Search NASA⌕ Search

Engineering topics

Warren, Glen A.

Publications and source records attributed to Warren, Glen A..

At least 19 records

A Discrete Event Simulation Approach to Nuclear Arms Enterprise Modeling and Analysis

We overview a discrete event simulation of an arms control enterprise developed to familiarize individuals with the challenges of verification and monitoring at the enterprise level. We will review the design of the simulation applied to a notional country’s nuclear arms enterprise. This simulation models how these nuclear weapons move over their lifetime from deployment, storage, maintenance, and dismantlement. With this output information, we then characterize the “ground truth” of the enterprise. Next, based on these data, we built a sophisticated analysis engine designed to provide treaty monitoring and verification information to support partner country inspectors and their evaluation. This tool was designed to be used as a game, enabling teams to compete on developing the best inspection plan to determine if the host country is complying with the conceptual treaty developed for this effort.

Pulliam, Rachel M.↗

A new algorithm for estimating radioxenon concentrations

A new algorithm (Xcounts) is introduced for estimating the activity concentrations of the xenon isotopes 131m Xe, 133m Xe, 133 Xe, and 135 Xe using beta-gamma coincidence data. The algorithm simultaneously estimates the decay counts associated with the four xenon isotopes, background, and radon in contrast to the net-counts method that uses sequential residual removal to account for background and interreferences. Calibration data for background counts are determined from gas-background measurements and simulation. In Xcounts, the false positive count rates for 131m Xe and 133m Xe are lower than the false positive rates for 133 Xe and 135 Xe. This algorithm appears to reliably detect the metastable isotopes at lower activity levels than the net-counts method and have similar performance for the other isotopes.

46 INSTRUMENTATION RELATED TO NUCLEAR SCIENCE AND ↗

New NDA Methods for Thorium Fuel Cycle Safeguards (Mid-Project Report)

This project is developing new Non-Destructive Assay (NDA) safeguards techniques for emergent thorium fuel cycles based on Neutron Resonance Transmission Analysis (NRTA), which can assay 233 U and 235 U when they are present together in a sample with potentially high gamma-ray backgrounds from fission products and 232 U. Existing passive techniques face large challenges for this task so new active interrogation methods are needed. This effort is also exploring how gamma-ray signatures can complement NRTA for enhanced assayed performance. This project leverages an NRTA system being developed at PNNL in collaboration with MIT, which uses a commercially available deuterium-tritium neutron generator at short standoff (~2 m). We aim to assess the feasibility and performance of these new NDA techniques for the range of relevant samples in thorium fuel cycles. Key advancements described in this mid-project report include NRTA system design for thorium safeguards measurements, characterization of 233 U oxide powder at PNNL, a survey of detector technologies suitable for NRTA in high gamma background environments, successful preliminary demonstration of a quantitative isotopic estimation algorithm, and first NRTA measurements of a thorium sample.

11 NUCLEAR FUEL CYCLE AND FUEL MATERIALS↗

Neutron-Neutron Correlations in the Photofission of 238U

Background: In the fission of actinides, the nearly back-to-back motion of the fission fragments has a strong effect on the kinematics of fission neutrons. This leads to a favoring of opening angles near 0? and 180? in the neutron-neutron (n-n) opening angle distributions of correlated neutron pairs from the same fission event. Purpose: To measure the n-n opening angle and energy correlations in the photofission of 238U. As of this writing, measurements of correlated n-n opening angle distributions have been reported only for the spontaneous and neutron-induced fission of actinides. This work is the first to report such a measurement using photofission and will provide useful experimental input for photofission models used in codes such as MCNP and FREYA. Method: Fission is induced using bremsstrahlung photons produced via a low duty factor, pulsed, linear electron accelerator. The bremsstrahlung photon beam impinges upon a 238U target that is surrounded by a large neutron scintillation detection system capable of measuring particle position and time of flight, from which n-n opening angle and energy are measured. Neutron-neutron angular correlations are determined by taking the ratio between a correlated neutron distribution and an uncorrelated neutron distribution formed by the pairing of neutrons produced during different beam pulses. This analysis technique greatly diminishes effects due to detector efficiencies, acceptance, and experimental drifts. Results: The angular correlation of neutrons from the photofission of 238U shows a high dependence on neutron energy as well as a dependence on the angle of the emitted neutrons with respect to the incoming photon beam. Angular correlations were also measured using neutrons from the spontaneous fission of 252Cf, showing good agreement with past measurements. Conclusions: The measured angular correlations reflect the underlying back-to-back nature of the fission fragments. An anomalous decline in n-n yield was observed for opening angles near 180? for 238U.

Burggraf, Jeff↗

Final Report on the Viability of Acoustic Techniques for Density and Mass Flow in Enrichment Plants

The primary purpose of this research is to study the viability of acoustic signatures and sensors that could support accurate, noninvasive, and unattended measurement of uranium hexafluoride (UF6) gas density and mass flow rate in situations representative of gaseous centrifuge enrichment plants (GCEP) under safeguards by the International Atomic Energy Agency. The measurement method under development can be readily retrofitted to the exterior of piping in existing systems, potentially facilitating acceptance by facility operators. The findings from the demonstration of a preliminary prototype design and first-generation analysis algorithms in this project will inform the safeguards community as to whether continued acoustic instrument and methods development are warranted. This project conducted two types of measurements, depending on the flow conditions of the gas. For static measurements, the focus is on understanding the acoustic properties at low pressure for non-flowing UF6. For flow measurements, the focus is on understanding the performance of the acoustic system in a simulation of a GCEP pipe using a surrogate gas under fully developed flow conditions. Testing with flowing UF6 was not considered because the cost of building a flowing UF6 system with flow similar to a GCEP was considerably greater than allocated project resources. This document summarizes the results of research conducted over the course of the project. Based on the results to date, the approach is seen to be promising with non-invasive acoustic measurements shown to be possible at the desired pressures. The project has demonstrated • 5% uncertainty of the UF6 gas density for static measurements at pressures relevant to GCEP operations over a 5-minute measurement window with a clear path forward to achieving considerably lower uncertainties over a two-hour period, • Measurements of flowing surrogate gases at pressures relevant to GCEP operations. However, additional research remains to be done to further develop the measurement approach and transition the technology for field use. These development needs include: • Understand the impact of flowing gas on gas density measurements, • Adding sensors and improving the measurement procedure, • Augmenting the data analysis methods by leveraging machine learning approaches, • Reevaluating uncertainty requirements for density and mass flow given observed Online Enrichment Monitor (OLEM) measurement uncertainties, • Designing a robust instrumentation package for field-testing, and • Evaluating measurement results to understand the potential impact on mass balance calculations within GCEP facilities.

42 ENGINEERING↗

Photofission Validation Measurements for Active Interrogation Standards

Executive Summary PNNL has been developing technical standards for the detection of special nuclear material (SNM) in cargo containers using active interrogation approaches. Since the use of kilogram-scale quantities of SNM is impractical for standards testing, the work focused on designing surrogates that provided similar signature as the SNM. There are many active interrogation approaches to detect SNM; the standards development considered photofission, differential die-away and nuclear resonance fluorescence. Of these approaches, photofission currently carries the most interest. However, uncertainties in the photofission cross sections are as large as 50%, so that validation measurements are necessary to provide confidence that the surrogate will perform similarly to the SNM. This document describes approaches for conducting those validation measurements as well as provides a rough order-of-magnitude cost estimate for performing them. Photofission provides many observables for the detection of SNM. The standards development considered prompt neutrons, delayed neutrons and delayed gamma rays as possible detected particles. The surrogates, which consist primarily of depleted uranium (DU), were designed to reproduce the strength of these particles for a targeted quantity of 2 kg of HEU. Different surrogates are required for different measurement approaches because of the difference in cross section between 235 U and 238 U. For the standards validations, the relative strength of the detected particles for HEU and DU must be measured. To avoid measurements with kilogram-sized SNM, the validation approach is focused on two comparisons. In the first comparison, the relative rates for approximately 10 g samples of DU and HEU will be measured. This comparison will provide the basis for validating the relative strength of the detected particles for HEU and DU. In the second comparison, the relative rates for the approximately 10 g and 1 kg sample of DU will be measured. This comparison will enable the validation of secondary processes that occur after photofission that impact the measurement for kilogram-scale samples. For instance, for 2 kg of HEU, as much as 50% of the fission induced in the sample is induced from fission neutrons generated through photofission. There is a limited range of facilities in the U.S. that have both the necessary accelerator capability and the ability and willingness to handle SNM. Two such facilities, the Idaho Accelerator Center at Idaho State University and the Nuclear Engineering Program at the University of Michigan, have both expressed an interest in participating in such measurements. Both would need to amend their licensing to handle the 10 g of HEU proposed for these measurements. The rough order-of-magnitude cost estimate for all three validation measurements is $1.1M, spread over three years. Each of the three measurements could be performed separately, at approximately one-third of that cost. There are a number of critical assumptions in these cost estimate that will need to be confirmed before a more reliable cost estimate can be established. PNNL will manage the effort to ensure that the overall objective of the validation measurements can be achieved and will fabricate the 10 g samples of HEU and DU. Most the labor for the measurements will be provided by two collaborating universities as research opportunities for students. The successful completion of these validation measurements will reduce the uncertainties in the proposed standards from about 50% to 5%. The measurements would also provide some much-needed nuclear data on photofission.

46 INSTRUMENTATION RELATED TO NUCLEAR SCIENCE AND ↗

Future of Radionuclide Aerosol Monitoring Systems

In the 1990s, Pacific Northwest National Laboratory staff developed the Radionuclide Aerosol Sampler Analyzer (RASA) for worldwide aerosol monitoring. RASA won an R&D 100 award in 1998 and a Federal Laboratory Consortium tech transfer award in 2000. For the last several years, staff of PNNL and Creare have made investigations into aspects of upgrading the RASA. Key themes have been a modular approach to additional radionuclide measurements, optimizing the sampling/analyzing times to improve detection and location capability, and improving the power consumption via the use of electrostatic collection versus classic filtration. These individual efforts have been made in the context of retrofits to the existing RASA. In in this work, we consider a complete RASA redesign at a notional level. Individual studies reported here contain theory and experimental investigations, but none of these has been tested with the others, and further work is needed to verify these gains. With these caveats, this work shows that substantial optimization of detection and location capability of a network of RASA systems is possible, multiple mission spaces can be addressed with additional measurements, and electrostatic collection is a practical advantage, although more work is needed. The quite unexpected result of this study is that some optimization of the existing RASA is possible without any hardware changes at all.

98 NUCLEAR DISARMAMENT, SAFEGUARDS, AND PHYSICAL P↗

Acoustic Techniques for UF6 Density and Mass Flow Measurements

A key enabling capability for enrichment plant safeguards is high-accuracy, non-invasive, unattended measurement of UF6 gas density and mass flow rate. Acoustic techniques are currently used to non-invasively monitor gas flow in industrial applications; however, the operating pressures at gaseous centrifuge enrichment plants (GCEPs) are roughly two orders magnitude below the capabilities of commercial instrumentation. Pacific Northwest National Laboratory is refining acoustic techniques for estimating density and mass flow rate of UF6 gas in scenarios typical of gaseous centrifuge enrichment plants, with the goal of achieving 1% measurement uncertainty. Proof-of-concept laboratory measurements of UF6 have demonstrated signature sensitivity to gas density at pressures equivalent to 10-50 Torr of UF6, typical pressures for GCEP unit header pipes. This sensitivity was clearly observable above background acoustic interference. Current efforts involve developing a test bed for conducting acoustic measurements on flowing surrogate gas, air and SF6, at representative flow rates and pressures to ascertain the viability of conducting gas flow measurements under these conditions. Density and flow measurements will be conducted to support the evaluation. If successful, the approach could enable an unattended, non-invasive approach to measure UF6 density and mass flow in unit header pipes of GCEPs.

International safeguards instrumentation, acoustic↗

Soil Sample Efficiency Approach for OSIRIS

The OSIRIS project is developing an approach to enable high-resolution gamma spectroscopy measurements for On-sight Inspections in support of the Comprehensive Test Ban Treaty (CTBT). This document discusses an approach for determining the detection efficiency the detector for a soil sample based on a radiation transport modeling study. The recommended efficiency calibration approach is inspired by the semi-empirical approach of Huy et al. (Huy and Binh 2014; Huy et al. 2013), which performs an efficiency measurement on a soil sample of known composition and known activity which is then corrected based on radiation transport modeling results. The primary difference between the approach of this paper and that of Huy et al., is a simplified correction for energy and density. While this approach is less than perfect, they provide reasonable uncertainties for on-site measurements. A more refined approach should be considered for laboratory measurements which may place greater demands on the uncertainties.

98 NUCLEAR DISARMAMENT, SAFEGUARDS, AND PHYSICAL P↗

Scenarios and Spectra Set for CTBT OSI Information Barrier Testing

The Comprehensive Nuclear-Test-Ban Treaty limits radiation measurements during an on-site inspection to those isotopes the States Parties have agreed are appropriate for the purpose of determining if a nuclear explosion has occurred without revealing irrelevant confidential information. To accomplish this, the radiation detectors used will need to have information barriers that are proven to function reliably over the wide range of possible inspection uses and scenarios. In order to provide a basis set of spectra for testing proposed information barrier systems, PNNL and LLNL defined a set of treaty-compliant and non-compliant scenarios and then independently developed a set of spectra relevant to those scenarios. Real spectra were utilized to the extent possible, but often computer simulations were necessary. These spectra will next be used to assess the performance of an INL information barrier system.

98 NUCLEAR DISARMAMENT, SAFEGUARDS, AND PHYSICAL P↗

UF6 Density and Mass Flow Measurements for Enrichment Plants using Acoustic Techniques

A key enabling capability for enrichment plant safeguards being considered by the International Atomic Energy Agency (IAEA) is high-accuracy, noninvasive, unattended measurement of UF6 gas density and mass flow rate. Acoustic techniques are currently used to noninvasively monitor gas flow in industrial applications; however, the operating pressures at gaseous centrifuge enrichment plants (GCEPs) are roughly two orders magnitude below the capabilities of commercial instrumentation. Pacific Northwest National Laboratory is refining acoustic techniques for estimating density and mass flow rate of UF6 gas in scenarios typical of GCEPs, with the goal of achieving 1% measurement accuracy. Proof-of-concept laboratory measurements using a surrogate gas for UF6 have demonstrated signatures sensitive to gas density at low operating pressures such as 10–50 Torr, which were observed over the background acoustic interference. Current efforts involve developing a test bed for conducting acoustic measurements on flowing SF6 gas at representative flow rates and pressures to ascertain the viability of conducting gas flow measurements under these conditions. Density and flow measurements will be conducted to support the evaluation. If successful, the approach could enable an unattended, noninvasive approach to measure mass flow in unit header pipes of GCEPs.

Good, Morris S.↗

Background Characterization of an Ultra-Low Background Liquid Scintillation Counter

The Ultra-Low Background Liquid Scintillation Counter developed by Pacific Northwest National Laboratory will expand the application of liquid scintillation counting by enabling lower detection limits and smaller sample volumes. By reducing the background environment approximately 2 orders of magnitude below commercially available systems, backgrounds on the order of tens of counts per day over an energy range of ~13– 2700 keV. Initial test results of the ULB LSC show promising results for ultra-low background detection with liquid scintillation counting.

low background, liquid scintillation counting, Sha↗

Acoustic Techniques for Density and Mass Flow in Enrichment Plants

In recent years, the IAEA has pursued innovative techniques and an integrated suite of safeguards measures to address the verification challenges posed by advanced centrifuge technologies and the growth in capacity at gaseous centrifuge enrichment plants (GCEPs) [1; 2]. A prominent theme in the development of a new generation of safeguards measures for GCEPs is the use of permanently installed, unattended instruments that can provide continuous monitoring of facility activities, while also reducing the need for on-site inspections [3]. For example, the U.S. Support Program to the IAEA leads the development of an On-Line Enrichment Monitor (OLEM) [4; 5] and an Unattended Cylinder Verification Station (UCVS) [6]. OLEM units will provide continuous enrichment measurement for 100% of the declared gas flowing through unit header pipes, thereby improving the IAEA’s capabilities to verify operator declarations of enrichment. The OLEM concept requires an accurate determination of gas density in order to produce accurate enrichment calculations (Fig. 1). The current OLEM design assumes that this gas density is derived from a pressure transducer signal shared with the operator. The IAEA has expressed the desire for a technology that can independently and noninvasively measures gas density, in support of a next-generation OLEM design.

IAEA, Enrichment Plants, Acoustic Techniques, OLEM↗

Viability of Acoustic Techniques for Density and Mass Flow in Enrichment Plants

A key enabling capability for enrichment plant safeguards approaches being considered by the International Atomic Energy Agency (IAEA) is high-accuracy, non-invasive, unattended measurement of UF 6 gas density and mass flow rate. The Office of Defense Nuclear Nonproliferation is funding this project to evaluate the viability of acoustic techniques for measuring density and mass flow rate of UF 6 gas in scenarios typical of gaseous centrifuge enrichment plants, with the goal of achieving better than 1% measurements. This report is a review of the progress in the first five months of the project. Initial results are encouraging: Air is a suitable surrogate gas for UF 6 for the initial research effort; Measurable acoustic energy transferred through the air from the transmitting to the receiving transducer for equivalent UF 6 pressures of 10 Torr; There is a monotonic relationship between air pressure and acoustic energy transferred through the air for equivalent UF 6 pressures down to 10 Torr; The acoustic energy transferred through the air is observable above the acoustic energy transferred through the pipe wall. While there is considerable research left to determine the viability of using acoustic techniques to noninvasively measure the gas flow for gaseous centrifuge enrichment plants, these initial results are very encouraging and warrant the continued research effort.

11 NUCLEAR FUEL CYCLE AND FUEL MATERIALS↗