Mesosiderite Silicates vs. HED Polymict Breccias

Abstract

The silicate portions of mesosiderites are broadly like howardites [1], and this has led to persistent interpretations that mesosiderites and howardites are derived from the same parent asteroid [2]. Yet, when examined carefully, one finds that there are substantial petrological and compositional differences between these polymict breccias. These differences indicate that separate parent asteroids are more probable [3, 4]. I will document the distinctions between these groups based on my data and literature information [5] and discuss their origins.