Comparative accuracy of selected multiple scattering approximations

Abstract

Doubling method computational results which have yielded plane albedo, total transmission and fractional absorption for plane-parallel atmospheres composed of cloud droplets are presently compared with data obtained with selected radiative transfer approximations. The relative and absolute accuracies of asymptotic theory for thick layers and delta-Eddington, Meador-Weaver (1980) and Coakley-Chylek (1975) approximations are compared as a function of optical thickness, solar zenith angle, and single scattering albedo. The delta-Eddington approximation is the most accurate for conservative scattering when the solar zenith angle is small, while Meador-Weaver is the most accurate for nonconservative scattering.