Search NASA⌕ Search

SEARCH · Search NASA

Results for “VIBRATION EFFECT”

Search indexed NASA NTRS and DOE OSTI research on propulsion, heat transfer, battery materials and energy systems. Follow report and document links to the original sources.

Quote a phrase for an exact phrase match. Source license links do not imply unrestricted reuse.

At least 181 records · Page 10

Bulk Anion Recognition Kinetically Holds Back Interfacial Adsorption

The competition between bulk and interfacial phenomena underlies many key processes in complex chemical phenomena and transport. While competitive processes are often framed in a thermodynamic context, opportunities to leverage transient species found away from equilibrium can provide a kinetic handle to achieve unconventional reaction outcomes. In this work, we outfit an iminoguanidinium headgroup capable of selective SO 4 2– complexation with alkyl tails of varying complexity to probe competitive bulk and interfacial reaction pathways and tune kinetic pathways for selective chemical separations. Using sum frequency generation (SFG) vibrational spectroscopy we unexpectedly find that adsorption of ligands to the air–aqueous interface was dramatically slowed down for species with increasingly hydrophobic tails. Underlying this phenomenon, we show that the formation of bulk colloidal species with differing propensities for SO 4 2– inhibited surface adsorption via a kinetic bottleneck in the exchange of molecular extractants with colloidal aggregates. This kinetic effect could open up avenues to access unconventional selectivity via complexation of strongly coordinating species in the bulk phase, allowing for more weakly coordinating species to transport via interfacial mechanisms. Furthermore, this work broadly probes nonequilibrium phenomena in chemical separations that arise through unexpected interfacial events that are neglected in traditional equilibrium descriptions.

37 INORGANIC, ORGANIC, PHYSICAL, AND ANALYTICAL CH↗

Monitoring Sulfuric Acid and Temperature Using Raman Spectroscopy and Multivariate Chemometrics

Multivariate regression models were optimized for the quantification of sulfuric acid (H 2 SO 4 ) [0–8 M] and temperature (20 °C–80 °C) in the presence of ammonium sulfate ((NH 4 ) 2 SO 4 [0–0.6 M]) using Raman spectroscopy. Optical vibrational spectroscopy is a useful nondestructive technique for the in situ analysis of complex chemical systems notoriously difficult to monitor in situ and in real-time. Multivariate analysis, a chemometrics method, can be paired with these nondestructive optical methods for determining analyte concentration and speciation in complex solutions, such as dissociated species in polyprotic acids, e.g., H 2 SO 4 . The effect of temperature is often overlooked although it can have a major influence on speciation and the corresponding Raman spectra. Here, in this study, partial least squares regression models were optimized for the quantification of H 2 SO 4 and its two deprotonated forms as a function of temperature. Measuring bisulfate as a function of temperature is particularly challenging owing to changes in the second dissociation constant. A designed training set effectively minimized the sample set size and trained a robust predictive model with percent root mean square error of <3% for H 2 SO 4 . The practical strategy employed here was demonstrated to be effective for building chemometric models that directly account for dynamic temperatures with static samples and is shown to be amenable to flow cell analysis applications with a simple calibration transfer for process monitoring applications.

D-optimal design↗

Element-specific ultrafast lattice dynamics in FePt nanoparticles

Light–matter interaction at the nanoscale in magnetic alloys and heterostructures is a topic of intense research in view of potential applications in high-density magnetic recording. While the element-specific dynamics of electron spins is directly accessible to resonant x-ray pulses with femtosecond time structure, the possible element-specific atomic motion remains largely unexplored. We use ultrafast electron diffraction (UED) to probe the temporal evolution of lattice Bragg peaks of FePt nanoparticles embedded in a carbon matrix following excitation by an optical femtosecond laser pulse. The diffraction interference between Fe and Pt sublattices enables us to demonstrate that the Fe mean square vibration amplitudes are significantly larger that those of Pt as expected from their different atomic mass. Both are found to increase as energy is transferred from the laser-excited electrons to the lattice. Contrary to this intuitive behavior, we observe a laser-induced lattice expansion that is larger for Pt than for Fe atoms during the first picosecond after laser excitation. This effect points to the strain-wave driven lattice expansion with the longitudinal acoustic Pt motion dominating that of Fe.

36 MATERIALS SCIENCE↗

An optimization-based approach to tailor the mechanical response of soft metamaterials undergoing rate-dependent instabilities

An optimization-based design framework is proposed to tune the response of soft metamaterials involving both geometric instabilities and nonlinear viscoelastic material behavior. Designing the response of soft metamaterials to harness instabilities and undergo large, tailored configuration changes will enable advancements in soft robotics, shock and vibration mitigation, and flexible electronics. In line with the metamaterial concept, the response of these materials is governed to a large extent by the geometric and topological makeup of their small-scale features. However, the link between structure and response is less intuitive for soft metamaterials due to their reliance upon highly nonlinear responses triggered by geometric instabilities. This is further complicated by the effects of viscoelastic relaxation, which recent studies have shown to alter the emergence of instabilities in non-intuitive ways. Here, these effects are accounted for in our framework to achieve various design objectives, including tailored force–displacement response and maximized energy absorption from both geometric and material effects. To fully automate this process, it is essential to have a completely robust equation solver for forward problems involving instabilities and viscoelastic relaxation. We achieve this by casting the search for stable mechanical equilibrium — i.e. the forward problem — as a minimization problem and utilize a trust region algorithm to robustly handle instabilities and follow energetically-favorable equilibrium paths through critical points.

97 MATHEMATICS AND COMPUTING↗

Rovibrationally resolved Rayleigh and Raman scattering cross sections for molecular hydrogen

Accurate Rayleigh and Raman scattering cross sections, tensor components, depolarization ratios, and reversal coefficients for all rovibrational transitions within the X1Σg+ ground electronic state of H2 have been calculated. Raman spectra have been generated using these data. A method for calculating Raman scattering cross sections is formulated that is valid below the ionization threshold and in the region containing resonances, which explicitly accounts for all bound and dissociative vibrational levels of the bound intermediate electronic states and approximately accounts for the ionization continuum. A representative set of cross sections is presented for incident photon energies below 15 eV and compared with existing results in the literature where possible. Convergence of our results with an increasing number of bound intermediate electronic states is demonstrated. The accuracy of the Placzek–Teller approximation is discussed. The effect of accounting for the intermediate ionization continuum is investigated. Local thermal equilibrium cross sections are calculated for Rayleigh and Raman scattering. This work represents the most accurate and complete treatment of Raman scattering for molecular hydrogen to date. A total of 9582 Rayleigh and Raman scattering cross sections have been generated and are openly available on Zenodo under an open-source Creative Commons Attribution license at https://zenodo.org/doi/10.5281/zenodo.13441471.

74 ATOMIC AND MOLECULAR PHYSICS↗

A multiscale design method using interpretable machine learning for phononic materials with closely interacting scales

Manipulating the dispersive characteristics of vibrational waves is beneficial for many applications, e.g., high-precision instruments. architected hierarchical phononic materials have sparked promise tunability of elastodynamic waves and vibrations over multiple frequency ranges. In this article, hierarchical unit-cells are obtained, where features at each length scale result in a band gap within a targeted frequency range. Our novel approach, the ‘‘hierarchical unit-cell template method,’’ is an interpretable machine-learning approach that uncovers global unit-cell shape/topology patterns corresponding to predefined band-gap objectives. A scale-separation effect is observed where the coarse-scale band-gap objective is mostly unaffected by the fine-scale features despite the closeness of their length scales, thus enabling an efficient hierarchical algorithm. Moreover, the hierarchical patterns revealed are not predefined or self-similar hierarchies as common in current hierarchical phononic materials. Furthermore, our approach offers a flexible and efficient method for the exploration of new regions in the hierarchical design space, extracting minimal effective patterns for inverse design in applications targeting multiple frequency ranges.

Architected materials↗

From Coherence to Function: Exploring the Connection in Chemical Systems

The role of quantum mechanical coherences or coherent superposition states in excited state processes has received considerable attention in the last two decades largely due to advancements in ultrafast laser spectroscopy. These coherence effects hold promise for enhancing the efficiency and robustness of functionally relevant processes, even when confronted with energy disorder and environmental fluctuations. Understanding coherence deeply drives us to unravel mechanisms and dynamics controlled by order and synchronization at a quantum mechanical level, envisioning optical control of coherence to enhance functions or create new ones in molecular and material systems. In this frontier, the interplay between electronic and vibrational dynamics, specifically the influence of vibrations in directing electronic dynamics, has emerged as the leading principle. Here, two energetically disparate quantum degrees of freedom work in-sync to dictate the trajectory of an excited state reaction. Moreover, with the vibrational degree being directly related to the structural composition of molecular or material systems, new molecular designs could be inspired by tailoring certain structural elements. In the realm of chemical kinetics, our understanding of the dynamics of chemical transformations is underpinned by fundamental theories, such as transition state theory, activated rate theory, and Marcus theory. These theories elucidate reaction rates by considering the energy barriers that must be overcome for reactants to transform into products. Those barriers are surmounted by the stochastic nature of energy gap fluctuations within reacting systems, emphasizing that the reaction coordinate, the pathway from reactants to products, is not rigidly defined by a specific vibrational motion but encompasses a diverse array of molecular motions. While less is known about the involvement of specific intramolecular vibrational modes, their significance in certain cases cannot be overlooked. In this Account, we summarize key experimental findings that offer deeper insights into the complex electronic–vibrational trajectories encompassing excited states afforded from state-of-the-art ultrafast laser spectroscopy in three exemplary processes: photoinduced electron transfer, singlet–triplet intersystem crossing, and intramolecular vibrational energy flow in molecular systems. We delve into the rapid decoherence, or loss of phase and amplitude correlations, of vibrational coherences along promoter vibrations during subpicosecond intersystem crossing dynamics in a series of binuclear platinum complexes. This rapid decoherence illustrates the vibration-driven reactive pathways from the Franck–Condon state to the curve crossing region. We also explore the generation of new vibrational coherences induced by impulsive reaction dynamics rather than by the laser pulse in these systems, which sheds light on specific energy dissipation pathways and thereby on the progression of the reaction trajectory in the vicinity of the curve crossing on the product side. Another property of vibrational coherences, amplitude, reveals how energy can flow from one vibration to another in the electronic excited state of a terpyridine–molybdenum complex hosting a nonreactive dinitrogen substrate. In conclusion, a slight change in vibrational energy triggers a quasi-resonant interaction, leading to constructive wavepacket interference and ultimately intramolecular vibrational redistribution from a Franck–Condon active terpyridine vibration to a dinitrogen stretching vibration, energizing the dinitrogen bond.

Electrical energy↗

Influence of support on Rh-Co bimetallic catalysts for ethylene hydroformylation

Bimetallic Rh- and Co-based catalysts are promising materials for the heterogenous ethylene hydroformylation reaction. Here, in this study, the influence of a mesoporous silica (SBA-15) support on Rh and Co bimetallic interactions was investigated through a comparison with silica gel and alumina supports. The bimetallic catalyst supported on mesoporous silica (RhCo 3 /SBA-15) showed the best C 3 oxygenate yield among the three bimetallic catalysts. In-situ vibrational studies suggested moderate binding of the gem-dicarbonyl and Rh(CO)(C 2 H 4 ) intermediates due to this bimetallic interaction that led to improved hydroformylation performance. Kinetic studies revealed a lower hydroformylation barrier for the bimetallic compared to a Rh monometallic catalyst, and in-situ X-ray absorption spectroscopy investigations showed clear Rh-Co alloy formation on RhCo 3 /SBA-15. The bimetallic enhancement effect from the interaction with the mesoporous silica support shown here can be further optimized to design olefin hydroformylation catalysts.

58 GEOSCIENCES↗

Thermally induced structural competitiveness and metastability of body-centered-cubic iron under nonequilibrium conditions

The structure and stability of iron near melting at multi-megabar pressures are of significant interest in high pressure physics and earth and planetary sciences. While the body-centered cubic (BCC) phase is generally recognized as unstable at lower temperatures, its stability relative to the hexagonal close-packed (HCP) phase at high temperatures (approximately 0.5 eV) in the Earth’s inner core (IC) remains a topic of ongoing theoretical and experimental debate. Motivated by a series of studies attempting to understand the state of the IC and resulting in contradictory findings, we aim to explore the physical factors that may contribute to this confusion in a broader context. Our ab initio calculations show a significant drop in energy, the emergence of a plateau and a local minimum in the potential energy surface, and stabilization of all phonon modes of BCC iron at elevated electron temperatures (>1–1.5 eV). These effects increase the competition among the BCC, HCP, and the face-centered cubic (FCC) phases and lead to the metastability of the BCC structure. Furthermore, at pressure-temperature conditions relevant to the IC, we can expect substantial coexistence of FCC and HCP iron due to their similar free energies and low transition barrier (∼0.2 eV/atom), and the thermodynamic stability of BCC iron is enhanced by its substantial lattice vibration entropy. In conclusion, these findings provide a clear theoretical framework for understanding iron phase relations and solidification processes, both experimentally and in the IC.

75 CONDENSED MATTER PHYSICS, SUPERCONDUCTIVITY AND↗

Developing cathode infiltration processes for all-solid-state bilayer LLZO cells

To realize the bilayer architecture of lithium lanthanum zirconate (LLZO) for application in solid-state batteries (SSBs), the scaffold structure must be optimized, and effective cathode infiltration strategies must be established. In this study, we fabricate a modified bilayer LLZO using a sacrificial layer to enhance surface porosity, and systematically investigate various cathode infiltration techniques to fill the scaffold with oxide cathode active materials (CAM). Structural characterizations showed that the sacrificial layer significantly increased open surface porosity, enabling the surface of the scaffold to be filled with CAM. To further increase infiltration depth, applying vacuum or vibration was compared, with the full-depth infiltration achieved using a sonicator-based vibration. Full cells prepared using the modified bilayer LLZO and vibration-assisted technique demonstrated successful operation. This work demonstrates a practical and scalable approach for engineering bilayer LLZO structures and integrating oxide cathodes into porous scaffolds, offering a promising pathway toward high-performance solid-state batteries.

Bilayer↗

Probing air-water interfaces of dibutyl phosphoric acid (HDBP) aqueous solutions using vibrational sum frequency generation (vSFG) spectroscopy

Liquid-liquid extraction is a separation technique implemented in a wide variety of areas, achieving particular success in both the nuclear and biomedical fields. In this work, vibrational sum frequency generation spectroscopy (VSFG) and surface tension measurements were used to investigate the adsorption of dibutyl phosphate (DBP) at air-aqueous interfaces to simulate liquid-liquid systems relevant to the Plutonium Uranium Redox Extraction (PUREX) Process. The objective of this work is to establish qualitative relationships between changes in the bulk aqueous phase concentrations of DBP and its concentration and structure at air-liquid interface as probed with VSFG. Nitric acid concentration and solution ionic strength were varied to examine their effect on the interfacial DBP.. Introduction of DBP into neat water resulted in reduction of the VSFG spectral intensity in the dangling O-H region (3680 – 3800 cm -1 ) but large increase in the H-bonded O-H stretch frequency region (3000 – 3500 cm-1) and the appearance of the CH 3 symmetric stretch and CH 3 Fermi resonance peaks at ~ 2880 and 2945 cm -1 , respectively, indicating DBP at the air-water interface. The intensity of the C-H strecth peaks increased as DBP concentration increased from 0.24 to 32 mM, accompanied by a decreasing surface tension values. At fixed DBP concentration, the addition of either or both of HNO 3 and NaNO 3 to an ionic strength of 1 M or 3 M led to significant reduction of the O-H VSFG peaks and enhancement of the C-H peaks. The origins of these experimental observations are attributed to both the increased HDBP molecules partitioning and adsorption to the interface and the protonation of the interfacial DBP- molecules.

37 INORGANIC, ORGANIC, PHYSICAL, AND ANALYTICAL CH↗

Fermi’s Golden Rule Rate Expression for Transitions Due to Nonadiabatic Derivative Couplings in the Adiabatic Basis

Starting from a general molecular Hamiltonian expressed in the basis of adiabatic electronic and nuclear position states, where a compact and complete expression for the nonadiabatic derivative coupling (NDC) Hamiltonian term is obtained, we provide a general analysis of the Fermi’s golden rule (FGR) rate expression for nonadiabatic transitions between adiabatic states. We then consider a quasi-adiabatic approximation that uses crude adiabatic states and NDC couplings, both evaluated at the minimum potential energy configuration of the initial adiabatic state, for the definition of the zeroth and first-order terms of the Hamiltonian. Although the application of this approximation is rather limited, it allows deriving a general FGR rate expression without further approximation while accounting for non-Condon contribution to the FGR rate arising from momentum operators of NDC terms and its coupling with vibronic displacements. For a generic and widely used model where all nuclear degrees of freedom and environmental effects are represented as linearly coupled harmonic oscillators, we derive a closed-form FGR rate expression that requires only Fourier transform. The resulting rate expression includes quadratic contributions of NDC terms and their couplings to Franck–Condon modes, which require evaluation of two additional bath spectral densities in addition to the conventional one that appears in a typical FGR rate theory based on the Condon approximation. Model calculations for the case where nuclear vibrations consist of both a sharp high-frequency mode and an Ohmic bath spectral density illustrate new features and implications of the rate expression. We then apply our theoretical expression to the nonradiative decay from the first excited singlet state of azulene, which illustrates the utility and implications of our theoretical results.

37 INORGANIC, ORGANIC, PHYSICAL, AND ANALYTICAL CH↗

An Experimental Setup for Mechanical Vibration Analysis Using VLC

This study explores the potential applications across various domains, including earthquake detection and warning systems, where the system’s sensitivity to ground vibrations can contribute to early seismic event detection. Additionally, the study paves the way of developing applications of VLC/T in mechanical vibration and stability analysis of engines and platforms, offering insights into structural integrity and performance optimization. These multifaceted applications underscore the adaptability and potential of VLC/T systems in diverse fields, heralding advancements in sensing, communication, and security technologies. To achieve this, in this study, Peak to Average Power Ratio (PAPR) is proposed to represent the impact of mechanical shocks and vibrations generated by several weights dropped onto the platform with which the receiver is fixed. Even though non-contact measurement methodology is preferred for various reasons, the proposed measurement campaign obtains the data in contact form; however, the system and signal model proposed in this study could easily be extended into non-contact form. Considering the fact that the proposed measurement campaign employs off-the-shelf products, it is cost-effective and very scalable.

Yilmaz, Ahmet Mucahit↗

Photovoltage behaviour of p-Sb 2 S 3 photocathodes for hydrogen evolution: effect of n-In 2 S 3 passivation layers

The 1.76 eV band gap of antimony(iii) sulphide (Sb 2 S 3 ) makes this semiconductor material a promising light absorber for photoelectrochemical water splitting, but scalable fabrication approaches to efficient devices are still lacking. Here we show that compact Sb 2 S 3 films on FTO can be obtained by electrochemical growth from aqueous colloidal sulphur and antimony trichloride solutions, followed by mild annealing. These films can be converted into hydrogen evolution photocathodes after coating with In 2 S 3 passivation layers and the addition of Pt proton reduction co-catalysts. For the first time, vibrating Kelvin probe surface photovoltage (VKP-SPV) spectroscopy is used to observe the carrier dynamics in such photoelectrodes. While the bare Sb 2 S 3 films suffer from high surface recombination rates and poor electron extraction, the In 2 S 3 overlayer is found to raise the photovoltage and cathodic photocurrent density, due to passivation of surface defects and formation of a p–n heterojunction. In thick In 2 S 3 films, these benefits are offset by shading and slow electron transfer. Also, we find that O 2 strongly affects the band bending in the Sb 2 S 3 –air and In 2 S 3 –air junctions and their photovoltage. The optimised devices evolve H 2 at 77.5% Faradaic efficiency and with 0.084% applied bias photon-to-current efficiency (ABPE) at 0.12 V vs. RHE. The low ABPE value is attributed to Sb 2 S 3 sub-bandgap defects visible in SPV spectra, the random orientation of Sb 2 S 3 crystallites in the films, which inhibits charge transport, the absence of crystal facets of Sb 2 S 3 , and a detrimental Schottky junction at the FTO|Sb 2 S 3 interface.

de Araújo, Moisés A. [University of California, Da↗

First-principles investigation of elastic, vibrational, and thermodynamic properties of kagome metals CsM 3 Te 5 (M = Ti, Zr, Hf)

Kagome metals are a unique class of quantum materials characterized by their distinct atomic lattice arrangement, featuring interlocking triangles and expansive hexagonal voids. These lattice structures impart exotic properties, including superconductivity, interaction-driven topological many-body phenomena, and magnetism, among others. The kagome metal CsM 3 ⁢Te 5 (where M = Ti, Zr, or Hf) exhibits both superconductivity and nontrivial topological electronic properties, offering a promising platform for exploring topological superconductivity. This study employs first-principles density functional theory calculations to systematically analyze the elastic, mechanical, vibrational, thermodynamic, and electronic properties of CsM 3 ⁢Te 5 (M = Ti, Zr, Hf). Our calculations reveal that the studied compounds—CsTi 3 ⁢Te 5 , CsZr 3 ⁢Te 5 , and CsHf 3 ⁢Te 5 —are ductile metals with elastic properties akin to the hexagonal Bi and Sb, with average elastic constants, including a bulk modulus of 27 GPa, a shear modulus of 11 GPa, and Young's modulus of 29 GPa. We observe peculiar dispersionless, flat, phonon branches in the vibrational spectra of these metals. Additionally, we thoroughly analyze the symmetries of the zone-center phonon eigenvectors and predict vibrational fingerprints of the Raman- and infrared-active phonon modes. The analysis of thermodynamic properties reveals the Einstein temperature for CsTi 3 ⁢Te 5 , CsZr 3 ⁢Te 5 , and CsHf 3 ⁢Te 5 to be 66, 54, and 53 K, respectively. Our orbital-decomposed electronic structure calculations reveal significant in-plane steric interactions and multiple Dirac band crossings near the Fermi level. We further investigate the role of spin-orbit coupling effect on the studied properties. Furthermore, this theoretical investigation sheds light on the intriguing quantum behavior of kagome metals.

36 MATERIALS SCIENCE↗

Diffusion and Solvation Dynamics of Ions in Water: Beyond the Brownian Approximation

The coupled dynamics of ions and water molecules in their first hydration shell impact a variety of processes including ion diffusion, selective ion transport in water-filled nanopores, and the kinetics of ion-pairing, ion adsorption, and metal-ligand binding reactions. In this work, we study these coupled dynamics for alkali metals (Li, Na, K, Rb, Cs), alkaline Earth metals (Mg, Ca, Sr, Ba), and chloride through the lens of their dependence on ion isotopic mass. Results are validated against previous measurements of the isotopic mass-dependence of ion diffusion coefficients in water and previous ab initio calculations of ion high-frequency dynamics in water. We find that the vibrational power spectra of ions in water consistently exhibit either two or three peaks, i.e., ions have several rattling frequencies within their solvations shells as previously reported for a subset of the species examined here. These frequencies have different sensititivies to isotopic mass that may serve as signatures of ion solvation processes (such as the tendency of ions to orient their first-shell water molecules) and that also may relate to Hofmeister-like effects including the relative affinity of different metals for ribonucleic acid (RNA).

37 INORGANIC, ORGANIC, PHYSICAL, AND ANALYTICAL CH↗

Selective incorporation of antimony into gallium nitride

Dilute concentrations of antimony (Sb) incorporation into GaN induce strong bandgap bowing and tunable room-temperature photoluminescence from the UV to the green spectral regions. However, the atomistic details of the incorporation of Sb into the GaN host remain unclear. In this work, we use first-principles calculations to understand the thermodynamics of Sb substitution into GaN and its effect on the optical and Raman spectra. Although it is empirically considered that Sb is preferentially incorporated as an anion (Sb3−) into the N sublattice, we demonstrate that Sb can also be incorporated as a cation (Sb3+, Sb5+) into the metal sublattice. Our thermodynamic analysis demonstrates that SbN0, SbGa2+, and SbGa0 can co-exist under Ga-rich conditions in n-type samples. We further confirm the dual incorporation of Sb by calculating the vibrational frequencies of different anionic and cationic substitutions to explain the origins of experimentally observed additional Raman peaks of Sb-doped GaN. Moreover, the calculated band structures of different Sb substitutions into GaN explain the experimental photoluminescence and optical absorption spectra. Overall, our analysis suggests that the coexistence of Sb3−, Sb3+, and Sb5+ substitutions into GaN explains the totality of experimental measurements. Our results demonstrate that the selective incorporation of Sb into GaN (and potentially other group-V elements such as As, P, or Bi) by tuning the growth conditions can drastically modify the electronic properties, for applications in visible light emitters and photocatalysis.

Physics↗

Reply to Smith and Siegel: Most lithium hops in paddlewheel-claimed conductors occur without spatially and temporally correlated anion-group rotations

We appreciate the engagement from Smith and Siegel on the topic of the “paddlewheel effect” and are pleased to see alignment regarding the absence of a paddlewheel effect, in which large-angle anion-group rotations directly propel lithium hops. In our paper, we clearly state the ambiguity surrounding the term “paddlewheel” to describe lithium transport. We believe that science is not well served by this vague term or its regular redefinition which is why we distinguish three types of anion-group rotation events: large-angle rotations (n-fold rotation returning to a rotationally invariant configuration), librations (e.g., rotational vibrations), and static changes of orientation in response to the change of Li occupancy. Here, we directly evaluate the spatial and temporal correlation between such polyanion rotations and Li hops.

37 INORGANIC, ORGANIC, PHYSICAL, AND ANALYTICAL CH↗