Si-Cr-Al-Mn Alloy for High Specific Resistivity

Abstract

Laboratory material produced in budget period one met the target resistivity, mechanical and magnetic requirements for the Go/No-Go decision to move to industrial trials. The chosen chemistry settled on a high Cr strategy, with moderate Mn and Al additions, providing a good comprise on core loss and induction with minimal impact on mechanical properties, important to successful downstream processing. Industrial trials began in budget period two with the chosen chemistry, referred to as Alloy X. Difficulties occurred during initial hot rolling trials. Reheating the material using the standard NOES practice caused slab cracking from high thermal gradients in areas exposed to the roof burners, this was solved using a modified reheat practice. High Cr caused poor dynamic recrystallization during hot rolling, which was solved using a modified hot rolling practice. The high Cr content of the steel also caused poor decarburization during final annealing, which necessitated lowering the melt carbon aim for the final heat, together with a modified decarburization practice. Steel was finished to final thicknesses of 0.20 – 0.50 mm and evaluated for magnetic and mechanical properties. Although the target core loss for the 0.25 and 0.35 mm material was not achieved, significant reductions in high frequency core loss were measured, compared to equivalent commercially available material. Alloy X at 0.35 mm showed a 26 % and 23 % improvement at 400 HZ and 1000 Hz respectively, over Cliffs’ M-19 (0.35 mm) commercially available NOES. At 0.25 mm, Alloy X showed a 23 % and a 26 % improvement at 400 HZ and 1000 Hz respectively, over Cliffs’ HF-10 (0.25 mm) commercially available NOES. The 0.25 mm product was chosen for motor efficiency evaluation. ORNL collaborated with Cleveland-Cliffs (CC) to build, assemble, and test two 5HP motors: a baseline motor with M19 steel and a motor made with high efficiency steel (Alloy X) developed for the project. Overall, results were as expected with comparable performance at low speeds, and with more than 8% efficiency improvement for high speeds. Increased motor steel efficiency at high frequencies not only results in direct efficiency improvements but can yield reductions in motor size and cost by facilitating higher operation speeds, or by increasing the number of poles in the machine. This allows the production of more power-dense motors which are sometimes avoided with conventional material due to increased core losses. The material developed on this project provides more viable options for achieving improved motor efficiency or reduced motor size and cost.