DOE OSTI2021
Thiophene-H2 reactions proceed via sulfur removal and hydrogenation routes on dispersed metal nanoparticles that become decorated by refractory S-adlayers during catalysis. The identity and kinetic relevance of the required elementary steps are described here based on rates measured at S-chemical potentials set by H2S/H2 ratios similar to those prevalent during practical catalysis on Re, ReSx, Ru, and Pt catalysts. Free energies for S adatom formation (from H2S decomposition and H2 evolution) are strongly exothermic (< -50 kJ mol-1 on Pt(111) and < -150 kJ mol-1 on Re and Ru(0001)), but strong repulsions between S adatoms cause adsorption free energies to increase significantly with coverage on all three surfaces, preventing complete monolayer formation. These adlayers, composed of unreactive S-atoms (S') that cover 1/3–2/3 ML leave residual interstitial spaces (*) that bind S-atoms (S*), intermediates, and transition states reversibly, as required for catalytic turnovers. The number and binding properties of these interstices depend on the identity and chemical state of the nanoparticle bulk phase, which influences S'-binding and coverages and cause large differences in direct desulfurization and hydrogenation turnover rates (per exposed metal atom) on dispersed Re, ReSx, Ru, and Pt. The identity and kinetic relevance of elementary steps for desulfurization (to C4¬ hydrocarbons) and hydrogenation (to tetrahydrothiophene; THT) are similar among these catalysts; they involve the kinetically-relevant formation of a thiophene-derived intermediate (monohydrothiophene on Re and ReSx; dihydrothiophene on Ru and Pt) that either cleaves its C-S bond or “over-hydrogenates” to THT in one surface sojourn. THT then undergoes C-S bond cleavage in secondary reactions that correct such over-hydrogenation to form the more unsaturated species that cleave C-S bonds. THT/C4 product ratios are insensitive to H2S/H2 ratios and thiophene pressure, even though active interstitial spaces are covered by kinetically-detectable coverages of S* and thiophene; therefore, primary and secondary reactions must involve the same active surfaces. The observed increase in THT/C4 ratios with H2 pressure shows that THT formation transition states involve a larger number of H-atoms than for C-S cleavage. The requirement for bound species with intermediate unsaturation (between THT and thiophene) for C-S bond cleavage is reminiscent of the H-shuttling required in C-C and C-O hydrogenolysis, reactions that involve the partial dehydrogenation of alkanes and alkanols, respectively, to weaken such bonds and to increase the formation entropy of the relevant transition states via the evolution of H2(g). These mechanistic details challenge prevalent paradigms about different site requirements for hydrogenation and desulfurization pathways and about how metal-sulfur bond energies act as descriptors of reactivity; in fact, such binding energies merely act to define the refractory S-adlayers that enable the formation of weakly-binding interstices that reversibly bind intermediates and transition states, thus allowing catalytic turnovers.