Using Dempster-Shafer theory to assess explanations for the Zimbabwe anthrax outbreak of 1978-79
I use a simple version of Dempster-Shafer theory (DST) to evaluate evidence from the anthrax outbreak in Zimbabwe (Rhodesia) during 1978-9 and assess the question of whether the outbreak arose naturally or was caused deliberately. The method is derived from a DST-based “opinion calculus” developed by Josang and others in which each item of evidence is used to elicit an opinion about the focal hypothesis, in this case the assertion that the outbreak was deliberately generated. I use a verbal probability expression mapping method to elicit opinions as vectors expressing degrees of belief, disbelief and uncertainty. Two rules for combining the evidence to produce an overall opinion are compared. Both rules result in an opinion favoring the hypothesis that the outbreak was natural in origin. Many items of evidence that have been proffered over the years are shown to be nearly irrelevant to the final conclusion, while the absence of certain expected types of evidence plays a critical role in the assessment.