Measured indoor PM2.5, black carbon, and oxidative potential before and after replacing gas with induction cooking in asthmatic households
Cooking is a major source of fine particulate matter (PM) in homes and evidence to date is inconclusive about the impact of cooking fuel on measures of residential PM exposure. The Cooking Energy and Ventilation Impacts on Children's Asthma (CEVICA) study measured cooking frequency, range hood use, indoor air quality (IAQ) and respiratory health indicators of children with asthma living in homes with gas stoves in California's San Joaquin Valley. Intensive measurements occurred over three 2-week intensive periods: at baseline and at the end of two consecutive 3-month study phases. Participants were randomly assigned to have their gas stoves replaced with electric induction at the start of Phase 1 or Phase 2. As part of the IAQ assessment, we collected particulate matter on Teflon filters using ultrasonic personal air samplers (UPAS). The filters were analyzed to quantify time-integrated PM 2.5 mass concentration, black carbon (BC) oxidative potential (OP). OP was measured using the SLF-OH assay, an acellular chemical assay that quantifies production of OH radicals in simulated lung fluid (SLF). Across all comparisons, PM 2.5 mass tended to be higher during gas cooking than induction electric cooking, although only one transition (Baseline to Phase 1) was statistically discernible at p<0.05. BC and mass-normalized OP showed no measurable differences across stove types or across phases. These preliminary findings suggest that stove fuel alone may not be the dominant determinant of indoor PM 2.5 concentrations in this sample, as previous studies have reported that indoor PM 2.5 during cooking can also be influenced by factors such as cooking practices, food and oil type, kitchen ventilation, and outdoor infiltration.