Correlating Nb-SRF Surface Processing with Evolution of Surface Electronic States

Abstract

The few nanometers of the surface exposed to RF field plays a major role in defining the RF performance of superconducting cavities. Over the past two decades, several pioneering surface treatment and processing methods have emerged, enabling remarkable improvements in cavity performance by simultaneously achieving high Q with increasing Eacc. These processing methods include: thermal treatment under ultra-high vacuum (UHV) conditions across lo¬¬¬¬¬¬¬w-, mid-, and high-temperature ranges and high temperature treatments under controlled N2 atmosphere. These processes also produce distinct surface oxide configurations with different valence states, thicknesses, and uniformity, as well as different oxygen concentration profiles in bulk Nb. In this work, we are trying to understand how do surface-processing methods and the resulting oxide/oxygen profiles affect the electronic structure of surface and the mechanism of superconductivity? With the help of Fermilab’s in-house X-ray photoemission facility and, in collaboration with the synchrotron-based angle-resolved photoemission (ARPES) facility at Argonne National Laboratory, we are investigating how the valence band structure and density of states (DoS) near the Fermi level modify with different surface treatments. Our observations show that different surface-processing methods lead to distinct evolutions of the valence-band states near the Fermi level during the superconducting transition. This behavior suggests variations in Nb-O orbital hybridizations and points towards the possibility of different underlying mechanisms of superconductivity governed by the surface chemistry and oxide configuration. We also correlate these distinct superconducting mechanisms with RF cavity performance, specifically focusing on measured surface resistance, the nature of the Q-slope, and quench fields observed in SRF measurements. These results will enable us to identify the potential limiting factors and relevant controllable parameters that can be further optimized to improve the performance of SRF cavities.