Fuels and Materials Irradiation Testing Needs, Recent Progress, and Future Opportunities
Explore the source record for details and available documents.
SEARCH · Search NASA
Search indexed NASA NTRS and DOE OSTI research on propulsion, heat transfer, battery materials and energy systems. Follow report and document links to the original sources.
Quote a phrase for an exact phrase match. Source license links do not imply unrestricted reuse.
Explore the source record for details and available documents.
Explore the source record for details and available documents.
Summary of activities from NMDQi/AMMT to be presented to the annual AMMT program integration meeting
The AGR-1 TRISO particle irradiation test was the first Advanced Gas Reactor test irradiated in the Advanced Test Reactor (ATR) at the Idaho National Laboratory. The TRISO particle fuel was 350 μm diameter uranium oxy-carbide (UCO) kernels enriched to 19.75 wt% U-235. The particles were embedded in cylindrical graphite compacts, placed in test capsules, and irradiated over a period of three years or 13 ATR power cycles. The fuel compacts achieved burnups approaching 20% FIMA and accumulated fast fluence up to 4.25E+25 n/m 2 (E n >0.18 MeV). This report describes the AGR-1 test train, capsules, compacts, and TRISO particle fuel in sufficient detail for a physics analyst to model the AGR-1 experiment as part of a larger ATR neutron transport model and perform a depletion calculation. The intent of the data herein is to define a practical numerical TRISO particle depletion benchmark problem for the AGR 1 irradiation test.
Four post-irradiation heating tests of fuel compacts from the U.S. Advanced Gas Reactor (AGR)-3/4 irradiation experiment were completed. In addition to tristructural isotropic (TRISO)-coated driver fuel, each compact contained designed-to-fail (DTF) particles with fuel kernels coated only in pyrocarbon so as to simulate exposed kernels. Tests at 1600/1700°C, 1400°C, and 1200°C were performed to measure fission product release as a function of time and temperature. Silver release was highest in the 1200°C test, supporting the observation that silver release rates are highest in the 1100–1300°C range. Compared to tests of AGR-1 compacts with no exposed kernels, the Cs-134 and Kr-85 releases were noticeably higher in AGR-3/4. The exposed kernels’ contributions to Eu and Sr release are inconclusive, due to the difficulty in distinguishing among the combined effects of higher irradiation temperatures in these particular AGR-3/4 compacts, the presence of the DTF particles, and the Fuel Accident Condition Simulator (FACS) test temperatures. These data can be used to make inferences about fission product retention in exposed kernels as a function of time and temperature.
Polymer solidification was attempted to produce stable waste form for the boric acid concentrates and the dewatered spent resins. The polymer mixture was directly injected into the mold or drum which was packed with the boric acid concentrates and the dewatered spent resins, respectively. The waste form was produced by entirely curing the polymer mixture. A series of performance tests was conducted including compressive strength test, water immersion test, leach test, thermal stability test, irradiation stability test and biodegradation stability test for the polymer waste forms. From the results of the performance tests for the polymer waste forms, it is believed that the polymer waste form is very stable and can satisfy the acceptance criteria for permanent disposal. At present, performance tests with full scale polymer waste forms are being carried out in order to obtain qualification certificate by the regulatory institute in Korea. Polymer waste forms were prepared with the surrogate of boric acid concentrates and the surrogate of spent ion exchange resins respectively. Waste forms were also made in lab scale and in full scale. Lab. scale waste forms were directly subjected to a series of the performance tests. In the case of full scale waste form, the test specimens for the performance test were taken from a part of waste form by coring. A series of performance tests was conducted including compressive strength test, thermal stability test, irradiation stability test and biodegradation stability test, water immersion test, leach test, and free standing water for the polymer waste forms. In addition, a fire resistance test was performed on the waste forms by the requirement of the regulatory institute in Korea. Every polymer waste forms containing the boric acid concentrates and the spent ion exchange resins had exhibited excellent structural integrity of more than 27.58 MPa (4,000 psi) of compressive strength. On thermal stability testing, biodegradation testing and water immersion testing, no degradation was observed in the waste forms. Also, by measuring the compressive strength after these tests, it was confirmed that the structural integrity was still retained. A leach test was performed by using non radioactive cobalt, cesium and strontium. The leaching of cobalt, cesium and strontium from the polymer waste forms was very low. Also, the polymer waste forms were found to possess adequate fire resistance. From the results of the performance tests, it is believed that the polymer waste form is very stable and can satisfy the acceptance criteria for permanent disposal. At present, Performance tests with full scale polymer waste forms are on-going in order to obtain qualification certificate by the regulatory institute in Korea. (authors)
Abstract –Fuel irradiation testing and post-irradiation examination are currently in progress as part of the Next Generation Nuclear Plant Fuels Development and Qualification Program. The PIE campaign will include extensive accident testing of irradiated very high temperature reactor fuel compacts to verify fission product retention characteristics at high temperatures. This work will be carried out at both the Idaho National Laboratory (INL) and the Oak Ridge National Laboratory, beginning with accident tests on irradiated fuel from the AGR-1 experiment in 2010. A new furnace system has been designed, built, and tested at INL to perform high temperature accident tests. The Fuel Accident Condition Simulator furnace system is designed to heat fuel specimens at temperatures up to 2000°C in helium while monitoring the release of volatile fission metals (e.g. Cs, Ag, Sr, Eu, and I) and fission gases (Kr, Xe). Fission gases released from the fuel to the sweep gas are monitored in real time using dual cryogenic traps fitted with high purity germanium detectors. Condensable fission products are collected on a plate attached to a water-cooled cold finger that can be exchanged periodically without interrupting the test. Analysis of fission products on the condensation plates involves dry gamma counting followed by chemical analysis of selected isotopes. This paper will describe design and operational details of the Fuel Accident Condition Simulator (FACS) furnace system, as well as preliminary system calibration results.
FeCrAl alloys are a promising new class of alloys for light water reactor (LWR) applications due to their superior oxidation and corrosion resistance in high temperature environments. The current R&D efforts have focused on the alloy composition and processing routes to generate nuclear grade FeCrAl alloys with optimized properties for enhanced accident tolerance while maintaining properties needed for normal operation conditions. Therefore, the composition and processing routes must be optimized to maintain the high temperature steam oxidation (typically achieved by increasing the Cr and Al content) while still exhibiting properties conducive to normal operation in a LWR (such as radiation tolerance where reducing Cr content is favorable). Within this balancing act is the addition of understanding the influence on composition and processing routes on the FeCrAl alloys for fuel-cladding chemical interactions (FCCI). Currently, limited knowledge exists on FCCI for the FeCrAl-UO 2 clad-fuel system. To overcome the knowledge gaps on the FCCI for the FeCrAl-UO2 clad-fuel system a series of fueled irradiation tests have been developed for irradiation in the Advanced Test Reactor (ATR) housed at the Idaho National Laboratory (INL). The first series of tests has already been reported. These tests used miniaturized 17x17 PWR fuel geometry rodlets of second-generation FeCrAl alloys fueled with industrial Westinghouse UO 2 fuel. These rodlets were encapsulated within a stainless steel housing.To provide high fidelity experiments and more robust testing, a new series of rodlets have been developed deemed the Accident Tolerant Fuel Experiment #1 Oak Ridge National Laboratory FCCI test (ATF-1 ORNL FCCI). The main driving factor, which is discussed in detail, was to provide a radiation environment where prototypical fuel-clad interface temperatures are met while still maintaining constant contact between industrial fuel and the candidate cladding alloys, hence promoting FCCI between the fuel-clad systems. The other factor was to develop a test bed where multiple candidate alloys could be evaluated within a single irradiation test train, thereby reducing overall costs and increasing efficiency in alloy screening efforts. A collaboration between ORNL and INL was developed to facilitate the completion of the test bed for FCCI testing. The report highlights the activities related to the development of the ATF-1 ORNL FCCI rodlets for irradiation in INL’s ATR as part of the on-going ATF-1 experiments.
This report summarizes the completed post-irradiation tensile testing of five ferritic-martensitic (FM) steel SS-J2 specimens at the Irradiated Materials Examination and Testing (IMET) hot cell facility at Oak Ridge National Laboratory (ORNL). A brief description of the motivation for the study, the properties and irradiation conditions of the samples, and the tensile testing conditions are provided. The results will be used to compare the mechanical properties of the irradiated specimens to un-irradiated conditions to determine how irradiation affects the steel alloy material behavior.
Abstract The Mechanistic Fuel Failure (MFF) series of metal fuel irradiations conducted in the Fast Flux Test Facility (FFTF) provides an important potential comparison between data generated in the Experimental Breeder Reactor (EBR-II) and that expected in a larger-scale fast reactor. The irradiations were the beginning tests to qualify U-10wt%Zr as a driver fuel for FFTF. The FFTF core, with a 91.4 cm tall fuel column and a chopped cosine neutron flux profile, operated with a peak cladding temperature at the top of the fuel column, but developed peak burnup at the centerline of the core. This places the peak fuel temperature midway between the core center and the top of fuel, lower in the fuel column than in previous EBR-II experiments that had a 32-cm height core. The MFF-3 and MFF-5 qualification assemblies operated in FFTF to >10 at% burnup, and performed very well with no cladding breaches. The MFF-3 assembly operated to 13.8 at% burnup with a peak inner cladding temperature of 643°C, and the MFF-5 assembly operated to 10.1 at% burnup with a peak inner cladding temperature of 651°C. Because of the very high operating temperatures for both the fuel and the cladding, data from the MFF assemblies are most comparable to the data obtained from the EBR-II X447 experiment, which experienced two pin breaches. The X447 breaches were strongly influenced by a large amount of fuel/cladding chemical interaction (FCCI). The MFF pins benefitted from different axial locations of high burnup and peak cladding temperature, which helped to reduce interdiffusion between rare earth fission products and stainless steel cladding. Post-irradiation examination evidence illustrates this advantage. Comparing other performance data of the long MFF pins to prior EBR-II test data, the MFF fuel inside the cladding grew less axially, and the gas release data did not reveal a definitive difference.
A furnace system was developed to thermally expose individual tristructural-isotropic (TRISO) coated particles to expand upon established postirradiation examination (PIE) safety testing that is used to explore particle failures and fission product release from compacts. Two systems were installed in the Irradiated Fuels Examination Facility (IFEL) at Oak Ridge National Laboratory (ORNL). The targeted design was intended to be simple and flexible to allow a range in conditions to be explored. Initial inert atmosphere testing indicated the presence of particle failures, so modifications to the testing approach were implemented to improve the furnace operation. Ultimately, burnback particles were analyzed to provide a direct measurement of fission product release, thus avoiding the complications from integral release that were observed during whole compact testing. Particles were exposed to temperatures ranging 1,150–1,300°C for up to 1,500 h and 1,600°C up to 500 h. No indication of uniform release of fission products such as 106 Ru, 125 Sb, or 154 Eu was observed, however, indication of particle dependent 154 Eu release was suggested for select particles. Exploration of 110m Ag release was limited to 1,150°C and 1,300°C up to 500 h. The analysis indicated that there was nonuniform release of 110m Ag and supports a possible bimodal temperature dependence on silver release.
Explore the source record for details and available documents.
This document presents the test plan for the AGR-5/6/7 irradiation experiment, the combined fifth, sixth, and seventh irradiations of the United States Department of Energy Advanced Gas Reactor (AGR) Fuel Development and Qualification Program. The combined irradiation tests will consist of fuel qualification tests (AGR-5/6) and a margin test (AGR-7) for the industrially produced uranium oxycarbide (UCO) tristructural isotropic (TRISO) coated particle fuel developed by the AGR Program. The objective of the AGR-5/6/7 irradiation experiment is to establish the performance of UCO TRISO fuel fabricated using engineering-scale equipment in a production environment under and beyond normal operating conditions. Specifically, the goals of the AGR 5/6/7 irradiation experiment are: 1. Irradiate reference design fuel containing low-enriched UCO TRISO fuel particles to support fuel qualification. 2. Establish the operating margins for the fuel beyond normal operating conditions. 3. Provide irradiated fuel performance data and irradiated fuel samples for post-irradiation examination and safety testing. 4. Support the refinement of fuel performance and fission product transport models with online, post-irradiation examination and safety test data. In order to achieve the test objectives, the AGR-5/6/7 experiment will be irradiated in the northeast flux trap position of the Advanced Test Reactor at Idaho National Laboratory. The larger diameter of the northeast flux trap provides greater flexibility for test train design, significantly enhancing the capability for the combined irradiations. The test train contains five separate and independently controlled and monitored capsules. The middle capsule contains the AGR 7 margin test fuel. The two bottom and two top capsules contain the AGR 5/6 fuel. Each capsule contains a variable number of fuel compacts filled with UCO TRISO particles.
Post-irradiation examination (PIE) is being performed in support of tristructural isotropic (TRISO) coated particle fuel development and qualification for High Temperature Gas-cooled Reactors (HTGRs). This work is sponsored by the Department of Energy Office of Nuclear Energy (DOE-NE) through the Advanced Reactor Technologies (ART) Office under the Advanced Gas Reactor Fuel Development and Qualification (AGR) Program. The AGR-1 experiment was the first in a series of TRISO fuel irradiation tests initiated in 2006. The AGR-1 TRISO particles and fuel compacts were fabricated at Oak Ridge National Laboratory (ORNL) in 2006 using laboratory-scale equipment and irradiated for 3 years in the Advanced Test Reactor (ATR) at Idaho National Laboratory (INL) to demonstrate and evaluate fuel performance under HTGR irradiation conditions. Post-irradiation examination was performed at INL and ORNL to study how the fuel behaved during irradiation, and to test fuel performance during exposure to elevated temperatures at or above temperatures that could occur during a depressurized conduction cooldown event. This report summarizes safety testing and post-safety testing PIE conducted at ORNL on loose particles extracted from irradiated AGR-1 Compact 4-4-2.
The Advanced Gas Reactor (AGR) program has a need to perform high-temperature oxidation testing of tristructural isotropic (TRISO)-coated particle fuel and reactor core materials to evaluate their performance under conditions relevant to air- and moisture-ingress events in high-temperature gas-cooled reactors (HTGRs). The objectives of these tests are to assess the impact of oxidizing environments on fission product release from exposed fuel kernels, compact matrix, and nuclear grade graphite, and to determine the impact of oxidizing environments on TRISO coating integrity. The program is currently developing a capability for testing irradiated fuel, matrix, and graphite specimens inside a hot cell. The Air/Moisture Ingress Experiment (AMIX) system will be capable of temperatures up to 1650°C in atmospheres containing oxygen or moisture with varying concentrations. The system will be capable of collecting fission gases as well as condensable fission products, in order to quantify total released inventory from the heated specimens. A basis for establishing experimental test matrices, and the test matrices themselves, are presented in this document. This includes considerations on specific objectives for the tests, types of oxidizing environments that should be tested, and the expected availability of irradiated specimens from the various AGR program irradiation experiments. This document only briefly discusses post-test analysis of the heated specimens, and it is recognized that in many cases the post-test analysis may be extensive. It is expected that this will be a “living” document, subject to revision as data are collected and scoping calculations are performed.
Irradiation creep compliance is a critical parameter for evaluating the stress evolution of silicon carbide (SiC) components during operation in various reactor concepts. Recent instrumented irradiation creep testing of SiC, performed at low dose in the Halden reactor, showed a creep compliance that is orders of magnitude higher than previous un-instrumented bend relaxation experiments performed in the High Flux Isotope Reactor (HFIR). This discrepancy illustrates the need for additional irradiation creep data for SiC. To this end, a novel irradiation capsule design has been developed to test miniature SiC tensile specimens under loading during irradiation in the HFIR. The experiment design uses the coolant pressure of the HFIR to compress a bellows, which applies the loading on the specimen. Preliminary thermal finite element models were developed to estimate the temperature distribution within the specimen and surrounding capsule components. Similar structural models were developed to evaluate the stress distribution within the specimen. The thermal analyses show that within the gauge section, the specimen temperatures remain within ~10°C of the nominal 300°C design temperature. Similarly, the structural analysis predicts axial stresses within ~10 MPa of the target stress of 100 MPa. These initial analyses show that irradiation creep testing of SiC in the HFIR is feasible and could provide a low-cost, high-throughput vehicle for gathering needed irradiation creep data.
Three post-irradiation heating tests of fuel compacts from the US AGR-3/4 irradiation experiment. In addition to TRISO-coated driver fuel, each compact contained 20 particles with UCO fuel kernels coated only in pyrocarbon to simulate exposed kernels. Tests at 1600/1700°C, 1400°C, and 1200°C were performed to measure fission product releases as a function of time and temperature. Silver releases were highest in the 1200°C test, supporting the observation that silver release rates are highest in the temperature range of 1100-1300°C. Except for Ag-110m (which was released in multiple particle equivalents) releases of Cs, Kr, Eu, and Sr were all less than one particle inventory per compact. This suggests that exposed kernels retain little Cs and Kr after irradiation. Despite these low releases, compared to tests of compacts with no exposed kernels, the Cs and Kr releases were noticeably higher, and at 1600°C the exposed kernels contributed noticeably more Eu and Sr than in AGR-1 compacts with no exposed kernels. These data can be used to make inferences on retention of fission products in exposed kernels.