frequencies produced depends on whether the hysteresis shape is smooth or pointed.

42 ENGINEERING↗

Mastodon

MASTODON has the capability to model stochastic nonlinear soil-structure interaction (NLSSI) in a dynamic probabilistic risk assessment framework. The NLSSI simulations include structural dynamics, time integration, dynamic porous media flow, nonlinear hysteretic soil constitutive models, geometric nonlinearities (gapping, sliding, and uplift). MASTODON is also the MOOSE based master application for dynamic PRA of external hazards.

Coleman, JustinLeigh↗

Advanced Seismic Probabilistic Risk Assessment Methodology: Development of Beta 1.0 MASTODON Toolset

Design of nuclear power plant (NPP) facilities to resist natural hazards has been a part of the regulatory process from the beginning of the NPP industry in the United States, but has evolved substantially over time. The original set of approaches and methods was entirely deterministic in nature and focused on a traditional engineering margins-based approach. However, over time probabilistic and risk-informed approaches were also developed and implemented in US Nuclear Regulatory Commission guidance and regulation. A defense-in-depth framework has also been incorporated into US regulatory guidance over time. As a result, today, the US regulatory framework incorporates deterministic and probabilistic approaches for a range of different applications and for a range of natural hazard considerations. Although the US regulatory framework has continued to evolve over time, the tools, methods and data available to the US nuclear industry to meet the changing requirements have not kept pace. Notably, there is room for improvement in the tools and methods available for external event probabilistic risk assessment (PRA), which is the principal assessment approach used in risk-informed regulations and risk-informed decision-making applied to natural hazard assessment and design. Development of a new set of tools and methods that incorporate current knowledge, modern best practice, and state-of-the-art computational resources would lead to more reliable assessment of facility risk and risk insights (e.g., the plant elements and accident sequences that are most risk-significant), with less uncertainty and reduced conservatisms. Development of the next generation tools and methods for external events PRA is ongoing under the Risk Informed Safety Margins Characterization (RISMC) technical pathway. The RISMC toolkit development centers on integration of the tools and methods under a common framework, MOOSE. These tools and methods make use of existing and newly developed tools and methods, coupled with the experience and data gained in the past decades, to define and analyze more realistic risk assessment models. Specific focus in this report is on the capability to model seismic risk using advanced SPRA methods. Over the last year, significant capability has been added to Mastodon to simulate 3-D wave passage effects through nonlinear soil. Verification has demonstrated the capability of Mastodon to model wave passage effects in 1-D, 2-D, and 3-D. Methods have been developed to incorporate probabilistic floor response capabilities. Additional capability will be added to Mastodon over the next year to implement a robust gapping and sliding element for cyclic shaking, web-based verification and user manuals, stochastic finite elements, and frequency independent damping. Verification of added capabilities has occured in parallel with code writing activities.

21 SPECIFIC NUCLEAR REACTORS AND ASSOCIATED PLANTS↗

EFFECT OF INCLINED WAVES ON DEEPLY EMBEDDED NUCLEAR FACILITIES

Several conceptual designs for advanced reactors show that most if not all of the structure is embedded in the soil. Consequently, analysis techniques that have been verified and validated for the analysis of light water reactors on surface foundations may not be directly applicable to deeply embedded reactors. Specifically two effects that may change the in-structure response (ISR) of embedded facilities are: (i) the effect of the kinematic interaction becomes more prominent as the embedment depth increases; (ii) non-vertically propagating waves, which are usually not considered for surface-founded facilities, may be more important for deeply embedded facilities. A preliminary study is presented in this article to understand the response of embedded nuclear facilities to non-vertically propagating seismic waves. The inclined wave field is generated from source-to-site simulations using representative earthquake faults with different dip angles. The embedment depth of the nuclear containment facility is also varied to obtain a better understanding of the effect of embedment. This analysis of the soil-structure ensemble is conducted using the application called Multi-hazard Analysis for STOchastic time-DOmaiN phenomena (MASTODON), developed on top of Idaho National Lab’s open source MOOSE finite element framework. The Domain Reduction Method implemented in MASTODON to incorporate the seismic excitation within the region of interest is verified and then used to reduce the computational effort in analyzing this problem. Preliminary analysis using linear soil and structure material properties and tied contact between the soil and structure indicate that embedding the nuclear facility reduces significantly the response of the structure in all the earthquake scenarios considered.

42 ENGINEERING↗

MASTODON Theory Manual

Multi-hazard Analysis for STOchastic time-DOmaiN phenomena (MASTODON) is a finite element application that aims at analyzing the response of 3-D soil-structure systems to natural and man-made hazards such as earthquakes, floods and fire. MASTODON currently focuses on the simulation of seismic events and has the capability to perform extensive ‘source-to-site’ simulations including earthquake fault rupture, nonlinear wave propagation and nonlinear soil-structure interaction (NLSSI) analysis. MASTODON is being developed to be a dynamic probabilistic risk assessment framework that enables analysts to not only perform deterministic analyses, but also easily perform probabilistic or stochastic simulations for the purpose of risk assessment.

42 ENGINEERING↗

Multi-Hazard Advanced Seismic Probabilistic Risk Assessment Tools and Applications

Design of nuclear power plant (NPP) facilities to resist natural hazards has been a part of the regulatory process from the beginning of the NPP industry in the United States (US), but has evolved substantially over time. The original set of approaches and methods was entirely deterministic in nature and focused on a traditional engineering margins-based approach. However, over time probabilistic and risk-informed approaches were also developed and implemented in US Nuclear Regulatory Commission (NRC) guidance and regulation. A defense-in-depth framework has also been incorporated into US regulatory guidance over time. As a result, today, the US regulatory framework incorporates deterministic and probabilistic approaches for a range of different applications and for a range of natural hazard considerations. This framework will continue to evolve as a result of improved knowledge and newly identified regulatory needs and objectives, most notably in response to the NRC activities developed in response to the 2011 Fukushima accident in Japan. Although the US regulatory framework has continued to evolve over time, the tools, methods and data available to the US nuclear industry to meet the changing requirements have not kept pace. Notably, there is significant room for improvement in the tools and methods available for external event probabilistic risk assessment (PRA), which is the principal assessment approach used in risk-informed regulations and risk-informed decision-making applied to natural hazard assessment and design. This is particularly true if PRA is applied to natural hazards other than seismic loading. Development of a new set of tools and methods that incorporate current knowledge, modern best practice, and state-of-the-art computational resources would lead to more reliable assessment of facility risk and risk insights (e.g., the SSCs and accident sequences that are most risk-significant), with less uncertainty and reduced conservatisms.

21 SPECIFIC NUCLEAR REACTORS AND ASSOCIATED PLANTS↗

Reactivity Insertion Accident (RIA) Capability Status in the BISON Fuel Performance Code

One of the Challenge Problems being considered within CASL relates to modelling and simulation of Light Water Reactor LWR) fuel under Reactivity Insertion Accident (RIA) conditions. BISON is the fuel performance code used within CASL for LWR fuel under both normal operating and accident conditions, and thus must be capable of addressing the RIA challenge problem. This report outlines required BISON capabilities for RIAs and describes the current status of the code. Information on recent accident capability enhancements, application of BISON to a RIA benchmark exercise, and plans for validation to RIA behavior are included.

22 GENERAL STUDIES OF NUCLEAR REACTORS↗