Comment on “Nonideal Fields Solve the Injection Problem in Relativistic Reconnection”

Abstract

Sironi (hereafter S22) reported the correlation between high-energy particles and their crossings of regions with electric field larger than magnetic field (E > B regions) in kinetic simulations of relativistic magnetic reconnection. They claim that E > B regions (for vanishing guide fields) accelerate particles to the injection energy γ inj ~ σ (magnetization). S22 shows that if test particles are reset to low energies in E > B regions, injection is suppressed. Here, we reexamine these claims using a simulation resembling the reference case in S22 with no guide field. We show that E > B regions contribute very little to injection (~ 10% γ inj ) as they only host particles for a short duration. The energization before any E > B crossings has a comparable contribution, indicating E > B regions are not unique for pre-acceleration. A new test-particle simulation that zeroes out E during E > B does not strongly influence injection. We suggest that the procedure to exclude E > B acceleration in S22 partly removes acceleration outside E > B, leading to a false conclusion.