Assessing the Limitations of Self-Interaction-Corrected Functionals for Describing the Hydrated Electron

Abstract

Simulating the hydrated electron using density functional theory is challenging due to the prevalence of self-interaction error in standard functionals. Hybrid functionals like PBEh(40) can reasonably describe the chemistry of an excess electron in water and partially mitigate self-interaction error by incorporating exact Hartree–Fock exchange, but they are computationally expensive making them impractical for large-scale and long-time ab initio molecular dynamics simulations. Explicit self-interaction correction schemes that are applied on an orbital-by-orbital basis offer a potential alternative when the correction is limited to the singly occupied molecular orbital obtained with a generalized gradient approximation functional. Here, we examine whether the Perdew–Zunger self-interaction correction scheme applied to the revPBE functional can provide a computationally efficient and physically sensible alternative to PBEh(40) for the hydrated electron. We find that functionals incorporating a self-interaction correction scheme should be viewed with caution when applied to the hydrated electron and its reactivity. Furthermore, we show that it is critical to consider extensive sampling and diverse chemical environments when validating their performance.