Search NASA⌕ Search

Engineering topics

Wilmarth, W. R.

Publications and source records attributed to Wilmarth, W. R..

Innovative mercury treatment technology options for the liquid waste system at the Savannah River Site: scoping studies

The Savannah River Site (SRS) Liquid Waste System (LWS) contains liquids, salts and sludges that are currently being processed into final wasteforms for disposition, specifically, waste glass for sludges, solids and liquids containing high levels of radioactivity, and saltstone grout for low activity decontaminated liquid solutions. The LWS also contains approximately 60,000 kg of mercury present in the following physical and chemical forms, specifically: a) ionic inorganic mercury, organomercury (e.g., methylmercury), and other minor components found in LWS fluids b) mercury solids such as oxides, hydroxides, amalgams sulfides and sorbed mercury, c) accumulations of dense liquid elemental mercury, and d) vapor phase elemental and organomercury mercury found in tank headspace gas and in evaporators. An effective and proactive management strategy of the mercury present in the LWS is needed to support processing of LWS wastes into glass and saltstone. Sustainable processing of the LAWS to completion requires mercury removal from the LWS at a rate of approximately 2,900 kg/yr. This removal can be accomplished through existing mercury treatment systems or newly implemented LWS “purge points”. The chemical speciation of mercury has emerged as the key factor that controls mercury behavior in the LWS. For example, past studies demonstrated that mercury speciation is adversely impacting the performance of existing removal systems so that significant levels of mercury are recycled from the Defense Waste Processing Facility (DWPF) back to the tank farm. Consequently, mercury concentrations have slowly increased in the LWS tank fluids over time. The presence of organo-mercury has also been identified as the cause of increased mercury leaching from saltstone. In response to these challenges, the Department of Energy (DOE) Office of Environmental Management (EM-TD) Technology Development Program has supported a series of scoping studies predicated on manipulating or controlling mercury speciation and mercury behaviors within the constraints of LWS waste chemistry and safety conditions. The intent of these studies was to rapidly triage potential technology options and develop a technically based go / no go recommendation for further work. This composite report presents the results of three scoping studies: 1) advanced photooxidation processes, 2) chemical reduction, and 3) mercury getters.

12 MANAGEMENT OF RADIOACTIVE AND NON-RADIOACTIVE W↗

Mercury Speciation and Stabilization in Saltstone - 19103

Mercury is a contaminant of concern in Savannah River Site (SRS) high level waste (HLW). For five decades elemental mercury was used in the catalytic dissolution of aluminum cladding from the enriched-alloy uranium recovery process. Over 60,000 kg of mercury are now distributed in the SRS HLW tanks. The mercury speciation in the liquid waste streams resulting from conditioning HLW sludge for vitrification and in the decontaminated low activity sodium salt solution removed from the tanks was initially thought to be primarily ionic with a minor amount of elemental mercury. Recent sampling detected organic mercury, primarily methylmercury, HgCH{sub 3}{sup +} (MeHg{sup +}), and a trace amount of ethylmercury (EtHg) in these streams in addition to the ionic and elemental forms of mercury. The objective of this work was to identify the fate of the organic mercury in saltstone, a waste form containing portland cement, slag cement, and Class F fly ash. This information is needed to evaluate total mercury and organic mercury limits for the saltstone Waste Acceptance Criteria to assure regulatory compliance with mixed waste disposal requirements and to evaluate opportunities to enhance the waste form performance. Results to date indicate that the MeHg{sup +} reacts with sulfide in the cementitious reagents, slag in particular, to form nanoparticles of β-HgS, meta cinnabar, which is very insoluble and has a solubility product in water, pK{sub sp}, at 25 deg. C of 53. (authors)

12 MANAGEMENT OF RADIOACTIVE AND NON-RADIOACTIVE W↗

Gaseous Diffusion Membrane Leaching with Select Lixiviants: Ammonium Carbonate, Sodium Phosphate and Ammonium thiosulfate

As part of ongoing efforts by the Department of Energy’s Portsmouth/Paducah Project Office to decommission the uranium enrichment gaseous diffusion plant at Paducah, KY, research efforts have been focused on removing the remaining kilogram quantities of technetium-99 (Tc-99) from the facility diffusion cascades to meet Tc-99 Waste Acceptance Criteria (WAC) disposal requirements for decommissioning waste.

12 MANAGEMENT OF RADIOACTIVE AND NON-RADIOACTIVE W↗

Mercury in aqueous tank waste at the Savannah River Site: Facts, forms, and impacts

Over the past two years, there has been an intense effort to understand the chemistry of mercury across the Savannah River Site’s high-level liquid waste system to determine the impacts of various mercury species. This effort started after high concentrations of mercury were measured in the leachates from a toxicity characteristic leaching procedure (TCLP) test on the low-level cementitious waste form produced in the Savannah River Saltstone facility. Speciation showed the dominant form of leached mercury to be the methylmercury cation. Neither the source of the methylmercury nor its concentration in the Saltstone feed was well established at the time of the testing. Finally, this assessment of mercury was necessary to inform points in the process operations that may be subject to new separation technologies for the removal of mercury.

12 MANAGEMENT OF RADIOACTIVE AND NON-RADIOACTIVE W↗

Mercury speciation comparison. BrooksApplied Laboratories and Eurofins Frontier Global Sciences

The Savannah River National Laboratory (SRNL) was tasked with preparing and shipping samples for Hg speciation by Eurofins Frontier Global Sciences (FGS), Inc. in Bothell, WA on behalf of the Savannah River Remediation (SRR) Mercury Program Team. These samples were analyzed for seven species including: total mercury, dissolved mercury, inorganic mercury ((Hg(I) and Hg(II)), elemental mercury, methylmercury, ethylmercury, and dimethylmercury, with an eighth species, particulate mercury, calculated from the difference between total and dissolved mercury after subtracting the elemental mercury. The species fraction of total mercury measured has ranged broadly from a low of 32% to a high of 146%, though the vast majority of samples have been <100%. This can be expected since one is summing multiple values that each have at least a ± 20% measurement uncertainty. Two liquid waste tanks particularly important to understanding the distribution of mercury species in the Savannah River Site (SRS) Tank Farm were selected for a round robin analysis by Eurofins FGS and BrooksApplied Laboratories (BAL). The analyses conducted by BAL on the Tank 22 and 38 samples and their agreement with those obtained from Eurofins FGS for total mercury, dissolved mercury, methylmercury, ethylmercury, and dimethylmercury provide a strong degree of confidence in these species measurements

12 MANAGEMENT OF RADIOACTIVE AND NON-RADIOACTIVE W↗

Mercury Phase II Study - Mercury Behavior in Salt Processing Flowsheet

Mercury (Hg) in the Savannah River Site Liquid Waste System (LWS) originated from decades of canyon processing where it was used as a catalyst for dissolving the aluminum cladding of reactor fuel. Approximately 60 metric tons of mercury is currently present throughout the LWS. Mercury has long been a consideration in the LWS, from both hazard and processing perspectives. In February 2015, a Mercury Program Team was established at the request of the Department of Energy to develop a comprehensive action plan for long-term management and removal of mercury. Evaluation was focused in two Phases. Phase I activities assessed the Liquid Waste inventory and chemical processing behavior using a system-by-system review methodology, and determined the speciation of the different mercury forms (Hg+, Hg++, elemental Hg, organomercury, and soluble versus insoluble mercury) within the LWS. Phase II activities are building on the Phase I activities, and results of the LWS flowsheet evaluations will be summarized in three reports: Mercury Behavior in the Salt Processing Flowsheet (i.e. this report); Mercury Behavior in the Defense Waste Processing Facility (DWPF) Flowsheet; and Mercury behavior in the Tank Farm Flowsheet (Evaporator Operations). The evaluation of the mercury behavior in the salt processing flowsheet indicates, inter alia, the following: (1) In the assembled Salt Batches 7, 8 and 9 in Tank 21, the total mercury is mostly soluble with methylmercury (MHg) contributing over 50% of the total mercury. Based on the analyses of samples from 2H Evaporator feed and drop tanks (Tanks 38/43), the source of MHg in Salt Batches 7, 8 and 9 can be attributed to the 2H evaporator concentrate used in assembling the salt batches. The 2H Evaporator is used to evaporate DWPF recycle water. (2) Comparison of data between Tank 21/49, Salt Solution Feed Tank (SSFT), Decontaminated Salt Solution Hold Tank (DSSHT), and Tank 50 samples suggests that the total mercury as well as speciated forms in the assembled salt batches in Tanks 21/49 pass through the Actinide Removal Process (ARP) / Modular Caustic Side Solvent Extraction Unit (MCU) process to Tank 50 with no significant change in the mercury chemistry. (3) In Tank 50, Decontaminated Salt Solution (DSS) from ARP/MCU is the major contributor to the total mercury including MHg. (4) Speciation analyses of TCLP leached solutions of the grout samples prepared from Tank 21, as well as Tank 50 samples, show the majority of the mercury released in the solution is MHg.

12 MANAGEMENT OF RADIOACTIVE AND NON-RADIOACTIVE W↗

Evaluation and Impacts of Mercury in the SRS Liquid Waste System - 16121

The Savannah River Site (SRS) Liquid Waste System (LWS) stores radioactive waste in 43 underground tanks. The radionuclides in the waste are removed through a series of separation processes and the low-level fraction is immobilized in a grout waste form while the high level fraction is disposed in a glass waste form. Mercury originated from decades of canyon processing (used as a catalyst for dissolving the aluminum cladding of reactor fuel) and is present throughout the LWS (∼60 metric tons). Mercury has long been a consideration in the LWS, from both hazard and processing perspectives. Mercury is removed from the LWS in many ways including: 1) the Tank Farm evaporator condensates; 2) at the Defense Waste Processing Facility (DWPF) where it is steam-stripped and removed during the feed preparation processes; 3) it is removed at the Effluent Treatment Plant (ETP); and it is immobilized in the low-level, grout waste form. An integrated, system-wide evaluation and assessment of mercury behavior in the LWS is being performed. The recently completed Phase I evaluation focused on mercury inventory and speciation in the LWS; mercury holdup and chemical processing behavior; mercury impact Identification, including worker safety and equipment degradation; and mercury removal and disposal options. The mercury removal system at the DWPF has been unable to remove mercury successfully due to equipment and chemistry challenges since the 2008 timeframe. Phase I evaluations indicate that approximately 43 percent of the mercury in waste sent to the DWPF is now returning to the Tank Farm in the recycle stream and is concentrating to higher than expected levels (∼500 mg/l) around the 2H evaporator system. The chemical behavior of mercury is further complicated by the formation of higher than expected quantities of organomercury species, specifically methyl mercury, now present in the DWPF recycle evaporator system (2H Tank farm evaporator), which is used to volume-reduce the recycle stream. Phase II activities are building on the Phase I mercury activities, including additional sampling and characterization activities, a re-assessment of overall system knowledge, ranking and prioritizing critical gaps/information in mercury behavior across the flowsheet, assessing impacts of mercury removal and disposal options, and documenting an action plan for overall mercury management in the LWS. Phase II activities include two System Engineering Evaluations to 1) 'Reestablish Mercury removal Capability within DWPF', and 2) 'Determine the Best Alternative Mercury Removal Location with the LWS'. This paper provides the results of the Phase I and II mercury evaluations for the SRS LWS. (authors)

12 MANAGEMENT OF RADIOACTIVE AND NON-RADIOACTIVE W↗

Mercury Speciation in Savannah River Site High-Level Waste: Determination and Implications for Waste Handling and Disposal - 16178

As part of a larger program to address mercury issues at the Savannah River Site, a number of samples from across the salt processing flowsheet have been collected and analyzed for several mercury species. The results indicate the presence of organomercury species, predominately methylmercury cation. This result was not expected, and it represents a significant paradigm shift in the understanding of mercury chemistry in high-level tank waste. Concentrations of total and soluble mercury have been measured as high as 0.5 g/L with methylmercury concentrations of at least fifty percent of that value. The distribution of mercury species being observed have ramifications to waste processing strategies. In particular, the mercury behavior across the cesium solvent extraction process has been examined. Leachates, from toxicity testing of the cementitious waste form used for decontaminated salt waste at Savannah River, have been tested and shows methylmercury as the dominant extractable species. (authors)

12 MANAGEMENT OF RADIOACTIVE AND NON-RADIOACTIVE W↗

Mercury Phase II Study - Mercury Behavior across the High-Level Waste Evaporator System

The Mercury Program team’s effort continues to develop more fundamental information concerning mercury behavior across the liquid waste facilities and unit operations. Previously, the team examined the mercury chemistry across salt processing, including the Actinide Removal Process/Modular Caustic Side Solvent Extraction Unit (ARP/MCU), and the Defense Waste Processing Facility (DWPF) flowsheets. This report documents the data and understanding of mercury across the high level waste 2H and 3H evaporator systems.

12 MANAGEMENT OF RADIOACTIVE AND NON-RADIOACTIVE W↗

Preliminary Assessment of the Low-Temperature Waste Form Technology Coupled with Technetium Removal

The U.S. Department of Energy Office of Environmental Management (EM) is engaging the national laboratories to provide the scientific and technological rigor to support EM program and project planning, technology development and deployment, project execution, and assessment of program outcomes. As an early demonstration of this new responsibility, Pacific Northwest National Laboratory (PNNL) and Savannah River National Laboratory (SRNL) have been chartered to implement a science and technology program addressing low-temperature waste forms for immobilization of DOE aqueous waste streams, including technetium removal as an implementing technology. As a first step, the laboratories examined the technical risks and uncertainties associated with the Cast Stone waste immobilization projects at Hanford. Science and technology needs were identified for work associated with 1) conducting performance assessments and risk assessments of waste form and disposal system performance, and 2) technetium chemistry in tank wastes and separations of technetium from waste processing streams. Technical approaches to address the science and technology needs were identified and an initial sequencing priority was suggested. The following table summarizes the most significant science and technology needs and associated approaches to address those needs. These approaches and priorities will be further refined and developed as strong integrated teams of researchers from national laboratories, contractors, industry, and academia are brought together to provide the best science and technology solutions. Implementation of a science and technology program that addresses these needs by pursuing the identified approaches will have immediate benefits to DOE in reducing risks and uncertainties associated with near-term decisions regarding supplemental immobilization at Hanford. Longer term, the work has the potential for cost savings and for providing a strong technical foundation for future performance assessments at Hanford and across the DOE complex.

12 MANAGEMENT OF RADIOACTIVE AND NON-RADIOACTIVE W↗

Enterprise SRS: leveraging ongoing operations to advance nuclear fuel cycles research and development programs

The Savannah River Site (SRS) is re-purposing its vast array of assets (including H Canyon - a nuclear chemical separation plant) to solve issues regarding advanced nuclear fuel cycle technologies, nuclear materials processing, packaging, storage and disposition. The vehicle for this transformation is Enterprise SRS which presents a new, radical view of SRS as a united endeavor for 'all things nuclear' as opposed to a group of distinct and separate entities with individual missions and organizations. Key among the Enterprise SRS strategic initiatives is the integration of research into SRS facilities but also in other facilities in conjunction with on-going missions to provide researchers from other national laboratories, academic institutions, and commercial entities the opportunity to demonstrate their technologies in a relevant environment and scale prior to deployment. To manage that integration of research demonstrations into site facilities, a center for applied nuclear materials processing and engineering research has been established in SRS.

11 NUCLEAR FUEL CYCLE AND FUEL MATERIALS↗

Enterprise SRS: Leveraging Ongoing Operations to Advance Nuclear Fuel Cycle Programs - 12579

The international leadership in nuclear technology development and deployment long held by the United States has eroded due to the lack of clear national strategies for advanced reactor fuel cycle concepts and for nuclear materials management, as well as to the recent policy decision that halts work on the nuclear fuel repository at Yucca Mountain. Although no national consensus on strategy has yet been reached, a number of recent high-profile reviews and workshops have clearly highlighted a national need for robust research, development and deployment (RD and D) programs in key areas of nuclear technology, especially nuclear separations science and engineering. Collectively, these reviews and workshops provide a picture of the nuclear separations mission needs for three major program offices: Department of Energy Office of-Environmental Management), DOE Office of Nuclear Energy), and the National Nuclear Security Administration (NNSA). While the individual program needs differ significantly in detail and timing, they share common needs in two critical areas of RD and D: - The need for access to and use of multi-purpose engineering-scale demonstration test facilities that can support testing with radioactive material, and - The need for collaborative research enterprises that encompass government research organizations (i.e., national laboratories), commercial industry and the academic community. Such collaborative enterprises effectively integrate theory and modeling with the actual experimental work at all scales, as well as strengthen the technical foundation for research in critical areas. The arguments for engineering-scale collaborative research facilities are compelling. Processing history has shown that test programs and demonstrations conducted with actual nuclear materials are essential to program success. It is widely recognized, however, that such facilities are expensive to build and maintain; creating an imposing, if not prohibitive, financial burden on an individual sponsoring office. Given that reality, success for the current and future nuclear separations missions is dependent on a concerted effort to develop new, creative, approaches that leverage existing facilities in a manner that supports both near- and long-term needs of national programs. As a result of this situation, the Savannah River National Laboratory (SRNL) organized the 'Nuclear Separations User Facility Strategy Session' in Washington, D.C. on July 29, 2011. This workshop brought together key stakeholders from DOE and the private sector to develop a strategy for using engineering-scale nuclear materials processing facilities to advance our nation's nuclear separations research needs. In particular, the meeting focused on recommending how these engineering-scale demonstration facilities, like the Savannah River Site H-Canyon, can be connected with smaller 'bench-scale' research activities to form a seamless approach that integrates across the continuum of RD and D of advanced separations technologies. Coming out of this workshop, a new vision has been developed for a collaborative research facility model that centers on H-Canyon. Unique to this approach is the fact that H-Canyon will continue to accomplish DOE's critical nuclear material processing missions, while simultaneously serving as an RD and D resource for the scientific and technical portions of the nuclear separations community. This paper describes the planned operations for H-Canyon in FY2012 and beyond and discusses how these operations fit within the context of a collaborative research facility model and support the ongoing fuel cycle research and development programs of the DOE. (authors)

12 MANAGEMENT OF RADIOACTIVE AND NON-RADIOACTIVE W↗

SRNL Phase 1 Assessment of the WAC/DQO and Unit Operations for the WTP Waste Qualification Program

The Hanford Tank Waste Treatment and Immobilization Plant (WTP) is currently transitioning its emphasis from a design and construction phase toward start-up and commissioning. With this transition, the WTP Project has initiated more detailed assessments of the requirements related to actual processing of the Hanford Site tank waste. One particular area of interest is the waste qualification program to be implemented to support the WTP. Given the successful implementation of similar waste qualification efforts at the Savannah River Site (SRS), based on critical technical support and guidance from the Savannah River National Laboratory (SRNL), WTP requested the utilization of subject matter experts from SRNL to support a technology exchange to perform a review of the WTP waste qualification program, discuss the general qualification approach at SRS, and to identify critical lessons learned through the support of DWPF's sludge batch qualification efforts. As part of Phase 1, SRNL subject matter experts in critical technical and/or process areas reviewed specific WTP waste qualification information. The Phase 1 review was a collaborative, interactive, and iterative process between the two organizations. WTP provided specific analytical procedures, descriptions of equipment, and general documentation as baseline review material. SRNL subject matter experts reviewed the information and, as appropriate, requested follow-up information or clarification to specific areas of interest. This process resulted in multiple teleconferences with key technical contacts from both organizations resolving technical issues that lead to the results presented in this report. This report provides the results of SRNL's Phase 1 review of the WAC-DQO waste acceptance criteria and processability parameters, and the specific unit operations which are required to support WTP waste qualification efforts. The review resulted in SRNL providing concurrence, alternative methods, or gap identification for the proposed WTP analytical methods or approaches. For the unit operations, the SRNL subject matter experts reviewed WTP concepts compared to what is used at SRS and provided thoughts on the outlined tasks with respect to waste qualification. Also documented in this report are recommendations and an outline on what would be required for the next phase to further mature the WTP waste qualification program.

12 MANAGEMENT OF RADIOACTIVE AND NON-RADIOACTIVE W↗