Search NASA⌕ Search

SEARCH · Search NASA

Results for “Comparative Study”

Search indexed NASA NTRS and DOE OSTI research on propulsion, heat transfer, battery materials and energy systems. Follow report and document links to the original sources.

Quote a phrase for an exact phrase match. Source license links do not imply unrestricted reuse.

At least 181 records · Page 10
All sourcesNASA NTRSDOE OSTI
NASA NTRS2004

What Multilevel Parallel Programs do when you are not Watching: A Performance Analysis Case Study Comparing MPI/OpenMP, MLP, and Nested OpenMP

With the current trend in parallel computer architectures towards clusters of shared memory symmetric multi-processors, parallel programming techniques have evolved that support parallelism beyond a single level. When comparing the performance of applications based on different programming paradigms, it is important to differentiate between the influence of the programming model itself and other factors, such as implementation specific behavior of the operating system (OS) or architectural issues. Rewriting-a large scientific application in order to employ a new programming paradigms is usually a time consuming and error prone task. Before embarking on such an endeavor it is important to determine that there is really a gain that would not be possible with the current implementation. A detailed performance analysis is crucial to clarify these issues. The multilevel programming paradigms considered in this study are hybrid MPI/OpenMP, MLP, and nested OpenMP. The hybrid MPI/OpenMP approach is based on using MPI [7] for the coarse grained parallelization and OpenMP [9] for fine grained loop level parallelism. The MPI programming paradigm assumes a private address space for each process. Data is transferred by explicitly exchanging messages via calls to the MPI library. This model was originally designed for distributed memory architectures but is also suitable for shared memory systems. The second paradigm under consideration is MLP which was developed by Taft. The approach is similar to MPi/OpenMP, using a mix of coarse grain process level parallelization and loop level OpenMP parallelization. As it is the case with MPI, a private address space is assumed for each process. The MLP approach was developed for ccNUMA architectures and explicitly takes advantage of the availability of shared memory. A shared memory arena which is accessible by all processes is required. Communication is done by reading from and writing to the shared memory.

Jost, Gabriele↗
NASA NTRS1992

A comparative study of two codes with an improved two-equation turbulence model for predicting jet plumes

Compressible jet plumes were studied using a two-equation turbulence model. A space marching procedure based on an upwind numerical scheme was used to solve the governing equations and turbulence transport equations. The computed results indicate that extending the space marching procedure for solving supersonic/subsonic mixing problems can be stable, efficient and accurate. Moreover, a newly developed correction for compressible dissipation has been verified in fully expanded and underexpanded jet plumes. For a sonic jet plume, no improvement in results over the standard two-equation model was seen. However for a supersonic jet plume, the correction due to compressible dissipation successfully predicted the reduced spreading rate of the jet compared to the sonic case. The computed results were generally in good agreement with the experimental data.

Balakrishnan, L.↗
NASA NTRSDate not supplied

A Comparative Study of Contrail Frequency Indices and GOES-16 Contrail Data Set

Contrail formations have been shown to contribute to the greenhouse effect: they are practically transparent to incoming solar radiation and do little to reflect heat away from Earth but are highly effective at trapping heat within Earth’s atmosphere. To understand the impact contrails have on climate change, contrail frequency indices (CFIs) can be used as a method to quantify aircraft-induced persistent contrails. These indices are capable of tracking long-term contrail formation and identify regions of airspace with the highest contrail formation rates. In this aper, an algorithm is proposed which is capable of using NASA Sherlock and Global Forecast System (GFS) datasets and computing CFIs over large geographic regions and long temporal intervals using NASA Ames’ High-End Computing Capability (HECC) supercomputing system. CFIs are computed using nowcast weather data and previously flown flight tracks. This paper calculated the CFIs of all twenty Air Route Traffic Control Centers in the National Airspace System on October 28th, 2019 and compared the distribution of non-zero CFIs with observed contrail data collected from GOES-16 Satellite data in order to assess the accuracy of the CFI system as a contrail prediction model. It was ultimately determined that the computed CFIs were broadly distributed in the same way as the GOES-16 contrail data and that the individual CFIs computed at the latitude/longitude points at which GOES-16 contrail masks were available had high precision and recall (at 0.75 and 0.86 respectively). While these validation results bode well for the accuracy of the CFI method, the number of provided GOES-16 masks was quite small. Future work should aim to increase the size of the GOES-16 dataset in order to perform a more comprehensive comparison between these two datasets.

Contrails↗
NASA NTRSDate not supplied

A Comparative Study of Contrail Frequency Indices and GOES-16 Contrail Data Set

Contrail formations have been shown to contribute to the greenhouse effect: they are practically transparent to incoming solar radiation and do little to reflect heat away from Earth but are highly effective at trapping heat within Earth’s atmosphere. To understand the impact contrails have on climate change, contrail frequency indices (CFIs) can be used as a method to quantify aircraft-induced persistent contrails. These indices are capable of tracking long-term contrail formation and identify regions of airspace with the highest contrail formation rates. In this aper, an algorithm is proposed which is capable of using NASA Sherlock and Global Forecast System (GFS) datasets and computing CFIs over large geographic regions and long temporal intervals using NASA Ames’ High-End Computing Capability (HECC) supercomputing system. CFIs are computed using nowcast weather data and previously flown flight tracks. This paper calculated the CFIs of all twenty Air Route Traffic Control Centers in the National Airspace System on October 28th, 2019 and compared the distribution of non-zero CFIs with observed contrail data collected from GOES-16 Satellite data in order to assess the accuracy of the CFI system as a contrail prediction model. It was ultimately determined that the computed CFIs were broadly distributed in the same way as the GOES-16 contrail data and that the individual CFIs computed at the latitude/longitude points at which GOES-16 contrail masks were available had high precision and recall (at 0.75 and 0.86 respectively). While these validation results bode well for the accuracy of the CFI method, the number of provided GOES-16 masks was quite small. Future work should aim to increase the size of the GOES-16 dataset in order to perform a more comprehensive comparison between these two datasets.

Contrails↗
NASA NTRS1988

Comparative study of cross-field and field-aligned electron beams in active experiments

Beam-plasma interactions associated with the cross-field and field-aligned injection of electron beams from spacecraft were investigated using a two-dimensional (three velocity component) electrostatic particle simulations. It is shown that the beam properties and plasma response can be characterized well by the ratio between the stagnation time and the plasma response time, which depends on the ratio of the ambient plasma density to the beam density, the beam width, the beam energy, and the spacecraft length. It was found that the beams injected across the field lines tend to lose their coherence after about one or two gyrations due to space-charge oscillations induced by the beam, irrespective of the spacecraft charging. These oscillations scatter the beam electrons into a hollow cylinder of a radius equal to a beam electron gyroradius and thickness of the order of two beam Debye lengths. Parallel injected beams are subjected to similar oscillations, which cause the beam to expand to fill a solid cylinder of a comparable thickness.

Winglee, R. M.↗
DOE OSTI2026

Electron beam irradiation effects on bulk metals: a comparative study of polycrystalline versus single-crystalline structures

This study investigates the effects of electron beam (e-beam) irradiation on the mechanical and structural properties of eight bulk metallic samples, comprising both polycrystalline (PC) and single-crystalline (SC) forms of Ni, Cr, V, and Ti. These metals were evaluated as potential candidates for beam exit windows in high-power (MW-class) particle accelerators. The primary objective is to identify metals capable of withstanding the conditions of high-power/MW-class e-beam accelerators and serve effectively as exit windows. Selection criteria were based on each metal’s intrinsic properties, power dissipation capability, and irradiation-induced changes in mechanical behavior, including hardness, elastic modulus, and defect density. Comprehensive characterization was conducted using field-emission scanning electron microscopy (FESEM), atomic force microscopy (AFM), scanning electron microscopy with energy-dispersive X-ray spectroscopy (SEM–EDS), X-ray diffraction (XRD), high-resolution transmission electron microscopy (HRTEM), selected area electron diffraction (SAED), and nanoindentation, performed both before and after exposure to a ~¿66 kGy dose from a 10 MeV e-beam accelerator. Results revealed that e-beam irradiation induced hardening in PC Ni, whereas PC Ti, commonly used in beam exit windows, exhibited softening. The observed softening in PC Ti is attributed to grain coarsening, elongation, and the formation of twins and twin boundaries, in contrast to the smaller, compressed grains in the pristine (Pr) PC Ti samples, consistent with the Hall–Petch relationship. The stresses due to twinning are small and insignificant in influencing the overall hardening of the PC Ti irradiated sample when compared to the stresses due to the dislocation density. Conversely, SC Ti samples exhibited irradiation-induced hardening. The SC Ti irradiated samples developed additional irradiation-induced modifications in crystallographic texture of (100), (101), (110), (200), (112), (004), and (211) as evidenced from the XRD results, which could probably explain the hardening effect that is caused by irradiation.

36 MATERIALS SCIENCE↗
DOE OSTI2026

A Comprehensive Comparative Study of Active Learning Schemes for Nanophotonics Design

We present a benchmarking study of active learning (AL) schemes for designing planar multilayer nanophotonic metamaterials, where the design tasks are formulated as binary optimization problems. Different surrogate models, including factorization machine (FM), Gaussian process regression (GPR), and convolutional neural network (CNN), combined with different optimization methods, including exhaustive enumeration, discrete particle swarm optimization (DPSO), quantum annealing (QA), hybrid QA, and simulated annealing are studied. The benchmark cases investigated range from small problems with short binary lengths (N = 25) to large problems with N up to 100, focusing on the design of two classes of photonic structures, including antireflective coatings for the long-wavelength infrared region and transparent radiative coolers. For small problems, CNN coupled with DPSO in AL achieves the best performance. As N increases, FM with QA outperforms GPR and CNN. For FM-based AL, hybrid QA yields the best optimization results, particularly in high-dimensional cases (N = 100). These results demonstrate that the optimization method can significantly affect in AL performance as N increases, and that QA-based optimization can provide practical routes for mitigating the optimization bottleneck in high-dimensional problems.

Jung, Serang [Kyung Hee University, Korea]↗
DOE OSTI2025

Comparative Study of Solvatomorphs of Stryker's Reagent Using MicroED and Quantum Mechanics

Abstract The atomic position of hydrogen atoms in metal hydrides has been a long‐standing structural question in inorganic chemistry given that hydride delivery is integral to diverse chemical reactions. Microcrystal electron diffraction (microED), with it's increased sensitivity toward hydrogen atoms relative to X‐ray diffraction, offers a potential path to addressing this challenge. Herein, the first microED study of Stryker's reagent is reported, resulting in the structure of a new benzene solvate. Improved accuracy for hydrogen atom positions was obtained via a quantum crystallography (QCr) approach, Hirshfeld atom refinement (HAR). Structural and topological analysis supports edge bridging hydrides in the microED structure of a THF solvate form, consistent with previous diffraction studies. Interestingly, analysis of a new benzene solvate, discovered in this study, is consistent with mixed edge‐ and face‐bridging hydrides.

Jha, Kunal K. [Division of Chemistry &amp, Chemica↗
DOE OSTI2026

A Comparative Study of Ethanol Upgrading to Butadiene Over Rare Earth Elements Incorporated in Dealuminated Beta Zeolites

Copper and rare earth element-containing dealuminated Beta zeolites (CuREE/deAlBeta) are promising catalysts for the conversion of ethanol to C 3+ olefins en route to sustainable aviation fuel. Product selectivities over CuREE/deAlBeta depend on the identity of the REE. Here, in this study, a suite of La/deAlBeta catalysts of varied La loading are prepared, and their reactivities, selectivities, and apparent C-C coupling kinetics in the cascade reaction between ethanol and acetaldehyde are reported. Ex situ and in situ titrations to quantify Lewis acidic La sites quantify distinct numbers of sites, suggesting a distribution of site types. Across a series of REE/deAlBeta catalysts (REE = Y, La, Lu, Yb, Gd), the selectivity to secondary products correlates with the pyridine heats of adsorption at REE Lewis acid sites. The turnover frequency (per Lewis acid site) for C–C coupling was similar across the series of REE/deAlBeta catalysts. Y/deAlBeta and La/deAlBeta, which have the most disparate secondary product selectivities, had similar kinetics for C–C coupling. These findings demonstrate the complexity of quantifying active sites in REE/deAlBeta zeolites, and the sensitivity of the selectivity, but not the reactivity for C–C coupling, to the identity of the REE atom in REE/deAlBeta zeolites.

alcohol upgrading↗
DOE OSTI2025

Comparative studies of cross-phase dynamics in turbulent momentum flux and particle flux at the tokamak edge

Turbulent transport events, including turbulent transport flux of momentum (i.e., turbulent momentum flux or Reynolds stress) and turbulent transport flux of particle (i.e., turbulent particle flux), have important effects on the confinement performance of magnetic confinement fusion devices. Poloidal Reynolds stress is the ensemble average of the product of radial velocity fluctuations and poloidal velocity fluctuations, i.e., $\langle {\widetilde{v}}_{r}{\widetilde{v}}_{\theta }\rangle$. Turbulent particle flux is the ensemble average of the product of radial velocity fluctuations and density fluctuations, i.e., $\langle \widetilde{n}{\widetilde{v}}_{r}\rangle$. Changes in either amplitude of fluctuations or cross phase between fluctuations can cause changes in turbulent transport. In this paper, cross-phase dynamics in the Reynolds stress and turbulent particle flux at the tokamak edge are studied in detail. Reynolds stress and turbulent particle flux are, respectively, written as the product of fluctuation amplitudes and an average cross-phase factor. The mathematical expressions of the average cross-phase factors are derived. The average cross-phase factors and the power spectra of cross phase are obtained using experimental measurement data. It is found that the cross-phase dynamics in Reynolds stress and particle flux are very different. Reynolds stress is found to be more sensitive to cross phase than particle flux is. In the strong $E\times B$ shear layer, spatial slips of cross phase lead to the obvious radial gradient of Reynolds stress. In the no/weak $E\times B$ shear region, the cross phase in Reynolds stress tends to lock. Here, phase locking refers to that the power spectra of phase tend to distribute around a fixed phase which does not change with radial position, while phase slip means that the power spectra of cross phase tend to distribute around a phase that varies with radial position. Phase slip or locking mainly describes the central phase weighted by the power spectra, while the phase scattering mainly describes the dispersion of the power spectrum distribution of the phase. The increased scattering of cross phase, which indicates the power spectra distribution of the phase is more dispersed, contributes to the decreased Reynolds stress for higher collisionality. The cross phase in particle flux tends to lock in both strong and no/weak shear regions. The degree of scattering of cross phase in the particle flux does not change obviously as collisionality increases. For higher collisionality, it is the increased density fluctuation amplitude rather than cross-phase dynamics that leads to the increased particle flux. The underlying physical mechanism that causes Reynolds stress and particle flux to exhibit different phase dynamics is discussed.

70 PLASMA PHYSICS AND FUSION TECHNOLOGY↗
DOE OSTI2026

A comparative study on cubic and tetragonal Ce-ZrO 2 supported Rh catalysts for N 2 O decomposition

Zirconium oxide (ZrO 2 ) exhibits strong synergy with cerium oxide (CeO 2 ), acting as a structural and electronic promoter during catalytic redox reactions. As a result, Ce-ZrO 2 composite oxides are widely used as supports in various catalytic systems. In our previous work, we demonstrated that the incorporation of Zr 4+ into the CeO 2 lattice significantly enhanced Rh dispersion, improved redox ability, and stabilized surface Rh species, which collectively boosted the de-N 2 O activity of Rh/Ce-ZrO 2 catalysts. Building on these findings, the present study emphasizes that the crystallographic phase of Ce-ZrO 2 , governed by the Ce/Zr ratio, plays a decisive role in tuning the physicochemical environment of Rh active sites and thereby optimizing catalytic performance. In conclusion, tailoring the Ce/Zr ratio to favor the cubic fluorite structure emerges as a promising strategy for the rational design of highly active and stable catalysts for N 2 O decomposition and potentially other redox-sensitive environmental applications.

36 MATERIALS SCIENCE↗
DOE OSTI2025

Experiment-modeling studies comparing energy dissipation in the DIII-D SAS and SAS-VW divertors

Recent DIII-D experiments on Small Angle Slot (SAS) divertors have confirmed that a combination of divertor closure and target shaping can enhance cooling across the divertor target and increase energy dissipation, but with significant dependence on B T (toroidal magnetic field) direction. In these novel divertors, the roles of closure, target shaping, drifts, and scale lengths are all interconnected in optimizing dissipation, with the separatrix electron density n eSEP being the key parameter associated with the level of dissipation/detachment. After modifying the original flat-targeted graphite SAS to include a V shape with a tungsten coating on the outer side of the divertor (SAS-VW), matched series of discharges were run to compare to detailed SOLPS-ITER modeling. Experimentally, when run as designed with the outer strike point at the slot vertex, SAS-VW requires nearly identical n eSEP for detachment as the original SAS, with little difference in dissipation for the new geometry. This is in contrast to (1) earlier modeling predictions that a small change of the SAS geometry to a V shape should enhance dissipation at the same n eSEP for magnetic configurations having better H-mode access (ion B × ∇B drift directed into the divertor), and (2) despite the achievement of significantly higher (2-7x) neutral pressures and compression in the SAS-VW slot. Comparisons of experimental density scans to the most recent SOLPS-ITER modeling with ExB drifts show reasonable agreement for dissipation/detachment onset when using separatrix density as the independent parameter. In order to help understand the discrepancy in modeled vs actual performance for the new configuration, additional measurements varying gas injection location and impurity injection were undertaken. In-slot D 2 gas fueling is more effective (5–22 %) in promoting detachment, in accord with modeling. In-slot impurity injection (N 2 or Ne) can yield 30 % lower core Z eff and 15 % less confinement degradation after detachment compared to main chamber puffing, as well as relatively lower tungsten leakage from the divertor. Modeling can also reproduce the improved detachment seen as the strike point moves inboard of the slot vertex. While we can explain the effects of the most important parameters causing energy dissipation in these slot divertors, it remains that many aspects of their behavior cannot be accurately modeled using state-of-art codes such as SOLPS-ITER. This is of concern for future model-driven designs utilizing similar V-shaped geometries.

70 PLASMA PHYSICS AND FUSION TECHNOLOGY↗
DOE OSTI2026

An ICP-OES method for the precise and accurate quantification of rare earth elements in natural water: A comparative study from mine waste sites in New Mexico, USA

Inductively coupled plasma techniques such as ICP-OES and ICP-MS are routinely used to determine the concentrations of rare earth elements (REE) in water samples. However, their performance for the determination of REE concentration in mine drainage waters from epithermal vein and porphyry copper mining districts has not been evaluated extensively. In this work, we develop an REE analysis method on an Agilent 5900 ICP-OES instrument and assess the accuracy and precision for the quantification of REE in the natural waters collected from mine adits and an acid seep of mine sites in the Steeple Rock and Hillsboro mining districts, New Mexico, USA. The total REE concentrations in the water samples were measured using the methods we developed for both ICP-OES and ICP-MS. The power of the new ICP-OES method lies in routine analysis of μg/L level concentrations normally analyzed using ICP-MS, including a U.S. Geological Survey standard reference sample, laboratory blank samples spiked with a National Institute of Standards and Technology traceable standard, and surface water samples from mine waste sites. This ICP-OES method achieves low quantification limits ranging from 0.2 to 5 μg/L and excellent analytical accuracy and precision for REE analysis. The precision of light (La-Gd) and heavy (Tb-Lu) REE analysis using this method are better than 5% at average concentrations above 5 ± 4 μg/L and 3 ± 2 μg/L, respectively, and 3% at average concentrations above 10 ± 9 μg/L and 5 ± 4 μg/L, respectively. This method also shows excellent sensitivity and reproducibility for our laboratory and field samples.

37 INORGANIC, ORGANIC, PHYSICAL, AND ANALYTICAL CH↗
DOE OSTI2026

A comparative study of multimodal data fusion strategies for planetary spectroscopy

Integrating heterogeneous data sources can improve scientific inference when different modalities capture complementary information, but doing so is challenging in high-dimensional, small-sample settings. In spectroscopy for planetary exploration, Laser-Induced Breakdown Spectroscopy (LIBS), Raman Spectroscopy (Raman), Visible Infrared Spectroscopy (VISIR), and Mid-Infrared Spectroscopy (MIR) each examine different aspects of composition and mineralogy, raising fundamental questions about when and how data fusion improves predictive performance. Using a Mars-relevant set of geologic standards with measurements from all four modalities, we present a rigorous systematic evaluation of four data fusion strategies: low-level (data) fusion, mid-level (feature) fusion, high-level (decision) fusion, and residual-boosting (sequential) fusion. We assess performance in predicting oxide composition via nested cross-validation and corrected significance testing to evaluate whether data fusion improves upon single-modality baselines. We show that data fusion does not uniformly improve accuracy, and that observed gains are modest, oxide-dependent, and sensitive to modality and model structure. To move beyond aggregate accuracy metrics, we use model coefficients, permutation importance, and residual gain analysis to examine how the fusion models weight individual modalities and to identify patterns of apparent complementarity or redundancy. Though focused on spectroscopy for planetary exploration, our framework for data fusion evaluation and interpretation extends to other scientific domains with heterogeneous and scarce data and provides a principled approach evaluating data fusion strategies, interpreting modality contributions, and understanding tradeoffs among data fusion strategies.

97 MATHEMATICS AND COMPUTING↗
DOE OSTI2024

Comparative Study of Neutral and Cationic Sn 2 H 2 : Toward Laboratory Detection of the Cation

Group 14 M 2 H 2 isomers (M = Si, Ge, Sn, and Pb) have attracted interest due to their radically differing electronic structures from acetylene. To better understand the Sn–H interactions of the neutral and cationic Sn 2 H 2 structures, we present the most rigorous study of these systems to date. CCSD(T)/cc-pwCVTZ harmonic frequencies are presented as the first predictions for the neutral and cationic species to date. CCSDT(Q)/CBS relative energies are reported using the focal point approach, confirming the butterfly isomer as the global minimum on the potential energy surface for both the neutral and cationic species. In all, there exist 7 minima and 15 transition states. NBO analysis is also performed to elucidate the changes in bond order going from neutral to cation across all isomers of Sn 2 H 2 . Our results provide insights into the important Sn–H interaction and provide guidance for future work that may detect Sn 2 H$^{+}_{2}$ in the laboratory for the first time.

37 INORGANIC, ORGANIC, PHYSICAL, AND ANALYTICAL CH↗