Computational Design of High-Entropy Rare Earth Disilicates as Next-Generation Thermal/Environmental Barrier Coatings
For presentation at Materials Science Technology 2023, Columbus, OH, October 1-4, 2023.
SEARCH · Search NASA
Search indexed NASA NTRS and DOE OSTI research on propulsion, heat transfer, battery materials and energy systems. Follow report and document links to the original sources.
Quote a phrase for an exact phrase match. Source license links do not imply unrestricted reuse.
For presentation at Materials Science Technology 2023, Columbus, OH, October 1-4, 2023.
Deployment of additively manufactured materials into nuclear energy systems requires investigation of the full range of the unique environmental effects on these materials. Hydrogen isotopes are common gaseous species in nuclear reactors and exhibit ample high mobility in most materials. While hydrogen isotopes mobility in wrought stainless steel is well understood, this property is not thoroughly studied for its additively manufactured variants. In this study, we investigated the deuterium permeation and retention in 316L stainless steel manufactured by laser powder bed fusion. The results showed that the deuterium permeability in the as-built additively manufactured 316L stainless steel (AM SS316L) is greater than that of the reference wrought 316L stainless steel by a factor of 2.8. However, the stress-relieved and solution-annealed AM SS316L samples exhibit lower deuterium permeability in comparison with the as-built condition. Following the solution annealing, the deuterium permeability of AM SS316L is comparable with that of the reference wrought SS316L. Deuterium retention in the as-built AM SS316L is 45% higher than that of the wrought 316L stainless steel and slightly higher than that of the two thermally annealed AM SS316L materials. Finally, transmission electron microscopy and positron annihilation lifetime spectroscopy were used to obtain microstructural information used to determine deuterium permeation and retention behavior in the studied materials.
Additive manufacturing, or simply 3D printing (3DP), where objects are built through layer-wise material deposition, has gained significant academic and industrial attention as a result of the development of advanced and functional materials requiring rapid, customized, and flexible solutions. In the context of green manufacturing, diversifying environmentally and economically sustainable material portfolios is an essential endeavor for the success of 3DP technology that uses widely available, highly valuable, and renewable materials. Here, we used stereolithography (SLA) for processing methacrylate-based photocurable resins containing crab shell-derived chitin nanowhiskers (CNWs), which are surface-functionalized by reactive acrylate groups. Results from full spectral, thermal, structural, and topological analyses corroborate not only the surface functionalization of CNWs but also indicate the presence of these photocurable CNW (pCNW) fillers in the 3D-printed nanocomposites. Owing to the strong interfacial bond induced by the physical and chemical crosslinking between the pCNW and methacrylate (MA) polymer matrix, the internally formulated nanocomposites displayed enhanced thermomechanical properties (e.g., storage modulus and glass transition temperature) compared to those of commercially available pure SLA resins. For instance, the inclusion of 0.5 wt % pCNW improved the tensile strength and stiffness to up to 78 and 71%, respectively, without compromising the toughness and ductility of the printed material. Accordingly, this result also evidences the compatibility between the filler and resin materials. Consequently, the formation of a crosslinked network in the nanocomposite structure results in a higher thermal stability and activation energy (i.e., up to ~79%) for all the hybrid materials than the pristine MA. Finally, the high-resolution SLA print features, dimensional accuracy, and enhanced mechanical performance of our microstructure-forming functionalized chitin-based nanocomposites make them promising materials for a wide range of robust and high-performance industrial applications.
Environmental barrier coatings (EBCs) are a commercially proven means of protecting SiC-based materials in gas turbine environments. However, there are little specific data in the literature on the impact of coatings like Yb 2 Si 2 O 7 on preventing accelerated SiO 2 growth in the presence of H 2 O. Quantification of reduced rates are necessary for evaluating and comparing EBC effectiveness and incorporation of silica growth rates into future EBC lifetime models. In this study, baseline kinetics of silica formation on bare Si and chemically vapor deposited (CVD) SiC in the 1250–1425 °C range were obtained via 100 h isothermal exposures in dry air and steam environments utilizing a SiC reaction tube to mitigate specimen volatility. An Arrhenius plot of the resulting rates was constructed, representing baseline minimum and maximum rates for Si and SiC oxidation at ambient pressure. Various EBC systems on CVD SiC substrates including air plasma sprayed (APS) EBCs with and without a Si bond coating and with surface roughening to enhance Yb 2 Si 2 O 7 adhesion were subjected to 1-h furnace cycle testing in air with 90vol%H 2 O at 1250–1350°C for up to 500 cycles. After exposure, silica formation rates were measured and compared to the baseline rates to assess EBC effectiveness, where EBC effectiveness is gauged as the propensity to reduce underlying rates of silica formation. With a Si bond coating, a ~180 µm Yb 2 Si 2 O 7 (YbDS) top coating reduced rates over the entire 1250°-1350°C range. Without a Si bond coating, ~60 µm (YbDS) coatings deposited directly onto CVD SiC exhibited poor adhesion, and had to be deposited onto substrates with enhanced roughness at 1350°C. Finally, while exhibiting good adhesion at 1350°C, overall the single layer YbDS coating exhibited a decreasing effectiveness from 1250° to 1350°C.
Fundamentals of Structural Materials for Nuclear Energy
Environmentally assisted cracking (EAC) is a critical failure mode in nuclear reactor environments, where materials are exposed to high temperatures, radiation, and corrosive media. Specific EAC studies in nuclear environments include stress corrosion cracking in primary water chemistry, irradiation-assisted stress corrosion cracking (IASCC) under neutron exposure, and hydrogen induced cracking (HIC) in reactor pressure vessels. The experimental methodologies of EAC include slow strain rate testing (SSRT), constant load, and cyclic loading techniques, conducted in autoclaves designed to simulate the reactor’s operational environments. This paper highlights several experimental case studies, especially on IASCC, conducted within the Nuclear Science User Facilities (NSUF).
Background: Subcritical crack growth can occur in a brittle material when the stress intensity factor is smaller than the fracture toughness if an oxidizing agent (such as water) is present at the crack tip. Objective: Here we present a novel bi-material beam specimen which can measure environmentally assisted crack growth rates. The specimen is “self-loaded” by residual stress and requires no external loading. Methods: Two materials with different coefficient of thermal expansion are diffusion bonded at high temperature. After cooling to room temperature a subcritical crack is driven by thermal residual stresses. A finite element model is used to design the specimen geometry in terms of material properties in order to achieve the desired crack tip driving force. Results: The specimen is designed so that the crack driving force decreases as the crack extends, thus enabling the measurement of the crack velocity versus driving force relationship with a single test. The method is demonstrated by measuring slow crack growth data in soda lime silicate glass and validated by comparison to previously published data. Conclusions: The self-loaded nature of the specimen makes it ideal for measuring the very low crack velocities needed to predict brittle failure at long lifetimes.
Energy and environmental issues have attracted increasing attention globally, where sustainability and low-carbon emissions are seriously considered and widely accepted by government officials. In response to this situation, the development of renewable energy and environmental technologies is urgently needed to complement the usage of traditional fossil fuels. While a big part of advancement in these technologies relies on materials innovations, new materials discovery is limited by sluggish conventional materials synthesis methods, greatly hindering the advancement of related technologies. To address this issue, this review introduces and comprehensively summarizes emerging ultrafast materials synthesis methods that could synthesize materials in times as short as nanoseconds, significantly improving research efficiency. We discuss the unique advantages of these methods, followed by how they benefit individual applications for renewable energy and the environment. We also highlight the scalability of ultrafast manufacturing towards their potential industrial utilization. Finally, we provide our perspectives on challenges and opportunities for the future development of ultrafast synthesis and manufacturing technologies. Here, we anticipate that fertile opportunities exist not only for energy and the environment but also for many other applications.
Polymer degradation under aggressive environmental stressors often develops heterogeneities due to diffusion-limited reaction phenomena. This is well established for diffusion-limited oxidation (DLO), which is known to occur for most polymeric materials at elevated temperatures but has been less summarized for the conditions of diffusion-limited hydrolysis (DLH). Here, an overview of hydrolysis for several materials and a computational model, analogous to the underlying equations for DLO, able to define this diffusion-reaction system is presented. A systematic study of the influence of various parameters, such as water diffusivity, reaction rate and order, and a more in-depth focus on residual isocyanate hydrolysis in a polymeric methylene diphenyl diisocyanate (pMDI) based polyurethane (PU) foam is given. For this system, we present experimental data for model ‘input’ parameters and discuss predictions for different conditions. We conceptually compare the behavior of diffusion-limited oxidation to that of diffusion-limited hydrolysis (DLH). With the mathematical framework and key material properties presented herein, any DLH phenomena following Fickian diffusion behavior can be understood, modeled, and predicted.
To enhance the protection of Ni-based superalloys in gas turbine engines’ high-temperature environments, it’s crucial to develop advanced thermal/environmental barrier coating (T/EBC) materials with a balanced combination of thermal and mechanical properties. This optimization is essential to safeguard against chemical and thermal challenges. Here, in this study, we harness the power of density functional theory (DFT) in conjunction with combinatorial chemistry methodologies to engineer high-performance high-entropy rare earth disilicates of the RE 3 Al 5 O 12 family (where RE denotes Y, Gd, Er, and Yb). These materials are meticulously designed to exhibit superior phase stability, a targeted coefficient of thermal expansion (CTE), low lattice thermal conductivity, and robust mechanical properties. The determination of CTE values is accomplished through phonon calculations at various volume settings within the quasi-harmonic approximation, while lattice thermal conductivities are rigorously assessed employing the Debye-Callaway model, accounting for three distinct phonon processes. Our findings highlight the remarkable attributes of the solid solution (Y 1/4 Gd 1/4 Er 1/4 Yb 1/4 ) 3 Al 5 O 12 , which displays a reduction in lattice thermal conductivity compared to its individual constituents while maintaining a favorable range of CTE values. The novel T/EBC material, distinguished by their multifaceted functionalities, are poised to use in substantial enhancements in the performance of engines.
Dissolution of actinide dioxides, including neptunium dioxide (NpO 2 (s)), is paramount for the prediction of the environmental fate of nuclear materials. Quantifying dissolution rates, as well as understanding qualitative dissolution mechanisms, informs performance assessment for geologic disposal of spent nuclear fuel and management of legacy radioactive waste. The aim of this research was to measure the dissolution rate of nanocrystalline NpO 2 (s), produced through legacy nuclear waste processing, under oxidizing conditions, as well as to characterize surface alteration to the material. The solid phase was characterized using electron microscopy techniques (SEM/STEM) and X-ray photoelectron spectroscopy (XPS), indicating preferential dissolution of Np-hydroxide contained in the grain boundaries of NpO 2 (s) and fragmentation of grains from the matrix. The oxidative dissolution was monitored over 40 weeks, yielding a two-step kinetic dissolution model involving hydration of NpO 2 (s) and subsequent oxidation and dissolution of the hydroxide phase. Here, the proposed dissolution models for nanocrystalline NpO 2 (s) suggest that microstructural features such as grain boundaries are key factors affecting dissolution, including release of colloidal particles, and ultimately, environmental fate and transport of nuclear materials.
Not provided.
Coal fly ash (CFA) is produced during the coal combustion process and contains trace elements (<100 ppm) including selenium (Se) and arsenic (As), both detrimental for environmental and human health. Existing management strategies for CFAs involve disposal in landfills and ash ponds, as well as beneficial usage in other applications such as in concrete. Both the direct disposal and beneficial usage of CFA raise concerns for environmental hazards due to the potential leaching of Se and As. CFAs were classified as reusable material by the U.S. Environmental Protection Agency (EPA) with the first federal regulation (Disposal of Coal Combustion Residuals from Electric Utilities, CCR) for its disposal established six years ago. During coal combustion process, parameters such as furnace firing type, emissions controls, coal rank, use of additives, and particulate matter controls, could contribute to significant variability in As/Se concentrations and their speciation. Although there have been a handful of studies on As/Se speciation on small sets of samples, they do not fully represent the current state of coal-fired electrical generating units. Little information exists on the detailed speciation (e.g. oxidation state, complexation state) of As/Se in large set of fly ash samples. To better investigate the role of the potential contributing parameters, a large-scale survey study with representative samples of typical coal source and combustion conditions is highly desired. The overall goal of this research is to systematically characterize As and Se speciation of representative coal fly ash samples using state-of-the-art synchrotron based spectroscopic and microscopic techniques, in order to develop a correlation between coal source/type, operation condition, As/Se speciation, and As/Se mobility. A detailed survey study was conducted documenting the current state-of-knowledge on fossil power generating units as a function of coal type/source, operating conditions, environmental control systems, additive use, and fly ash handling methods. Based on this survey, a matrix of fly ash samples representing a range of conditions were chosen and collected. The collected ash samples were analyzed for bulk characteristics such as elemental composition, microstructure, chemical and mineralogical composition, surface area, and particle size distribution. State-of-the-art synchrotron X-ray microscopy and spectroscopy techniques were applied to reveal the molecular scale speciation information of As and Se, such as oxidation state, association with other elements/minerals, and complexation states.
The ever-increasing demand for higher system thermal efficiency necessitates the operation of power generation cycles and heat conversion systems for chemical processes at progressively higher temperatures. As the system operating temperature increases, fewer and fewer materials are available with the required mechanical properties and environmental compatibility. This dearth of materials is particularly acute in structural applications at temperatures above 700°C in liquid Fluoride Salt Cooled High-Temperature Reactors (FHRs) and Concentrated Solar Power (CSP) systems where liquid fluoride and/or liquid chloride salts are used for their high thermal capacity and low thermal conductivity to store and transport heat. It has been shown that fluorides and chlorides can degrade the properties of the material used for storage and transport due to corrosive effects thus affecting the performance and lifetime characteristics. Thus, materials used for storage and transport for fluoride/chloride-salt must at the minimum have good compatibility with the salt by exhibiting low corrosion rates at the required temperatures. In addition, since many of the components will be subject to stresses in service, they need to have sufficient strength to resist plastic deformation, and the resistance to time dependent creep deformation at these temperatures, and stress levels. Achieving the combination of these properties required for higher temperatures is particularly challenging considering traditionally, the expected lifetime of some of the components used in these systems are from 30 years (CSP) to 80 years (FHRs). Although 316 stainless steel and associated redox corrosion reduction techniques are being considered for use in the first generational systems, use of 316SS is limited to operating temperatures up to ~ 650°C, thereby resulting in lower reactor efficiencies. Hastelloy ® N, developed at ORNL in the 1950s-60s for molten salt service is currently the leading candidate FHR structural alloy but has inadequate creep properties at high temperatures. Using a computationally-guided approach, Oak Ridge National Laboratory had developed new high strength alloys strengthened by γ’ precipitates (about 2X the strength of Hastelloy ® N) in small laboratory-scale heats that show good resistance to corrosion by fluorides and improved creep rupture life at temperatures up to 850°C (U.S. Patent Application No. 13/833,357 entitled “High Strength Alloys for High Temperature Service in Liquid-Salt Cooled Energy Systems”- granted U. S. Patent No. 9,540,714).
Metal halide perovskites (MHPs) are interesting semiconductor materials with potential for use in optoelectronic and photonic devices. Their practical applications are hindered due to the negative environmental effects of the lead ions (Pb 2+ ) used in these materials and stability issues. Exploring new environmentally friendly materials with lead-free metal halides and investigating the factors affecting their optical properties and stability are essential. The broadband emission and high (near-unity; ~100%) photoluminescence quantum yield (PLQY) of low-dimensional copper(I) halides make them great candidates for the next-generation luminescent materials for lighting applications. Here, a Cu(I) iodide based organic/inorganic hybrid halide (benzo-15-crown-5) 2 NaH 2 OCu 4 I 6 (BCNCI) with a zero-dimensional (0D) cluster was prepared. The BCNCI has a broadband yellow emission peaked at 548 nm with a near-unity PLQY (99.1%) upon excitation at 365 nm (ultraviolet). Upon excitation at 450 nm (blue), a high PLQY of 82% was also achieved. The luminescence mechanism was discussed in detail. Interestingly, BCNCI exhibits ultra-broad band excitation in the 300–500 nm range, which matches commercially available UV and blue-emitting chips. Compared to commercial YAG:Ce 3+ phosphors, the emission spectrum is sufficiently broad to cover the visible spectral region. This work illustrates a good example of developing an environmentally friendly white light source, using high-performance copper halides with adequate broadband excitation and emission.
Remanufacturing is a well-established end-of-life (EOL) strategy that promises significant savings in energy and carbon emissions. However, the current design practices are not remanufacturing-inclusive, i.e., the majority of products are designed for a single life cycle. As a result, potential products that can sustain multiple life cycles are deprived of additional benefits of being designed for remanufacturing, such as reduced material usage, lower cost, and improved environmental impact. Moreover, the uncertainty in design, material selection, and economics are not considered to produce remanufacturable designs. Accordingly, this research proposes a design for remanufacturing (DfRem) framework that accounts for design uncertainty and material price volatility. The framework systematically explores the design space, performs design optimization under uncertainty, followed by topology optimization to provide additional mass savings, and finally, a price volatility analysis for plausible design material choices. The candidate designs are evaluated based on their design mass, material price volatility, failure mode characteristics, carbon footprint, and embodied energy impacts. The proposed framework's utility is demonstrated via the use of an engine cylinder head case study subjected to thermo-mechanical loads along with fatigue and wear failure. Considering grey cast iron and aluminum alloy as the design material choices, it was found that the cast iron design reduced the initial design mass by 6% as opposed to a 5% decrease for aluminum. On the other hand, about 8% area of the cast iron design failed due to fatigue, compared to 3% for aluminum. Here, we further observed that although the aluminum design provided better mechanical performance than the cast iron design, this material was more expensive and volatile in price.
The innovative research conducted by Arizona State University and Princeton University in the project "Mixed Ionic-Electronic Conducting Quaternary Perovskites: Materials by Design for Solar Thermochemical Hydrogen" marks a significant stride forward in thermochemical water splitting. Through an intricate blend of computational design and experimental validation, the project delved into the promising potential of Mixed Ionic Electronic Conducting (MIEC) perovskites. These complex materials, characterized by their unique redox-active nature and adaptability in stoichiometry, present a promising frontier for efficient solar thermochemical hydrogen production. Firstly, the research enhanced the science by utilizing state-of-the-art computational methodologies to unravel the nuanced chemical potentials of MIEC perovskites. By simulating various off-stoichiometric scenarios and redox conditions, the team was able to predict material behaviors under diverse environmental conditions, a feat unachievable through conventional experimental methodologies alone. This approach not only fast-tracks the material screening process, significantly reducing the time from laboratory re-search to practical application, but also uncovers trends and correlations that are pivotal for future materials innovation. Regarding technical effectiveness, the project stands out in its economic feasibility. Traditional methods of materials discovery are often marred by high costs and extensive timeframes, owing to the iterative nature of experimental processes. However, by employing theoretical computations and validating these findings with targeted experiments, the project introduced a cost-effective paradigm for materials discovery and the first ever prediction, synthesis, and preliminary validation of a material solely from computational and theoretical considerations. This synergy between computation and experimentation expedites the discovery of optimal materials conducive to high-efficiency solar-to-hydrogen conversion processes. Furthermore, the public stands to benefit substantially from this research. The success of MIEC perovskites in solar thermochemical applications heralds a shift towards lower cost and lower electricity input for clean hydrogen production, hence potentially impacting climate and energy resilience. By improving the efficiency of solar-to-hydrogen conversions, the research paves the way for reduced dependency on fossil fuels, addressing the urgent global need for accessible and renewable energy sources. Moreover, the project's advancements contribute to scientific literacy in renewable energy technologies, empowering society through knowledge and spurring future innovations. In essence, this research project demonstrates significant progress in the realm of advanced water splitting through solar thermochemistry. Through its groundbreaking approaches in computational materials science and its implications for real-world applications, it holds the promise of a cleaner, more energy-resilient future.
Considering the growing concerns about natural resource depletion, energy inequality, and climate crises, biomass-derived materials—the most abundant organic matter on the planet—have received a lot of attention as a potential alternative to petroleum-based plastics. Herbaceous biomasses and extracted cellulose have recently been extensively used in the development of high-performance and multifunctional materials. Herbaceous biomass has sparked interest due to its species diversity, abundance, low cost, lightweight, and sustainability. This review discusses the structure versus property relationships of various sources of herbaceous biomasses (e.g., sugarcane, straw, and bamboo) and their extracted biomaterials, as well as the latest emerging applications from macro- and microscales to nanoscales. We report, high-strength structural materials, porous carbon materials, multichannel materials, and flexible materials are examples of these applications, which include sustainable electronics, environmentally friendly energy harvesting, smart materials, and biodegradable structural buildings.