Low cost silicon carbide fibers, tapes and architectures for accident tolerant nuclear fuel cladding and components
Explore the source record for details and available documents.
SEARCH · Search NASA
Search indexed NASA NTRS and DOE OSTI research on propulsion, heat transfer, battery materials and energy systems. Follow report and document links to the original sources.
Quote a phrase for an exact phrase match. Source license links do not imply unrestricted reuse.
Explore the source record for details and available documents.
The recent trend towards a high burn-up discharge spent nuclear fuel necessitates a thorough understanding of hydrogen uptake in Zr-based cladding materials that encapsulate spent nuclear fuel. Although it is challenging to experimentally replicate exact conditions in a nuclear reactor that lead to hydrogen uptake in claddings, in this study we have attempted to understand the kinetics of hydrogen uptake by first electrolytically charging Zircaloy-2 (Zr-2) cladding material for various durations (100 to 2,600 s), and subsequently examining hydrogen ingress with elastic recoil detection (ERD) and transmission electron microscopy (TEM). To understand the influence of irradiation damage defects on hydrogen uptake, an analogous study was performed on ion - irradiated (0.1, 1 and 25 dpa) Zr-2. Analysis of ERD data from the un-irradiated Zr-2 suggests that the growth of the hydride layer is diffusion controlled, and preliminary TEM results support this assertion. In un-irradiated Zr-2, the diffusivity of hydrogen in the hydride phase was found to be approximately 1.1 Multiplication-Sign 10{sup -11} cm{sup 2}/s, while the diffusivity in the hydride phase for lightly irradiated (0.1 and 1 dpa) Zr-2 is an order of magnitude lower. Irradiation to 25 dpa results in a hydrogen diffusivity that is comparable to the un-irradiated Zr-2. These results are compared with existing literature on hydrogen transport in Zr - based materials.
No abstract prepared.
In this work, high purity SiC and SiC/SiC composites coated with commercial TiN, Cr, CrN, or CrN/Cr multilayer coatings were irradiated in Ar or flowing PWR water in the Massachusetts Institute of Technology Nuclear Reactor Laboratory (MITR). Irradiation in Ar was performed in the core. In the water environment, identical samples were placed in one of three different locations: in-core, providing exposure to neutron damage and radiolysis-affected water; above-core, where samples were exposed to radiolysis-affected water but not neutron damage, or outside of the core, where samples were exposed to the coolant water without the effects of radiation. Radiation in Ar revealed significant cracking of all but the TiN coatings, attributed to differential swelling between the coating and substrate. Lattice swelling was not observed in any of the coatings, but 0.2% void swelling was observed in the Cr coating. All of the coatings failed during water exposures in the core. Likewise, CrN/Cr spalled in each condition. Cr was protective, except under radiation damage as a result of cracking, and TiN severely degraded in the core with no coating was found following exposure. A SiC/coating ATF cladding system is anticipated to perform adequately following improvements in coating ductility and purity.
Thermal–hydraulics (T-H) experiments have been on the progress to evaluate boiling heat transfer characteristics of accident tolerant fuel (ATF) candidates for further supporting the core-loading of these advanced ATF concepts in light water reactors (LWRs). Here this study covers recent experimental studies of ATF claddings and summarizes some significant results. Recent T-H experimental results of ATF cladding candidates demonstrated that the material thermal–physical properties have pronounced effects on critical heat flux (CHF). Such effects have not been well resolved in the current physics-governing models. These effects of cladding materials on CHF could be potentially rationalized by the material-conjugated boiling heat transfer, where the material-dominated heat conduction competes with the flow boiling-dominated heat convection. As progressively increasing the mass flux and/or liquid subcooling, CHF differences between different materials gradually decrease, which is in agreement with the recent T-H experimental results of ATF claddings. This is because the dominance of heat convection over heat conduction is primarily improved by liquid subcooling and/or mass flow rate. It is noteworthy that surface oxidization of claddings may have unknown impacts on T-H performances because the formation of oxide layers on cladding surfaces introduces variations of material thermal–physical properties and then changes the surface morphological features, which results in some difficulties in evaluating the thermal safety margins of ATF claddings.
Not Available
SiC-based ceramic matrix composites (CMCs) [5–8] are being developed and evaluated internationally as potential LWR cladding options. These development activities include interests within both the DOE-NE LWR Sustainability (LWRS) Program and the DOE-NE Advanced Fuels Campaign. The LWRS Program considers SiC ceramic matrix composites (CMCs) as offering potentially revolutionary gains as a cladding material, with possible benefits including more efficient normal operating conditions and higher safety margins under accident conditions [9]. Within the Advanced Fuels Campaign, SiC-based composites are a candidate ATF cladding material that could achieve several goals, such as reducing the rates of heat and hydrogen generation due to lower cladding oxidation rates in HT steam [10]. This work focuses on the application of SiC cladding as an ATF cladding material in PWRs, but these work efforts also support the general development and assessment of SiC as an LWR cladding material in a much broader sense.
This report uses thermal and decay heat modeling to investigate spent fuel performance and the potential for cladding to anneal in dry storage conditions. Annealing is an important feature to investigate in SNF cladding because it has a direct relationship to cladding response in storage, transportation and disposal conditions. Annealed cladding may have lower strength than unannealed cladding, however its increased ductility would provide better protection against rupture in high strain rate situations such as severe accidents. These consequences are the driver for this work however are outside of the scope of this report. The modeling focused on three representative storage systems, the TN-32B, MAGNASTOR with TSC-37 canister, and NUHOMS AHSM with a 32PTH2 canister. This covers the vertical dual-purpose, vertical ventilated and horizontal ventilated casks respectively. Decay heat modeling using high and low enrichment assemblies was used to bound the decay heat curves that might be expected in dry storage. To bound the temperature relationship, the storage casks were modeled starting at the design basis heat loads with heat decaying through time. Although the results are bounding there is not an attempt to maximize conservatism, rather the intent to form a reasonable upper limit on temperature that will be broadly applicable to the U.S. cask fleet. This will allow materials testing to focus on relevant conditions for annealing that may affect the U.S. spent fuel inventory. The results show a clear dependence on heat load pattern in time in Figure S-1 and Figure S-2. This dependence is due to the different assembly decay heat curves for different assemblies in preferentially loaded casks. It shows the need for careful decay heat modeling when examining in service fuel temperatures that are less than the cask design basis heat load. The body of the report shows percent cladding cutoffs of 300°C and 350 °C as well. These results can be used to inform testing and conclusions about cladding performance through time and the potential for cladding annealing during dry storage.
Building the material database for accident tolerant fuel concepts requires movement of experiments to ORNL from other national laboratories, commercial reactors, and international collaborators. This report summarizes the current fleet of available and proposed casks for handling small scale fuel shipments and the immediate challenges to be addressed in order to perform shipments in support of accident tolerant fuels development under the Advanced Fuels Campaign. Shipping recommendations and a description of unresolved issues associated with the shipment are provided for three experiments: ATF-1 LOCA (ATF-18), the Halden irradiated Instrumented Fuel Assembly (IFA) 796 experiment, and the Hatch lead test rods. Each of these experiments represents an important step in continuing the accelerated testing of FeCrAl cladding for commercial applications.
The Idaho National Laboratory (INL) Transient Reactor Test Facility (TREAT) is a nuclear test facility designed to provide safety data for fuel designs by simulating conditions during various types of nuclear excursions. The M5 alloy cladding material for the conceptual TREAT Low Enriched Uranium fuel core shall be supplied according to this specification.
Multi-layered Silicon Carbide (SiC) cladding has been proposed to replace the current Zircaloy (Zr) cladding in existing nuclear power plants. Due to its ceramic property, SiC may have a different failure mechanism from that of metallic Zr clad. This characteristic should be considered in designing the plant’s safety system performance, such that the fuel’s integrity is reasonably assured during accident scenarios. This paper aims at optimizing the Emergency Core Cooling System (ECCS) performance criteria in mitigating LBLOCA accidents at a Pressurized Water Reactor (PWR) using the uranium dioxide fuel and duplex or triplex SiC cladding structures. Clad failures by brittle fractures and thermal degradation were modeled in a fuel analysis code. This fuel model was coupled with the RELAP5 plant model by adapting the fuel’s mesh configuration and formulating the effective heat transfer coefficients. A model to quantify the likelihood of clad functional failure as a combination of individual layer fractures at various axial positions was proposed. Updated SiC material properties were gathered from recent reference studies. Clad reliability estimates using the proposed model were compared with the estimates obtained using other models. The results were used to relax the criterion of required actuation timing of ECCS, such that the risk of the new plant design is less or equal to that of the initial plant configuration. Triplex clad was more reliable than duplex clad and Zr, reducing the conditional core damage probability by three orders of magnitude in the reference LBLOCA scenario. Compressive stresses due to irradiation swelling played the determining role in the vulnerabilities of each clad design. The duplex clad was vulnerable to pressure-loading stresses while triplex clad was prone to fail due to thermal shocks experienced during the LOCA reflood phase. Additionally, it was concluded that the most vulnerable axial fuel rod location in the reference LBLOCA scenario was located at the highest axial power peaking location. A sensitivity study on the ECCS timing density was conducted. The results showed that ECCS actuation timing could be extended from the initial technical specification, without increasing the fuel damage likelihood. The time extension was distributed in the order of several hundreds of seconds, which was comparable with time extensions offered by FeCrAl and Cr-coated-Zr clad designs in LBLOCA scenarios. This time extension may potentially reduce the failure probabilities of EDGs and pumps, hence improving the plant safety further.
Alternative cladding materials to Zr-based alloys are being investigated for accident tolerance, which can be defined as > 100X improvement (compared to Zr-based alloys) in oxidation resistance to steam or steam-H 2 environments at ≥ 1200°C for short times. After reviewing a wide range of candidates, current steam oxidation testing is being conducted on Mo, MAX phases and FeCrAl alloys. Recently reported low mass losses for Mo in steam at 800°C could not be reproduced. Both FeCrAl and MAX phase Ti 2 AlC form a protective alumina scale in steam. However, commercial Ti 2 AlC that was not single phase, formed a much thicker oxide at 1200°C in steam and significant TiO 2 , and therefore Ti 2 AlC may be challenging to form as a cladding or a coating. Alloy development for FeCrAl is seeking to maintain its steam oxidation resistance to 1475°C, while reducing its Cr content to minimize susceptibility to irradiation-assisted α´ formation. The composition effects and critical limits to retaining protective scale formation at > 1400°C are still being evaluated.
Alternative cladding materials are being investigated for accident tolerance, which can be defined as >100X improvement (compared to current Zr-based alloys) in oxidation resistance in steam environments at ≥1200°C for short (≤4 h) times. After reviewing a wide range of candidates, current steam oxidation testing is being conducted on Mo, MAX phases and FeCrAl alloys. Recently reported low mass losses for Mo in steam at 800°C could not be reproduced. Both FeCrAl and MAX phase Ti 2 AlC form a protective alumina scale in steam. Therefore, commercial Ti 2 AlC that is not single phase, formed a much thicker oxide at 1200°C in steam and significant TiO 2 , and therefore may be challenging to use as a cladding or a coating. Alloy development for FeCrAl is seeking to maintain its steam oxidation resistance to 1475°C, while reducing its Cr content to minimize susceptibility to irradiation assisted Cr-rich α’ formation. The composition effects and critical limits to retaining protective scale formation at >1400°C are still being evaluated.
Here, this work is motivated by the desire to devise an internal pressure test that can mimic a displacement-controlled loading scenario and demonstrate how to apply the multiaxial stress and strain data from the test to develop an elastic/plastic constitutive model for a thin-walled tubular component. This is achieved by conducting simultaneous measurements of tangential and axial strain during the pressure test and integrating these strain measures into a feedback loop with the pressure controller. It is shown how data from such a test can be used to develop a large mechanical property data set relevant to biaxial loading conditions. The data obtained have high confidence evidenced by their low variability and alignment with other literature studies. Additionally, data from these internal pressure tests combined with full-tube axial tensile tests allow for the derivation of the Hill anisotropic yield function. The developed Hill yield function is validated by comparing the plastic strain ratios from the full-tube tension tests and by comparing the predicted yield stress in the tangential direction with measured values from ring tension tests in a previous study.
In this work, SiC-SiC tubes with representative LWR (water cooled reactor) cladding dimensions were subjected to cycles of out-of-pile thermal stress followed by quenching. Samples were held at elevated temperatures and dropped into a water bath to replicate the high thermal stresses generated during reflooding. The samples were then characterized to measure changes in strength, permeability, and structure. Results were evaluated both for quenching into room temperature and boiling water. The results show that SiC-SiC composite tubes quenched from 1000 Celsius degrees in air into a boiling water bath exhibited no increase in He leak rate through the cylinder wall up to a pressure difference of 34.5 kPa compared to the as-fabricated state. SiC-SiC composite tubes quenched from 300-400 C. degrees into room temperature water showed an increase in He leak rate compared to the as-fabricated state. We attribute this to the more severe thermal gradient generated through the wall thickness due to higher heat flux characteristic of nucleate boiling compared to film boiling. A persistent vapor film forms around the samples quenched into boiling water, whereas no vapor film forms for the samples quenched into room temperature water. Another important result is that not loss in strength was noted compared to unquenched samples and that the stresses generated by the quenching were not enough to cause fiber fracture.
After the Fukushima nuclear disaster, the nuclear materials community has been vastly investing in accident tolerant fuel (ATF) concepts to modify/replace Zircaloy cladding material. Iron–chromium–aluminum (FeCrAl) alloys are one of the leading contenders in this race. In this study, we investigated FA-SMT (or APMT-2), PM-C26M, and Fe17Cr5.5Al over a time period of 6 months in simulated BWR environments and compared their performance with standard Zirc-2 and SS316 materials. Our results implied that water chemistry along with alloy chemistry has a profound effect on the corrosion rate of FeCrAl alloys. Apart from SS316 and Zirc-2 tube specimens, all FeCrAl alloys showed a mass loss in hydrogen water chemistry (HWC). FA-SMT displayed minimal mass loss compared to PM-C26M and Fe17Cr5.5Al because of its higher Cr content. The mass gain of FeCrAl alloys in normal water chemistry (NWC) is significantly less when compared to Zirc-2.
The U.S. Department of Energy Office of Nuclear Energy, Office of Fuel Cycle Technology established the Used Fuel Disposition Campaign (UFDC) to conduct research and development activities related to storage, transportation, and disposal of used nuclear fuel (UNF) and high-level radioactive waste. Within the UFDC, the storage and transportation task has been created to address issues of extended storage and transportation. One gap in knowledge identified as high priority by UFDC includes hydrogen effects in zirconium alloy cladding and reorientation of cladding hydrides. During reactor operations, hydrogen is generated from the oxidation of the surface of zirconium alloy materials in the coolant of light water reactors can be absorbed into the cladding and form zirconium hydrides. At high temperatures and hoop stresses, these normally circumferential oriented hydrides in high burnup UNF (HB-UNF) may reorient in the radial direction and affect the mechanical properties of the cladding. Understanding these changes in mechanical properties will aid in analyzing how UNF will perform during storage and transportation. Separate effects testing to measure the mechanical properties of un-hydrided, pre-hydrided, and irradiated HB-UNF is currently underway at Pacific Northwest National Laboratory (PNNL). In order to measure these mechanical properties, staff at PNNL are employing tensile, compression, and burst testing. Systems have been developed to pre-hydride cladding and reorient cladding hydrides. The development of these systems and the testing methods are described herein.
In 2017, a report was prepared by the Spent Nuclear Fuel Working Group in 2017 and titled “Technical Considerations and Challenges for Extended (>50 Years) Dry Storage” [1-2]. In this report several key scientific issues were identified pertaining to the problem of aluminum spent nuclear fuel (ASNF) and its safe removal from wet storage with subsequent drying and transfer to dry storage at the Department of Energy (DOE) Idaho National Laboratory (INL). This report outlines two modeling analyses performed for aluminum and aluminum oxides. The first analysis examined the solubility of aluminum oxides as a function of temperature and pH. This report presents existing literature produced as far back as the 1950’s and including significant analysis and reporting performed at Alcoa in the 1980’s. The primary technical gap was the lack of solubility data beyond that reported at standard temperature (25°C). The analysis examined these solubility curves as a function of temperature as well as phase type. The pH value of minimum solubility shifted with temperature but was insensitive to the oxide phase type. The solubility increases with temperature as would be expected, where an order of magnitude increase was observed from 25°C and 90°C. This data provides greater information to understand the various conditions experiences by ASNF including in dry storage in cases where water filming may occur. A second thermodynamic analysis was performed to examine the aluminum phase behavior as a function of temperature. This was performed to understand limitations and possible problems with fuel drying at elevated temperatures. Based on what has been established in previous reports, water remains chemically entrained within boehmite until temperatures exceeding 400°C. Analysis showed that significant phase changes occurred with highly alloyed AA6061 and AA5052 while the more pure aluminum (AA1100) showed nearly ideal behavior (i.e. limited phase changes). In the case of the more alloyed AA5052 and AA6061, the phase changes could take place at relatively low temperatures (100°C to 250°C), and thus may have already experienced some of these phase changes in service. As results are thermodynamic in nature, assessment of kinetics will be examined to determine if the phase changes are a concern for the relatively short fuel drying step.