Search NASA⌕ Search

SEARCH · Search NASA

Results for “DUCTILITY”

Search indexed NASA NTRS and DOE OSTI research on propulsion, heat transfer, battery materials and energy systems. Follow report and document links to the original sources.

Quote a phrase for an exact phrase match. Source license links do not imply unrestricted reuse.

At least 199 records · Page 11

Synergistic Effects of Molten Salt Corrosion and Proton Irradiation on Grain Boundary Strength in Ni-20Cr

Nickel-based alloys are leading contenders for use as structural materials in molten salt reactors. While there have been extensive studies on the impact of fluoride/chloride-based molten salt corrosion on the microstructural evolution of various nickel-based alloys, the effects of simultaneous molten salt corrosion and radiation on the mechanical integrity of grain boundaries (GBs) remain underexplored. In this study, we use a Ni-20Cr model alloy to investigate this issue, subjecting it to simultaneous molten fluoride salt corrosion and proton irradiation. We performed cross-sectional and chemically-sensitive electron microscopy characterization of the microstructures of these materials, identifying the characteristic corrosion-induced microstructure and local chemical heterogeneity near GBs. After developing a sample preparation method for reliable characterization of GB strength, we assess the mechanical degradation of GBs using in situ push-to-pull micro tensile tests. Our findings reveal that voids induced by corrosion are the primary influence on the failure mode of GBs, regardless of whether proton irradiation is present. For materials that exhibit ductile fracture, those subjected to simultaneous corrosion and radiation exhibit lower yield strengths than those exposed to corrosion alone, which may be linked to the previously observed phenomenon of proton irradiation-decelerated intergranular corrosion in molten salt.

36 - MATERIALS SCIENCE↗

A theoretical study of solid solution strengthening in the refractory medium entropy alloy Nb 45 Ta 25 Ti 15 Hf 15

The refractory medium-entropy alloy (RMEA) Nb 45 Ta 25 Ti 15 Hf 15 exhibits exceptional tensile ductility and fracture toughness at ambient temperature, but its engineering applications are limited by a lack of high temperature strength. Using a machine-learning interatomic potential (MLIP) with near-density functional theory (DFT) accuracy, we conducted molecular dynamics (MD) and statics simulations of the behavior of dislocations with both screw and edge characters. We also analyze experimentally measured yield strengths using the Rao-Suzuki model and the Maresca-Curtin model modified to include a temperature-dependent shear modulus and a bulk modulus-dependent misfit volume, thereby uncovering the mechanisms underlying the yielding of this RMEA. Compared with the published experimental yield strength, the models parameterized by the MLIP effectively reproduce the experimental results over a wide temperature range. The models and MD simulations indicate that yielding is governed by screw dislocations, with dipole dragging as the dominant mechanism. In MD simulations, we observed a potential softening mechanism not considered by the Rao-Suzuki screw model: slow migration of interstitial jogs along the dislocation core, which could lead to the annihilation of vacancy and interstitial jog pairs by their combination.

BCC complex concentrated alloys↗

Enhancing microsegregation during rapid directional solidification through ternary microalloying

The nano-cellular dendritic microstructure formed during rapid directional solidification in powder bed fusion additive manufacturing creates unique properties such as simultaneous improvement in strength and ductility. However, process control of microsegregation features remains challenging due to low sensitivity of critical solidification mechanisms to process parameters. This study leverages microalloying to achieve large changes in dendrite composition, microstructure, and interdendritic zone width during laser powder bed fusion without modifying process parameters. CALPHAD simulations predict that the addition of Zr significantly steepens the solidus line of the dilute Cu-Cr alloy system, leading to enhanced Cr rejection into the melt and greater than 95% reduction in solubility of Cr in the solidified Cu matrix. Experimental validation using time-of-flight secondary ion mass spectrometry and Kelvin probe force microscopy reveals that the ternary alloy containing 0.01 wt% Zr exhibited wider interdendritic regions compared to the binary, a significantly higher number of Cr-rich particles within interdendritic regions, near-complete ejection of oxygen impurities from the matrix, and greater nanoscale work function contrast. These features indicate more aggressive Cr segregation in the presence of Zr and a purer Cu matrix and provide a potentially robust method for engineering the nano-cellular dendritic solidification microstructure.

CALPHAD↗

An FFT-based micromechanical model for gradient enhanced brittle fracture

Damage models incorporated within FFT-based micromechanical methods have received much attention recently because of the need to better understand and predict brittle and ductile fracture. An important aspect of a damage model is non-local regularization, which removes the mesh dependence of the predictions that otherwise become physically unacceptable upon grid refinement. In this work, the Helmholtz-type equation for non-local gradient regularization of a damage model on a distorted grid is solved using an FFT-based approach. Further, the resulting system of equations is solved using the Jacobi iterative method. The model is applied to simulate brittle fracture of an intermetallic. The influence of the time and space discretization, the length-scale parameter, and intermetallic crystallographic orientation on crack evolution is studied.

36 MATERIALS SCIENCE↗

Crystal plasticity modeling and analysis for the transition from intergranular to transgranular failure in nickel-based alloy Inconel 740H at elevated temperature

The precipitation-strengthened Nickel alloy Inconel® 740H® (IN740H) exhibits increased ductility at higher applied strain rates during quasi-static tensile tests at an elevated temperature of 760°C. The examination of fracture surfaces in this context reveals a noteworthy transition of underlying fracture mechanisms from transgranular to intergranular fracture as the applied strain rate decreases from 1×10 -3 / s to 0.83×10 -4 / s . To thoroughly understand the mechanical response of IN740H under these conditions, this study develops a crystal plasticity finite element (CPFE) model. Further, this model incorporates various deformation mechanisms including dislocation slips, climb, and grain boundary sliding, which are relevant to the test conditions. The model is calibrated using data from both tensile tests at different strain rates and creep tests across a broad stress range at 760°C, enabling the accurate determination of model parameters for each mechanism. Simulation results well captured the experimental observations of different failure modes. At higher strain rates, the model shows a dominance of dislocation slip leading to heterogeneous plastic deformation and formation of transgranular shear bands causing the failure, while at lower strain rates, an increased activity of grain boundary sliding causes grain boundaries crack leading to intergranular failure.

37 INORGANIC, ORGANIC, PHYSICAL, AND ANALYTICAL CH↗

Microstructural refinement of an Al-Ce-Mg alloy via Shear Assisted Processing and Extrusion

Al-Ce alloys have attracted recent interest because of their high thermal stability due to the low solubility of Ce in the Al matrix. The Al 11 Ce 3 eutectic phase gives excellent strain hardening behavior and moderate high-temperature strength in the as-cast state. However, its strengthening effect is limited by its coarse as-cast structure. Therefore, alternative manufacturing methods such as additive manufacturing or equal channel angular pressing have been applied to refine the Al 11 Ce 3 phase to good effect. However, these techniques are both expensive and time-consuming. Therefore, this study aims to use Shear Assisted Processing and Extrusion (ShAPE), an emerging solid phase processing technique that is more easily scalable than the previously mentioned methods. ShAPE can produce useful cross-sections of an Al-8Ce-4Mg alloy while refining the Al 11 Ce 3 phase to produce a higher strength material. It was found that a low temperature ShAPE process can improve the room temperature yield strength by ~60 % compared to a binary Al-4Mg alloy. Additionally, the high-temperature yield strength of the Al-Ce alloys increased by 20%, with a simultaneous 15% improvement in ductility compared to the binary Al-Mg alloy. Finally, these results highlight the potential for ShAPE as a processing technique for Al-Ce alloys.

36 MATERIALS SCIENCE↗

Precipitation hardening of laser powder bed fusion Ti-6Al-4V

Here, the laser powder bed fusion (PBF-L) additive manufacturing (AM) community has dedicated significant efforts into process optimization and control for defect-free Ti-6Al-4V. As defects become less of an issue for PBF-L Ti-6Al-4V, the processing-structure-properties (PSP) relationships between AM microstructures can now be explored to optimize mechanical properties. Lower temperature aging treatments around 550 °C in wrought Ti-6A-4V have been historically understood to precipitation harden the α phase with an ordered, hexagonal close packed (HCP) α 2 phase. The α 2 phase existed as nanoscale Ti 3 Al precipitates coherent with the parent α phase. The goal of the present investigation was to implement a vacuum heat treatment of 545 °C for 100 hours on PBF-L Ti-6Al-4V. This vacuum heat treatment took place after an initial hot isostatic pressure (HIP) treatment that decomposed the as-built, martensitic microstructure. The vacuum aging successfully produced nanoscale precipitates of α 2 phase within α-laths, confirmed via atom probe tomography (APT). Microstructural-length scale and quasi-static mechanical properties were investigated by nanoindentation and uniaxial tensile tests of miniaturized test specimens. Given the sensitivity of Ti-6Al-4V mechanical properties to small changes in chemistry, all test specimens originated from the same build. The α 2 precipitation resulted in significantly harder α-laths (≈ 2 GPa) as measured via nanoindentation, as well as a relative yield and ultimate tensile strength increase of 60 MPa and 38 MPa, respectively. Analysis of Variance (ANOVA) of the datasets revealed no statistical differences in total elongation between the HIPed and HIPed + aged specimens, indicative of the aging treatment producing a net benefit of strength with no loss in ductility.

36 MATERIALS SCIENCE↗

Microstructure, stored energy, and stability of H/He-filled nanocavities in low temperature irradiated Inconel 718

The microstructure, trapped transmutation gases, stored energy, and mechanical behavior of samples from an irradiated Inconel 718 proton beam window were characterized using transmission electron microcopy, thermal desorption spectrometry (TDS), differential scanning calorimetry (DSC), and tensile testing. In the as-irradiated condition the microstructure contained a high number density of 1–3 nm gas-filled nanocavities. Emissions of trapped gases, H and He, during TDS correlated with peaks of the energy release curves from DSC examinations, which suggest these gases were likely stored in highly stable defect traps. The stored energy from radiation damage saturated at doses of a few dpa and did not increase with increasing radiation dose, but the amount of stored H and He increased with increasing dose. Effects of post-irradiation annealing were studied as well. After exposure to 700 °C, the nanocavities grew only slightly to 2–4 nm in diameter, but after exposure to 900 °C, the cavities grew to 10–20 nm in diameter and electron energy-loss spectroscopy showed these cavities contained a core of He surrounded by a shell of H. Further, this study demonstrated that the irradiation defect structures containing H and He were remarkably stable during irradiation and after exposure up to 700 °C. The effect of the irradiation temperature, defect mobility, and interaction of H, He, and irradiation defects on mechanical behavior provides insight into the processes responsible for the unusual recovery in ductility with increasing radiation dose observed in Inconel 718 after high energy proton and spallation neutron irradiation.

36 MATERIALS SCIENCE↗

Understanding the deformation behavior of the γ rich transformative Fe 38.5 Mn 20 Co 20 Cr 15 Si 5 Cu 1.5 complex concentrated alloy using in situ synchrotron diffraction

In situ tensile testing coupled with synchrotron x-ray diffraction was used to study the deformation behavior of metastability-engineered Fe 38.5 Mn 20 Co 20 Cr 15 Si 5 Cu 1.5 complex concentrated alloy. Monitoring the evolution of phase fraction and strain hardening response allowed the determination of true critical stress for the onset of the transformation-induced plasticity (TRIP) to be ∼375 MPa, preceded by slip starting at ∼255 MPa. In situ EBSD was used to validate the critical stress for transformation at the microstructure level and observe slip traces to confirm prior slip activity before the transformation. Further, a modeling framework based on stacking fault energy (SFE) was developed to predict the critical stress for transformation. Modeling suggested the SFE of the alloy to fall nearly 15 mJ/m 2 , which agrees well with SFE values calculated using synchrotron peak shifting (12 mJ/m 2 ) and thermodynamic calculation (11 mJ/m 2 ). As a result of γ-fcc to ε-hcp phase transformation, new {0002} ε planes emerged parallel to unaligned {111} γ planes with the tensile loading following S-N orientation relationship. Such selective emergence of new diffraction rings corresponding to ε phase is understood based on the reorientation of γ crystals with reference to tensile axis. In conclusion, this approach can be extended to effectively design alloys based on critical stress required for activating different deformation mechanisms to further push the limits of the strength-ductility envelope.

Complex concentrated alloy↗

A high strength Al-2Ni-0.5Zr conductor alloy fabricated via laser powder bed fusion

There is a current need for new aluminum alloy design strategies to target applications requiring high strength and conductivity with reductions in mass. A new lightweight Al-2Ni-0.5Zr (wt. %) conductor alloy was fabricated using laser powder bed fusion. A design of experiments probed the alloy's solidification cracking susceptibility. It was observed that solidification cracking was generally reduced with fast scan speeds, above 1500 mm/s, and smaller hatch spacings. The different cooling rates throughout the melt pool produced a heterogeneous distribution of cellular and equiaxed Al 3 Ni precipitates in the as-printed alloy. Additionally, the rapid solidification characteristic of laser powder bed fusion created a super-saturated Zr solid solution. An aging heat treatment at 375 °C for 24 h imparted strengthening through the precipitation of L1 2 -Al 3 Zr nanoprecipitates, which counteracted the softening caused by the fragmentation and coarsening of Al 3 Ni precipitates. The yield strength increased from 138 MPa in the as-printed condition to 168 MPa after aging, while the ductility remained constant at ∼21%. The aging treatment simultaneously increased the electrical conductivity from 40.8% IACS (International Annealed Copper Standard) to 53.5% IACS. Modeling of the strengthening mechanisms and electrical conductivity contributions rationalized the simultaneous increase in strength and conductivity upon aging. Furthermore, the strengthening efficacy of the Al 3 Ni and L1 2 -Al 3 Zr precipitates, combined with the low Ni and Zr solubility in the FCC Al matrix, facilitated both high strength and electrical conductivity. Overall, the combination of strength and electrical conductivity positions this alloy as a suitable choice for additively manufactured lightweight conductors.

Additive manufacturing↗

Mechanical properties and strengthening mechanisms of cold sprayed Al-Mg alloys

This paper investigates the mechanical properties and strengthening mechanisms of cold sprayed Al-Mg alloys as a function of Mg content. Cold spray (CS) is a solid-state deposition process that can be used as a repair technique for structural components. However, the limited ductility of cold sprayed materials is an unsettled issue in CS community. Herein, reproducible, and significantly increased elongation to failure (∼15%) in as-deposited conditions is reported in CS Al-Mg binary alloys with low Mg content (≤ 2.5 wt%). Furthermore, reducing Mg content down to 2.5 wt% in CS Al-Mg binary alloys demonstrated comparable mechanical strength to its wrought counterparts. Strengthening mechanisms were analyzed in wrought and CS Al-Mg alloys based upon microstructural characteristics, such as grain size, Mg solute concentration, and dislocation density. A quantitative evaluation of yield strength revealed that grain boundary strengthening is predominant in CS Al-Mg alloys as compared with their wrought counterparts. When comparing among CS Al-Mg binary alloys of different compositions, Mg solute concentration, and dislocation density governed mechanical strength. In conclusion, the underlying mechanism for the variation of mechanical properties and strengthening mechanisms is discussed in terms of these microstructural characteristics.

Additive manufacturing↗

Laser powder bed fusion of ODS Fe–Cr–Al (0.3Zr, 0.3Y 2 O 3 ): Unveiling processing-microstructure- mechanical property relationships

Here, this study investigates the fabrication of oxide dispersion strengthened (ODS) Fe-Cr-Al alloys via laser powder bed fusion (LPBF) with strategic additions of 0.3 wt% Zr and 0.3 wt% Y 2 O 3 for enhanced mechanical performance in nuclear applications. Systematic processing parameter optimization yielded three distinct conditions: one low-density product with significant defects and two near-full-density materials with improved consolidation. Comprehensive characterization confirmed single-phase α-ferrite matrix formation with successful incorporation of Y-, Zr-, O-, and C-rich precipitates characteristic of ODS alloys. However, precipitate density remained low (∼10 7 cm −3 ), resulting in sink strength values substantially below optimal levels for radiation resistance. Microhardness values (mid-200s HV) correlated inversely with grain size following the Hall-Petch relationship, indicating grain boundary strengthening as the dominant mechanism rather than precipitation strengthening. The optimized processing conditions achieved excellent mechanical properties with room temperature yield strength of approximately 500 MPa and 30 % elongation, demonstrating superior strength-ductility synergy compared to other additively manufactured ODS materials and performance consistent with literature values for LPBF-processed ODS-FeCrAl alloys. This investigation reveals both the potential and limitations of LPBF processing for ODS Fe-Cr-Al alloys. While successful defect-free fabrication was achieved, results highlight the critical need for systematic optimization of processing parameters and post-processing heat treatments to enhance precipitate density for effective dispersion strengthening and radiation resistance while maintaining additive manufacturing advantages.

Additive manufacturing↗

Hydrogen embrittlement and mechanical response of 304L steel with ZrC additions

While stainless steels are widely used for hydrogen storage infrastructure, they can still be vulnerable to hydrogen embrittlement justifying the need to further improve their hydrogen resiliency. Here, we investigate the potential for transition metal carbide additions to improve the hydrogen compatibility of austenitic stainless steels. ZrC nanoparticles were dispersed in contents of 0.01–10 wt% in 304 L stainless steel powder, mixed via high energy ball milling, and subsequently consolidated using direct current sintering. To assess hydrogen compatibility, the tensile properties of similarly processed 304 L without ZrC nanoparticles were compared to 304 L with the ZrC additions; both materials were evaluated prior to and after hydrogen exposure (non-charged and H-precharged, respectively). Depending upon the ZrC phase fraction, the yield strengths varied from ∼325 to 560 MPa in the non-charged condition and from ∼375 to 550 MPa in the H-precharged condition. Strain at failure varied from ∼5 to 90 % and from ∼5 to 35 % in the non-charged and hydrogen-precharged conditions, respectively. Results from stress-strain profiles demonstrate limited efficacy of ZrC as a method to mitigate hydrogen embrittlement entirely but does demonstrate the potency of ZrC inclusions as strengthening addition to 304 L alloys without a loss of ductility.

08 HYDROGEN↗

Influence of the as-built microstructure on the recrystallization of an additively manufactured Inconel939 Ni-based superalloy

This study investigates the influence of the as-built microstructure on the recrystallization (RX) behavior and mechanical properties of the Ni-based superalloy Inconel 939 produced by laser powder bed fusion (PBF-LB/M). Two distinct as-built microstructures were obtained by varying the hatch distance (h d ): a columnar, strongly textured condition (h d =50, termed h d 50) and an equiaxed, weakly textured condition (h d =70, termed h d 70)). Both were subjected to nine solution treatments combining three temperatures (1100, 1150, and 1200 °C) and three holding times (1, 4, and 8 h). Comprehensive microstructural characterization was conducted to assess grain morphology, texture, grain boundary character, dislocation density, and precipitate distribution. Recrystallization was found to be significantly slower than in cast counterparts, requiring higher temperatures and longer times for completion. The initial microstructure plays a decisive role: full RX was achieved only in hd70 specimens after treatment at 1200 °C for 8 h, whereas hd50 samples exhibited delayed and incomplete RX under identical conditions. This behavior is attributed to the finer grain size and higher fraction of high-angle grain boundaries in hd70, which promote recrystallization. Mechanical testing revealed that hd70 samples subjected to a 1200 °C/8 h treatment followed by standard double ageing show higher yield and tensile strengths across the investigated temperature range than both printed and cast Inconel939 processed under conventional conditions, albeit with slightly reduced ductility. The enhanced mechanical performance is attributed to the larger grain size, which limits grain boundary sliding. These results demonstrate the critical importance of controlling the as-built microstructure and tailoring post-processing strategies to optimize high-temperature performance of PBF-LB/M Inconel939.

Inconel939↗

Temperature dependent interfacial microstructure in HIP-bonded Al6061/Zr joints

Pressing (HIP) at 450 °C and 560 °C under 103 MPa for 90 minutes to evaluate interfacial diffusion and microstructural evolution. Sound metallurgical bonding was achieved at both temperatures, with Zr serving as an effective diffusion barrier. Microstructural analysis revealed the the formation of a (Al,Si)3Zr intermetallic layer at the Al/Zr interface, whose thickness increased from ~100 nm at 450 °C to ~2100 nm at 560 °C, consistent with temperature-driven diffusion kinetics. The thin and continuous reaction layer observed at 450 °C indicates controlled interdiffusion and minimal reaction zone growth, favorable for maintaining interface stability and ductility. At 560 °C, enhanced atomic mobility led to pronounced intermetallic development, confirming diffusion-controlled growth behavior. These results provide valuable insights for optimizing Al/Zr interface design and diffusion barrier performance in advanced structural and energy systems.

Al/Zr interface↗

New class of tritium breeders for fusion applications: Metal-reinforced composite breeders

Commercial fusion reactors operating on a D-T fuel cycle will require a steady supply of tritium to maintain the burning plasma required for continuous power generation. Since tritium has a short half-life, there is negligible natural abundance which necessitates fusion reactors to produce their own source of tritium. Tritium is most easily produced by surrounding a fusion reactor core with lithium (Li), which reacts under the intense neutron flux leaving the reactor core to form tritium and helium. Due to the hazards and technical challenges associated with surrounding a fusion reactor core with many tons of molten Li, other Li-bearing tritium breeder materials have been pursued. Unfortunately, most of the liquid breeders historically examined are exceedingly corrosive to reactor structural materials while many solid breeders in the form of ceramics are forced to make tradeoffs between Li content and mechanical integrity. In this work, to break the historic limit between Li-density and mechanical integrity of traditional solid breeders, a new class of solid tritium breeders is developed: metal-reinforced composite (MERC) breeders. Specifically, the high Li-density of lithium oxide (Li 2 O) is exploited through the addition of a metal reinforcing phase, producing a composite breeder material exhibiting high splitting tensile strength and quasi-ductility with a Li-density greater than other leading solid breeder candidates, including lithium orthosilicate (Li 4 SiO 4 ) and lithium metatitanate (Li 2 TiO 3 ). Mechanical testing, microstructural characterization, and neutronic simulation results are presented and discussed in light of fusion reactor design considerations.

11 - NUCLEAR FUEL CYCLE AND FUEL MATERIALS↗

Controlling mechanical properties of laser powder bed fused AlSi10Mg through manipulation of laser scan rotation

The microstructure and mechanical properties of laser powder bed fused (LPBF) AlSi10Mg alloys can be controlled by many processing parameters. This study focuses on the scan rotation angle, α, between adjacent layers, and establishes the relationship between α and tensile behavior of the as-built LPBF-processed AlSi10Mg alloy. Near-full density cubic coupons were manufactured using the same processing parameters but with systematic variation of α from 0° to 90°. Microscopic observations and X-ray diffraction analysis showed that differences among various coupons mainly include orientations of the melt pools with respect to the build direction and development of the crystallographic texture. The α=0° coupon and α=30° coupon showed the highest and lowest texture index, although the overall crystallographic texture was mild. Tensile specimens were manufactured horizontally and vertically using either α=0° or α=30°, but with various first layer laser direction with respect to the build plate. Notably, the α=0° specimen that was tested along the laser scan direction showed the largest yield strength (283 MPa) and highest tensile ductility (10.1 %). Quantitative image analysis and fractography were performed on all specimens. Results showed that the melt pool orientation with respect to the tensile direction affected the tensile behavior across the different specimens. This was closely related to the localized strain distribution within the melt pool and along the melt pool boundary for the different melt pool orientations observed. Further, these results demonstrate that the laser scan rotation angle between layers can be used to fine tune the mechanical properties of LPBF AlSi10Mg alloy.

36 MATERIALS SCIENCE↗

Influence of preheating on tungsten damage under pulsed hydrogen plasma exposure

Preheated tungsten plate behavior under multiple pulsed hydrogen plasma irradiations in the PW-7 plasma accelerator was investigated. The preheating temperature was 973 K, which is above the ductile to brittle transition temperature (DBTT ≈ 673 K). The plate was exposed to three consecutive series of 13 plasma pulses each. Preheating sufficiently suppressed surface cracking at the early irradiation stage: after 13 pulses, cracks were rare, localized, and did not form extensive fractures. During subsequent irradiation series, the area fraction of fine cracks increased by ∼ 2% due to accumulation of dislocations around the pre-existing defects. However, their width remained nearly constant, averaging 0.2–0.3 μm, with rare cracks up to 1 μm in size. Repeated plasma exposure resulted in pronounced surface roughening associated with multiple melting cycles, crater formation and blister rupture, with roughness reaching ∼ 204 nm and a recorded sample mass loss of ∼ 2.8 mg. These results indicate that controlling tungsten preheating well above DBTT effectively reduces damage. However, the surface condition during initial irradiation significantly influences its subsequent morphological evolution. Preheating to 773 K, selected regarding the minimum DBTT value, has previously been demonstrated to be an effective approach for limiting crack growth. A further increase in temperature of approximately ∼ 1000 K did not qualitatively improve results: crack still formed and widths did not decrease. At the same time, the absence of further crack coarsening indicates that the limiting effect of preheating has been reached. Considering the increased energy costs, further increasing the preheating temperature seems unjustified.

70 PLASMA PHYSICS AND FUSION TECHNOLOGY↗