Dissimilar Metal Bonding of Corrosion-Resistant Cladding to Structural Materials in Next Generation Nuclear Reactors
Explore the source record for details and available documents.
Cladding, corrosion resistance, molten salts, molt↗
SEARCH · Search NASA
Results for “nuclear cladding”
Search indexed NASA NTRS and DOE OSTI research on propulsion, heat transfer, battery materials and energy systems. Follow report and document links to the original sources.
Quote a phrase for an exact phrase match. Source license links do not imply unrestricted reuse.
A comparative study on the wear behaviors of cladding candidates for accident-tolerant fuel
Accident-tolerant fuels are expected to have considerably longer coping time to respond to the loss of active cooling under severe accidents and, at the same time, have comparable or improved fuel performance during normal operation. The wear resistance of accident tolerant fuels, therefore, needs to be examined to determine the applicability of these cladding candidates to the current operating PWRs because the most common failure of nuclear fuel claddings is still caused by grid-to-rod fretting during normal operations. In this study, reciprocating sliding wear tests on three kinds of cladding candidates for accident-tolerant fuels have been performed to investigate the tribological compatibilities of selfmated cladding candidates and to determine the direct applicability of conventional Zirconium-based alloys as supporting structural materials. The friction coefficients of the cladding candidates are strongly influenced by the test environments and coupled materials. The wear test results under water lubrication conditions indicate that the supporting structural materials for the cladding candidates of accident-tolerant fuels need to be replaced with the same cladding materials instead of using conventional Zirconium-based alloys.
11 NUCLEAR FUEL CYCLE AND FUEL MATERIALS↗
Probabilistic Failure Analysis for Wound Composite Ceramic Cladding Assembly
Advanced ceramic matrix composites based on silicon carbide (SiC) are being considered as candidate material systems for nuclear fuel cladding in light water reactors. The SiC composite structure is considered due to its assumed exceptional performance under accident scenarios, where its excellent high-temperature strength and slow reaction kinetics with steam and associated mitigated hydrogen production are desirable. The specific structures of interest consist of a monolithic SiC cylinder surrounded by interphase-coated SiC woven fibers in a tubular form and infiltrated with SiC. Additional SiC coatings on the outermost surface of the assembly are also being considered to prevent hydrothermal corrosion of the fibrous structure. The inner monolithic cylinder is expected to provide a hermetic seal to contain fission products under normal conditions. While this approach offers the promise of higher burn-up rates and safer behavior in the case of LOCA events, the reliability of such structures must be demonstrated in advance. Therefore, a probability failure analysis study was performed of such monolithic-composite hybrid structures to determine the feasibility of these design concepts. This analysis will be used to predict the future performance of candidate systems in an effort to determine the feasibility of these design concepts and to make future recommendations regarding materials selection.
Hemrick, James Gordon↗
Post Irradiation Examination of Fast Neutron Irradiated 14YWT Tubes at Nuclear Science User Facilities
Cladding materials for next generation nuclear reactors require resistance to high doses of fast neutron flux. Work through the Department of Energy's (DOE) Nuclear Technology Research and Development (NTR and D) Program's Advanced Fuel Campaign has identified 14YWT, a nano-ferritic oxide dispersion strengthened alloy as a promising alloy and has made a 50 kg batch of material, FCRD-NFA1, with nominal composition Fe-14Cr-3W0.4Ti-0.2Y in weight percentage. Plates were extruded from milled powder at Oak Ridge National Laboratory and then electro-discharge machined (EDM) into two sizes of tubes at Los Alamos National Laboratory (LANL). The OD of the tubes were polished to remove the EDM recast layer. Twenty-four of these tubes were placed into the BOR60 reactor, a sodium fast reactor, at the RIAR lab in Dimitrovgrad Russia. Irradiation conditions depended on exact location within the reactor, but the two samples in this study (L108 and L202) were irradiated to 7 dpa at 360-370 deg. C (Sample L108), and 6 dpa at 385-430 deg. C (L202). More detailed temperature models are pending for sample L202. Post irradiation examination took place at both LANL and the University of California, Berkeley (UCB). Facilities used at LANL (CMR Wing 9 Hot Cells, Electron Microscopy Lab (EML)) are part of a pending NSUF partner facility application, while the work at UCB was completed under a Nuclear Science User Facility, Rapid Turnaround Experiment Proposal (NSUF-RTE)
36 MATERIALS SCIENCE↗
Milestone 1.2.9: Radiolytic Gas Generation Measurements from Helium Backfilled Samples of AA1100 and AA6061 Coupons
Nearly 18 metric tons of aluminum-clad spent nuclear fuel (ASNF) is safely managed by the U.S. Department of Energy (DOE). These assemblies are currently in interim storage, with the intention of extended storage (>50 years) until final disposal. Strategies for the continued safe storage of this material are under evaluation, of which a key criterion is the extent of molecular hydrogen gas (H2) formation from the radiolysis of hydrated (oxy)hydroxide aluminum corrosion layers arising from in-reactor and wet storage conditions. Radiation-induced H2 formation has the potential to compromise cladding and storage canister integrity, in addition to promoting the formation of unfavorable gaseous environments. Consequently, understanding this radiation-induced phenomenon is essential for the development of predictive modeling capabilities to support technical considerations and the identification of radiation related challenges for the extended storage of ASNF. Here, we report radiolytic H2 yields (G-values, G(H2)) from the gamma irradiation of ‘pristine’ and pre-corroded aluminum coupons in helium (He) environments as a function of alloy composition (AA1100 and AA6061), relative humidity, and absorbed gamma dose. Measured yields were lower than corresponding values reported for argon environments, a positive result for proposed extended dry storage strategies that would employ helium as a backfill gas. Interestingly, the presented G(H2)He values are comparable to those previously measured in nitrogen environments, suggesting a He mediated H2 inhibition process, attributed here to Penning ionization.
38 RADIATION CHEMISTRY, RADIOCHEMISTRY, AND NUCLEA↗
Diffusion Barrier Properties of Nitride-Based Coatings on Fuel Cladding
In this work titanium nitride (TiN) and zirconium nitride (ZrN) coatings are proposed as diffusion barriers between stainless steel nuclear fuel cladding and lanthanide fission products. TiN and ZrN have been coated as barrier materials between pure Fe and Ce, i.e. diffusion couples of Fe/TiN/Ce and Fe/ZrN/Ce, annealed up to a temperature of 600 degrees C, and compared to the diffusion behavior of uncoated Fe/Ce. Backscattered electron images and electron dispersive X-ray spectroscopy measurements confirm that, with a 500 nm TiN or ZrN layer, no obvious diffusion is observed between Fe and Ce. Basic diffusion characteristics of the Fe/Ce couple have also been measured and compared with the TiN and ZrN coated ones. The results strongly advocate that TiN and ZrN coatings provide reliable diffusion barrier characteristics against Ce and possibly other lanthanide fission products.
36 MATERIALS SCIENCE↗
Prospects for additive manufacturing of nuclear fuel forms
Additive manufacturing (AM) is viewed as a critical enabling technology for achieving superior performance and improved economics across many sectors. Although the past decade has seen increased application of AM methods to nuclear reactor cladding and structural materials, exploration of AM as applied to the uranium-bearing nuclear fuel forms has been limited. The two major families of nuclear fuel forms (monolithic, particle/dispersion) are utilized with their own set of core objectives in mind, and their differences require distinct fabrication infrastructures. These reference fabrication methods impose many limitations on nuclear fuels. Further, both currently operating reactors and future concepts have the potential for improved performance if these accepted limitations are relaxed or removed entirely. The primary limitations of reference fabrication processes for the common nuclear fuel forms are outlined in this paper. This groundwork is then used to identify avenues of fuel performance specific to each of these fuel architectures that could be exploited if the restrictions of conventional fuel fabrication are removed. Moreover, multiple targets for AM studies are laid out for each of the major nuclear fuel variants. Finally, key strategic components to guide research activities in AM of nuclear fuels are outlined, with an emphasis on use of modeling and simulation to motivate research aims and embrace of an accelerated testing methodology to screen and quality new fuel forms.
11 NUCLEAR FUEL CYCLE AND FUEL MATERIALS↗
Adhesion, structure, and mechanical properties of Cr HiPIMS and cathodic arc deposited coatings on SiC
Chromium deposited by high-power impulse magnetron sputtering (HIPIMS) versus cathodic arc (CA) processes exhibits very different mechanical properties. Combining the two can result in a single-phase with superior performance that can be tailored for use in coating SiC for advanced nuclear fuel cladding. Coating morphology, residual stress, elemental depth profiles, and mechanical testing by scratch, pull-off adhesion, and microcantilevers are shown for HiPIMS, CA, and combined coatings. CA coatings were likely to spall and had lower adhesion strength due to tensile residual stresses but had desirable material properties. Additionally, by depositing an initial layer of Cr by HiPIMS followed by a layer of Cr by CA, a more adherent coating was achieved and some of the stress issues with CA morphology were resolved. Combined coatings withstood at least 80 MPa in pull-off adhesion tests and had maximum failure stress values of 5GPa in microcantilever tests. These results were better than either individual deposition method and point to a hybrid approach being a path forward for a more robust coating.
36 MATERIALS SCIENCE↗
An approach for spent nuclear fuel containment integrity verification using gas tagging
Verification of containment integrity is required for spent nuclear fuel (SNF) managed by the commercial nuclear industry and U.S. Department of Energy (DOE), especially after extended storage. Certain SNF storage systems, such as the DOE road-ready dry storage system, hold several packaged containments within a welded over-canister. These packaged containments are called Department of Energy Standard Canisters (DOESCs). DOESC leakage identification is challenging because their containment boundary cannot be accessed for testing and their contents (i.e., SNF and fill gas) are often similar. There are concerns that this could result in costly characterization and repackaging operations of DOE road-ready dry storage systems if compromised DOESCs are suspected. Here, to address these concerns, this paper presents an approach for applying a gas tagging process using xenon to uniquely identify compromised inaccessible containments following extended storage. The containments considered for this application are seven DOESCs, each packaged within a single over-canister. Two different SNF loading configurations from the Advanced Test Reactor and Fort Saint Vrain nuclear power plant are considered. These configurations are used to represent research reactor aluminum-clad spent nuclear fuel (ASNF) and TRi-structural ISOtropic (TRISO) SNF types. Results for this application show that for ASNF and TRISO type fuels for which the selected fuels are representative, the volume of taggant required at loading is determined primarily by the lower detection limit and leak rate of taggant from a compromised DOESC, rather than the amount of fission-generated xenon in the loaded fuel. While the application presented is suited for larger leaks, smaller leaks could be detected by modifying certain design parameters. This gas tagging approach can also be applied to other DOE containments and advanced reactor SNF storage systems.
07 - ISOTOPES AND RADIATION SOURCES↗
An investigation of FeCrAl cladding behavior under normal operating and loss of coolant conditions
Iron-chromium-aluminum (FeCrAl) alloys are candidates to be used as nuclear fuel cladding for increased accident tolerance. An analysis of the response of FeCrAl under normal operating and loss of coolant conditions has been performed using fuel performance modeling. In particular, recent information on FeCrAl material properties and phenomena from separate effects tests has been implemented in the BISON fuel performance code and analyses of integral fuel rod behavior with FeCrAl cladding have been performed. BISON simulations included both light water reactor normal operation and loss-of-coolant accidental transients. In order to model fuel rod behavior during accidents, a cladding failure criterion is desirable. For FeCrAl alloys, a failure criterion is developed using recent burst experiments under loss of coolant like conditions. The added material models are utilized to perform comparative studies with Zircaloy-4 under normal operating conditions and oxidizing and non-oxidizing out-of-pile loss of coolant conditions. The results indicate that for all conditions studied, FeCrAl behaves similarly to Zircaloy-4 with the exception of improved oxidation performance. Here, further experiments are required to confirm these observations.
11 NUCLEAR FUEL CYCLE AND FUEL MATERIALS↗
An Investigation of the Applicability and Limitations of the ORNL Expanded Plug Test
The expanded plug test technique for measuring the circumferential tensile properties of irradiated nuclear fuel cladding was developed at Oak Ridge National Laboratory (ORNL) and has been used successfully in several applications. The primary advantage of this technique over other procedures is its simplicity for application in the complex hot cell environment. During the development stage, efforts were made to both qualify the technique as much as possible regarding its experimental application and to develop and validate the data reduction procedures. However, since this is a new technique, the technical community is cautious in adopting a procedure that has not been fully vetted. The purpose of this effort was to address several baseline issues regarding the applicability of the technique and the precision of the use of experimental expanded ring load-deformation data to calculate material circumferential stress-strain properties. The tests performed, in conjunction with the developed data reduction procedures, demonstrate good reliability in the prediction of ring material stress-strain behavior for several materials of widely different strengths.
tensile, nuclear fuel cladding↗
Milestone 1.2.15: Feasibility of In Situ Accelerated Aluminum Coupon Radiolysis by Synchrotron X-Rays
Extended dry storage of aluminum-clad spent nuclear fuel (ASNF) requires an assessment of the radiolytic generation of molecular hydrogen gas (H2) from the ASNF’s corrosion layers. H2 accumulation can potentially lead to storage canister embrittlement/rupture and the accumulation of flammable gas mixtures in accident scenarios. To date, computational models have been developed for the prediction of radiolytic H2 generation from samples exposed to lower absorbed dose regimes (up to ~3 MGy). However, greater accuracy is needed for higher absorbed doses (> 25 MGy) where the concentration of H2 ultimately reaches a steady-state. Data in this area is limited due to the amount of time taken (months) to accumulate such high gamma doses. Furthermore, a recent study observed radiation-induced damage to the surface of pre-corroded aluminum alloy coupons at high absorbed gamma doses. Despite this observation and its implications, there is currently no computational connection between the radiolytic formation of H2 and changes in the composition and morphology of the cladding’s corrosion layers with absorbed dose. To develop a better understanding of the processes and effects described above, the present study aimed to evaluate the feasibility of leveraging synchrotron x-ray capabilities for coupled accelerated irradiation and in situ surface characterization of ASNF alloys. To that end, National Synchrotron Light Source II (NSLS-II) beamtime was secured and a series of aluminum alloy 1100 (AA1100) wires, prepared under a variety of conditions, were interrogated using ex situ x-ray diffraction (XRD) and scanning electron microscopy (SEM) techniques at Idaho National Laboratory (INL) and ex situ and in situ XRD capabilities at the NSLS-II x-ray powder diffraction (XPD) beamline. Results indicated that performing synchrotron XRD using the available XPD beamline configuration can provide sufficient radiation dose but cannot discern changes in the composition and morphology of sample corrosion layers. Additionally, ex situ XRD and SEM data from Idaho National Laboratory (INL) indicated that the pre-corrosion of AA1100 wires did not generate an appreciably thick corrosion layer, as compared with previous aluminum coupon studies. These thinner surface corrosion layers were not sufficient for detection by both ex situ and in situ synchrotron XRD, specifically under consideration of the NSLS-II XPD beamline’s configuration primarily capturing information from the sample’s bulk material, i.e., aluminum metal. In summary, the use of the NSLS-II XPD beamline for promoting accelerated radiolysis and in situ surface characterization is not appropriate for this program’s goals.
38 RADIATION CHEMISTRY, RADIOCHEMISTRY, AND NUCLEA↗
Unveiling damage mechanisms of chromium-coated zirconium-based fuel claddings at LWR operating temperature by in-situ digital image correlation
Here, we investigate the coupled thermomechanical fracture mechanisms of coated nuclear fuel claddings at Light Water Reactor (LWR) operating temperatures. These coated claddings are a highly attractive, near-term solution, which addresses the demands for accident-tolerant fuel systems and provide greater oxidation resistance. However, the fracture mechanisms of these coatings, which may create channels for oxidation ingression, must be fully understood prior to implementation. Thus, high-temperature expanding plug experiments were conducted on coated cladding specimens at a temperature of 315 °C, consistent with the operating environment of LWRs. Furthermore, in-situ thermomechanical deformation was measured with stereo digital image correlation during heating and mechanical testing to separately resolve contributions of thermal and mechanical strain. Digital image correlation, supported by acoustic emissions (AE) detection, was also leveraged to track cracking activity during loading. Coating fracture was found to initiate at total hoop strains of 0.34%. The thermal deformation of the coated claddings was investigated via finite element simulations, revealing a bidirectional stress-state within the coating with axial and circumferential strains of 0.026 and 0.031%. This bidirectional stress-state was attributed with the generation of off-axis fracture pattern within the coating as identified via post-experiment scanning electron microscopy. Thus, this study unveiled critical, coupled thermomechanical mechanisms governing the coating fracture of coated claddings at LWR temperatures.
36 MATERIALS SCIENCE↗
Designing Cladded Components for High Temperature Nuclear Service: Part II—Design Rules
The challenge of using existing ASME Section III, Division 5, class A metallic materials for the construction of structural components of advanced reactors with corrosive coolants could be mitigated by allowing designers to use cladding to protect the base material from corrosion. However, the existing Section III, Division 5 rules provide no guidance on the evaluation of strain accumulation and creep-fatigue damage in cladded components. The availability of design rules for cladded components that do not require long-term clad material testing could promote the application of the cladding approach to accelerate the deployment schedule of these advanced reactor systems. To avoid long-term properties for the clad materials Part I of this work proposes two approximate design analysis methods for two types of clad materials—soft clads that creep much faster and have lower yield stress than the class A base material, and hard clads that creep much slower and have higher yield stress than the class A base material. The proposed analysis methods approximate the response of a soft clad by treating it as perfectly compliant and of a hard clad by treating it as linear elastic. Based on these approximate design analysis strategies this Part II develops a complete set of design rules for class A components cladded with either soft or hard clad materials. In conclusion, Part II discusses the reasoning behind the proposed design rules and uses example finite element analyses of representative reactor components to illustrate the use of these design methods.
22 GENERAL STUDIES OF NUCLEAR REACTORS↗
Thermal Modeling of Advanced Test Reactor Fuel in a Generalized Dry Storage System Under Hypothetical Accident Conditions
Work was performed to investigate the thermal behavior of a sealed aluminum-clad spent nuclear fuel (ASNF) dry storage configuration under hypothetical accident conditions during long-term storage. The considered system consists of a concrete dry storage overpack; a welded over canister, backfilled with argon; and nine Department of Energy (DOE) standardized canisters (DOESCs) loaded with ASNF, backfilled with helium gas. One technical concern associated with the long-term storage of ASNF includes radiolytic hydrogen generation. The yield of large quantities of hydrogen could lead to DOESC over pressurization or a flammable internal atmosphere. While flammability concerns can be resolved by preventing the ingress of oxygen, the canister pressure is partially controlled by the atmosphere temperature. This memorandum summarizes the results of modeling and simulation (M&S) work completed with Star CCM+ (a computational fluid dynamics [CFD] software) considering the thermal effects of a fully engulfing flame and another scenario with the vent ports of the concrete dry storage overpack completely blocked. The goal was to determine the bounding maximum temperature of the DOESC internal atmosphere to evaluate a worst-case pressure scenario, as well as the critical vent port blockage durations.
11 NUCLEAR FUEL CYCLE AND FUEL MATERIALS↗
Thermal Dehydration of Aluminum (Oxy)hydroxides on Fuel Cladding Material - 20200
The aluminum cladding of research-reactor fuel undergoes general corrosion with resulting formation of adherent aluminum (oxy)hydroxide films during in-reactor and post-discharge exposure to water under various conditions and temperatures. These (oxy)hydroxides contain chemically-bound water that poses challenges for extended dry storage due to the risk of thermal or radiolytic decomposition releasing free water and/or hydrogen and oxygen gases. This study comprised laboratory experiments of thermal drying behavior of aluminum (oxy)hydroxides to identify approaches for reducing bound water on fuel cladding prior to sealed dry storage. Effective drying strategies for adherent (oxy)hydroxides on fuel cladding will improve the safety of dry storage by mitigating potential avenues for additional corrosion and/or generation of flammable gases inside the storage canister. This work is part of a broader investigation to address knowledge gaps and technical data needs for dry storage of aluminum-clad spent nuclear fuel (ASNF), which included investigation of (oxy)hydroxide formation on aluminum alloy substrates immersed in water, characterization of service-grown films from ASNF, and radiolytic yield of hydrogen from (oxy)hydroxide powders and films. The current work comprises experimental thermal dehydration of aluminum trihydroxides (bayerite and gibbsite) characteristic of low-temperature (<80 deg. C) corrosion in water and aluminum oxyhydroxide (boehmite) characteristic of high temperature (>80 deg. C) corrosion in water. First, commercially produced (oxy)hydroxide powders (boehmite and gibbsite) were tested via thermogravimetric analysis (TGA) and differential scanning calorimetry (DSC). The effort aimed to identify or confirm key temperature ranges/thresholds for the thermal decomposition reactions, as well as impacts of ramp rate and hold times, for drying of isolated, high-surface-area (oxy)hydroxides. The information gleaned from powder tests was used to guide subsequent drying tests on adherent (oxy)hydroxide films grown on aluminum alloy substrates. TGA was used to analyze small samples of the aluminum coupons with adherent (oxy)hydroxide films. Specimens were characterized both pre- and post-drying using X-ray diffraction (XRD) to determine the film composition and scanning electron microscopy (SEM) to determine its morphology. Drying of adherent (oxy)hydroxide films was anticipated to pose additional complications relative to drying of (oxy)hydroxide powders. Anticipated challenges include achieving sufficient drying of the (oxy)hydroxide at low-enough temperature to avoid melting or other undesirable phase changes in the aluminum substrate and overcoming transport limitations of water through the thickness of a dense film or through a tortuous pore structure to reach the outer surface of the film. Inn addition, dehydration of (oxy)hydroxides significantly changes the film density, which may lead to substantial alterations in the morphology, including potential cracking and spalling of the film. TGA/DSC tests of gibbsite powders resulted in successful conversion to boehmite or alumina, depending on the maximum temperature reached. At low ramp rates (≤5 deg. C/min), the conversion to boehmite occurred around 300 deg. C (210-340 deg. C). XRD confirmed that boehmite was the only phase detected after tests reaching 450 deg. C. The transition to alumina occurred around 510 deg. C (470-550 deg. C), with XRD detecting only alumina after tests reaching at least 600 deg. C. Boehmite powders dehydrated to alumina at about 400 deg. C (330-460 deg. C) for coarse (77-μm particle diameter) powder and about 490 deg. C (420-520 deg. C) for fine (0.7-μm particle diameter) powder. For all powders tested, the maximum percent mass loss after drying to high temperature slightly exceeded the theoretical mass loss for complete dehydration of the stoichiometric (oxy)hydroxide to alumina, which is likely attributable to physisorbed water in the powder. Drying of a thick (∼8.6 μm), predominantly bayerite adherent film displayed a dramatic change in film morphology, with the initially continuous trihydroxide film cracking into sections on the order of 50 μm square and partially delaminating. The outermost layer of the film completely faked of in some regions. The layer exposed under the spalled oxide also displayed prominent cracking, with spacing on the order of 10 μm, but this surface layer appeared to remain completely adhered to the aluminum substrate. TGA showed mass losses per unit surface area up to ∼1.0 mg/cm{sup 2}. XRD characterization of the remaining oxide was inconclusive, with no crystalline phases detected. (authors)
11 NUCLEAR FUEL CYCLE AND FUEL MATERIALS↗
Quantifying the effect of hydride microstructure on zirconium alloys embrittlement using image analysis
Since hydride microstructure can significantly influence Zr alloy nuclear fuel cladding’s ductility, a new metric has been developed to quantify hydride microstructure in 2D micrographs and relate it to crack propagation. As cladding failure usually results from a hoop stress, this new metric, called the Radial Hydride Continuous Path (RHCP), is based on quantifying the continuity of brittle hydride particles along the radial direction of the cladding tube. Compared to previous metrics, this approach more closely relates to the propensity of a crack to propagate radially through the cladding tube thickness. The RHCP takes into account hydride length, orientation, and connectivity to choose the optimal path for crack propagation through the cladding thickness. The RHCP can therefore be more closely linked to hydride embrittlement of the Zr alloy material, thus creating a relationship between material structure, properties, and performance. The new definition, along with previously proposed metrics such as the Radial Hydride Fraction (RHF), the Hydride Continuity Coefficient (HCC), and the Radial Hydride Continuity Factor (RHCF), have been implemented and automated in MATLAB. These codes are made available with this publication as supplementary materials. These metrics were verified by comparing their predictions of hydride morphology against expected values in simple cases, and the implementation of the new metric was validated by comparing its predictions with manual measurements of hydride microstructure performed on ImageJ. The RHCP was also validated against experimental measurements of fracture behavior and it was shown to correlate with cladding failure better than previous metrics. The information provided by these metrics will help accurately assess cladding integrity during operation, transportation, and storage.
36 MATERIALS SCIENCE↗