Search NASA⌕ Search

Engineering topics

Zoelle, Alexander

Publications and source records attributed to Zoelle, Alexander.

Insights from FEED studies for retrofitting existing fossil power plants with carbon capture technology

Recent United States Department of Energy (DOE) sponsored front-end engineering design (FEED) studies for retrofitting existing fossil-fueled power plants with state-of-the-art carbon capture technology contain previously overlooked real-world design considerations for near-term deployment of carbon capture. Insights from examining seven recently published FEED study reports are summarized in this paper. This includes a discussion of the design, performance, and cost implications associated with (1) location-specific considerations such as water availability, land availability, and accessibility; (2) host-plant-specific factors such as flue gas specifications, allowable degree of integration between the capture system and host plant, and operational mode; and (3) miscellaneous factors such as market conditions, permitting requirements, and business case incentives. In conclusion, this manuscript highlights (1) water availability as a key design and cost driver, with host plant steam extraction increasing capture system cooling water availability, (2) modularization and constructability impacts on the number of capture trains, (3) the impacts of host plant operational mode and capacity factor on the business case for installing capture, and (4) the merit of continued research, development, and demonstration efforts addressing steam extraction, host plant tie-in at the stack, solvent reclamation and air emissions control.

32 ENERGY CONSERVATION, CONSUMPTION, AND UTILIZATI↗

Research goals for minimizing the cost of CO 2 capture when using steam methane reforming for hydrogen production

This paper presents a techno-economic assessment of adding state-of-the-art solvent-based CO 2 capture technologies to greenfield steam methane reforming (SMR)-based H 2 production plants and quantifies the impacts of improvements in CO 2 capture technology. Current conventional capture technologies are reviewed, and future technologies in intermediate and long-term scenarios are analyzed. The results show that adding significantly more efficient solvent-based capture technologies leads to an equivalent rate of natural gas consumption as that of a conventional SMR plant without capture, despite capturing most of the CO 2 and producing the same amount of H 2 . Overall, improvements in reboiler duty and reductions in capital costs can significantly reduce the cost of H 2 production and cost of capture. Particularly, the reboiler duty of pre-combustion capture and the capital cost of post-combustion capture have the greatest impact. Based on the results, research goals are suggested. Solvent development is recommended—particularly pre-combustion solvents—for reducing the reboiler duties, and process schemes to reduce the capital costs. Costlier but more efficient solvents can be considered. A sensitivity analysis using natural gas price shows that technological improvements can reduce the impacts of high natural gas prices. The degree of economic feasibility of CO 2 capture increases with improvements to the capture technology.

08 HYDROGEN↗

Quality Guidelines for Energy System Studies: Performing a Techno-Economic Analysis for Carbon Conversion Technologies (Final Report)

This document provides DOE-FECM specific guidance for conducting techno-economic analysis (TEA) on carbon conversion technologies using NETL's established TEA methodology. The intent is to provide guidance to develop a consistent methodology for evaluating carbon conversion technologies within the DOE-FECM portfolio. The document provides guidance on the analysis methodology, evaluation metrics including performance, cost, emissions, and market considerations, and ample references to guide the end user in the development of consistent TEA of carbon conversion technologies.

29 ENERGY PLANNING, POLICY, AND ECONOMY↗

Cost and Performance Projections for Coal- and Natural Gas-Fired Power Plants

This report provides quantitative estimates of future cost and performance improvements for fossil-fueled power plants equipped with carbon capture developed through the adaption/modification of relevant Aspen Plus ® case study models from published NETL techno-economic analyses. The cost and performance estimates in this report are meant to represent prospective improvements that may be realized for low-carbon-emitting PC and NGCC power plants through robust commercial deployment (e.g., learning by doing) of high TRL technologies as well as additional investments in targeted RD&D activities. The methodology used to develop the estimates in this report is intended to allow direct comparison of the technology improvements with the SOA baseline published in NETL’s Fossil Energy Baseline (Rev 4a) Report.

20 FOSSIL-FUELED POWER PLANTS↗

Cost and Performance Baseline for Fossil Energy Plants Volume 1: Bituminous Coal and Natural Gas to Electricity

This revised report presents an independent assessment of the cost and performance of select fossil energy power systems—integrated gasification combined cycle (IGCC), pulverized coal (PC), and natural gas combined cycle (NGCC) plants—using a systematic, transparent technical and economic approach. The cost and performance of fossil fuel-based generation technologies represented in this report (and the series at large) are important inputs to assessments and determinations of technology combinations to be utilized to meet the projected demands of future power markets. In addition to informing technology comparisons, the reference plant configurations found in this report provide perspective for regulators and policy makers. From a research and development perspective, this report is used to assess goals and metrics and to provide a consistent basis for comparing developing technologies.

01 COAL, LIGNITE, AND PEAT↗

Direct Air Capture Case Studies: Solvent System

This case study provides cost and performance estimates for a solvent-based direct air capture (DAC) system at varying scales. The performance of the DAC system is largely based upon vendor performance while the costs of the system were developed as independently as possible. This study is representative of an example DAC system configuration and is not an optimized design.

42 ENGINEERING↗

Direct Air Capture Case Studies: Sorbent System

This report serves as an independent assessment of the performance and cost of a generic sorbent-based direct air capture (DAC) system. The sorbent considered is not reflective of any one material type or functionalization approach; rather, it represents an approximate average of reported material performance in the literature. The system configuration represents what was judged to be the most reasonable configuration if these systems were to be deployed in the near term.

42 ENGINEERING↗

Quality Guidelines for Energy System Studies: Capital Cost Scaling Methodology (Revision 4 Report)

NETL regularly updates legacy analysis with new studies as the Department of Energy objectives change, technology performance improves, costs are reduced, regulations change, market drivers are established, fuel prices fluctuate, and any number of other relevant factors vary in the market. As legacy studies are updated by NETL, the underlying performance and cost of the cases changes, and the methods for interpreting and scaling the cost estimates change. Therefore, it is important that NETL maintain public guidance documents associated with different sets of cost estimates that delineate how a specific set should be scaled. This QGESS report, providing guidance on capital cost scaling, should generally be applied to NETL case costs included in the report “Cost and Performance Baseline for Fossil Energy Plants Volume 1: Bituminous Coal and Natural Gas to Electricity Revision 4” (BBR4), or any cases derived from the cases presented in the referenced report.

29 ENERGY PLANNING, POLICY, AND ECONOMY↗

Quality Guidelines for Energy System Studies: Process Modeling Design Parameters

The National Energy Technology Laboratory (NETL) conducts systems analysis studies that require a large number of inputs, from ambient conditions to parameters for Aspen Plus® (Aspen) process blocks. The sheer number of assumptions required makes it impractical to document all of them in each issued report. The purpose of this section of the Quality Guidelines for Energy System Studies (QGESS) is to document the assumptions most commonly used in system analysis studies and the basis for those assumptions. In order to develop the systems analysis models presented in various NETL reports, significant vendor data has been obtained, and this data enhances the model outputs. Much of the vendor data obtained is considered proprietary and not suitable for public release, or attribution to a specific vendor. As such, several sub-systems common in NETL reports and their processparameter data are not reported in this document to protect proprietary vendor information.

42 ENGINEERING↗

Alternative Scenarios to Meet the Requirements of the Carbon Pollution Standards for New, Coal-Fueled Plants without Carbon Capture (Final Report)

The objective of this study was to characterize the performance and cost of newly constructed coal-fired power plants capable of meeting the Carbon Pollution Standard, without the use of carbon capture and sequestration (CCS). The specific configurations that were investigated are combined heat and power applications, and coal-fired power plants co-firing natural gas in the boiler. The reference coal plants, or technology base cases, considered include supercritical (SC) pulverized coal (PC), advanced ultra-supercritical (AUSC) PC, and IGCC plants. The reference cases considered are taken from the report "Cost and Performance Baseline for Fossil Energy Plants Volume 1: Bituminous Coal and Natural Gas to Electricity Revision 3."

20 FOSSIL-FUELED POWER PLANTS↗

Cost and Performance Baseline for Fossil Energy Plants Volume 1b: Bituminous Coal (IGCC) to Electricity Revision 2b – Year Dollar Update

This report presents the cost and performance results of an assessment of seven integrated gasification combined cycle (IGCC) plants. The primary value of this report lies not in the absolute accuracy of the capital cost estimates for the individual cases (estimated to be -15 percent/+30), but in the application of a consistent approach to allow meaningful comparisons of relative costs among the cases evaluated.

01 COAL, LIGNITE, AND PEAT↗

Cost and Performance Baseline for Fossil Energy Plants Volume 1a: Bituminous Coal (PC) and Natural Gas to Electricity (Rev. 3)

This report presents the cost and performance results of pulverized coal (PC) and natural gas combined cycle (NGCC) plants, using a consistent technical and economic approach that reflects current market conditions. The primary value of this report lies not in the absolute accuracy of the capital cost estimates for the individual cases (estimated to be -15%/+30%), but in application of a consistent approach to allow meaningful comparisons of relative costs among the cases evaluated.

01 COAL, LIGNITE, AND PEAT↗

Quality Guide Energy System Studies: Performing a Techno-economic Analysis for Power Generation Plants

The QGESS: Performing a Techno-Economic Analysis for Power Generation Plants provides guidelines on performing a techno-economic analysis (TEA) of power generation processes. The report includes guidance on preparing a technology analysis plan (TAP), a design basis, performing the technical analysis, performing the economic analysis, and information that should be reported. This guideline references numerous reports that provide examples of TEAs and provides a short description of most of the QGESS reports listed on this web page that provide useful information for specific aspects of performing a TEA.

20 FOSSIL-FUELED POWER PLANTS↗

Quality Guide Energy System Studies: Introduction to Performing a Techno-Economic Analysis for Power Generation Plants

The QGESS: Performing a Techno-Economic Analysis for Power Generation Plants provides guidelines on performing a techno-economic analysis (TEA) of power generation processes. The report includes guidance on preparing a technology analysis plan (TAP), a design basis, performing the technical analysis, performing the economic analysis, and information that should be reported. This guideline references numerous reports that provide examples of TEAs and provides a short description of most of the QGESS reports listed on this web page that provide useful information for specific aspects of performing a TEA.

20 FOSSIL-FUELED POWER PLANTS↗

Cost and Performance Metrics Used to Assess Carbon Utilization and Storage Technologies

The report presents a diverse set of twelve metrics grouped under the subheadings of performance, cost, emissions, market, and safety that have been developed for use in comparing and/or screening CO 2 utilization projects and technologies. Utilization technologies could involve the chemical conversion of CO 2 into valued products such as polycarbonate plastics, or the integration of CO 2 into products such as cement or concrete.

37 INORGANIC, ORGANIC, PHYSICAL, AND ANALYTICAL CH↗