Evaluation of the Impacts of Heat Exchanger Operation on Quality of Water Used as Heat Source and Sink
To help inform future decisions about the subsequent uses of water that has served as a heat source and sink in the heat exchanger component of a geothermal heat pump system, ORNL performed an independent assessment of data characterizing the quality of water that had passed through a heat exchanger supporting a geothermal heat pump in a school building. Water supply to the heat exchanger is treated drinking water from a public water supply system that derives its water from a groundwater source. Water analyses and bacteriological measurements collected from heat exchanger and inflow and outflow lines were supplied to ORNL for review. Data were compared with regulatory standards and inflow and outflow data were compared to identify changes occurring in the water resulting from its passage through the heat exchanger. Review of the data identified no conditions that would prevent the use of heat exchange outflow water for water supply. Water quality conforms with applicable regulatory standards. There were no discernible differences between inflow and outflow water quality for any parameters other than water temperature and formation of heterotrophic bacterial biofilms. Changes in water temperature are an expected result of the operation of the heat exchanger system and do not by themselves affect the suitability of the water for human consumption. Bacterial biofilm formation can be affected by water temperature, but the data did not show a consistent or statistically significant relationship between temperature parameters and biofilm formation, and the observations of biofilms formed in the heat exchanger water lines do not affect the suitability of the outflow water for water supply. Legionella, a bacterial genus that has been associated with outbreaks of waterborne pathogenic disease, was detected in one biofilm sample, and the water company is performing follow-up testing to assess the significance of this detection.