Quantum phases in the honeycomb-lattice J 1 – J 3 ferro-antiferromagnetic model
The significant role of quantum effects in magnets with competing interactions remains at the forefront of condensed matter physics for over 50 years, inspiring a multitude of quests for exotic states, models that can realize them, and real materials that can host them. The elusive spin-liquid states with strong entanglement are but one example; others include valence-bond phases with spatial symmetry breaking, quantum spin nematics that are quantum analogues of liquid crystals, and an especially extensive class of unconventional magnetically ordered phases that do not appear in the classical solutions of the underlying spin models. It is the latter group of phenomena that creates a broader context for the research effort in the present work concerning the search for and an identification of the novel ground states of quantum magnets. In this work, we have studied one of the paradigmatic models in quantum magnetism that is also attracting a significant recent interest because it appears to be providing a tantalizingly close description for many of the newly synthesized materials. We demonstrated that the phase diagram of the quantum ferro-antiferromagnetic model on the honeycomb lattice differs dramatically from the classical one. It hosts the double-zigzag and Ising-z phases as unexpected intermediaries between ferromagnetic and zigzag states that are also extended beyond their classical regions of stability. In broad agreement with quantum order-by-disorder arguments, these collinear phases completely supersede the classical spiral state.