Search NASA⌕ Search

SEARCH · Search NASA

Results for “Capacity degradation”

Search indexed NASA NTRS and DOE OSTI research on propulsion, heat transfer, battery materials and energy systems. Follow report and document links to the original sources.

Quote a phrase for an exact phrase match. Source license links do not imply unrestricted reuse.

At least 235 records · Page 13
All sourcesNASA NTRSDOE OSTI
DOE OSTI2024

Development and Testing of an Advanced Cascaded Thermoelectric Residential Heat Pump

Electricity-driven heat pumps using vapor compression cycle are an energy-efficient solution to replace fossil fuel burning and reduce greenhouse gas emissions for space heating in residential buildings. However, heating capacity and Coefficient of Performance (COP) of heat pumps degrade significantly with increasing temperature difference between ambient and indoor environments. Residents and building owners are hence reluctant to fully embrace electric heat pumps. The use of conventional all-electric heat pumps also causes concern for electric utilities due to an increased winter peak demand arising from the use of supplemental electric resistance heaters. Our research is an attempt to alleviate these concerns by designing and laboratory testing a thermoelectric (TE) heat pump cascaded with a vapor compression cycle to enhance heating capacity and COP. TE modules increase the subcooling in the refrigerant liquid of the vapor compression cycle to enlarge the evaporating capacity and works at an efficiency greater than a conventional electric resistance strip. This results in a simple, affordable, efficient and highly controllable solution to adequately meet space heating needs in dwellings. The laboratory testing of the 3-stage cascaded TE heat pump performed in this research has exhibited a higher heating capacity by above 15%, while maintaining a heating COP of 2.0-3.6 in the ambient temperature range of -18˚C to 8˚C (0˚F to 47 ˚F), which represents more than 60% of winter temperatures observed in US. If successfully commercialized, this technology can advance space-heating electrification by overcoming consumer cost barrier of heat pumps.

Shen, Bo↗
DOE OSTI2022

Multimodal quantification of degradation pathways during extreme fast charging of lithium-ion batteries

Enabling fast charging of Li-ion batteries will be a key step towards realizing the technology's full potential in electric vehicles. Currently, fast charging is limited by a variety of processes that reduce cell capacity upon extended cycling. Using a multimodal approach combining incremental capacity analysis (dQ/dV), high energy X-ray diffraction (HEXRD), and mass spectrometry titration (MST), we identify specific degradation mechanisms—including Li plating, dead Li x C 6 formation, Li 2 C 2 formation, solid carbonate solid-electrolyte interphase (SEI) deposition, and loss of positive electrode active material (LAM PE )—that occur during extended fast charge cycling. We find that Li plating is the major source of capacity loss in cells cycled at 6C, while non-carbonate SEI species deposition on the graphite anode is the main source of capacity loss when cycled at 4C. We also study local degradative phenomena by examining specific ~1–5 cm 2 regions of the cells using HEXRD and MST. Here, we find that plated Li is often collocated with dead Li x C 6 , Li 2 C 2 , and solid carbonate SEI species, and these additional species cumulatively account for ~20% of the capacity lost during 6C cycling. Finally, in a cell with an anomalously high amount of LAM PE (quantified via dQ/dV), we find that regions of cathode degradation were accompanied by non-carbonate SEI products on the adjacent region of the anode. We postulate that this phenomenon arises due to crosstalk between the electrodes, wherein soluble electrolyte oxidation products formed at the delithiated cathode migrate to the graphite anode and are ultimately deposited on the graphite surface. This work demonstrates the utility of combining multiple characterization techniques to reveal a more holistic understanding of degradative phenomena that occur across multiple length scales during fast charge.

25 ENERGY STORAGE↗
DOE OSTI2020

Beneficial Effect of Li 5 FeO 4 Lithium Source for Li-Ion Batteries with a Layered NMC Cathode and Si Anode

The energy density of lithium-ion batteries can be increased by replacing the traditional graphite anode with a high capacity silicon anode. However, volume changes and interfacial instabilities cause a large irreversible capacity and a continual loss of lithium during cycling, which lead to rapid capacity loss. In this work, we add Li 5 FeO 4 (LFO) to a LiNi 0.5 Mn 0.3 Co 0.2 O 2 (NMC) cathode as a pre-lithiation additive, which increases the lithium inventory and extends the cycle life of Si-graphite/NMC full cells, and decreases the NMC particle degradation. LFO delivers a large 764 mAh g –1 LFO capacity below 4.7 V vs Li/Li + . By tuning the LFO content in Si-graphite/LFO-NMC full cells, we show higher capacity, improved retention, lower impedance, and superior rate performance compared to full cells without LFO. Post-test characterizations demonstrate that LFO inclusion in the cathode matrix leads to less NMC secondary particle segregation/cracking and a thinner surface reduced layer on the NMC particles. The beneficial effects of LFO endure after the lithium reserve has been exhausted, highlighting a lasting synergy between the lithium source and electrode active materials. This study introduces a new approach to simultaneously increase lithium inventory and reduce cathode degradation, and makes critical advances toward enabling Si anodes for lithium-ion batteries.

25 ENERGY STORAGE↗
DOE OSTI2021

Essential effect of the electrolyte on the mechanical and chemical degradation of LiNi 0.8 Co 0.15 Al 0.05 O 2 cathodes upon long-term cycling

Capacity fading during long-term cycling (>1500×) is still a critical challenge for Li-ion batteries that use Ni-rich layered oxides, e.g. LiNi 0.8 Co 0.15 Al 0.05 O 2 (NCA), as the cathode. Microcracks have been previously recognized as one of the primary reasons for the observed capacity fade. Although there exists a generally developed mechanical understanding of microcracks, the role of the electrolyte has not been clearly understood, especially after extended cycling and at the atomic scale. Here, we unveil the microstructural evolution of spherical NCA secondary particles after long-term cycling using scanning transmission electron microscopy accompanied with electron energy loss spectroscopy. In this work, we found that the microcracks initiated and grew through grain boundaries, which then serve as the pathway for electrolyte penetration into secondary NCA particles. Additionally, the rock-salt phase reconstruction is prone to occur at the (003) surfaces of the primary particles or the crack surfaces, largely due to electrolyte (LiPF 6 EC/EMC) corrosion. Crack propagation within the NCA grains is primarily a joint consequence from electrolyte corrosion and mechanical strain during lithiation/delithiation. During extended cycling, due to the distinctive surface facets, the primary grains located in the center of the secondary particles experience more intensive electrolyte corrosion, leading to a reduced contact with nearby particles, impairing the overall capacity. These results establish the initiation and growth mechanism of microcracks and voids in NCA-based cathodes during cycling and point out the role of the electrolyte in affecting the degradation of NCA-based cathodes.

25 ENERGY STORAGE↗
DOE OSTI2022

Overcoming the Intrinsic Limitations of Fast Charging Lithium‐Ion Batteries Using Integrated Acoustic Streaming

A lithium‐ion battery's maximum charge rate and energy density are intrinsically limited by the ion diffusion rate in the electrolyte. Most research focuses on materials science solutions to this problem, with gradual improvement over the years. A mechanical solution is proposed to integrate an MHz‐order frequency surface acoustic wave (SAW) device into an existing 1.8 Ah multilayered Li‐ion pouch cell to enhance the ion diffusion rate and the overall battery performance. Both the charging rate and cycling lifetime are improved from SAW. At a 6C (10 min) charge and C/3 discharge rate, typical of electric vehicle applications, integrating SAW into the Li‐ion cell doubles the energy density and maintains at least 72% of the battery's initial capacity after 2000 cycles. Moreover, using SAW quantifiably reduces battery degradation in these conditions as determined by optical imaging, scanning electron microscopy, X‐ray diffraction, and neutron diffraction. The use of SAW appears to offer a method to avoid undesirable Li metal plating on the graphite anode during charging, and leads to a much longer battery lifetime and good charge capacity, all despite rapid charging.

Huang, An↗
DOE OSTI2025

Low-nickel cathode chemistry for sustainable and high-energy lithium-ion batteries

The transition to sustainable energy storage demands lithium-ion batteries with high energy density and reduced reliance on critical metals such as nickel (Ni), yet current strategies to increase capacity have largely depended on raising Ni content, leading to escalating supply risks, rising costs and sustainability concerns. More critically, Ni-rich cathodes suffer from rapid electrochemical degradation driven by structural instability, creating an insurmountable trade-off between capacity and cycle life. Here, in this study, we introduce a low-Ni chemistry cathode, Li(Li 0.05 Ni 0.57 Mn 0.31 Co 0.07 )O 2 , with a radial phase integration design that overcomes these limitations, enabling a remarkable Ni usage reduction (Ni < 0.6) while demonstrating high capacity (215 mAh g −1 ) and markedly improved cyclability (~97% retention over 400 cycles) compared to conventional high-Ni cathodes (Ni = 0.8). Advanced X-ray and electron microscopy analyses reveal that the designed cathode exhibits a highly reversible oxygen anionic redox, benefiting from a structurally stable surface and minimizing irreversible phase transitions. Moreover, the integrated structure substantially mitigates lattice strain and improves mechanical stability even under harsh conditions. In conclusion, this advance offers a general design principle for developing next-generation cathodes that combine resource efficiency with long-term electrochemical reliability.

36 MATERIALS SCIENCE↗
DOE OSTI2022

Assessing the Oxidative Stability of Anion Exchange Membranes in Oxygen Saturated Aqueous Alkaline Solutions

While anion exchange membrane water electrolyzers show promise as a source of green hydrogen using low-temperatures and non-platinum group metal catalysts, many concerns must be addressed. A primary challenge for the development of high-performance anion exchange membrane water electrolyzers is the fabrication of a stable membrane that will be able to survive long-term stability test while maintaining high anion conductivity, which is a necessity for a durable water electrolyzer. This method will present a standardized protocol that can be used by researchers to assess the quality of their AEM materials and be able to provide insight into how materials may be degrading and how to improve the quality of AEMs. Using Mohr or Volhard titration to measure ion-exchange capacity, EIS to determine the ionic conductivity, NMR and FTIR to understand the extent of membrane degradation over time, and mechanical analyzers to determine the strength of their AEMs, this standardized protocol will guide researchers to determining and improving upon the long-term durability and performance of their AEM materials.

36 MATERIALS SCIENCE↗
DOE OSTI2023

An Investigation of Heuristic Control Strategies for Multi-Electrolyzer Wind-Hydrogen Systems Considering Degradation

With the growing demand for renewable-energy-powered hydrogen generation and the corresponding increase in plant capacity, individually controlling many electrolyzer stacks will be critical for increasing the plant's lifetime and efficiency. This paper introduces a rule-based controller framework targeting electrolyzer degradation to explore the opportunity space in multi-stack hydrogen plant control. A novel control-oriented degradation model is also presented in this work, which quantifies the impact of steady power input, fluctuating power input, and the number of startup/shutdown cycles on electrolyzer degradation. Using a wind power input signal, 13 controller configurations are tested on 5 MW hydrogen plants consisting of 2, 5, 10, and 25 stacks. These configurations are evaluated on their capability to mitigate electrolyzer degradation and efficiently produce hydrogen from the time-varying input power. The results show that multi-stack control for degradation can extend the plant's lifetime by more than a factor of 3 with minimal impact on instantaneous hydrogen production.

control↗
DOE OSTI2023

Electric vehicle batteries alone could satisfy short-term grid storage demand by as early as 2030

The energy transition will require a rapid deployment of renewable energy (RE) and electric vehicles (EVs) where other transit modes are unavailable. EV batteries could complement RE generation by providing short-term grid services. However, estimating the market opportunity requires an understanding of many socio-technical parameters and constraints. We quantify the global EV battery capacity available for grid storage using an integrated model incorporating future EV battery deployment, battery degradation, and market participation. We include both in-use and end-of-vehicle-life use phases and find a technical capacity of 32–62 terawatt-hours by 2050. Low participation rates of 12%–43% are needed to provide short-term grid storage demand globally. Participation rates fall below 10% if half of EV batteries at end-of-vehicle-life are used as stationary storage. Short-term grid storage demand could be met as early as 2030 across most regions. Our estimates are generally conservative and offer a lower bound of future opportunities.

25 ENERGY STORAGE↗
DOE OSTI2020

Concentration dependent properties and plastic deformation facilitate instability of the solid-electrolyte interphase in Li-ion batteries

Lithium-ion batteries (LIBs) often suffer from capacity fading and poor cyclic performance due to mechanical degradation of the solid-electrolyte interphase (SEI). Here we perform numerical simulations and theoretical analysis to elucidate the role of plasticity in wrinkling and ratcheting behaviors of an SEI/electrode system. A coupled diffusion and finite deformation framework is formulated and numerically implemented as a user-element subroutine (UEL) to describe transient lithium diffusion and accompanying elastic–viscoplastic deformation of the electrode. It is found that concentration dependent properties and plastic deformation facilitate wrinkling in such a system. A wrinkled morphology may further lead to ratcheting and related failure under cycling. A phase diagram of four types of cyclic behaviorsis identified in terms of the charging rate and time. Our analysis suggests several potential strategies to avoid wrinkling and ratcheting instabilities, such as charging/discharging the electrode at a sufficiently slow rate, and/or introducing a thick artificial SEI with a pre-tension.

25 ENERGY STORAGE↗
DOE OSTI2023

Liquid Phase Exfoliation of Chemically Prelithiated Bilayered Vanadium Oxide in Aqueous Media for Li-Ion Batteries

Bilayered vanadium oxides are attractive for energy storage due to their high initial specific capacities, which could be stabilized by integrating the bilayers with conductive nanoflakes often produced in a form of aqueous dispersions. Therefore, exfoliation of the bilayered vanadium oxides in water with high yield is desirable. Here, this work introduces the first aqueous exfoliation of chemically prelithiated bilayered vanadium oxide (i.e., δ-Li x V 2 O 5 ·nH 2 O or LVO) followed by vacuum filtration to produce a free-standing film, exhibiting a lamellar stacking of the bilayered vanadium oxide nanoflakes as evidenced by scanning electron microscopy. Due to the hydrated nature of bilayered vanadium oxides, the relationship between interlayer water content and the vacuum drying temperature (105 °C vs 200 °C) was studied using X-ray diffraction, thermogravimetric analysis, and Raman spectroscopy. It was found that vacuum drying the LVO nanoflakes at 200 °C enabled more efficient removal of crystallographic water than drying at 105 °C, and did not induce a phase transformation. Scanning transmission electron microscopy confirmed the layered structure of the samples, which was more well-ordered in the 200 °C case and had no clear boundaries between flakes at the atomic scale. Furthermore, electrochemical testing in nonaqueous Li-ion cells revealed that vacuum drying at 200 °C led to improvements in ion storage capacity and electrochemical stability. Improvements in electrochemical charge storage properties of the electrodes obtained via LVO exfoliation and free-standing film assembly in water dried at 200 °C reveal that conventional battery electrode drying protocols need to be revised as new electrochemically active materials are synthesized, such as hydrated layered oxides with expanded interlayer regions. The remaining capacity fading can be attributed to the structural LVO degradation, dissolution of vanadium oxide in electrolyte, and parasitic effects of the remaining interlayer water molecules. Our results establish an environmentally friendly and safe approach to obtain two-dimensional (2D) bilayered vanadium oxide nanoflakes and create a pathway to constructing novel 2D heterostructures for improved performance in energy storage applications.

37 INORGANIC, ORGANIC, PHYSICAL, AND ANALYTICAL CH↗
DOE OSTI2026

Understanding the Performance Gap between Polycrystalline and Single-Crystal Nickel-Rich Layered Oxide Cathodes

Singe-crystal (SC) nickel-rich layered oxide cathodes, composed of boundary-free particles with high tap density, offer significant advantages in volumetric energy density and mechanical strength compared with polycrystalline (PC) cathode materials. However, as the nickel content increases (≥80%), SC Ni-rich cathodes often suffer from faster performance degradation than PC cathodes of the same composition, and the underlying causes of this discrepancy remain poorly understood. Herein, we reveal the distinct Ni redox behaviors that govern the electrochemical performance of SC and PC Ni-rich cathodes using multiscale and operando characterization techniques. Our results indicate that the increasingly heterogeneous Ni oxidation process in SC cathodes leads to the additional irreversible oxygen redox activity that deteriorates both the mechanical and chemical structures. In contrast, PC cathodes, despite with more pronounced surface reconstruction, exhibit greater chemomechanical stability due to homogeneous redox reactions during charging. Consequently, we find that bulk degradation, more than surface reactions, ultimately leads to fast capacity decay of SC Ni-rich cathodes during cycling. In conclusion, this work offers a comprehensive view on the impact of Ni redox evolutions on the chemomechanical stability in Ni-rich layered oxide cathodes, providing new insights into the longstanding performance gap between SC and PC cathodes, and guiding the rational design of Ni-rich cathode architectures.

36 MATERIALS SCIENCE↗
DOE OSTI2021

Elucidating and Mitigating High-Voltage Degradation Cascades in Cobalt-Free LiNiO 2 Lithium-Ion Battery Cathodes

LiNiO 2 (LNO) is a promising cathode material for next-generation Li-ion batteries due to its exceptionally high capacity and cobalt-free composition that enables more sustainable and ethical large-scale manufacturing. However, its poor cycle life at high operating voltages over 4.1 V impedes its practical use, thus motivating efforts to elucidate and mitigate LiNiO 2 degradation mechanisms at high states of charge. Here, a multiscale exploration of high-voltage degradation cascades associated with oxygen stacking chemistry in cobalt-free LiNiO 2 , is presented. In this work, lattice oxygen loss is found to play a critical role in the local O3–O1 stacking transition at high states of charge, which subsequently leads to Ni-ion migration and irreversible stacking faults during cycling. This undesirable atomic-scale structural evolution accelerates microscale electrochemical creep, cracking, and even bending of layers, ultimately resulting in macroscopic mechanical degradation of LNO particles. By employing a graphene-based hermetic surface coating, oxygen loss is attenuated in LNO at high states of charge, which suppresses the initiation of the degradation cascade and thus substantially improves the high-voltage capacity retention of LNO. Overall, this study provides mechanistic insight into the high-voltage degradation of LNO, which will inform ongoing efforts to employ cobalt-free cathodes in Li-ion battery technology.

25 ENERGY STORAGE↗
DOE OSTI2025

Neutron-Friendly Li-Ion Battery Coin Cell for In Situ 3D Visualization of Li Plating

Advanced battery characterization using in situ/operando neutron imaging is critical for uncovering degradation modes such as lithium (Li) plating in Li-ion batteries (LIBs). However, conventional LIBs hinder operando neutron radiography (NR) and in situ neutron micro-computed tomography (N-μCT) for visualizing Li plating near the graphite-separator interface due to strong attenuation from hydrogen-rich components like PP–PE–PP separators, electrolyte, and Fe-based spacers. In this work, we designed and tested a neutron-friendly battery (NFB) optimized for in situ Li detection during extreme fast charging (XFC). Guided by neutron attenuation cross-sections and material transmission, the NFB enables clear visualization at the graphite–separator interface, which is typically opaque in standard LIBs. Electrochemical tests show the NFB exhibits voltage/current responses like standard cells for up to 50 XFC cycles. However, its lower reversibility and capacity are likely due to Cu-coated Al spacer degradation from delamination or corrosion. We propose titanium spacers as a more stable alternative, albeit requiring custom machining. Using this optimized cell, we achieved simultaneous neutron tomography of multiple cells, capturing in situ 3D images of dead Li accumulation, particularly near graphite edges. These heterogeneous deposits and disconnected Li clusters suggest localized current density hotspots during XFC.

25 ENERGY STORAGE↗
DOE OSTI2021

Anionic redox induced anomalous structural transition in Ni-rich cathodes

Ni-rich cathodes have emerged as one of the most promising candidates for power next generation electric vehicles. However, they often suffer from poor capacity retention when charged to high voltages and the origin of this degradation remains elusive. Here, by using high throughput operando neutron diffraction, a universal four-stage structural evolution of Ni-rich cathodes is revealed during the initial cycle for the first time. Particularly, we discovered a universal structural transition in Ni-rich cathodes at ~75% delithiation irrespective of Ni or substituent contents. This transition is hallmarked by the anomalous increase of average TM–O bond lengths, contradicting the conventional wisdom that TM–O bond lengths decrease during charge (oxidation). This anomaly is induced by the direct oxidation of lattice oxygen ions, which is rooted in the drastic decrease of oxygen-to-TM charge transfer gap at high degrees of delithiation. The onset of this anomalous transition matches very well with the onset of oxygen gas release and severe decline of capacity retention in Ni-rich cathodes, suggesting that this bulk structural transition plays an indispensable role in the degradation process. These findings shed light on the elusive degradation mechanism of Ni-rich cathodes, providing valuable clues to stabilize oxidized oxygen ions for stable cycling of layered oxide cathodes at high voltages.

25 ENERGY STORAGE↗
DOE OSTI2025

Delineating the Factors Impacting the Electrochemical Behavior of Single-Crystal High-Nickel Layered Oxide Cathodes

High-nickel (Ni) (≥80%) single-crystal LiNi 1-x-y Mn x Co y O 2 (NMCs) have garnered recent interest as cathodes in lithium (Li)-ion batteries (LIBs). However, capacity fade at high voltages, particularly after the onset of the H2–H3 phase transition, hampers their viability. In this study, single-crystal LiNi 0.8 Mn x Co 0.2-x O 2 (x = 0.2, 0.1, 0) are synthesized and tested in LiPF 6 in ethyl methyl carbonate-based electrolytes, with and without monofluoroethylene carbonate and LiF 2 PO 2 additives, to clarify the effects of Co/Mn ratio and surface stabilization on high-voltage cycling degradation. By imposing a kinetic barrier to the accessible H2–H3 capacity, surface reconstruction is identified as the primary driver of high-voltage capacity loss, being greater in the Co-free cathode and in the absence of fluorinated electrolyte components. This is attributed to a synergy between increased mechanical stress due to worsened bulk and interfacial H2–H3 kinetics and decreased interfacial stability due to the poor passivating capability of the electrolyte. Here, the findings highlight the importance of limiting cathode impedance growth during high-voltage cycling, which can be achieved by tuning bulk dopants and electrolyte chemistry.

25 ENERGY STORAGE↗
DOE OSTI2022

Understanding of bacterial lignin extracellular degradation mechanisms by Pseudomonas putida KT2440 via secretomic analysis

Abstract Background Bacterial lignin degradation is believed to be primarily achieved by a secreted enzyme system. Effects of such extracellular enzyme systems on lignin structural changes and degradation pathways are still not clearly understood, which remains as a bottleneck in the bacterial lignin bioconversion process. Results This study investigated lignin degradation using an isolated secretome secreted by Pseudomonas putida KT2440 that grew on glucose as the only carbon source. Enzyme assays revealed that the secretome harbored oxidase and peroxidase/Mn 2+ -peroxidase capacity and reached the highest activity at 120 h of the fermentation time. The degradation rate of alkali lignin was found to be only 8.1% by oxidases, but increased to 14.5% with the activation of peroxidase/Mn 2+ -peroxidase. Gas chromatography–mass spectrometry (GC–MS) and two-dimensional 1 H– 13 C heteronuclear single-quantum coherence (HSQC) NMR analysis revealed that the oxidases exhibited strong C–C bond ( β-β , β -5, and β -1) cleavage. The activation of peroxidases enhanced lignin degradation by stimulating C–O bond ( β -O-4) cleavage, resulting in increased yields of aromatic monomers and dimers. Further mass spectrometry-based quantitative proteomics measurements comprehensively identified different groups of enzymes particularly oxidoreductases in P. putida secretome, including reductases, peroxidases, monooxygenases, dioxygenases, oxidases, and dehydrogenases, potentially contributed to the lignin degradation process. Conclusions Overall, we discovered that bacterial extracellular degradation of alkali lignin to vanillin, vanillic acid, and other lignin-derived aromatics involved a series of oxidative cleavage, catalyzed by active DyP-type peroxidase, multicopper oxidase, and other accessory enzymes. These results will guide further metabolic engineering design to improve the efficiency of lignin bioconversion. Graphical Abstract

09 BIOMASS FUELS↗
DOE OSTI2022

The Economic Impact of Battery Degradation Modelling Uncertainty

Battery energy storage systems (BESS) are used for a variety of applications, with their economic benefit often being the decisive factor for deployment. A multitude of physico-chemical aging mechanisms lead to capacity fade over a BESS life cycle. The models that are used to describe this capacity fade are prone to inherent model errors. Through a holistic techno-economic modelling approach, we investigate the impact of battery degradation modelling uncertainty on the economic benefit of representative BESS applications. Here, it is shown how improved parameter fit quality can reduce the resulting economic uncertainty. Furthermore, we highlight that the consideration of degradation modelling uncertainty is especially crucial when: (i) the cash flow highly depends on the available battery capacity, (ii) a fixed, e.g. warranty mandated, state of health limit acts as the threshold for battery end-of-life, (iii) long evaluation periods and low discount rates are the focus of economic evaluation.

aging↗