Effect of Electronic Shot Noise on Dynamic Measurements using Optical Techniques: Examples from Rayleigh Scattering and Unsteady PSP

Abstract

Electronic shot noise is an unavoidable reality in all optical techniques that depend on measuring light intensity. For steady-state, time-averaged measurements the impact of shot noise can be easily reduced by increasing the exposure time, or by averaging over multiple-exposures. That is not the case for unsteady measurements, where time histories of light intensity variations need to be created either by high-speed photography (unsteady PSP) or via photoelectron counting (spectrally resolved Rayleigh scattering) over short time durations using a photo-multiplier tube (PMT) and photon counting electronics. Electronic shot noise introduces a fixed amount of random error, which can overwhelm the light intensity variation caused by turbulent fluctuations. Spectrum computed from such time series shows a fixed noise floor that is independent of the number of data points in the time series. For a fixed optical system, where the collected power of the luminescent light (uPSP), or the scattered light (Rayleigh) is fixed, one needs to resort to special techniques to obtain enough signal-to noise ratio (SNR). For the uPSP application it is shown that averaging of the adjacent pixels improves SNR; although this may lead to a sacrifice of spatial resolution. A second means is to increase the exposure time, which leads to a lowering of the frequency range. For the Rayleigh application, improvements of SNR can be achieved via two different cross-correlation based approaches. The first involves measuring the light intensity using two PMTs using short, contiguous gates; thereby, creating two time-series of data. The second one involves collecting one long time-series of data using one set of measurement device, followed by an odd-even splitting into two time series. When the two time-series are cross-correlated, and a power spectrum is calculated, a significant reduction in the shot noise floor can be achieved. Examples from measurements of density and velocity fluctuations spectra from two different Rayleigh setup are presented to demonstrate the process.