Model-Based Design of Experiments for Temporal Analysis of Products (TAP): A Simulated Case Study in Oxidative Propane Dehydrogenation
Not Available
Engineering topics
Publications and source records attributed to Yonge, Adam.
Not Available
We present a case study of catalytic propane dehydrogenation with our open-source multiphysics solver, Mesoflow. The solver was developed to simulate reactive flow coupled to heterogeneous catalytic reactions and deactivation in the context of complex, mesoscale geometry. The method leverages cartesian block-structured adaptive mesh refinement to capture realistic catalyst microstructural features acquired directly from X-ray computed tomography data. A kinetic model for propane dehydrogenation and catalyst deactivation was developed based on temporal analysis of products (TAP) reactor experiments. The TAP reactor experiments allow for precise characterization of intrinsic kinetic reaction steps which are implemented into Mesoflow simulations to model the spatial and temporal evolution of reactants, products, and catalyst active sites. The short-term and long-term deactivation behavior is studied by using XCT data collected from fresh and aged catalyst pellets, which exhibit different microstructural features. This study employs time-splitting algorithms to connect disparate reaction and flow timescales, enabling the simulations to achieve realistic deactivation timescales on the order of minutes while the flow time-scales for small particles (100 microns) are several milliseconds. We also introduce a flexible automated python script that writes the necessary files to construct a Mesoflow simulation from user-created chemical mechanisms. We will also introduce a few new features that are added to Mesoflow such as higher order schemes, implicit chemistry integrators and the ability to run on AMD and NVIDIA graphics-processing-units.
The temporal analysis of products (TAP) reactor provides a vast amount of transient kinetic information that may be used to describe a variety of chemical features including residence time distributions, kinetic coefficients, number of active sites, reaction mechanism, etc. However, as with any measurement device, the TAP reactor signal is convoluted with noise and drift is common. In order to reduce the uncertainty of the kinetic measurement and any derived parameters or mechanisms, proper preprocessing must be performed prior to any advanced type of analysis. This preprocessing includes baseline correction, i.e., a shift in the voltage response, and calibration, i.e., a scaling of the flux response based on prior experiments. The traditional methodology of preprocessing requires significant user discretion and reliance on separate calibration experiments that may drift over time. Herein we use machine learning techniques combined with physical constraints to understand the noise and drift that is being generated within and between experiments for enhancement of the chemical kinetic signal. As such, the proposed methodology demonstrates clear benefits over the traditional preprocessing approach by eliminating the need for separate calibration experiments or heuristic input from the user.
The temporal analysis of products (TAP) reactor, a transient kinetic tool, provides users with information as the catalyst state evolves. However, the state of the art for TAP uncertainty quantification only considers the experimental noise present in the outlet flow signal. Additional sources of uncertainty, including, but not limited to, initial surface coverages, the catalyst zone location, the inert void fraction, and the gas pulse intensity and pulse delay, are not included. For this reason, a framework for quantifying all uncertainty sources present in TAP experiments is presented and applied to a carbon monoxide oxidation case study. Herein, two methods for quantifying these sources of uncertainty are introduced. The first utilizes initial state sensitivities to approximate the parameter variances, as well as to provide insights into the structural certainty of the model. The second generates parameter confidence distributions through an ensemble-based sampling algorithm. This initial state covariance matrix can ultimately be merged with the experimental noise covariance matrix, providing a unified description of the parameter uncertainties for a single TAP experiment.
Not Available
Cu-based alloy catalysts have recently been investigated experimentally for the hydrodeoxygenation (HDO) of biomass-derived organic acids. Here, the HDO of propanoic acid (PAc) has been studied over Cu(111) by mean-field microkinetic modeling based on parameters obtained from first-principles calculations. Models were developed for the gas- and liquid-phase HDO in condensed water and 1,4-dioxane. In agreement with experimental observations, the gas-phase PAc conversion rate is low at 573 K and increases in liquid water by 1 order of magnitude. In all reaction environments, the decarboxylation mechanism is dominant at low hydrogen partial pressures less than 0.1 bar, and the C–COO bond dissociation is the rate-controlling elementary step. This observation contrasts with the rate-controlling step identified over most group VIII metal surfaces, which is the C–OH bond dissociation in the decarbonylation mechanism. At high hydrogen (H 2 ) partial pressures greater than 10 bar, the HDO of PAc produces propionaldehyde that can readsorb and further react through decarbonylation to produce C 2 alkane products, which is conceptually different from the low H 2 partial pressure scenario. At high H 2 partial pressures, the initial hydrogenation at the carbonyl carbon of PAc becomes the rate-controlling elementary step.
TAPsolver is a python package, which automates TAP simulation and analysis routines. TAPsolver is built around the python packages FEniCS and Dolfin-Adjoint, which help take advantage of model adjoints to provide automatic derivatives. TAPsolver is flexible, with reaction mechanisms and rate constants that can be set through input files that allow users to take advantage of the different functionalities, which include sensitivity analyses, parameter optimization and uncertainty quantification.
TAPsolver is a python package, which automates TAP simulation and analysis routines. TAPsolver is built around the python packages FEniCS and Dolfin-Adjoint, which help take advantage of model adjoints to provide automatic derivatives. TAPsolver is flexible, with reaction mechanisms and rate constants that can be set through input files that allow users to take advantage of the different functionalities, which include sensitivity analyses, parameter optimization and uncertainty quantification.
The effect of two solvents, liquid water and 1,4-dioxane, has been studied from first principles on the hydrodeoxygenation of propionic acid over a Ni (111) catalyst surface model. A mean-field microkinetic model was developed to investigate these effects at a temperature of 473 K. Under all reaction conditions, a decarbonylation mechanism is favored significantly over a decarboxylation pathway. Although no significant solvent effects were observed on the decarbonylation rate, a substantial solvent stabilization of two key surface intermediates in the decarboxylation mechanism, CH 3 CCOO and CH 3 CHCOO, lead to a notable increase of the decarboxylation rate by two orders of magnitude in liquid water and by one order of magnitude in liquid 1,4-dioxane. Furthermore, a significant solvent stabilization of the transition state of C-H bond cleavage of the α-carbon of CH 3 CHCO, relative to the stabilization of the C-C bond cleavage of the α-carbon of CH 3 CHCO, leads to a change in dominant pathway in the liquid phase environments. Finally, a sensitivity analysis shows that the C-OH bond cleavage of propionic acid and C-C bond cleavage of the α-carbon of CH 3 CHCO are the most rate controlling states in the gas phase. In contrast, in solvents the dehydrogenation of CH 3 CHCO becomes the most influential step. This shift in rate controlling state is attributed to the solvent effect on the dehydrogenation of CH 3 CHCO, which is facilitated in aqueous phase. Altogether, it is likely that the investigated (111) facet of Ni is not active for the hydrodeoxygenation of propionic acid in neither the gas nor liquid phase and other Ni facets or phases must be responsible for the experimentally observed kinetics.
Computational catalyst discovery involves identification of a meaningful model and suitable descriptors that determine the catalyst properties. We study the impact of combining various descriptors (e.g., reaction energies, metal descriptors, and bond counts) for modeling transition-state energies (TS) based on a database of adsorption and TS energies across transition-metal surfaces for the decarboxylation and decarbonylation of propionic acid, a chemistry characteristic for biomass conversion. Results of different machine learning models for more than 1572 descriptor combinations suggest that there is no statistically significant difference between linear and nonlinear models when using the right combination of reactant energies, metal descriptors, and bond counts. However, linear models are inferior when not including bond count and metal descriptors. In conclusion, when there are missing data for reaction steps on all metals, conventional linear scaling is inferior to linear and nonlinear models with proper choice of descriptors that are surprisingly robust.