Absence of magnetic order in epitaxial RuO 2 revealed by x-ray linear dichroism
Recently the topic of altermagnetism has attracted tremendous attention, and RuO 2 has been demonstrated to be one of the most promising altermagnetic candidates. However, disputes still remain on the existence of magnetic order in RuO 2 . Here in this work, we employ x-ray linear dichroism (XLD), a widely utilized technique for characterizing antiferromagnets, in conjunction with photoemission electron microscopy and multiple scattering calculation to provide clear evidence of the absence of magnetic order in epitaxial RuO 2 films. The observed XLD signal is nearly invariant with temperature and independent of cooling-field direction, in stark contrast to the substantial magnetic-order-related XLD signal predicted by multiple scattering calculation. This finding strongly suggests a nonmagnetic origin for RuO 2 . Furthermore, we observed significantly distinct XLD signals at the Ru M 3 and O K edges in RuO 2 films grown on TiO 2 substrate with different surface orientations, which can be attributed to the low-symmetry crystal field. In conclusion, these results unequivocally demonstrate the absence of magnetic order in RuO 2 and establish XLD measurement as a robust technique for probing the low-symmetry magnetic materials.